Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?

238 replies

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 22:39

I have friends and colleagues in Nordics, Spain, Italy, Germany and they all keep asking what the hell is going on in Britain, with double digit inflation and 80% increases in fuel costs. They don’t seem to be feeling all of this to the same extent.

So why is it happening here, and not so much elsewhere? I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes). But what about elsewhere?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 11:00

The free (or more correctly, low cost) train travel is also a direct benefit to the users as the infrastructure investment has already been made. The marginal cost of transporting one more passenger, or even 100 more passengers, is minimal - the train runs whether it carries 50 passengers or 150 passengers, so the fixed cost is the same. For the individual passenger it means a cost saving; for the environment it represents a reduction of pollution; for the government it means that the individual person might be able to keep their job (and therefore not need to claim benefits), or not demand such a high pay rise, thus keeping inflation down.

Spot on. Being in favour of such measures doesn’t mean people don’t understand ‘the economy’.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 10:57

@sst1234
The fact that we are applauding any country for giving freebies and nationalising energy that it doesn’t produce (thereby subsidising it) shows a complete lack of understanding of the economy works.

EDF does produce the energy that it sells - and it sells it to the French market at below international market price (i.e. it could sell at a higher price into the international market), but not below the cost of production. Subsidising vital services (energy, transport, healthcare, infrastructure etc.) is the way to ensure that everyone is able to afford these services regardless of their circumstances.

"Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future."

You're only describing one version of "the economy." Nationalisation, or alternatives such as mutually-owned entities or co-operatives, mean that any "profits" generated are retained by the taxpayers or the consumer/owners rather than being creamed off by investors. Currently in the UK, the £400 fuel payments will go directly into the pockets of the investors (often overseas companies, thus removing money from the UK economy) rather than into investment in storage facilities, generating capacity or environmental improvements. Nationalisation (or mutualisation) does not necessarily mean that "you pay in the future" - done well it can mean that consumers benefit in the future as the "profits" are not skimmed off.

The free (or more correctly, low cost) train travel is also a direct benefit to the users as the infrastructure investment has already been made. The marginal cost of transporting one more passenger, or even 100 more passengers, is minimal - the train runs whether it carries 50 passengers or 150 passengers, so the fixed cost is the same. For the individual passenger it means a cost saving; for the environment it represents a reduction of pollution; for the government it means that the individual person might be able to keep their job (and therefore not need to claim benefits), or not demand such a high pay rise, thus keeping inflation down.

hewouldwouldnthe · 29/08/2022 10:52

I was watching Euro news last week and it said some european countries were heading for recession.

I think everywhere is pretty bad, it just that the UK loves to trumpet misery on the news...hence i watch Euro news and CNN regularly

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 10:47

Ah but European kids don’t have student debt @BloodyHellKen ;-)

BloodyHellKen · 29/08/2022 10:43

hop321 · 29/08/2022 09:29

But people WILL pay for this. The money has to be taken from people and put back into the economy sooner than later.

This is the thing. Many of the examples given involve government subsidies, which would increase our enormous public debt even more. There's no 'freebies' just borrowing that will have to be repaid through higher taxes in the future.

👏
The older I get the more I agree with this. I don't want everything subsidised for my generation so that our children can pay for it later on. It's bad enough they will have huge student debt to contend with.

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 10:27

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 10:21

Where I live in Spain there is lots of work , my adult children have also moved out here and are in good jobs It's area dependant. Same is in any country. Difficult to find work in rural wales/Scotland too.

It’s not the same as in any country. At least by Eurozone standards.

As the data has been shared previously upthread, Spain has 12.5% unemployment and youth unemployment runs at 25%. It makes the economy weaker and less able to deal with global shocks. These are real numbers, not opinions.

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 10:25

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 10:23

That's over simplified and misleading

They ran an illegal election and used illegal activities. They were arrested for breaking the law

It’s not misleading. Spain’s ranking for corruption is well documented by transparency international. This is data, not untested anecdotes.

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 10:23

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 10:21

Where I live in Spain there is lots of work , my adult children have also moved out here and are in good jobs It's area dependant. Same is in any country. Difficult to find work in rural wales/Scotland too.

It’s industry dependant, not only area dependant. There are certain sectors that are still running way behind some of their European counterparts. But that’s the same in most countries, although pronounced in Spain.

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 10:23

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 09:26

Even the monarchy is shady. Real shady. Spain is ranked the lowest on the corruption index out of all the major eurozone countries.

That's over simplified and misleading

They ran an illegal election and used illegal activities. They were arrested for breaking the law

Fifife · 29/08/2022 10:22

I went to Greece recently and they had power cuts all the time food was also more expensive in supermarkets and the average income is lower petrol was also more expensive than home. I think some people like to insult the UK all the time but don't realise things are also bad abroad.

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 10:21

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 10:13

I would not encourage my DC to move from the UK to Spain. I would, however, encourage them to move from the UK to other countries where conditions and opportunities are much better.

Being in a slightly better position than Spain is nothing to brag about, sadly. I love both countries dearly and yet have had to move somewhere else where the situation isn’t as bad.

Where I live in Spain there is lots of work , my adult children have also moved out here and are in good jobs It's area dependant. Same is in any country. Difficult to find work in rural wales/Scotland too.

hop321 · 29/08/2022 10:19

It’s like we no lessons were learned from 14 years of quantative easing, or the inflationary impact of locking up healthy people, paying them to do nothing while stoking demand for goods that are weren’t being produced. Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future. Just like lockdowns were now free and we are paying now through inflation.

I agree. There's no magic money tree. As hard as it is, do we want to subsidise the cost of energy? And add to the debt mountain?

Inflation is a similar issue. If everyone has pay rises at the rate of inflation, it makes it even higher. That stores up major economic problems which have a knock-on impact on employment amongst other things.

It's pretty bleak at the moment and I understand the concern about being able to afford to heat the house etc. But if we take short term populist measures, it's going to get even worse and be a longer-term issue.

Camomila · 29/08/2022 10:18

I haven't heard anyone complaining about gas/electricity yet (went to visit relatives in Italy in August) but general COL seems to be increasing there too...a friends nursery is now €500 a month in Milan (most I've ever heard an Italian nursery costing) and another friends rental contract on her house finished (also Milan) and the landlord wanted to put the price up from 1300€ a month to €2000 instead (they left the house and bought in the suburbs instead).

MarshaBradyo · 29/08/2022 10:16

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 10:13

I would not encourage my DC to move from the UK to Spain. I would, however, encourage them to move from the UK to other countries where conditions and opportunities are much better.

Being in a slightly better position than Spain is nothing to brag about, sadly. I love both countries dearly and yet have had to move somewhere else where the situation isn’t as bad.

It’s probably area dependent and not blanket for everyone

I moved to U.K. and see opportunities in comparison - although I’m in London and I already see it with late teen

Where are you thinking?

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 10:15

This thread is indicative of overly simplistic thinking. Sometimes understandably in times of crisis.

The fact that we are applauding any country for giving freebies and nationalising energy that it doesn’t produce (thereby subsidising it) shows a complete lack of understanding of the economy works.

It’s like we no lessons were learned from 14 years of quantative easing, or the inflationary impact of locking up healthy people, paying them to do nothing while stoking demand for goods that are weren’t being produced. Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future. Just like lockdowns were now free and we are paying now through inflation.

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 10:13

MarshaBradyo · 29/08/2022 10:07

Obviously people make different choices at stages of their life, hence retirement towns, but I’d not encourage dc to move to high youth unemployment country.

I would not encourage my DC to move from the UK to Spain. I would, however, encourage them to move from the UK to other countries where conditions and opportunities are much better.

Being in a slightly better position than Spain is nothing to brag about, sadly. I love both countries dearly and yet have had to move somewhere else where the situation isn’t as bad.

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 10:10

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 09:56

A very large % of the Spanish youth, myself included, HAVE indeed exercised their right and left the country because it’s impossible to develop any kind of career of future if we stay home. It’s one of the big social issues in Spain right now. I left for uni and never went back. The country is losing their best scientists, artists, researchers. In my industry, over 75% of young people have either moved to Northern Europe or have at least studied for a few years abroad because the conditions are pretty dire for our generation back home. Although having said that, at least the higher education system is fit for purpose for those who do stay, with tuition fees less than 1k per year, and completely free of charge for high achievers. They can at least get a good degree which allows them to then explore other options.

You can’t expect every single under 25 to move somewhere else though, because that, too, requires money. Money the average Spanish family doesn’t have. I was lucky that I was offered a bursary when I started uni which meant I could afford my flight, halls deposit and the first few food shops. Then straight into work alongside a full time practical degree.

That’s the experience of many of my peers. We’re now thousands of miles away trying to build a future and yes, Spain is not somewhere I’d want to return to right now. But at least I know my parents are not in danger of having their heating cut off this winter. If they were to lose their house there are decent social housing options where they live. Healthcare is top notch and they can be seen in A&E within the hour, even at weekends. Their medicines will be cheap for the foreseeable and they’re not as worried as I’d be in the UK about doing the food shop.

This experience is indicative of the problem Spain has. Brain drain that has been going on for over a decade.

Spain is projected to suffer a net loss of -24% in the next 50 years. The best and the brightest leave Spain to work elsewhere while it imports cheap labour and elderly pensioners. Of the young who are left behind, 25% are unemployed. Is that utopia? A distaste in the making, more like.

MarshaBradyo · 29/08/2022 10:07

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 09:35

And yet you have an unemployment rate of around 13%, and youth u employment of over 25%. Sounds like a really happy and sustainable position to be in. You'd have thought with that wonderful EU FoM and the right to live and work anywhere in the EU, that some of those workers would have exercised that right to make their lot better, wouldn't you?

Obviously people make different choices at stages of their life, hence retirement towns, but I’d not encourage dc to move to high youth unemployment country.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2022 10:01

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 23:41

If you want to start a discussion, maybe start by presenting some data, so it we know your motive isn't just political bashing based on a false premise.

Its responses like this that are ruining MN. If you think I have some nefarious purpose then ask MNHQ to check me out.

Thanks to those who are contributing more genuinely! It’s interesting to hear the differences. With MN being quite U.K.-centric there is a tendency to think it’s the same everywhere.

Why do you think it unreasonable to want to see some hard evidence when your anecdata doesn't reflect everyone else's?

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 09:56

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 09:35

And yet you have an unemployment rate of around 13%, and youth u employment of over 25%. Sounds like a really happy and sustainable position to be in. You'd have thought with that wonderful EU FoM and the right to live and work anywhere in the EU, that some of those workers would have exercised that right to make their lot better, wouldn't you?

A very large % of the Spanish youth, myself included, HAVE indeed exercised their right and left the country because it’s impossible to develop any kind of career of future if we stay home. It’s one of the big social issues in Spain right now. I left for uni and never went back. The country is losing their best scientists, artists, researchers. In my industry, over 75% of young people have either moved to Northern Europe or have at least studied for a few years abroad because the conditions are pretty dire for our generation back home. Although having said that, at least the higher education system is fit for purpose for those who do stay, with tuition fees less than 1k per year, and completely free of charge for high achievers. They can at least get a good degree which allows them to then explore other options.

You can’t expect every single under 25 to move somewhere else though, because that, too, requires money. Money the average Spanish family doesn’t have. I was lucky that I was offered a bursary when I started uni which meant I could afford my flight, halls deposit and the first few food shops. Then straight into work alongside a full time practical degree.

That’s the experience of many of my peers. We’re now thousands of miles away trying to build a future and yes, Spain is not somewhere I’d want to return to right now. But at least I know my parents are not in danger of having their heating cut off this winter. If they were to lose their house there are decent social housing options where they live. Healthcare is top notch and they can be seen in A&E within the hour, even at weekends. Their medicines will be cheap for the foreseeable and they’re not as worried as I’d be in the UK about doing the food shop.

Eyesopenwideawake · 29/08/2022 09:53

PersonaNonGarter · 28/08/2022 22:53

The French are in complete chaos - EDF has had to be nationalised. And they are unable to take advantage of the energy crisis as they are not able to generate as much as usual. Further, they are in the grip of a crime wave and the government is paralysed as Macron lost his majority.

Germany has had a horrendous time and is planning for worse to come on the gas front.

Italy’s government dissolved into total mayhem and has been disbanded with more elections to come.

And on, and on.

Strange as it may seem, our government isn’t that unusually bad.

Nice to see not all the Tory cabinet are on holiday but are instead taking the time to post on MN.

DdraigGoch · 29/08/2022 09:49

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 07:03

this isn’t true, there’s a website that compares global fuel prices. I have also just driven through Luxembourg Belgium France and Spain so looked it up. The uk price for diesel on Wednesday was 1.84£ and the French 1.84€ so I saved a fair bit waiting until calais.

scandinavia and Greece are the only countries with more expensive petrol than uk (globalpetrolprices.com)

The UK has long had more expensive petrol and diesel than across the Channel - it's because there's so much tax on it. Lorry drivers had been complaining for years about Eastern European drivers being able to fill up cheaply before arriving in the UK with their load, do a few internal trips using the cheap tank of fuel, then pick up their back load and return home with it, refilling the tank after leaving the UK.

Rapidtango · 29/08/2022 09:49

www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-62710522

nether · 29/08/2022 09:48

One of the things they're doing is providing Evusheld to their most vulnerable (those of any age whodon't form intended response to covid vaccinations and who are also most likely to be severely ill with it)

Currently in UK in summer 25% of ICU beds are taken up with people in that category, and that could be cut by over 90%. That's an important difference to hospital capacity, especially as absolute numbers are set to rise.

UK hasn't explained the decision making on this point (no minutes published, as they are for other covid treatment and vaccination measures, so we don't know who made the decision or how it was reached) and the only given reason so far (effectiveness against later omicron variants) applies with greater force to the new vaccine that the government has chosen (which explicitly states effectiveness and duration is not known). Big double standards, as there is plenty of data (primarily from US and Israel showing Evusheld is effective - I mean the vaccine probably is: the double standards is there is more actual peer-reviewed evidence for the one dismissed for 'lack of evidence' than there is for the one approved

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 09:47

"what is your reasoning for the crime wave?! News to me"

@sjxoxo thousands of Albanian criminals, who could come legally to the UK if they weren't criminals, choosing to come on dinghys from France, which is being paid millions to sit on its ass and wave them off, could be a small contributing factor. All the nice Albanians just get on a plane with their passports, rather than tossing them in La Manche.