Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?

238 replies

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 22:39

I have friends and colleagues in Nordics, Spain, Italy, Germany and they all keep asking what the hell is going on in Britain, with double digit inflation and 80% increases in fuel costs. They don’t seem to be feeling all of this to the same extent.

So why is it happening here, and not so much elsewhere? I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes). But what about elsewhere?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
sst1234 · 29/08/2022 12:31

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 12:10

State subsidies have to be paid for by taxation, it's not a magic bullet. Our public debt is enormous so you have to draw the line somewhere. The next generation isn't likely to be enjoying the sunny economic uplands so who do you choose to make the later sacrifice of subsidies now?

UK public debt is enormous, but then UK taxation is low relative to many other EU countries. The government raises too little in tax, but instead of increasing taxes to cover the shortfall, successive governments have gone into denial and have borrowed and managed the money supply in an effort to hide the size of the problem.

At some point in time the government and population is going to be forced to confront the truth that you can't have Rolls-Royce levels of public service (which the UK doesn't have anyway) if you're only willing to pay for a Dacia.

Truss's idea that she can cut taxes and still maintain the current levels of service, poor though they are compared with those in many other countries, makes no financial or social sense.

‘Enormous’ relative to what? Yet again more anecdotes without any data.

Here are some numbers on debt to GDP ratio:
Greece 193%
Italy 150%
Protugal 127%
Spain 118%
France 112%
UK 96%
Germany 69%

For resentence US is 127% but is a special case because everything is traded in dollars so US has that leverage.

gatehouseoffleet · 29/08/2022 12:30

I almost wept the other day when I read an article about how we shouldn't be so squeamish about drinking sewage water

people have joked for decades that water in London passes through its residents many times - it actually tastes quite decent compared with the water in other areas as well!

gatehouseoffleet · 29/08/2022 12:28

There is an EU-wide agreement to (try to?) cut power usage by 15% by doing things like lowering heating in public buildings and asking shops to turn off lightings (signs/window displays) at night. Switzerland is in on this too, not sure about other EEA countries

The UK needs to do this too. Too many businesses still leaving their lights on overnight. Even if they can currently afford it, it's a moral imperative to save energy as well to avoid running out this winter.

DumpedByText · 29/08/2022 12:25

Kendodd · 28/08/2022 22:49

Do you think us constantly voting Tory could possibly be a factor?

This, this and more of this!

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 12:24

Decidualcast · 29/08/2022 12:19

I was very curious about France, having just visited Paris and Provence. No sign of COL crisis - restaurants were full to the brim, high streets full of (mostly independent shops). It was in very stark contrast to the UK. There is clearly heavy investment in police and transport eg aside from ticket inspectors, there were 4 transport police on my local train to Marseille.

What would you expect to see? People wearing signs? If you are out and about this BH weekend, I’m sure you would think there was coat of living crisis in UK either.

pawkins · 29/08/2022 12:22

Decidualcast · 29/08/2022 12:19

I was very curious about France, having just visited Paris and Provence. No sign of COL crisis - restaurants were full to the brim, high streets full of (mostly independent shops). It was in very stark contrast to the UK. There is clearly heavy investment in police and transport eg aside from ticket inspectors, there were 4 transport police on my local train to Marseille.

London is also full of tourists - although those stranded due to train strikes might rethink future trips.

MythicalBiologicalFennel · 29/08/2022 12:21

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 08:55

The UK didn’t really go through the recession to the extent that Portugal, Spain, Italy or Greece did. Those countries had to overhaul their economies and lifestyle basically. Property devalued massively (UK housing costs have been on the rise for decades), simple things like eating out, paid-for leisure activities or holidays were off the table for low to mid-income families. Not just the poor.

The current 30 year olds in Spain grew up very differently to the British 30 year olds, who have had a higher level of disposable income throughout their lives. The standard of living is different. You still can’t afford to buy property as a young adult in Spain. There’s nothing to inherit because your parents’ house is now valued at 50k whilst they still have 200k left on the mortgage. All this talk of ‘house deposits’ on MN sounds like Japanese script to a Spanish couple in their 30s who’d like to settle down.

I do agree that socially some countries are better prepared to deal with it than others.

The experiences that you mention about severe negative equity, persistent lack of disposable income and significant changes to the economy don't match mine - I grew up in Spain, have friends and family there, in different regions, and visit often.

Whilst I don't think the way to tackle the current crisis is through subsidies, posters who criticise the "plaster" or "pay now and be bailed later" approach might be interested in reading the "20 years of the euro - winners and losers" report. It shows that despite widespread perceptions the euro has massively benefitted Germany at the expense of other counties (mainly Italy and France).

MarshaBradyo · 29/08/2022 12:21

hop321 · 29/08/2022 12:00

I don't think it's anti EU as such, more pointing out both sides of the coin.

State subsidies have to be paid for by taxation, it's not a magic bullet. Our public debt is enormous so you have to draw the line somewhere. The next generation isn't likely to be enjoying the sunny economic uplands so who do you choose to make the later sacrifice of subsidies now?

Yes they generally start off as anti U.K. then posters correct or add different view points

There are ups and downs to all. I know what I want but others are looking for something different which is fine.

Decidualcast · 29/08/2022 12:19

I was very curious about France, having just visited Paris and Provence. No sign of COL crisis - restaurants were full to the brim, high streets full of (mostly independent shops). It was in very stark contrast to the UK. There is clearly heavy investment in police and transport eg aside from ticket inspectors, there were 4 transport police on my local train to Marseille.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 12:10

State subsidies have to be paid for by taxation, it's not a magic bullet. Our public debt is enormous so you have to draw the line somewhere. The next generation isn't likely to be enjoying the sunny economic uplands so who do you choose to make the later sacrifice of subsidies now?

UK public debt is enormous, but then UK taxation is low relative to many other EU countries. The government raises too little in tax, but instead of increasing taxes to cover the shortfall, successive governments have gone into denial and have borrowed and managed the money supply in an effort to hide the size of the problem.

At some point in time the government and population is going to be forced to confront the truth that you can't have Rolls-Royce levels of public service (which the UK doesn't have anyway) if you're only willing to pay for a Dacia.

Truss's idea that she can cut taxes and still maintain the current levels of service, poor though they are compared with those in many other countries, makes no financial or social sense.

Softplayhooray · 29/08/2022 12:09

We have lots of friends in Switzerland, Austria and Germany as DH used to work for a company in Berlin that covers the territory. I think it depends where in those countries they live, but it always feels like their quality of life is just a lot higher, so even if bills are harder to pay life is still so much nicer, if that makes sense. Less of a grind, just general clean air, clean water, lots of nature, more work life balance, that kind of thing. Some of them live in areas where renewable energy is higher too. And they all have wood burners and are used to bloody cold winters so just seem more set up for this kind of thing.

I almost wept the other day when I read an article about how we shouldn't be so squeamish about drinking sewage water and all the raw sewage being pumped into our local beaches - it's that kind of nightmare on top of the bills and everything else that just makes it all so much worse. I don't think that's a common thing in other countries. I think also they have better care for old people where you can bugger off for a 2 week spa break to just get your health back if you've been a bit ill. In fact it might even be mandatory.

Obviously I'm sure in inner cities in any European countries it must be grim like it would be anywhere, I guess like anywhere countryside is better than cities etc.

hop321 · 29/08/2022 12:00

I don't think it's anti EU as such, more pointing out both sides of the coin.

State subsidies have to be paid for by taxation, it's not a magic bullet. Our public debt is enormous so you have to draw the line somewhere. The next generation isn't likely to be enjoying the sunny economic uplands so who do you choose to make the later sacrifice of subsidies now?

Humphriescushion · 29/08/2022 11:47

pawkins · 29/08/2022 11:01

As usual on MN such threads turn into anti EU ones. It’s tiresome.

My thoughts exactly!

BigWoollyJumpers · 29/08/2022 11:43

Our % rises are higher, because actually we have paid lower prices than most of Europe for decades. It's all relative. Historically Electricity and Gas in Italy and Spain in particular have always been much more expensive than here.

Farmageddon · 29/08/2022 11:41

J0y · 29/08/2022 08:21

I'm in Ireland and we are being braced by the media anyway for a tough winter. Articles advising us to put on our dressing gowns over our clothes at home, I did that last year.

Interesting that France will be protected from the price hikes

Yes, here in Ireland it's going to be a tough winter also. We have high inflation, and worries about energy costs, but also worries about the availability of energy. Many of those big data centres that the tech companies use are built here (with more planned) and they are huge energy drains. It's estimated they currently use up to 15% of our grid energy, which is a problem.

However, the government have tried to offset rising prices a bit, energy rebates and lowering the cost of public transport, and there will be a Cost of Living budget next month to bring in new measures. We had a tax surplus this year, so they are going to throw some money at the situation. Not sure how effective it will be in the long run.

Prices in the supermarket have definitely gone up, and people are feeling the squeeze. Filling up the oil tank this week, 500 litres is almost 700 euro, whereas a few years ago it would have been less than half that.

MoodyTwo · 29/08/2022 11:41

I may be wrong, however I believe we are running out of gas.
Supply and demand = higher prices.
Countries that are limiting costs are not doing any favours , as we all need to use less.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 11:35

tuition might be free.
but accommodation is often prohibitively expensive and materials have to be bought as well.

But the student has to live somewhere anyway, so it is not an additional cost, and it is usual to flat-share in cities in order to keep the accommodation affordable.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 11:28

Just to add to the answers about "what are European countries doing differently" question, where I live in the EU there is a 356 Public Transport ticket, that gives low-cost transport on all buses and trains in the region for an entire year. 365 days travel for €365. The equivalent in the UK would a ticket that allowed travel throughout the TfL area, or Yorkshire, or South Wales or the Central Belt in Scotland for €1 (90p) a day.

greenacrylicpaint · 29/08/2022 11:20

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 10:47

Ah but European kids don’t have student debt @BloodyHellKen ;-)

they do

tuition might be free.
but accomodation is often prohibitively expensive and materials have to be bought as well.
student finance in germany is means tested and if your parents earn 'too much' then you won't get it.

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 11:20

GrandSlamFinalee · 29/08/2022 11:00

The free (or more correctly, low cost) train travel is also a direct benefit to the users as the infrastructure investment has already been made. The marginal cost of transporting one more passenger, or even 100 more passengers, is minimal - the train runs whether it carries 50 passengers or 150 passengers, so the fixed cost is the same. For the individual passenger it means a cost saving; for the environment it represents a reduction of pollution; for the government it means that the individual person might be able to keep their job (and therefore not need to claim benefits), or not demand such a high pay rise, thus keeping inflation down.

Spot on. Being in favour of such measures doesn’t mean people don’t understand ‘the economy’.

I was in Luxembourg recently, where all public transport has been made completely free for environmental reasons (organised before the energy crisis I think). The infrastructure there was excellent. It was wonderful and strange to just get on a bus or train without a ticket. Of course Luxembourg is a very rich/expensive country...

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 11:16

BloodyHellKen · 29/08/2022 11:09

@QuentininQuarantino whether European children have student debt is immaterial. Our children in England have student debt and that is what I am referring to.

I know that, I am saddled with an enormous one.

I just mean that although it might inform your own politics, it isnt going to be as big a consideration for a European voter.

The future does look bleak for our DC, especially with FOM gone.

Alaimo · 29/08/2022 11:12

OrangeDuck · 29/08/2022 09:22

Question about property. If we should expect going forward it becomes the norm for future generations to not own property and we should prepare them for this - then who does own it?Even if they rent, someone has to own the property for them to rent it from? How does this work in Spain where pp have explained that couples in their 30s etc cannot buy property. Who owns all these properties that they live in? If people cannot afford to buy property what happens when properties are left empty? It's just blowing my mind a bit trying to work out how we would adjust to the new norm being for the next generations to not own property - where will they live if no one can afford property to rent out? Will the government have to provide more council houses again?

I can see that renting will increase but surely we still need people to own the properties to rent out? Is this where the rich can come swooping in and mop up properties and rent out at extortionate prices??

In Sweden many (most?) rental properties are owned by housing corporations. And they are restricted in how much rent they are allowed to charge (although there has been some liberalisation so that for example they can charge more for new builds than for older properties, but they can't just charge whatever they want).

There's just not really a buy to let sector here. In fact, if you own an apartment / leasehold property you can usually only rent it out for 1-2 years maximum, after that you either have to move back in or sell it. Freehold houses can usually be let out for as long as the owner wants, but I still don't think there are as many BtL houses as in the UK.

BloodyHellKen · 29/08/2022 11:09

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 10:47

Ah but European kids don’t have student debt @BloodyHellKen ;-)

@QuentininQuarantino whether European children have student debt is immaterial. Our children in England have student debt and that is what I am referring to.

Oblomov22 · 29/08/2022 11:04

I can't understand it all. I can't understand why someone hasn't said to Truss and Sunak: why can France Capp and we can't? What are you. Actually going to DO?

pawkins · 29/08/2022 11:01

As usual on MN such threads turn into anti EU ones. It’s tiresome.