Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?

238 replies

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 22:39

I have friends and colleagues in Nordics, Spain, Italy, Germany and they all keep asking what the hell is going on in Britain, with double digit inflation and 80% increases in fuel costs. They don’t seem to be feeling all of this to the same extent.

So why is it happening here, and not so much elsewhere? I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes). But what about elsewhere?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:17

a loss making nationalised company (like EDF) needs taxpayers to pay for its losses (how else so you think it is funding these losses?).

True - but it doesn't mean that the shortfall has to come from income tax. There are company taxes, capital gains taxes, luxury taxes and transaction taxes too.

Nationalised companies are also less efficient almost always and so cost the taxpayer.

This is only an opinion. An alternative view is that private utilities are less desirable because they extract a dividend or profit instead of returning any "profit" to the consumers in the form of lower prices, increased investment (or both), and that earning a profit on essential services is fundamentally unethical.

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 15:13

and the country is now resorting to importing indentured labour from Asia and elsewhere

We're not paying Asian people who work here? 🤔

Hyacinth2 · 29/08/2022 15:13

Zonder · 29/08/2022 05:08

Unfortunately we have a government who choose to spend the money raised by taxes in ways that don't always benefit the public.

They also choose not to bother properly taxing their friends and their businesses.

Then they choose to give big contracts to incompetent friends eg PPE.

Then they don't bother funding the NHS because the money has to be used for their mates, so that is failing.

They are allowing the energy companies to make insane profits at the expense of you and me.

As someone said upthread, other countries may also worry about cost of living rises but compare them and us and frankly we would be happy to swap.

Then there's the whole Brexit disaster which is costing us enormously.

We have such scarily self serving government that we are totally buggered until people stop voting Tory.

But thankfully all our pensions are invested in the big companies (apparently owned by friends of the gov) and are doing very well . Whew.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:09

Pre-Brexit we were told that there were 3.5m EU citizens here. Post-Brexit there are now 2.8m with settled status and 2.3m with pre-settled status. How have we lost over a million? Are you trying to tell us that the Remain campaign lied, and under-estimated the number of EU citizens who were already here?

The number of EU citizens in the UK at any one time varied according to season - so there were hundreds of thousands of EU citizens in the UK during harvest time and working seasonally in the hospitality industry. Many EU citizens were in the UK for short periods only and so were not counted as being resident (the usual definition of residency is being resident and working for one year or more, which also resulted in an underestimate of the number of UK citizens in the EU). Of course there were also people working without being registered anywhere (unlike almost all EU countries, the UK does not have a compulsory registration system).

Nobody is suggesting that any side of the campaign lied. Perhaps the Remain side underestimated the numbers, but just as importantly, the Leave side believed that losing these workers would have no impact on the UK economy either and that the foreigners were "taking our jobs". And then when they all left, they discovered that the UK had too few lorry drivers, too few agricultural and food workers, too few care workers etc. and the country is now resorting to importing indentured labour from Asia and elsewhere.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:05

Getoff · 28/08/2022 23:21

I don't believe there is generally any great difference between the UK and the rest of Europe, with regard to energy prices or inflation.

A week or so ago when I last looked at wholesale energy prices, the UK and Scandinavian countries were actually slightly cheaper than the rest of Europe. (Possibly ignoring France, which is a bit of a special case.) I could be wrong, but I seem to remember Poland and Germany and Italy having higher prices than the UK.

If you want to start a discussion, maybe start by presenting some data, so it we know your motive isn't just political bashing based on a false premise.

This. Inflation and energy prices are a global phenomenon and are affecting European countries too.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:02

DitzyBluebells · 29/08/2022 04:18

I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes).

If it's nationalised why would they get hit in taxes especially? A nationalised company is basically providing a public service, that's their purpose in life. If costs have gone up those will likely be passed onto the consumer, but that's it.

We're getting hit with huge rising costs because there's a middle man (private energy company) whose purpose in life is to make a profit, and because what they're selling is one of life's basic essentials people don't have the option of saying "no thanks I'll go without". They're not running a public service for the lowest effective price they can. They're running a company to make themselves as much profit as possible.

a loss making nationalised company (like EDF) needs taxpayers to pay for its losses (how else so you think it is funding these losses?). Nationalised companies are also less efficient almost always and so cost the taxpayer.

the current high prices are not due to profits being high (lots of energy suppliers are going bust as they can’t sell even at cost due to price cap) but to high demand for oil and gas globally and low supply.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 14:57

Govt debt to GDP is high in France, Belgium and Italy. You can't borrow indefinitely, at some point that has to be paid back. Or you can raise taxes, but who is going to vote in a government that proposes a tax rate increase?

Increased taxes don't have to come from personal income tax. Companies in general could pay more tax. Some companies that operate in the UK pay very little tax at all. Boots (the chemist) has a HQ in Switzerland and uses this to minimise its UK taxation - £millions a year - despite much of the company's revenue coming from NHS payments. What if the government said "no more NHS business until you relocate your HQ and tax residency to the UK?"

Or look at taxation another way. I live in a EU country that has twice as many doctors per capita as the UK. I can just walk in and see my GP. The local hospital has no waiting list to speak of - when I recently needed a minor operation, it took less than 5 weeks from seeing the GP to seeing a Consultant and then having the operation. I can travel anywhere on public transport for €1 a day on buses and trains that are frequent, reliable and clean. Pre-school nurseries cost less than €100 a month. University education is free. Trainee nurses receive a bursary and have heavily subsidised meals and accommodation (they pay about €30 a month for each).

How much more tax would you be willing to pay to have this in the UK? 1% more on income tax? 1% on Corporation Tax? 1% more on petrol tax? A 1% transaction tax on share dealing. Any or all of these (and other options) would make this possible, but instead of facing up to the inevitable, politicians of all parties are living in denial. The UK got away with it in the 1970s and 1980s by selling off council houses and spaffing North Sea oil revenues on tax cuts. Now that successive governments have sold off almost all of the family silver, there is nothing left to take (except perhaps the bits of the NHS that might turn a profit).
And Truss's great plan for the future? The complete opposite of what is required. Tax cuts - which will inevitably result in cuts to essential services and more problems for the country.

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 14:56

Decidualcast · 29/08/2022 12:19

I was very curious about France, having just visited Paris and Provence. No sign of COL crisis - restaurants were full to the brim, high streets full of (mostly independent shops). It was in very stark contrast to the UK. There is clearly heavy investment in police and transport eg aside from ticket inspectors, there were 4 transport police on my local train to Marseille.

I've been out in Manchester recently; restaurants and shops were overflowing, no CoL crisis here either 🙄 If you look outside of the affluent urban areas you'll find plenty of people struggling, but from what I see daily there is also a large cohort of those who either aren't struggling, or are just ignoring it and spending regardless.

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 14:53

pawkins · 29/08/2022 11:01

As usual on MN such threads turn into anti EU ones. It’s tiresome.

You mean an anti-UK thread suddenly contains some anti-EU comments? Oh, the horror 😱 clutches pearls

EmpressoftheMundane · 29/08/2022 14:46

@gatehouseoffleet There is no point saving energy now that we have no way to save for later. The UK decide to get rid of its natural gas storage in 2017. We didn't want to invest. We are grasshoppers not ants. We only have three or four days capacity. Prices have spiked because Germany is stock piling about 6 weeks worth in preparation for winter. We couldn't do that even if we wanted to.

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/sep/24/how-uk-energy-policies-have-left-britain-exposed-to-winter-gas-price-hikes

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 14:41

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 08:50

@poshme Low unemployment is not necessarily an indicator of economic health.

The UK currently has low unemployment because there is a shortage of workers, over a million EU skilled and willing workers having left since Brexit and another half a million older workers deciding to leave the job market after Covid made them re-assess their lives.

A society cannot lose that many workers without there being a detrimental impact on services and prices. The NHS and social care facilities have 250,000 vacancies. Bus drivers are changing jobs and becoming lorry drivers - resulting in a shortage of bus drivers. The food and drinks industry is short of workers across all stages of the production chain - from fruit pickers to packers and sorters, food factory workers and delivery drivers. All of this has a knock-on effect on prices and availability.

The Government keeps talking about growth, but the UK cannot grow if there are not the workers available, with the skills required, to facilitate this growth.

Pre-Brexit we were told that there were 3.5m EU citizens here. Post-Brexit there are now 2.8m with settled status and 2.3m with pre-settled status. How have we lost over a million? Are you trying to tell us that the Remain campaign lied, and under-estimated the number of EU citizens who were already here?

usernamealreadytaken · 29/08/2022 14:36

maddy68 · 29/08/2022 08:19

The UK is now again the sick man of Europe though chart attached

Not sure where that data came from, but the actual IMF appears to rate the UK as reasonable, currently.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?
To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?
hop321 · 29/08/2022 14:33

But what I can’t really understand is why this is the case - where there low level of taxation in the UK compared to other countries what I find really interesting is the public attitude - I think in many euro countries paying tax is not really seen as such a huge negative.

I think people view paying 50% odd income tax/NI as 'enough'. I do.

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 14:30

@OrangeDuck i don’t recognise that description of Spain. I’m in my mid 30s and of DS’ class’ parents (state school, class of 20) half own their homes including us, 4 rent privately, 1 rents from the council and 5 bought affordable housing from the council (you buy at a very very low price but you can only sell on for the council stipulated price and not profit from it.)

I am in a wealthy area of Spain though, Unemployment rate here is 8.8%. Youth unemployment is higher but they’re all at university or in VET (where they don’t pay tuition) and living at home.

sjxoxo · 29/08/2022 14:13

StepAwayFromGoogling · 29/08/2022 13:53

This, in a nutshell. Govt debt to GDP is high in France, Belgium and Italy. You can't borrow indefinitely, at some point that has to be paid back. Or you can raise taxes, but who is going to vote in a government that proposes a tax rate increase? Ultimately, every country is going to feel the pinch, there's no way around it. You can pay now, or pay later, but you will have to pay.

Absolutely this. But what I can’t really understand is why this is the case - where there low level of taxation in the UK compared to other countries what I find really interesting is the public attitude - I think in many euro countries paying tax is not really seen as such a huge negative. People don’t love it but they’d choose to pay more and have better services for the good of everyone. We don’t choose this in the UK. Why is that? I wonder if it has its roots in the class system, maybe our culture is to always try and get more/more wealth so we don’t want to share if we can avoid it whereas in many other cultures it’s seen as more ‘normal’ to share more of what you have. I don’t know if that’s really correct, it makes some logical sense I feel, but I find this point really interesting. We consistently vote Tory.. we know for most people that’s a crap choice then why do we do it? And ok our system is skewed with First past the post but we obviously don’t care enough to change it or we would have. X

StepAwayFromGoogling · 29/08/2022 13:53

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 12:10

State subsidies have to be paid for by taxation, it's not a magic bullet. Our public debt is enormous so you have to draw the line somewhere. The next generation isn't likely to be enjoying the sunny economic uplands so who do you choose to make the later sacrifice of subsidies now?

UK public debt is enormous, but then UK taxation is low relative to many other EU countries. The government raises too little in tax, but instead of increasing taxes to cover the shortfall, successive governments have gone into denial and have borrowed and managed the money supply in an effort to hide the size of the problem.

At some point in time the government and population is going to be forced to confront the truth that you can't have Rolls-Royce levels of public service (which the UK doesn't have anyway) if you're only willing to pay for a Dacia.

Truss's idea that she can cut taxes and still maintain the current levels of service, poor though they are compared with those in many other countries, makes no financial or social sense.

This, in a nutshell. Govt debt to GDP is high in France, Belgium and Italy. You can't borrow indefinitely, at some point that has to be paid back. Or you can raise taxes, but who is going to vote in a government that proposes a tax rate increase? Ultimately, every country is going to feel the pinch, there's no way around it. You can pay now, or pay later, but you will have to pay.

Eeksteek · 29/08/2022 13:47

OrangeDuck · 29/08/2022 09:22

Question about property. If we should expect going forward it becomes the norm for future generations to not own property and we should prepare them for this - then who does own it?Even if they rent, someone has to own the property for them to rent it from? How does this work in Spain where pp have explained that couples in their 30s etc cannot buy property. Who owns all these properties that they live in? If people cannot afford to buy property what happens when properties are left empty? It's just blowing my mind a bit trying to work out how we would adjust to the new norm being for the next generations to not own property - where will they live if no one can afford property to rent out? Will the government have to provide more council houses again?

I can see that renting will increase but surely we still need people to own the properties to rent out? Is this where the rich can come swooping in and mop up properties and rent out at extortionate prices??

Large corporate companies. They are buying up property from small investors. Limited, so not affected by the tax changes and likely Tory mates like other big businesses, so will be exempt form any future changes too. We are essentially seeing the incorporation of the rental market they way we've seen incorporation of, well, everything else. In future you'll rent from a big chain I imagine.

ToodlePipYouLongHairedGit · 29/08/2022 13:38

QuentininQuarantino · 29/08/2022 11:20

I was in Luxembourg recently, where all public transport has been made completely free for environmental reasons (organised before the energy crisis I think). The infrastructure there was excellent. It was wonderful and strange to just get on a bus or train without a ticket. Of course Luxembourg is a very rich/expensive country...

Is that because Luxembourg does not contribute to the EU budget but one of the big recipients ie they can afford it?

BloodyHellKen · 29/08/2022 13:13

BeanieTeen · 29/08/2022 12:52

I know from friends that things aren't great in Germany - they don't seem to be doom mongering, though.

I found this when I lived in Germany. Obviously you have SM and more ‘tabloid’ type newspapers and shows that are always a bit OTT but in general mainstream news is reported in a very ‘matter of fact’ kind of way with little use of emotive language, it’s also a lot more varied so they don’t linger on one news item for ages eeking out every last drop of drama. I certainly had a level headed approach to current affairs when I was living there. After watching the news in the UK you always feel a bit on high alert, even about the most basic things - remember just a few weeks ago the massive panic build up to our 2 day heatwave? In Germany I imagine it would have been a brief ‘temperatures will be expected to reach 38 degrees on Tuesday in many areas, with some isolated areas reaching up to 40. Experts advise caution and taking measures such as x y and z. Next news item…’ Here it was news item after news item after news item about the impeding hot weather. It was crazy and did send many into a pointless panic.
In the UK the manner of reporting and the sensationalism is more akin to how the US media operates.

I agree @BeanieTeen All the sensationalist news in the UK is very, very irritating. Everything is dramatised and over emotive.

I've just been listening to the R4 lunchtime news and currently affairs programme. It was a drama-fest largely fuelled by the presenter ramping up the hand wringing and emotive language. She even referred to an interviewers children as her 'your babes' at one point just to squeeze out more sympathy and drama 🙄😂

BeanieTeen · 29/08/2022 12:52

I know from friends that things aren't great in Germany - they don't seem to be doom mongering, though.

I found this when I lived in Germany. Obviously you have SM and more ‘tabloid’ type newspapers and shows that are always a bit OTT but in general mainstream news is reported in a very ‘matter of fact’ kind of way with little use of emotive language, it’s also a lot more varied so they don’t linger on one news item for ages eeking out every last drop of drama. I certainly had a level headed approach to current affairs when I was living there. After watching the news in the UK you always feel a bit on high alert, even about the most basic things - remember just a few weeks ago the massive panic build up to our 2 day heatwave? In Germany I imagine it would have been a brief ‘temperatures will be expected to reach 38 degrees on Tuesday in many areas, with some isolated areas reaching up to 40. Experts advise caution and taking measures such as x y and z. Next news item…’ Here it was news item after news item after news item about the impeding hot weather. It was crazy and did send many into a pointless panic.
In the UK the manner of reporting and the sensationalism is more akin to how the US media operates.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 29/08/2022 12:49

Truss's idea that she can cut taxes and still maintain the current levels of service, poor though they are compared with those in many other countries, makes no financial or social sense.
Yes, the Tories' big idea is to cut inefficiency. That's being done by reducing the income of government and local government departments, expecting them to make up the shortfalls from things like business rates. But at the same time, those business rates are falling. The upshot is that all the things that might make a difference like nurses or crime reduction programmes are going. And the government has clung to power long enough that the effects are now being felt. We've got a mountain of social problems as well as Brexit, Covid and general recession problems. The social problems aren't going away any time soon.

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/08/2022 12:46

hop321 · 29/08/2022 10:19

It’s like we no lessons were learned from 14 years of quantative easing, or the inflationary impact of locking up healthy people, paying them to do nothing while stoking demand for goods that are weren’t being produced. Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future. Just like lockdowns were now free and we are paying now through inflation.

I agree. There's no magic money tree. As hard as it is, do we want to subsidise the cost of energy? And add to the debt mountain?

Inflation is a similar issue. If everyone has pay rises at the rate of inflation, it makes it even higher. That stores up major economic problems which have a knock-on impact on employment amongst other things.

It's pretty bleak at the moment and I understand the concern about being able to afford to heat the house etc. But if we take short term populist measures, it's going to get even worse and be a longer-term issue.

What is your suggestion for what the government should do? If we aren’t going to fix the cap or give handouts to people, then what are the other options that you think will go far enough to deal with the problem and stop people’s health deteriorating and the economy from getting trashed because people aren’t spending the money they don’t have.

Truss’s proposed income tax & VAT cuts are woefully inadequate and benefit the rich while doing almost nothing for the poor. I get that at the moment she needs to play to a very small group of Tory voters who are genuinely terrible people but we are facing a winter of power outages and people having to chose between heating and eating. Even those who would normally be considered reasonably OK are going to struggle this winter and the government are missing in action. They have been since January when it became quite clear that they needed a plan.

MarshaBradyo · 29/08/2022 12:34

Decidualcast · 29/08/2022 12:19

I was very curious about France, having just visited Paris and Provence. No sign of COL crisis - restaurants were full to the brim, high streets full of (mostly independent shops). It was in very stark contrast to the UK. There is clearly heavy investment in police and transport eg aside from ticket inspectors, there were 4 transport police on my local train to Marseille.

Central London is packed, tourism type stuff included

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 12:34

gatehouseoffleet · 29/08/2022 12:28

There is an EU-wide agreement to (try to?) cut power usage by 15% by doing things like lowering heating in public buildings and asking shops to turn off lightings (signs/window displays) at night. Switzerland is in on this too, not sure about other EEA countries

The UK needs to do this too. Too many businesses still leaving their lights on overnight. Even if they can currently afford it, it's a moral imperative to save energy as well to avoid running out this winter.

Shops switching off their lights won’t make your energy cheaper.

As has been explained many many many times on the various threads about this topic, you can’t control the price of something your don’t produce, or produce enough of. You can only subsidize it.

Fifife · 29/08/2022 12:33

I thought we already drank recycled water ?!! It's perfectly safe. With climate change we will have to fresh water will be running out.