Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?

238 replies

CanIJustAskAnotherStupidQuestion · 28/08/2022 22:39

I have friends and colleagues in Nordics, Spain, Italy, Germany and they all keep asking what the hell is going on in Britain, with double digit inflation and 80% increases in fuel costs. They don’t seem to be feeling all of this to the same extent.

So why is it happening here, and not so much elsewhere? I know that e.g. France hasn’t been hit with fuel bills for consumers because EDF is nationalised (but presumably that means they will get hit in taxes). But what about elsewhere?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
loveisagirlnameddaisy · 29/08/2022 22:06

AllLopsided · 28/08/2022 23:27

Petrol prices have been capped in France too - it's around €1.70/L where I am.

I think there is a higher cap on gas than electricity - maybe 12%? We pay a fixed amount monthly and there doesn't seem to be a way to find out actual usage. It was already expensive though!

Food costs have gone up - items that were say €2.00 a few months ago are now €2.30. Going up in 5c increments so that we don't notice Confused Food here was already much more expensive than in the U.K.

We will be ordering wood soon - we live in an area with cold winters and lots of people have fireplaces or stoves. My usual supplier has increased the price from 78 last year to 102 this year. I have found another supplier offering it at 90. Still a big increase.

There is an EU-wide agreement to (try to?) cut power usage by 15% by doing things like lowering heating in public buildings and asking shops to turn off lightings (signs/window displays) at night. Switzerland is in on this too, not sure about other EEA countries.

Am envious of the countries with cheaper/free public transport!

I'm on holiday in France now and today paid just over 2 euro per litre of diesel (gazole). What is the capped price?

Capri3 · 29/08/2022 17:07

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 16:37

It was nu Labour under Tony Blair that utterly failed the country in so many ways. Unfortunately the Tories have failed to correct any of the mistakes.

Lest we forget the abysmal mess that Labour created - refusing to build nuclear power stations, creating a low pay culture with tax credits, failing to invest in any infrastructure for this country, selling off the gold reserves, the illegal war. But hey, a few people got some freebies so never mind the long term decline of the country.

You forgot Labour’s ridiculous PFI debt, which means the taxpayer is paying over £300 billion for infrastructure projects worth £54 billion.

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 16:43

In the UK everything seems to be so much more expensive and always has been

This just isn't true. The UK has had the probably cheapest food in Europe for a long time. And our energy costs have been lower than or at least comparative to other EU countries.
I guess if you believe things that aren't true, though, it will skew your view of the country overall.

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 16:39

If a criminal gang has forced you to pay £5,000 up front

First if all, I don't see any mention in any of those articles that anyone was forced to come here

If they've paid up front, there's no debt.

offer your house as security in order to get the job in the UK, the debt is very real and will be enforced.

If they staked their house on it, there's debt but nowhere do I see that they're being forced to work for nothing to work off that debt. Why would they? They'd just take the house and sell it.

It's clear that people are being overcharged by recruitment agencies and that's wrong. But I can't see why that makes them indentured.

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 16:37

Justwantanicepeacfulholiday · 29/08/2022 16:15

We knew 20 years ago we needed to invest in nuclear power. We didn’t. The French did.

It was nu Labour under Tony Blair that utterly failed the country in so many ways. Unfortunately the Tories have failed to correct any of the mistakes.

Lest we forget the abysmal mess that Labour created - refusing to build nuclear power stations, creating a low pay culture with tax credits, failing to invest in any infrastructure for this country, selling off the gold reserves, the illegal war. But hey, a few people got some freebies so never mind the long term decline of the country.

BeanieTeen · 29/08/2022 16:35

Am in Belgium - huge energy rises, petrol, food and so on. The only thing here is public transport is cheaper (€12 for an 18-25 yr old for a year on bus network) , and we have amazing health care! Our energy costs have always been higher than UK ime.

This is my experience too. Energy is going up everywhere but is often mitigated in other countries by the fact that other things are not so expensive. In the UK everything seems to be so much more expensive and always has been.Transport, food and household shopping, house prices, eating out, places like theme parks and zoos are also extortionate compared to what you would pay in other countries. When all of this accumulates, and you add a massive price rise in fuel and energy to the mix it’s going to tip things over the edge very easily.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 16:29

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 16:13

@MsPincher
They’re not indentured as there is no valid debt as you point out in your post above.

If a criminal gang has forced you to pay £5,000 up front or offer your house as security in order to get the job in the UK, the debt is very real and will be enforced.

we are not « importing indentured servants from Asia » at all. There are some criminals carrying on criminal activity in respect of the (very few) people who come to the uk on a seasonal worker visa. It’s not at all what you said.

I wrote "indentured labour" not "servants" and the articles quoted confirm that these people are paying off a debt, illegal or otherwise - the very definition of "indenture". Whether it is a few hundred or a few thousand workers is immaterial - it is happening in a field, care home or factory near you and is both morally and legally unacceptable and the businesses employing these workers are just as complicit as the "agents".

Don’t be silly. You made claims that « we » are importing indentured workers from Asia. In actual fact we are not at all as you are well aware.

There are a lot of different safeguards and laws to stop the sort of criminal activity alleged in those articles you posted (which were reported and at most affected a few hundred people) but of course you can’t stop every crime.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 16:20

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 16:03

@MsPincher
"Of course they should enforce minimum wage laws better but public sector is often inefficient."

The enforcement of immigration and minimum wage laws falls under the Home Office, specifically the Border Force, and HMRC.

You'll recognise both of these as being amongst the government agencies that have been cut and underfunded by May, Johnson and now Rees-Mogg. Far from being "inefficient" they are totally ineffective if they don't have sufficient personnel and funding required in order to do the job.

HMRC enforces the minimum wage (as we are all aware). HMRC have their challenges but are not at all « totally ineffective » Rather they are a huge and very expensive organisation. I would stick with inefficient.

Justwantanicepeacfulholiday · 29/08/2022 16:15

We knew 20 years ago we needed to invest in nuclear power. We didn’t. The French did.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 16:13

@MsPincher
They’re not indentured as there is no valid debt as you point out in your post above.

If a criminal gang has forced you to pay £5,000 up front or offer your house as security in order to get the job in the UK, the debt is very real and will be enforced.

we are not « importing indentured servants from Asia » at all. There are some criminals carrying on criminal activity in respect of the (very few) people who come to the uk on a seasonal worker visa. It’s not at all what you said.

I wrote "indentured labour" not "servants" and the articles quoted confirm that these people are paying off a debt, illegal or otherwise - the very definition of "indenture". Whether it is a few hundred or a few thousand workers is immaterial - it is happening in a field, care home or factory near you and is both morally and legally unacceptable and the businesses employing these workers are just as complicit as the "agents".

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 16:08

@Havanananana
I confess I thought you said that last one was behind a paywall so I didn't open it, but it turns out to be another guardian one.

It says...
Migrant rights experts said the potential to be trapped in debt bondage put workers at risk of essentially forced labour.

So there's potential for it but it's not happened. In fact there's nothing in the report to say anything about them being bound to the agent. One person says they put their land up for collateral. All the complaints are about overcharging. Which is clearly wrong but they're being paid the going rate by their employers here.

And you also say that the govt is not investigating when it's quite clear from that report that it is being investigated, both here and in Indonesia.

belge2 · 29/08/2022 16:07

Am in Belgium - huge energy rises, petrol, food and so on. The only thing here is public transport is cheaper (€12 for an 18-25 yr old for a year on bus network) , and we have amazing health care! Our energy costs have always been higher than UK ime.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 16:03

@MsPincher
"Of course they should enforce minimum wage laws better but public sector is often inefficient."

The enforcement of immigration and minimum wage laws falls under the Home Office, specifically the Border Force, and HMRC.

You'll recognise both of these as being amongst the government agencies that have been cut and underfunded by May, Johnson and now Rees-Mogg. Far from being "inefficient" they are totally ineffective if they don't have sufficient personnel and funding required in order to do the job.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:59

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:54

@MarshaMelrose

They are indentured, or bonded - as in they are bound to the Agent for the period that it takes to pay off the (illegal) debt. The fact that they being paid a subsistence wage does not mean that they are free of the debt or the contract.

From Webster's dictionary:
Definition of indentured:

  • required by contract to work for another for a certain period of time

www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/indonesia-to-investigate-claims-fruit-pickers-charged-thousands-to-work-in-kent/ar-AA11ejHw?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=ee1a5a4f81c1328dfdd49b8853d1b7ea

They’re not indentured as there is no valid debt as you point out in your post above.

we are not « importing indentured servants from Asia » at all. There are some criminals carrying on criminal activity in respect of the (very few) people who come to the uk on a seasonal worker visa. It’s not at all what you said.

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:55

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:32

@MarshaMelrose
"We're not paying Asian people who work here?"

They, and people from elsewhere, are being paid but the Government is turning a blind eye to how they are being exploited by "Agents" and only being paid a fraction of their wages, as well as being charged illegal recruitment fees.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/apr/19/ukrainian-workers-flee-modern-slavery-conditions-on-uk-farms

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/may/27/migrant-fruit-pickers-charged-thousands-in-fees-to-work-on-uk-farms-investigation-shows

www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/how-nurses-recruited-from-zimbabwe-are-being-caught-in-uk-bonded-labour-schemes/ar-AA11boCI?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=d0da13e82b310e01c0995307b7747ef0

(The last report is from the Telegraph but is behind a paywall on their site)

Lol. The government has actually cut right down on permitted migration (I don’t personally think that’s a good thing as a second generation migrant). There’s no evidence at all that they are deliberately turning a blind eye to anything.

Of course they should enforce minimum wage laws better but public sector is often inefficient.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:54

@MarshaMelrose

They are indentured, or bonded - as in they are bound to the Agent for the period that it takes to pay off the (illegal) debt. The fact that they being paid a subsistence wage does not mean that they are free of the debt or the contract.

From Webster's dictionary:
Definition of indentured:

  • required by contract to work for another for a certain period of time

www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/indonesia-to-investigate-claims-fruit-pickers-charged-thousands-to-work-in-kent/ar-AA11ejHw?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=ee1a5a4f81c1328dfdd49b8853d1b7ea

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 15:53

MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 15:39

They, and people from elsewhere, are being paid.

So not indentured then. Rather, underpaid.

I should have read those two articles before commenting!
The first one is nothing to do with money. The woman didn't like the conditions and is now working here illegally.
The second one is being overcharging for recruitment. But they're paid the going rate while they're here and I can't see where the company they worked for kept money back to pay off their debts. It looks to me like like she paid the amount upfront. The recruitment agency has wrongly taken advantage of her but you can't say any of this is indentured labour.

hop321 · 29/08/2022 15:49

a loss making nationalised company (like EDF) needs taxpayers to pay for its losses (how else so you think it is funding these losses?). *

True - but it doesn't mean that the shortfall has to come from income tax. There are company taxes, capital gains taxes, luxury taxes and transaction taxes too.*

All of which are taxes and most of which are personal taxes. Back to the same point of it having to be paid for by somebody.

Even raising corporation tax isn't a clear cut positive. You end up disincentivising some of the big corporations from locating in the U.K. Not only does the government end up with a net loss in corporation tax revenue but there's a knock-on impact on employment, and by extension, revenue from income tax too.

Energy prices are sky high due to global supply and demand, not helped by war in Ukraine. It's not specific to the U.K. Economically there's not a magic fix without a corresponding burden to the tax payer, in the short term at least (granted that alternative energy may be the answer in the future),

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:47

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:17

a loss making nationalised company (like EDF) needs taxpayers to pay for its losses (how else so you think it is funding these losses?).

True - but it doesn't mean that the shortfall has to come from income tax. There are company taxes, capital gains taxes, luxury taxes and transaction taxes too.

Nationalised companies are also less efficient almost always and so cost the taxpayer.

This is only an opinion. An alternative view is that private utilities are less desirable because they extract a dividend or profit instead of returning any "profit" to the consumers in the form of lower prices, increased investment (or both), and that earning a profit on essential services is fundamentally unethical.

Regardless of which tax is paying for it, loss making nationalised companies need to be subsidized by the taxpayer. They are taking money that would otherwise go to schools and hospitals, etc.

Why is that a good idea to give money to ALL energy consumers when the vast majority of energy consumers are not poor?

its not an opinion that privatised energy companies are more efficient. It’s a fact borne out of decades of studies. Efficiency itself brings lower prices. I don’t see that making a profit out of energy is immoral - people make profit out of healthcare, food, transport and so on.

And anyway as the prices they can charge for domestic energy are regulated there is a balance of interests.

jcyclops · 29/08/2022 15:43

This shows inflation in EU countries for July, using HICP which is directly comparable to our CPI. The EU average is 9.8% and the UK is 10.1% - very close to the average.
UK would be 17th in this list just below Belgium (10.4%) and also below Spain (10.7%) and Netherlands (11.6%).

To ask what the rest of (geographic) Europe are doing differently?
MarshaMelrose · 29/08/2022 15:39

They, and people from elsewhere, are being paid.

So not indentured then. Rather, underpaid.

Havanananana · 29/08/2022 15:32

@MarshaMelrose
"We're not paying Asian people who work here?"

They, and people from elsewhere, are being paid but the Government is turning a blind eye to how they are being exploited by "Agents" and only being paid a fraction of their wages, as well as being charged illegal recruitment fees.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/apr/19/ukrainian-workers-flee-modern-slavery-conditions-on-uk-farms

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/may/27/migrant-fruit-pickers-charged-thousands-in-fees-to-work-on-uk-farms-investigation-shows

www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/how-nurses-recruited-from-zimbabwe-are-being-caught-in-uk-bonded-labour-schemes/ar-AA11boCI?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=d0da13e82b310e01c0995307b7747ef0

(The last report is from the Telegraph but is behind a paywall on their site)

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 15:25

sst1234 · 29/08/2022 10:15

This thread is indicative of overly simplistic thinking. Sometimes understandably in times of crisis.

The fact that we are applauding any country for giving freebies and nationalising energy that it doesn’t produce (thereby subsidising it) shows a complete lack of understanding of the economy works.

It’s like we no lessons were learned from 14 years of quantative easing, or the inflationary impact of locking up healthy people, paying them to do nothing while stoking demand for goods that are weren’t being produced. Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future. Just like lockdowns were now free and we are paying now through inflation.

This. And things like free train travel or subsidized energy for all regardless of income is a very costly bribe.

JuvenileEmu · 29/08/2022 15:20

ToodlePipYouLongHairedGit · 29/08/2022 13:38

Is that because Luxembourg does not contribute to the EU budget but one of the big recipients ie they can afford it?

No, but I think being a tax haven probably helps them income wise Hmm

DitzyBluebells · 29/08/2022 15:17

hop321 · 29/08/2022 10:19

It’s like we no lessons were learned from 14 years of quantative easing, or the inflationary impact of locking up healthy people, paying them to do nothing while stoking demand for goods that are weren’t being produced. Nationalising energy and giving out freebies like free train travel now is nothing short of bribery to people who refuse to understand how the economy works. Nationalisation means you pay in the future. Just like lockdowns were now free and we are paying now through inflation.

I agree. There's no magic money tree. As hard as it is, do we want to subsidise the cost of energy? And add to the debt mountain?

Inflation is a similar issue. If everyone has pay rises at the rate of inflation, it makes it even higher. That stores up major economic problems which have a knock-on impact on employment amongst other things.

It's pretty bleak at the moment and I understand the concern about being able to afford to heat the house etc. But if we take short term populist measures, it's going to get even worse and be a longer-term issue.

I think it's maybe to do with where abouts you are on humanity's food chain. I see your perspective, but at the same time I'm basically reading it as "sacrifice the poor so the not-as-poor have a better chance of survival" because that's what's going to happen if people go without help, hypothermia and illness because they can't afford heating, starving because they can't afford food, homeless because they can't afford housing, jobless because all these things affect ones ability to perform well at work.