Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I have outgrown men

580 replies

Namechanged007 · 28/08/2022 22:16

Before all the namalt brigade come along I'm well aware.

Thing is it's true I have outgrown the ridiculouness and childishness of men.

I'm married but even so I feel like I'd be better off alone most of the time. Nothing wrong with dh as such but I'm more able and stronger alone.

I have just been to the pub and all the women were complimentary of each other. Going with the flow. And enjoying themselves. The men were either grumpy or showing brovado. There was an incident on our table that involved new men intimidating each other and I just went home.

The thing is this isn't a table of young men. It's professionals and grown ups. I just cant be bothered with it.

None of the women got involved but it spoilt the night.

I told dh I don't have time for such pathetic behaviour.

It never ends. It doesn't matter how old or wise we become men seem to revert back to this strange behaviour.

I deal with it day in day out at my work and I simply can't be bothered. If I never had to see another man, mansplaining, dominating conversation, throwing their weight around, bravado, dick measuring, causing a scene in my life it would be too soon.

Absolutely done with it.

OP posts:
WorkHardPlayHard1 · 31/08/2022 21:42

justasking111 · 28/08/2022 23:19

We've tried as a group of women friends to invite the men along. It doesn't really work. They're so busy Willy waving talking over each other. Politics, sports, etc they've got all the answers. They're confrontational rather than empathic it's very boring

Today at an event sat next to my OH four times I thought he had finished talking. So I started to say something to the woman opposite, four times he started up again like a chainsaw. In the end I just rolled my eyes and shrugged making a chatting endlessly sign with my hand.

I'd have talked over him so he got the message but I am 50 and couldn't care less any more!! 😘

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 21:33

Well, it was just an example - nevertheless, in the context of the thread, it seems that women in marriages or LTR are having experiences that puts them off repeating it (and they had relationships before marriage so they aren't going this is a one off). And women initiate most divorces, and are more reluctant to remarry whereas men are keen.

I think that is not children, but domestics, social expectations which benefit men more. They get more out of it. It doesn't surprise me that as women get their own money, they are much choosier about men, to the point where they don't see the benefit. Women do better at building a social circle, living alone.

I think young men will also change - they will not have the expectations their fathers did, nor the same example. Living alone by men and women will grow, I think.

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 21:27

@LexMitior

But that's not what posters or the very limited research they're using to back themselves up on are saying

Of course miserable people who want a divorce will be happier post divorce

That's basic common sense

Just like people with leg cramp are happier once their cramp is gone

That doesn't however = women are happier without men

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 21:25

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 21:15

I think there's a bit of evidence that women who have been married, or in similar long relationships are happier on divorce. Women get more unhappy the longer they are married, in other words.

So having a long term (heterosexual) relationship does seem to put women off men, and they report being happier when they are single after they are out of marriage. Which is what a lot of posters here have said, in effect. Some of them are even saying it and they are still married....

I don't think its bad thing, because it suggests women are getting much choosier.

No shit Sherlock

People who want a divorce are happier post divorce

Confused
LexMitior · 31/08/2022 21:15

I think there's a bit of evidence that women who have been married, or in similar long relationships are happier on divorce. Women get more unhappy the longer they are married, in other words.

So having a long term (heterosexual) relationship does seem to put women off men, and they report being happier when they are single after they are out of marriage. Which is what a lot of posters here have said, in effect. Some of them are even saying it and they are still married....

I don't think its bad thing, because it suggests women are getting much choosier.

AgnestaVipers · 31/08/2022 20:55

You clearly don't read Mumsnet much.

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 20:47

AgnestaVipers · 31/08/2022 20:42

So being with a man isn't the cause of married womens dissatisfaction.

Except for all the women who say it is.

I can well believe that children don't make life fun. They are hugely overrated and for long periods of time, boring or unpleasant.

What makes heterosexual marriage difficult for women is that they often discover that their husband is just another child who they have to manage.

And which women are they?

Women in relationships (other than marriage) with men aren't less happy than single women

Married Women with children are found (on a small scale) to be less happy than single women

Both men and women with children are less happy than children men and women

What is so hard to understand?

The difference is the children

Not the marriage

AgnestaVipers · 31/08/2022 20:42

So being with a man isn't the cause of married womens dissatisfaction.

Except for all the women who say it is.

I can well believe that children don't make life fun. They are hugely overrated and for long periods of time, boring or unpleasant.

What makes heterosexual marriage difficult for women is that they often discover that their husband is just another child who they have to manage.

LittleSid · 31/08/2022 20:41

Annieisalright · 28/08/2022 22:58

And the common denominator in all these relationships?

Would that be you perhaps?

The common denominator is possibly that with the ending of each shitty relationship, her standards have risen considerably higher.

And fair fucking play to her! 💜

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 20:24

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 20:22

Marriage is for children really. And maybe most of the labour related to children falls on the woman.Really, that's about the core relationship about who does what, not children. Until that time, you can sort of pretend that your marriage makes you more committed than people who aren't, which is true in the legal sense, but in any other way, its just still people making promises. Thats acknowledged in the last bit:

Getting married won’t automatically make you a happy person. In fact, you can gain similar benefits from other kinds of relationships with friends and relatives. In building a happier life, both women and men all have something better than magic. We have the ability to learn the specific skills we need to forge and maintain better relationships of all kinds.

Except it's not

Many married childless couples are happier than their peers with children

The studies used by the miserable on here to claim validity in their view that women are less happy when married aren't valid due to this issue

Also studies into women in relationships also doesn't find they're less happy than married women

So being with a man isn't the cause of married womens dissatisfaction

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 20:22

Marriage is for children really. And maybe most of the labour related to children falls on the woman.Really, that's about the core relationship about who does what, not children. Until that time, you can sort of pretend that your marriage makes you more committed than people who aren't, which is true in the legal sense, but in any other way, its just still people making promises. Thats acknowledged in the last bit:

Getting married won’t automatically make you a happy person. In fact, you can gain similar benefits from other kinds of relationships with friends and relatives. In building a happier life, both women and men all have something better than magic. We have the ability to learn the specific skills we need to forge and maintain better relationships of all kinds.

AgnestaVipers · 31/08/2022 20:18

@DaughterofBrum , "God give me the confidence of a mediocre male."

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 20:09

@LexMitior

Men being annoying doesn't make the 'married women are less happy' trope true

There are long term studies showing the opposite

The only research showing married women are less happy is continually criticized based on methodology and the fact all of that very small sample size of women had children

Children are known to make both men and women less happy

Odds are it's the kids

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 20:08

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 20:02

Here is a more accessible article for you and a snippet to help, since you're not capable of Independant research

Since you linked to an article from "The Greater Good Magazine", which appears to have a rather pseudo scientific agenda of its own, I'm not sure you're all that great with 'Independant' research yourself.

Why so rude?

The links to the studies are included in said article

It's not rude to point out laziness

People are posting very biased 'research' on here to back up their bias

Which is expected but come on, at least engage your brain a little bit before doing so

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 20:07

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:56

Here is a more accessible article for you and a snippet to help, since you're not capable of Independant research

All of the studies listed here saying married women are worse off than single women (very few of them actually, most online is just reposting of the same few) were done on small sample size and the methodology has been continually criticized. Most are done via phone calls and all were women with children. Again, since studies show childless people are happier than those with children, it's most likely having children that's the key factor in those marriage studies parroted on here.

'According to science, no. Historically, large studies show that, on average, married people report greater happiness later in life than unmarried people. Separated and divorced people tend to fall into a less-happy bucket, while the never-married and widowed fall someplace in between. Studies also report upticks in happiness in the lead-up to weddings and just afterthe so-called “honeymoon effect”though this benefit to happiness gradually wanes to slightly above pre-wedding levels over time. These positive effects of marriage on happiness are there for both women and men.'

https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/ismarriageereallybaddforwomenss_happiness

But the rest of the article puts a much greater degree of context around it, and rather supports the OP's point? The boorishness nature of the men that she encounters has put her off. The article is good, because its pointing out what people don't like, and perhaps men are more guilty of not meeting these requirements.

After elementary school, skills that help us form, strengthen, and sustain long-term social bonds—like empathic listening, expressing gratitude, or forgiveness—are rarely practiced. We mostly assume these abilities will arise with maturity.

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 20:02

Here is a more accessible article for you and a snippet to help, since you're not capable of Independant research

Since you linked to an article from "The Greater Good Magazine", which appears to have a rather pseudo scientific agenda of its own, I'm not sure you're all that great with 'Independant' research yourself.

Why so rude?

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:56

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 19:48

All the studies into this issue saying women are better off without men are specifically married women WITH children

They're also snapshot studies, so some will have been married a few years others decades

Long term studies show the opposite, and follow couples throughout and sample every few years

Have you got current, accessible links supporting these claims?

Here is a more accessible article for you and a snippet to help, since you're not capable of Independant research

All of the studies listed here saying married women are worse off than single women (very few of them actually, most online is just reposting of the same few) were done on small sample size and the methodology has been continually criticized. Most are done via phone calls and all were women with children. Again, since studies show childless people are happier than those with children, it's most likely having children that's the key factor in those marriage studies parroted on here.

'According to science, no. Historically, large studies show that, on average, married people report greater happiness later in life than unmarried people. Separated and divorced people tend to fall into a less-happy bucket, while the never-married and widowed fall someplace in between. Studies also report upticks in happiness in the lead-up to weddings and just afterthe so-called “honeymoon effect”though this benefit to happiness gradually wanes to slightly above pre-wedding levels over time. These positive effects of marriage on happiness are there for both women and men.'

https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/ismarriageereallybaddforwomenss_happiness

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 19:48

All the studies into this issue saying women are better off without men are specifically married women WITH children

They're also snapshot studies, so some will have been married a few years others decades

Long term studies show the opposite, and follow couples throughout and sample every few years

Have you got current, accessible links supporting these claims?

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:47

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 19:41

Isn't that study old (2005) and the newer study confirms the single women are happier than those married?

The long term study copied is indeed from 2005

However the studies parroted on here are for women with children

They're also snapshot studies, not done over a length of time

Considering studies also show Childless men and women are happier than their child having counterparts, it's more likely it's the children dragging the married women down on the studies mentioned thus far. Over the spouse

YouAreNotBatman · 31/08/2022 19:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:46

@IcedPurple

The full data set is split by sex

All the studies into this issue saying women are better off without men are specifically married women WITH children

They're also snapshot studies, so some will have been married a few years others decades

Long term studies show the opposite, and follow couples throughout and sample every few years

Considering childless men and women are happier than those with children the likely hood is, it's the children dragging the married women down in the studies you parrot on here

LexMitior · 31/08/2022 19:41

Isn't that study old (2005) and the newer study confirms the single women are happier than those married?

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 19:41

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:36

Except that's not true

The studies cited are on married women with children

Long term studies have actually found the opposite, that those married are happier than their single counterparts (both men and women)

journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0265407505056438

It's most likely the issue is the children over the husband

I can't access that study, but it refers to 'individuals', not women.

brookstar · 31/08/2022 19:41

I am very happily married, my DH is fab and we have a great relationship.
However, I've said to DH that if I were to ever find myself single I probably wouldn't have a relationship with another man. He gets it and doesn't blame me.

PainsandAches · 31/08/2022 19:36

IcedPurple · 31/08/2022 19:20

What is it with this place and insist that single women so happy and married women miserable?

It's not 'this place'. Study after study has shown that life satisfaction declines for women after marriage, while the opposite is true for men.

That's not to say that there aren't plenty of happy married women, but as a general rule, it seems to be the case that single women are happier than married women.

Except that's not true

The studies cited are on married women with children

Long term studies have actually found the opposite, that those married are happier than their single counterparts (both men and women)

journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0265407505056438

It's most likely the issue is the children over the husband

Swipe left for the next trending thread