Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were the PM what would you do to fix the mess we are in?

294 replies

HoppingKangaroo · 28/08/2022 19:59

Just that really, if you were the prime minister what would you do to help fix the country and the cost of living crisis.

OP posts:
TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:11

Lurkerlot · 28/08/2022 20:08

I was reading this thinking how bonkers it was then I got to the end and it all made sense: the delusional Richard Murphy strikes again!

ohffsomg · 28/08/2022 22:07

Increase benefits for the poorest families

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:05

WhatTheFlap · 28/08/2022 22:03

Someone called into LBC with some amazing recommendations - link below.

For anyone who hasn’t got time to watch:

  1. Cut the personal income tax limit down to zero for anyone earning £100k or above for 2 years - would cost them all around £2.5k per year overall but raise £6bn
  2. Companies with earnings over £100k would have their taxes raised from 19% to 21% for 1 year, also bringing in £6bn
  3. Windfall taxes on energy companies to raise another £6bn and give £2k to all households

Link here

It’s not amazing. It Mickey Mouse economics. People’s frustration with the current situation is understandable but fantasy’s economics won’t improve the situation.

WhatTheFlap · 28/08/2022 22:03

Someone called into LBC with some amazing recommendations - link below.

For anyone who hasn’t got time to watch:

  1. Cut the personal income tax limit down to zero for anyone earning £100k or above for 2 years - would cost them all around £2.5k per year overall but raise £6bn
  2. Companies with earnings over £100k would have their taxes raised from 19% to 21% for 1 year, also bringing in £6bn
  3. Windfall taxes on energy companies to raise another £6bn and give £2k to all households

Link here

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 22:02

Charley50 · 28/08/2022 20:15

Big tax on wealthy individuals. Wealth inequality has gone too far. The rich should bear this.
Privatise energy industry.

Why would you privatise the energy industry? The public purse doesn't have enough to make the investments necessary to install the GW we need.

Privatising energy is easy to say, gains votes from the masses that don't think it through / understand it.

Grumpybutfunny · 28/08/2022 22:01

Invest in sustainable and self sufficiency with regards to energy. Tax free solar, heat pumps with low interest loans to fund it and look to grow our nuclear power options. In the mean time I would also look to extend the price cap to cover businesses. It would be great if we could come up with a system where everyone got a normal amount of gas and electric at a reasonable price and anything above was charged at say 3x the cap to discourage excessive usage.

Prioritise spending on health and education by capping benefits at X number of months/years then make work schemes mandatory. I would also make private pension contributions and income protection mandatory as this is one of our biggest expenses as a country. We should provide significant tax reliefs for companies that fund private healthcare and discounted childcare for their workers.

Look at the pay of the public sector and ensure they are inline with equivalent private sector salaries to aid retention. Would also look to cut student loan contribution or total write off for those who go into the public sector.

I do like Liz to an extent other than her desire to fund a lot of her cuts from the public sector as I think this will just make the staffing crisis worse. I would like to see the standards remain with maybe reduced access for those that don't contribute to the system.

I would love to see a easy online system where the general population can vote on significant issues e.g. the lock downs and the options to tackle the energy crisis.

Inextremis · 28/08/2022 21:59

BorgQueen · 28/08/2022 21:52

Yes, the country really needs more mental health problems caused by cannabis, including the mental impact of having to smell the vile stench of people smoking it.

I'm not sure that more people would smoke the stuff (I don't, btw) - anyone who wants it can easily get hold of it right now. It's ubiquitous. Legalising and taxing would do more good than harm, I think.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 21:59

Skinnermarink · 28/08/2022 20:05

Sort childcare out properly. Pay nursery workers properly. Stop rinsing parents that don’t have another option but to use it so they can work. Maybe nationalise it in some way, so the standard and pricing is similar across the whole board.

100% agree sorting our childcare system is a necessity - should help boast the economy no end. I think the stats compared to other countries are crazy in terms of what we pay!

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 21:58

meow1989 · 28/08/2022 20:02

Higher taxes on the highest earners as a starter for 10 that would make a pretty decent impact all round.

Why should only they bear the brunt? I don't get it, why does everyone want to tax those that have more than them. Is it jealousy? Surely equality is everyone being in it together - not some people having to bear the brunt and pick up the costs of all.

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 21:57

sst1234
Increase places/funding for teaching and medicine degrees by 25% with the stipulation that candidates need to pay back if they leave before they get a certain pay scale in their professional role or before certain number of years.

I would go a couple of steps further. in that teaching and medicine courses would be free, payback fees etc. if you drop out of uni, but you have to work in a specific area of the country for 5 years you can apply to move if needed (housing included at a discounted rate possibly free) if you leave before a set time scale you also pay it back.

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 21:57

Nancydrawn · 28/08/2022 21:46

Who do you think is going to work at and/or run the creative and entertainment studios if you get rid of all university funding for anything but STEM?

I agree that there's some economic naïveté on this thread. But the technocratic obsession also doesn't work if there's a national collapse in retail and services in the next three years due to the majority of disposable income paying towards energy costs. The long-term shift towards the minimum wage of £15 does absolutely nothing for the pinch of this winter. And there have been plenty of occasions where higher taxation (though I'm more in favor of wealth than income) and borrowing have saved the day, not crashed the system. Saying it hasn't is just as naïve.

No one, literally no one needs more media studies graduates, or whatever the equivalent pointless degrees are nowadays. The only professions crying out for skilled workers are STEM related, even the film studios. High taxation is a sticking plaster that peels off within hours leaving a nasty leaking wound. It never solves anything. Just ask Macron.

PoseyFlump · 28/08/2022 21:55

Lurkerlot · 28/08/2022 20:08

Thanks for posting @Lurkerlot

Thirty pages but well worth a read. I feel like I now understand what is happening, why and what is likely to happen.

BorgQueen · 28/08/2022 21:52

Yes, the country really needs more mental health problems caused by cannabis, including the mental impact of having to smell the vile stench of people smoking it.

Inextremis · 28/08/2022 21:49

Legalise and tax cannabis and its derivatives. Whole new stream of income for the government, and reduced pressure on the police and courts.

Well, it's a thought :)

Nancydrawn · 28/08/2022 21:46

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 21:31

This thread is like reading year 5 economics, if they taught economics in primary school.

Lets start with the economy since the magic money tree aka high taxation, money printing and high borrowing always leads to disaster.

Preferential tax rates for tech and finance startups listing on FTSE. R&D investment above £1bn to be matched by 25% by govt. Incentivise infrastructure investment with tax breaks for projects above £1bn and completing before 2030. 0 tax on creative industries to accelerate the growth of foreign investment in UK based entertainment studios. Accelerate free trade negotiations with China, joining of NAFTA and ASEAN. Relax immigration rules for STEM sectors where incoming workers are earning £50k or more. Give the green light to 3rd runway at Heathrow and find a team that can run this airport effectively. 0 tax on all startups and corporations investing in electric battery manufacturing in the UK.

Target 2% inflation and bake into legislation the following from 2024 - minimum wage to increase to £15 by 2026. Personal allowance to increase to £15k by 2025. Reduce top rate to 40%.

Start shale extraction in the short term, 3 additional Sizewell C sized nuclear power stations to be online by 2028. Accelerate Shetlands isle offshore wind project. Offshore wind expansion to conincide with Decommission of nuclear power stations.

Increase places/funding for teaching and medicine degrees by 25% with the stipulation that candidates need to pay back if they leave before they get a certainpay scale in their professional role or before certain number of years. Remove subsidies from all university education that isn’t STEM and redirect to STEM.

Who do you think is going to work at and/or run the creative and entertainment studios if you get rid of all university funding for anything but STEM?

I agree that there's some economic naïveté on this thread. But the technocratic obsession also doesn't work if there's a national collapse in retail and services in the next three years due to the majority of disposable income paying towards energy costs. The long-term shift towards the minimum wage of £15 does absolutely nothing for the pinch of this winter. And there have been plenty of occasions where higher taxation (though I'm more in favor of wealth than income) and borrowing have saved the day, not crashed the system. Saying it hasn't is just as naïve.

HappyHappyHermit · 28/08/2022 21:46

If I was a Tory PM I'd tell people not to be so stupid as to vote for me and my ridiculous party.

PhoneyM · 28/08/2022 21:46

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 21:31

This thread is like reading year 5 economics, if they taught economics in primary school.

Lets start with the economy since the magic money tree aka high taxation, money printing and high borrowing always leads to disaster.

Preferential tax rates for tech and finance startups listing on FTSE. R&D investment above £1bn to be matched by 25% by govt. Incentivise infrastructure investment with tax breaks for projects above £1bn and completing before 2030. 0 tax on creative industries to accelerate the growth of foreign investment in UK based entertainment studios. Accelerate free trade negotiations with China, joining of NAFTA and ASEAN. Relax immigration rules for STEM sectors where incoming workers are earning £50k or more. Give the green light to 3rd runway at Heathrow and find a team that can run this airport effectively. 0 tax on all startups and corporations investing in electric battery manufacturing in the UK.

Target 2% inflation and bake into legislation the following from 2024 - minimum wage to increase to £15 by 2026. Personal allowance to increase to £15k by 2025. Reduce top rate to 40%.

Start shale extraction in the short term, 3 additional Sizewell C sized nuclear power stations to be online by 2028. Accelerate Shetlands isle offshore wind project. Offshore wind expansion to conincide with Decommission of nuclear power stations.

Increase places/funding for teaching and medicine degrees by 25% with the stipulation that candidates need to pay back if they leave before they get a certainpay scale in their professional role or before certain number of years. Remove subsidies from all university education that isn’t STEM and redirect to STEM.

This 👏🏻

Unphased · 28/08/2022 21:45

Please can the people that suggest we rejoin the EU, if we rejoined tomorrow, tell me in what way will that possibly make any difference to the cost of living crisis we are in now, Energy prices rising etc,

absolutelyanythingwilldo · 28/08/2022 21:44

Begin renationalisation of water and rail. Energy I do not think should be renationalised as there is genuine competition in the market but the government should fully fund and run more nuclear power stations as a cash cow to the public purse and restrict foreign investment in British infrastructure.

Bring building regs up to near Passivhaus standards so all new builds are generating renewable power and are super insulated.

MushMonster · 28/08/2022 21:44

I 100% agree with regulating the wages and benefits that MP get.
Also, if you are a MP, that is it! That is your job, you will turn up for work each day and be subjected to performance reviews and targets setting.

breatheinskipthegym · 28/08/2022 21:37

Increase minimum wage significantly, and introduce rent controls with no loopholes. These should mean that no-one who works full time, even at minimum wage, should also have to claim benefits. Allow SMEs a tax relief for a limited time to offset this, if they can demonstrate that they cannot operate at a profit by paying wages in line with cost of living.

Invest heavily in education, early years, childcare and social care. Employees in this sector should be highly trained, well-remunerated and recognised for their value and professionalism. These services should be accessible to all, and to a high standard. Same with healthcare.

Don’t renationalise utilities and rail, but impose strict operating conditions and minimum standards of performance, else they lose their licence to operate, including controls on profits and dividends. Innovation is to encouraged in these industries, but they currently have us, the consumer, by the balls with their high prices & mega profits combo and the shifting of the price cap means they’re virtually a monopoly. Our government are toothless in this (as they are with many issues) and must take a firm stance. (See also the issues around water/sewage).

Increase the financial support given to disabled people and to their carers. £300 carers allowance does not make up for lost earnings of a person unable to work due to caring responsibilities, and a disabled person’s carer being so stretched and undervalued is suboptimal to both.

Enforce child maintenance collection. Vastly improve the level of service given by the CMA, and ensure non-payment is investigated and explored robustly. Would eradicate swathes of universal credit claims and improve outcomes for children.

Tax the wealthy.

Reverse the decision not to investigate covid-related fraud and what I’ll generously call underperformed contracts. Claw back money spent on unusable PPE, fraudulently claimed loans etc.

Measures to ensure MPs behave ethically, including disallowing second jobs, more stringent requirements for personal finances (tax affairs, donations, and suchlike). Second homes allowed where this is very clearly justified, but all travel/rented accommodation/hotel expenditure to be modest and subject to spending limits. Subsidised canteen fine, but a typical work canteen, not the excessively luxurious facilities they currently have.

Absolutely no drinking on the job for MPs. In-house bar scrapped immediately.

Reverse Brexit. End our onward human-trafficking, ie forwarding refugees to Rwanda. Highly consider universal basic income, perhaps modified so offered to all with earnings below say £60k. Scrap work coaches and the like, as admin costs of benefits is excessive.

This would result in increased consumer spending and increased savings (therefore interest) and increase the public purse. Educate the public at large that actually levelling up all of society by ensuring they have high enough quality and quantity of facilities, safety nets and public services, actually reduces the numbers of poor and vulnerable in generations that follow, and this improves society for everyone (including the wealthy, healthy and self-sufficient).

Flapjacker48 · 28/08/2022 21:33

In the 70s, The PM (Heath) had the chairmen of BP and Shell into Downing St and pleaded with them to help reduce power costs. It was not possible - even bearing in mind a huge part of BP was owned by the state at this time.

MushMonster · 28/08/2022 21:33

@BluebelllsRosesDaffodills did ypu jyst say get rid of maternity and paternity pay?
Population is already in decline in western countries, by the way.
There is a point whete there is not enough young people to pay for the system for the retired people. Some countries are rather close to it. Immigration is needed in those cases.
I do not think we need to punish people for the natural desire to have children. Children are not the cause of our issues.
But if the solution to all this is depopulation of the world, then for me, it is not worthy. Why should I bother for a world that has no future?

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 21:31

This thread is like reading year 5 economics, if they taught economics in primary school.

Lets start with the economy since the magic money tree aka high taxation, money printing and high borrowing always leads to disaster.

Preferential tax rates for tech and finance startups listing on FTSE. R&D investment above £1bn to be matched by 25% by govt. Incentivise infrastructure investment with tax breaks for projects above £1bn and completing before 2030. 0 tax on creative industries to accelerate the growth of foreign investment in UK based entertainment studios. Accelerate free trade negotiations with China, joining of NAFTA and ASEAN. Relax immigration rules for STEM sectors where incoming workers are earning £50k or more. Give the green light to 3rd runway at Heathrow and find a team that can run this airport effectively. 0 tax on all startups and corporations investing in electric battery manufacturing in the UK.

Target 2% inflation and bake into legislation the following from 2024 - minimum wage to increase to £15 by 2026. Personal allowance to increase to £15k by 2025. Reduce top rate to 40%.

Start shale extraction in the short term, 3 additional Sizewell C sized nuclear power stations to be online by 2028. Accelerate Shetlands isle offshore wind project. Offshore wind expansion to conincide with Decommission of nuclear power stations.

Increase places/funding for teaching and medicine degrees by 25% with the stipulation that candidates need to pay back if they leave before they get a certainpay scale in their professional role or before certain number of years. Remove subsidies from all university education that isn’t STEM and redirect to STEM.

100problems · 28/08/2022 21:27

Scrap Ofsted

Return to a system where every child goes to their nearest school

Empower Headteachers to know what's the best way to run their school and give them more straightforward ways to fund it

Build more and better facilities for the children that cannot access mainstream education

Scrap Ofgen

Drag every CEO of every energy company into a room and make them come up with creative ways to unpick this ridiculous situation we are facing or face draconian fines for operating in this market

Publish which are and which are not prepared to dig us out of this shitshow