Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were the PM what would you do to fix the mess we are in?

294 replies

HoppingKangaroo · 28/08/2022 19:59

Just that really, if you were the prime minister what would you do to help fix the country and the cost of living crisis.

OP posts:
Liebig · 28/08/2022 22:41

Ladybyrd · 28/08/2022 22:39

It isn't an ordinary recession. It is triggered by unaffordable fuel prices so that's what they need to concentrate on. And I don't mean "naming and shaming" fuel companies that don't pass on the paltry 5p fuel tax cut. I mean putting in place mandates and levies on profits. And what is the point of an energy cap if they change the rules so it can be raised four times a year instead of twice and go up and up and up? Not really a cap at all, is it.

If you cap prices, then sellers have no reason to sell to you at or below cost.

Ask Venezuela how well price caps on essentials like energy and food went for them. I hear their refugees are great fun for these stories.

NotMeNoNo · 28/08/2022 22:39

Call a general election

Ladybyrd · 28/08/2022 22:39

It isn't an ordinary recession. It is triggered by unaffordable fuel prices so that's what they need to concentrate on. And I don't mean "naming and shaming" fuel companies that don't pass on the paltry 5p fuel tax cut. I mean putting in place mandates and levies on profits. And what is the point of an energy cap if they change the rules so it can be raised four times a year instead of twice and go up and up and up? Not really a cap at all, is it.

Liebig · 28/08/2022 22:38

Unphased · 28/08/2022 22:36

TheSandwoman Please tell me what good would it do to rejoin the EU, how would that possibly help with the rising cost of stuff?

It wouldn't. Neoliberals just need to get their cheap foreign labour back, because it's so expensive to pay natives for childcare and wait for understaffed Starbucks to serve lattes.

The EU is fucked, and for some reason people think if we were in it we'd be doing gangbusters.

ImaginaryDragon · 28/08/2022 22:38

JustTheOneSwan · 28/08/2022 21:00

Invest in the police and stop this focus on inclusiveness and diversity and start policing the smaller stuff again.

So only we should only 'fix the mess' for for white , heterosexual males?

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 22:37

Moonmelodies · 28/08/2022 21:16

Once all these utility companies get privatised, how would you deal with their staff who would probably be on strike?

🤣🤣🤣

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 22:36

Another one.

Do what Spain does in that anyone that lives there for any length of time has to pay tax on their earnings. (see the Shakira case for more details)

Unphased · 28/08/2022 22:36

TheSandwoman Please tell me what good would it do to rejoin the EU, how would that possibly help with the rising cost of stuff?

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 22:34

BorgQueen · 28/08/2022 20:57

Raise the limit for paying tax to at least £15k income or to the level of full time minimum wage.
Allow non earning / non tax paying spouses to transfer their whole tax free allowance to their spouse, instead of just £1250 of it.

Those two things would massively help low income familes.

I'd go further, I'd change the tax system to tax family units rather than individuals*

*albeit todays systems effectively screws families over every which way as it seems to choose worse case:
-individuals for income
-families for stamp duty
-families for uni fees
-families for child care costs etc

Abcdefgh1234 · 28/08/2022 22:34

If the multi million company get tax a lot arent they gonna move from the UK and built their company to somewhere cheaper?. Its gonna kill our economy.

if i were PM i think i’m gonna raise the tax a little bit for very high earner individuals not the company.

also sort out benefits. Lots of people ‘playing’ their benefits. Benefits should go to people who needs it. Not people who is lazy.

next i’m gonna raise salary for childcare worker, teachers and nhs. And reduce tube driver salary. Those tube driver just pressing button i dont think they should have more salary than teachers!.

i will make childcare cost affordable so parents can work rather than claiming benefits.

FloydPepper · 28/08/2022 22:31

Flapjacker48 · 28/08/2022 21:08

People spouting the schoolchild line "re-nationalise the energy companies!" to reduce bills, can you explain what you mean? The energy suppliers generally do not produce oil/gas. Nothing can take away from very high price of gas at the moment.

If you mean nationalising firms like Shell etc it is impossible and the price of gas would still be at record highs.

They don’t know. They don’t understand who does what and how the industry works and it’s an easy thing to shout

goosed · 28/08/2022 22:29

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the request of the user.

RonnieMcdonnie · 28/08/2022 22:29

Simply tax the rich more

Gingernaut · 28/08/2022 22:27

Breathalyse all MPs before sessions and make them perform regular, witnessed drug tests

Less funding for arts and media and more on critical thinking and STEM subjects - we need computer programmers, informatics and digital workers, doctors, nurses, care workers, biochemists, engineers and biologists and fewer Owen Jones, Benjamin Butterworths and Piers Morgans

Less emphasis on university degrees for all and more on properly funded and organised apprenticeships, BTECs and C&G subjects - expecting adults to survive on £4.30 per hour is just ludicrous

Make television companies stick to a charter to EDUCATE and INFORM with unbiased information - Fuck Love Island, Married at First Sight, TOWIE and the rest of the lazy, cretinous output, give us more investigative journalism, fact based programming and documentaries

Force all property owners to sell up if they don't intend to occupy it themselves and can't find occupiers for their buildings after a year

Stop slumlords putting vulnerable, drug addicted, alcoholic, mentally ill and parolees into unsuitable, unsupervised bedsits/one bedroomed apartments

Fund comprehensive drug and alcohol rehab, renationalise social care, take it out of private hands and open up day centres for the elderly, disabled and vulnerable.

Rent control, toughen up laws for landlords and let councils build social housing without recourse to private firms having a say in how many homes are 'affordable'.

Do not allow any more building on green belt land - not for homes, caravan parks or leisure facilities.

Stop building on flood plains - either site new reservoirs there, or leave them as seasonal arable or grazing land.

Make the benefits system less unwieldy - make it easier for people to take on short term, contract work without jeopardising their homes

Force the owners of derelict, brownfield sites to develop them into homes or workplaces

NHS - we're at the ludicrous stage, where there aren't enough tutors, mentors and trainers for all the new staff we need.

I'm stumped.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:27

Reversing Brexit is impossible. Actually impossible. The UK will never be able to re join on the same terms, including keeping the sterling. It’s fantasy’ land. Best to move on from it and think ahead.

I'm well aware of that. That's why it was such an utterly idiotic thing to do in the first place. But any Government wanting to improve things for UK citizens would have rejoining the single market at the top of its agenda.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:26

It’s basically several pages of words. Nonsensical, filler words with no substance, regurgitated narrative you can find on most social media threads like this one.

Indeed. A political rant, not a hint of a serious economic proposal to actually increase productivity or generate wealth or good quality jobs or future industries or how to fix our power and food security issue. Nada. He is an absolute joker.

TakeTheOffPisteRoute · 28/08/2022 22:26

VoiceaFromUranus · 28/08/2022 20:44

Do you go for total nationalisation or partial? Do you change company law to remove protection for smaller shareholders once the government start to price according to policy not market forces?

Do you pay market value for the shareholdings or just simply steal other peoples assets? (which is what I'm guessing a lot of people think nationalisation actually is). Do you somehow ensure that pension funds/insurers are somehow able to meet their liabilities now bloody good companies have been taken out of their portfolios?

Once you have nationalised, how do you control union influence over a monopoly?

And how do you ensure that investors continue to invest considering that the UK government no longer consider ownership as anything more than an inconvenience.

It's not that easy.

Well said!

"Nationalise everything" is an easy tribalistic cry but isn't practical and would put us in a worse position...

... shame it's not logic but instead nationalistic vitriol that wins votes

TiredzzZZ · 28/08/2022 22:24

Well if I was Borris and I genuinely (impossible in his case) wanted to do the right thing and help the country, I'd admit the Tories are useless and suggest a quick election and handover the baton to labour

Liebig · 28/08/2022 22:23

You can't solve it. That's the thing.

Oh, we're pretending we can? Print a billion pounds for every man, woman and child on the island so they can outcompete Johnny foreigner for resources on the global market of goods, services and commodities.

Might as well go with the delusion the central banks have, it's worked out so well for them so far.

PoseyFlump · 28/08/2022 22:21

@TheSandwoman and @sst1234 I, as someone who has no knowledge of this situation, am genuinely asking you both this question. Is this excerpt from the article you thought was nonsense true?

"Broadly speaking, electricity can be generated from coal, nuclear, hydro, renewable sources and gas in the UK. What electricity we get through the wire into our house does, whatever our energy company tells us, come from a mix of all these sources. And what Ofgem does is set the price so that the most unprofitable of these production methods will always make a profit, come what may.
What Ofgem then requires is that all the other producers of electricity charge the same price as the weakest producer needs to charge to be profitable.
This, though, is absurd. If, for example, all of the producers made electricity for £1 a unit in 2020 but now, the price of gas has increased meaning it now costs £2 to make electricity from gas then, even though the costs of hydro, nuclear, coal and renewables have not changed the price to consumers from all producers will be doubled by Ofgem just so that those producing electricity from gas can still be profitable."

ZenNudist · 28/08/2022 22:18

Renationalise the utilities and railways,
Windfall tax on the energy companies, sort out housing by discouraging property as investment. Bring back proper social housing. Tax the rich. Investigate those in government for flagrant waste during covid and giving contracts to their mates, encourage immigration to fill the low paid jobs no one wants. Invest in renewable energy. Invest in our manufacturing base.

Put an end to public private initiatives that mean that the people get poor quality services and the tax payer gets stung whilst private companies cream off the profits. It's criminal.

Probably try and contain what the nhs is supposed to do. It was never designed as a fresbie service for everything. We do need to have some things not nhs funded.

Try and reverse all the damage thatcher did.

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:18

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:15

Other than reversing Brexit (no brainer) the rest of your post is tinfoil hat material.

Reversing Brexit is impossible. Actually impossible. The UK will never be able to re join on the same terms, including keeping the sterling. It’s fantasy’ land. Best to move on from it and think ahead.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:15

BluebelllsRosesDaffodills · 28/08/2022 21:06

Put an extra tax on people who received furlough during lockdowns from the govt

Strongly discourage people from having more children

Get rid of maternity and paternity leave

Reverse Brexit

Slowly phase out paid sick leave from public sector jobs

Means test benefits such as the old age pension

Other than reversing Brexit (no brainer) the rest of your post is tinfoil hat material.

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:14

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:11

I was reading this thinking how bonkers it was then I got to the end and it all made sense: the delusional Richard Murphy strikes again!

It’s basically several pages of words. Nonsensical, filler words with no substance, regurgitated narrative you can find on most social media threads like this one.

PoseyFlump · 28/08/2022 22:14

For those saying windfall taxes on energy companies I think this excerpt from the article @Lurkerlot posted answers that:

"And, as we saw in 2021, energy companies can, and do, fail. The actual producers of oil and gas will not. Maybe the electricity generators might not (but it’s harder to be sure) but those who actually sell us the energy that comes into our houses can fail. And they are going to do so. This is inevitable. You cannot try to sell most of your product to people who cannot pay for it and expect to stay in business. That just cannot happen. In that case it is not just consumers who should be panicking about the forecast price increases: all of the domestic energy companies should be too. They are at extreme risk in the situation that is developing."