Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were the PM what would you do to fix the mess we are in?

294 replies

HoppingKangaroo · 28/08/2022 19:59

Just that really, if you were the prime minister what would you do to help fix the country and the cost of living crisis.

OP posts:
BurscoughBooths · 28/08/2022 23:11

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:46

I'd go further, I'd change the tax system to tax family units rather than individuals

Absolutely this. The French and many other countries tax on a household basis. Single people and single parents especially are massively overtaxed in the UK, paying way more than a two adult household with the same income. This would be a very quick fix to relieving a huge amount of poverty. And as you say, the claims that it would be "too difficult" don't stand up to the slightest scrutiny when they manage it perfectly well when it benefits them to consider incomes on a household basis e.g. for benefits.

So DH & I would each pay less tax if we split up?

Independent taxation was brought in in 1990 and was seen as a huge advance in equality - before this, a married woman’s income was simply part of her husband’s income and taxed as such.

What if DH was a 40% tax payer and I wanted to return to work part time? If we were taxed as a family unit, my £10k pa earnings would be taxed at 40% too

TheEggChair · 28/08/2022 23:11

Closing all tax loopholes that businesses and wealthy individuals use to avoid paying tax.

Getting rid of non Dom status

Make anti vaxxers take out private health insurance so if they catch covid, they're not using NHS funds. Same for alcoholics & druggies & those with illnesses caused by lifestyle choices. This will free up some NHS funds for more patients as the health system is on its knees

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 23:10

sst1234

If we are going for completely serious, how about fast tracking the Saltfleetby gas field refinery build and their connection to the national gas system?

Wouldloveanother · 28/08/2022 23:06

EtnaVesuvius · 28/08/2022 23:04

The last thing the NHS needs is more money.

Why?

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 23:06

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:55

If this is designed to be a warm fuzzy thread, then sure let’s give out prizes and claps for every comment. But if it’s meant to be serious debate, then you can’t take this ‘Eat the Rich’, ‘Renationalize everything’ nonsense seriously.

and we probably shouldn't but if its a serious debate then posters should explain there points before belittling others.

EtnaVesuvius · 28/08/2022 23:04

The last thing the NHS needs is more money.

Nancydrawn · 28/08/2022 23:03

In terms of the pound against the dollar, it should be noted that in times of economic uncertainty, the dollar tends to get stronger, as it's the safest currency in the world. The real key is how a country's doing against other major currencies.

The pound's actually doing okay against the Euro, believe it or not. I mean, much, much, much worse than before Brexit, but better than a lot of 2017/2018. Better against the yen than since before Brexit, too (down massively since Brexit, but still better than 2017/2018).

This doesn't mean the energy situation isn't fucked. It is. Really fucked, and it's problematic because UK salaries are relatively low for the average worker and there's very little leeway.

But the pound's doing not as bad as it could be. If only the UK actually produced any meaningful non-service based exports--we could take real advantage of the low pound. Unfortunately, partly due to Brexit and partly due to supply chain, the UK's number one material export, cars, are at pretty much their lowest point of production in over 25 years.

But yeah, let's keep nattering on about 'cheap labour' and the 'upsides of Brexit.'

Unphased · 28/08/2022 23:02

TheSandwoman I am serious, Eu average inflation is running at 9.8%, not much difference to ours, we are exporting gas to the EU at present, the Euro has tanked against the Dollar, every country seems to have staff shortages at present, so I ask again, if we rejoined the EU tomorrow how would that help with the cost of living crisis?

EveSix · 28/08/2022 23:00

sst1234, just a note on your suggestion to tie ECTs (newly qualified 'Early Career Teachers') into teaching for a set amount of time; given that the highest number of teachers exiting the profession do so within the first five years, I can't see it working.
Teaching is a profession which lots of people think they'd like to have a go at, and subsequently discover they are not able to sustain. The thing is, you really can't 'fake it' if you're not feeling it in teaching and to expect someone to stay teaching who had arrived at the end of their professional tether would be nothing short of monstrous. In my 25+ year teaching career, I have only seen colleagues leave the profession more or less broken, whether it was after their first year or their 41st.

SunRainSummer22 · 28/08/2022 22:57

BigYellowElephant · 28/08/2022 20:24

Renationalise all of the utilities, rail etc redistribute wealth and absolutely pump money into the NHS as a matter of urgency. Put Priti Patel on a dinghy and push her out to sea, preferably one with sharks in

I’ll second that

Liebig · 28/08/2022 22:56

Ladybyrd · 28/08/2022 22:49

@Liebig In a country where we're now being told we're being picky turning our noses up at recycled water from sewage plants, I certainly won't be blowing our trumpet any time soon. The pound is in freefall against the dollar. We have one of the worst inflation rates of any G20 countries. But yes, you're quite right. If you look hard enough, there's always a country whose government has fucked it up a little bit more than yours.

There's nothing wrong with recycled water. Many countries do that with no issue. In fact, I was surprised it wasn't widespread here in any case. The water is eventually getting to you one way or another. The more kidneys its been through, the purer it is...

On the pound sterling, I think we're doing a tad better than the euros. They're at below parity with the dollar.

We have barely much worse inflation, and we're also not the worst in terms of energy prices given the contracts on the continent. Yes, the gov't hasn't held down prices like, say, France has, the favourite go to for people who believe Europe is doing better by some metric. Except, that cap comes undone in the New Year. And France has a huge swathe of their nuclear fleet out of action because of terrible (now nationalised) energy management by EdF, which has massive debt obligations.

The Germans are shutting down everything from glass to fertiliser manufacturing to try and save energy. In an economy that is primarily heavy industry exports that seems... unwise.

If you were the PM what would you do to fix the mess we are in?
If you were the PM what would you do to fix the mess we are in?
sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:55

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 22:52

And yet it would cut out a middleman and the profits redirected or redistributed.

And the OP didn't ask for answers just from experts.

but its a shame that you feel the need to belittle peoples thoughts, maybe you should explain as you are such an expert?

If this is designed to be a warm fuzzy thread, then sure let’s give out prizes and claps for every comment. But if it’s meant to be serious debate, then you can’t take this ‘Eat the Rich’, ‘Renationalize everything’ nonsense seriously.

Wouldloveanother · 28/08/2022 22:55

End the NHS bed blocking by ‘social patients’ and elderly people who refuse to live in suitable accommodation. After the 2nd fall requiring hospital care, an order should be put in place to sell their home and the proceeds go into finding them a suitable care home. This would also help free up some stock for the housing market.

Flapjacker48 · 28/08/2022 22:55

*NOT the answer

blackpearwhitelilies · 28/08/2022 22:54

Aabsolutely not redirecting all funding to STEM. This is so unbalanced. We need more linguists. We need more diplomacy. We need, my God we need, more critical thinking. Humanities degrees serve a really important function. I am so sick of this drive to pish everyone to STEM.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:54

Unphased · 28/08/2022 22:36

TheSandwoman Please tell me what good would it do to rejoin the EU, how would that possibly help with the rising cost of stuff?

You can't be serious?

By leaving the single market we have created huge unnecessary red tape which has destroyed many businesses (reducing tax income to HMRC). Our balance if payments deficit has increased from 2% to 8% because of Brexit trade barriers, and foreign investment that propped up our economy has understandably fallen off a cliff.

So as a direct result of Brexit GBP has taken a hammering against USD and EUR and most of our essentials that are imported (a large proportion of food and fuel) are priced in USD. Effectively this has made such imported products around 20% more expensive than they would be were it not for Brexit.

It also led to a huge exodus of skilled workers so we now have labour shortages that are feeding inflation.

All of the things that Project Reality stated would happen. And for zero benefit.

Not to mention that to keep the lights on in Jan if there is a cold snap we may need urgent fuel imports from France. And our prospective PM is busy insulting them in interviews even when Macron offered an olive branch. That will help, I'm sure. Now we're a third country there will be no pressure on them to help us if they don't feel like it.

Flapjacker48 · 28/08/2022 22:52

Anyone who is thinking we should have more and more renewables, see this:

grid.iamkate.com/

At this moment in time 70% of the UK's electricity needs are from fossil fuels. The answer would have been to start maybe 40 new nuclear power stations 20 years ago, but to late now.

Without reliable, cost effective storage wind and solar is now the answer.

FrippEnos · 28/08/2022 22:52

FloydPepper · 28/08/2022 22:31

They don’t know. They don’t understand who does what and how the industry works and it’s an easy thing to shout

And yet it would cut out a middleman and the profits redirected or redistributed.

And the OP didn't ask for answers just from experts.

but its a shame that you feel the need to belittle peoples thoughts, maybe you should explain as you are such an expert?

Unphased · 28/08/2022 22:49

NotMeNoNo, How would a general election help right now? We would have less than a functioning government than we have now, it would take months before a new government would take over, we haven’t got a Tory leader yet to even call a general election and get it voted through Parliament

Ladybyrd · 28/08/2022 22:49

@Liebig In a country where we're now being told we're being picky turning our noses up at recycled water from sewage plants, I certainly won't be blowing our trumpet any time soon. The pound is in freefall against the dollar. We have one of the worst inflation rates of any G20 countries. But yes, you're quite right. If you look hard enough, there's always a country whose government has fucked it up a little bit more than yours.

sst1234 · 28/08/2022 22:48

@PoseyFlump

The description of how Ofgem works is correct. My comment was that the article or essay completely fails to address any of the structural causes of the issues we have.

The UK produces over 40% of its electricity from gas, then the gas usage itself too. Gas is bought by electricity producers or gas suppliers at either a spot price or futures price. Half of our gas comes from the North Sea, the rest from Norway and beyond. Ofgem is toothless in situations like these. It cannot determine spot or futures pricing. We need more home grown energy. To use, store and to export. Because it benefits both domestic consumption pricing and export revenues.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:46

I'd go further, I'd change the tax system to tax family units rather than individuals

Absolutely this. The French and many other countries tax on a household basis. Single people and single parents especially are massively overtaxed in the UK, paying way more than a two adult household with the same income. This would be a very quick fix to relieving a huge amount of poverty. And as you say, the claims that it would be "too difficult" don't stand up to the slightest scrutiny when they manage it perfectly well when it benefits them to consider incomes on a household basis e.g. for benefits.

maddy68 · 28/08/2022 22:45

Resign and offer a general election

Unphased · 28/08/2022 22:44

It appears by reading this, that not many people have many good and workable ideas to help out in our situation, it’s all very complex and interwoven, As far as I can see the quickest answer would be to kiss ass to Putin, let him have Ukraine, open the gas pipelines again, but where will he stop, this is a result of low interest rates for to long, to much money printing, Covid shutting down countries production for months on end, then the war. Very tough times ahead, we should have let the economy fall after the financial crash in 2008, we’ve been treading water since then.

TheSandwoman · 28/08/2022 22:42

@PoseyFlump

@TheSandwoman and @sst1234 I, as someone who has no knowledge of this situation, am genuinely asking you both this question. Is this excerpt from the article you thought was nonsense true?

"Broadly speaking, electricity can be generated from coal, nuclear, hydro, renewable sources and gas in the UK. What electricity we get through the wire into our house does, whatever our energy company tells us, come from a mix of all these sources.

^This is true

And what Ofgem does is set the price so that the most unprofitable of these production methods will always make a profit, come what may.

^This is not true. UK electricity prices are set based on gas as that is how the majority of our electricity is produced. In the current situation that does skew the calculation because it is gas that has rocketed in price internationally, and we have insufficient storage facilities. I believe Ofgem are working on changing the pricing methodology, which also makes sense as we gradually move to a higher proportion of renewables in the mix. But no, Ofgem do not look at the price for each type of generation and deliberately choose to set the cap based on whatever is most expensive to stitch up consumers. That's Murphy mumbo-jumbo.

What Ofgem then requires is that all the other producers of electricity charge the same price as the weakest producer needs to charge to be profitable.

Clearly not otherwise how could any of them have gone bust? That said, a member of Ofgem's board recently resigned because she believes the calculation method for the cap gave more weight to the needs of the supplier companies versus consumers than was appropriate. But again Murphy's comment is hyperbolic and misleading.

This, though, is absurd. If, for example, all of the producers made electricity for £1 a unit in 2020 but now, the price of gas has increased meaning it now costs £2 to make electricity from gas then, even though the costs of hydro, nuclear, coal and renewables have not changed the price to consumers from all producers will be doubled by Ofgem just so that those producing electricity from gas can still be profitable."

Again no nuance. Agree the pricing of all electricity based on gas is no longer functional. Agree that wind and hydro have gone up far less. However - while this issue should be fixed - it is not the main driver of the increases in bills.

Also interesting to note that despite being surrounded by coastline we generate almost no hydro power! The concerns with wind or solar about unreliability wouldn't apply to hydro. Given how much fossil fuels have increased it is increasingly a good option economically. Currently we are importing hydro power generated electricity from Norway!!

In summary, if you want a clear picture of what is going on and workable solutions that would actually be possible to implement and effective, don't ask Richard Murphy! He's a nutter.

Swipe left for the next trending thread