@PoseyFlump
@TheSandwoman and @sst1234 I, as someone who has no knowledge of this situation, am genuinely asking you both this question. Is this excerpt from the article you thought was nonsense true?
"Broadly speaking, electricity can be generated from coal, nuclear, hydro, renewable sources and gas in the UK. What electricity we get through the wire into our house does, whatever our energy company tells us, come from a mix of all these sources.
^This is true
And what Ofgem does is set the price so that the most unprofitable of these production methods will always make a profit, come what may.
^This is not true. UK electricity prices are set based on gas as that is how the majority of our electricity is produced. In the current situation that does skew the calculation because it is gas that has rocketed in price internationally, and we have insufficient storage facilities. I believe Ofgem are working on changing the pricing methodology, which also makes sense as we gradually move to a higher proportion of renewables in the mix. But no, Ofgem do not look at the price for each type of generation and deliberately choose to set the cap based on whatever is most expensive to stitch up consumers. That's Murphy mumbo-jumbo.
What Ofgem then requires is that all the other producers of electricity charge the same price as the weakest producer needs to charge to be profitable.
Clearly not otherwise how could any of them have gone bust? That said, a member of Ofgem's board recently resigned because she believes the calculation method for the cap gave more weight to the needs of the supplier companies versus consumers than was appropriate. But again Murphy's comment is hyperbolic and misleading.
This, though, is absurd. If, for example, all of the producers made electricity for £1 a unit in 2020 but now, the price of gas has increased meaning it now costs £2 to make electricity from gas then, even though the costs of hydro, nuclear, coal and renewables have not changed the price to consumers from all producers will be doubled by Ofgem just so that those producing electricity from gas can still be profitable."
Again no nuance. Agree the pricing of all electricity based on gas is no longer functional. Agree that wind and hydro have gone up far less. However - while this issue should be fixed - it is not the main driver of the increases in bills.
Also interesting to note that despite being surrounded by coastline we generate almost no hydro power! The concerns with wind or solar about unreliability wouldn't apply to hydro. Given how much fossil fuels have increased it is increasingly a good option economically. Currently we are importing hydro power generated electricity from Norway!!
In summary, if you want a clear picture of what is going on and workable solutions that would actually be possible to implement and effective, don't ask Richard Murphy! He's a nutter.