Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1 week of intermittent fasting, not a single lb down

37 replies

Idliketothankyouforajobwelldone · 28/08/2022 12:43

I've been doing 14:10 for a week (trying to build up to 16:8!)
I didn't overeat in my time window, ate 3 small meals and 2/3 small snacks. Balanced diet. I treated myself to a pizza on Friday but that's all.. I'd say I was on around 1200 calories a day which is pretty low. Also exercised several times in the week.
Anyway weighed myself today and nothing at all.
I'm 9st 12 and just under 5'7 so I know I'm a healthy weight. I just have a bit of a belly and wobbly thighs/arms.
I'm 31, so not menopause related or anything that I know of.
Maybe I just have to give it a few weeks?
Has anyone else had success with IF?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
threepointonefourone · 29/08/2022 13:13

i should clarify, I got the biggest losses on 5:2. I think you really do need those all day fasts to make it work effectively. but overall effectiveness will depend on what your normal eating pattern is.

I find the 16:8 is purely maintenance. It works for me because I’m a grubby snacker, and that keeps me out of the biscuit tin. If you aren’t a habitual snackier, I can’t imagine anything other than full day fasting working very well tbh.

IodineQueen · 28/08/2022 16:34

FriendOfDorothyGale · 28/08/2022 14:35

Under 9st 5 or around that mark, would be classed as underweight.

9st 5lbs at 5’ 7” would be a BMI of 20.5. Not underweight at all.

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 28/08/2022 15:49

ElspethTascioni · 28/08/2022 13:34

How can 14/10 count as intermittent fasting? That’s just not eating overnight basically. And the pizza probably undid the pound you might have lost the rest of the week!

That’s what I thought! Eating 3 meals and two snacks on a normal day won’t result in weight loss for most people.

I’m not IFing, I just don’t fancy breakfast most days so usually do all my eating between midday and 8pm. Haven’t lost any weight doing it though!

Zilla1 · 28/08/2022 15:36

HNRTT but the last time I looked fasting diets have zero evidence base for working for pre-menopausal women's anabolic/catabolic hormonal cycles and some evidence of actively making sustainable weight loss harder. Wonder how many of those promoting them to women know and don't say or can't be bothered to look for an evidence base beyond anecdata?

ZaraElizabethIsMyNewSpyName · 28/08/2022 15:18

It's a lifestyle change not a quick fix diet.

If you were morbidly obese due to all day grazing you would see a difference with 14:10 in a week, especially if you simply cut out eating during your habitual worst snacking hours (for most people evenings after dinner).

However you have very little to lose and are already a healthy weight so it will be slower and you'll need to do at least 16:8 (maybe 18:6) and cut right down on simple carbohydrates - the same as someone who has lost the bulk of their weight has to do for the last 5-10kg/ stone or 20lb.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/08/2022 15:12

If it's only your arms/legs and your tummy you want to see a difference in, that's achieved through exercise. Which you need to fuel.

SheWoreYellow · 28/08/2022 15:09

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 28/08/2022 15:07

Also 1200kcals is far too few surely. I'm 5'5 and 60kg and have a lot more than that without putting on weight!

But the OP is trying to lose weight.

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 28/08/2022 15:07

Also 1200kcals is far too few surely. I'm 5'5 and 60kg and have a lot more than that without putting on weight!

HoneyIShrunkThePizza · 28/08/2022 15:06

I've been doing it this month and lost 5lbs or so. Am also a healthy weight but not my favourite weight. I do 16:8 and couldn't fit in three meals and two snacks, it's more like two meals and one snack. The best thing you can do for your arms though is lift some weights.

Pinklady245612 · 28/08/2022 15:04

I'm doing the 5:2 again at the moment. First 10 days I lost 3.5lb (I'm 5ft 3 and started at 9st 5lb so top end of healthy BMI). On my eating days I'm still eating in an 8 hour window and eating 1200-1500 calories a day. Strangely, I started adding exercise to my routine and I started putting on again! Only a little bit but I was confused. My muscle mass had gained, but so had my fat %. Going to go back to just fasting and see how it goes.

SheWoreYellow · 28/08/2022 15:03

It sounds like you are doing low calorie rather than IF.

OoglyMoogly · 28/08/2022 15:01

You're not overweight. You could maybe do some toning exercises - have a look at Lucy Wyndham-Reed on YouTube. She's got a lot of exercise routines, some only 7 minutes a day and they do work.

FlowerArranger · 28/08/2022 14:52

I know I'm a healthy weight. I just have a bit of a belly and wobbly thighs/arms.

@Idliketothankyouforajobwelldone - I missed this.... i think you need to focus on weight training rather than dieting.

I highly recommend Caroline Girvan and her EPIC series - free on YouTube. Use serious weights - enough to challenge yourself but not so heavy as to risk injury. You'll soon see a difference and wave goodbye to bingo wings.

Also do the Bowflex 3-minute plank or similar, and a short abs workout, every day.

And eat healthy - mostly lean protein and lots of vegetables. And no UPF, sugar or refined carbs.

FriendOfDorothyGale · 28/08/2022 14:35

Under 9st 5 or around that mark, would be classed as underweight.

FlowerArranger · 28/08/2022 14:05

I've lost 10 lb in about 7 weeks, eating c. 1200 calories a day between 11 am and 7 pm. But it took about 2 weeks for the scales to register a drop. Exercising helps with motivation and reduces pizza emergencies 😄

anotherpotoftea · 28/08/2022 14:04

Sorry OP but 14:10 isn’t enough for IF. You have to leave at least 16 hours.

2bazookas · 28/08/2022 13:57

You haven't mentioned the fasting days; they are the essential part of altering your metabolism.

We did 5 and 2 intermittent fasting and steadily lost weight. We used a book of similar name.

PeloAddict · 28/08/2022 13:52

I do 2 meals and a snack if I need one
So stop eating after tea (whatever time that is, it varies for me) and don't eat until lunch (1-2pm ish) usually about 18hrs
With that, and a LOT of exercise i have lost 9lbs, and I'm really fat so.. it takes a lot

Merryoldgoat · 28/08/2022 13:44

14:10 isn’t amazing for weight loss. Good for health and hormones but it’s generally what the normal pattern should be.

Look at Jason Fung et al on YT for better information.

Essentially 16:8 with an extended fast is better. No snacking and keto will power it up further.

However I doubt you have much weight to lose at all and therefore that may be a bigger issue.

felulageller · 28/08/2022 13:37

You are exceptionally slim already. Trying to lose more weight is bordering on disordered eating.

If you are 'wobbly' what you need is more exercise/ weights not starvation diets.

ElspethTascioni · 28/08/2022 13:34

How can 14/10 count as intermittent fasting? That’s just not eating overnight basically. And the pizza probably undid the pound you might have lost the rest of the week!

LemonSwan · 28/08/2022 13:30

I intermittent fast. I really wouldn’t limit calories whilst doing it. The idea is you eat as much as your body wants in infrequent large meals not small regular ones.

I have to be honest I don’t really understand 14-10 or 16-8. Surely that’s just not eating when you sleep. I am not sure I really class that as intermittent even though people do. The aim is to enter a time period where you body is not running on the fuel from your last meal, but on your body reserves. I think is called metabolic switching. I am not sure how much energy sleeping takes but I can’t imagine it’s using any considerable energy reserves as probably still digesting dinner.

If you really want to do proper IF I would throw the timed plans out of the window whilst you adjust. You are setting yourself up to fail IMO as it’s a completely different way to eat and your not going to get to 18-6, 20-4 or 23-1 without an adjustment period.

Eat the largest meal you can and then wait as long as you can before another. And only break fast with a large meal. So maybe start with a late large dinner one day. Don’t eat until your starving the next day, say lunch time maybe, then have a huge late lunch, then day after you might need a large breakfast and potentially a late dinner depending how you are doing.

If you ever feel faint or really sick then stop fast and eat. I also drink whatever I want during fasting but many don’t.

Goodluck ☺️

Wombat27A · 28/08/2022 13:29

For reasons to do with blood pressure, I did a really strict few months of alternate day fasting. It took me ages to lose any weight at all. It's not the biggest calorie restriction, even if you are pretty strict.

If you're not particularly unhealthy eating a load of junk or really fat, one week of calorie counting won't do much.

Get yourself a weight app that shows the ups and downs of individual measurements smoothed, it's easier to see the direction of travel.

Sally99 · 28/08/2022 13:28

I did the16:8 diet and lost a decent amount of weight but it tools couple of weeks for the weight loss to show. The good thing I found about the diet is that with the gradual weight loss it came off all over which is what I wanted. I must do it again

Reagol · 28/08/2022 13:24

I'm brand new to IF, been doing 18:6 for four days now, I'm 2lb down. Could just be initial water loss though.

I'm definitely eating less as it's cut out breakfast (300kcal) and no snacks after dinner (500kcal). I've upped my exercise too, running and gym everyday.

Have you tracked your calories? It can be easy to underestimate.

I'm at a healthy weight like you (8 stone 10lbs) but I just need to lose some that I've gained.

Finding it okay so far, just super hungry in the last 2 hours before the fast ends!

Swipe left for the next trending thread