Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
SwimmingOnEggshells · 29/08/2022 16:48

@Fixyourself cancer rates are soaring because people live longer. But yes, obesity is because of processed foods which are so widely available and cheap.

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 16:47

I doubt I'd use a pack of carrots in a month, not without really trying! I probably could make myself but I'd just end up eating most of them raw instead of other things like tomatoes or just adding them to things where they weren't needed, which is just using them up for the sake of it when I didn't necessarily want that many in the first place. And of course I'd be trying to use up various other veg and leftover bits too. Lettuce seems to always go off, for example.

Of course it's possible to be a much better cook and planner than I am. But cooking for one, especially if you aren't always in every night, is surprisingly hard and not always cheap to do from scratch without a fair number of compromises.

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 16:43

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 16:08

Shops in other countries manage just fine🙈

Tell that to the ones around here then. Those are the reasons they tend to give when pressed to sell more things individually. Yes, I'm sure there are ways they could overcome some of those problems. But they're not going to bother if they can just get people to buy 3-packs because that's what they sell.

Perhaps other countries have different distribution/supply systems, point of sales, size of shops, and other factors - or perhaps in urban areas like I am talking about, other countries might also have more packaged things that we're aware of.

There is one more 'market like' shop that I could go to, and do something, for veg or herbs, where you can get more unusual things or buy things individually. It's less convenient, and I can't get other things there though, but I do sometimes go. But it doesn't change the point that so much of what is sold isn't in sizes that make it easy for people to buy small quantities, whether because of budget or singledom, and those things might be more common in areas where people don't get in a car and head off to a big supermarket. The local smaller supermarkets are also more expensive even for the very same pack size and products as they are at the larger ones.

Skethylita · 29/08/2022 16:32

sheepdogdelight · 29/08/2022 16:12

I think OP's initial premise is odd. It might be cheaper to buy a ready meal lasagne, than make one from scratch, but it's even cheaper to make dahl or veggie curry with whatever veggies are cheap (yes there's an initial outlay but curry power is pretty cheap) or baked potato and cheese or beans on toast.

That is actually a very good point. Spaghetti bolognaise, the way it is meant to be made, is more of a luxury food.

Carrots are also an interesting example. They easily last 4 weeks in my fridge. Is there really anyone saying they couldn't use up a pack of carrots, however big, in 4 weeks? I make so much with it - almost all mexican street food, almost all Italian food, salads, starters (grated with apples), as a filler in anything tomato-based, made into soup with a bit of coriander on its own. Carrots don't go off in my household.

sheepdogdelight · 29/08/2022 16:12

I think OP's initial premise is odd. It might be cheaper to buy a ready meal lasagne, than make one from scratch, but it's even cheaper to make dahl or veggie curry with whatever veggies are cheap (yes there's an initial outlay but curry power is pretty cheap) or baked potato and cheese or beans on toast.

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 16:08

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 16:06

and the packs aren't there just to make you buy more, though that's part of it. Many supermarkets, especially small ones, only sell one size/type/pack of anything, so it's more likeliy to be a 3-pack. So you have to buy more in the end even if you just want one. But it's also easier to transport, store, display etc for the shop, easier for the self checkouts without weighing, less shoplifting, less wastage in the shop with things getting dropped/bruised, and so on. So there is very little incentive for the shops to sell things individually either, much as some of us might appreciate it.

Shops in other countries manage just fine🙈

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 16:06

and the packs aren't there just to make you buy more, though that's part of it. Many supermarkets, especially small ones, only sell one size/type/pack of anything, so it's more likeliy to be a 3-pack. So you have to buy more in the end even if you just want one. But it's also easier to transport, store, display etc for the shop, easier for the self checkouts without weighing, less shoplifting, less wastage in the shop with things getting dropped/bruised, and so on. So there is very little incentive for the shops to sell things individually either, much as some of us might appreciate it.

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 16:04

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 14:59

@QuattroFromagio , shop at a different shop then or buy something you can buy what you need. The packs are there to make you buy more.

You don't have to use things like cream cheese or creme fraiche -you can use a different recipe or use a substitute. You could use something like greek yoghurt

It's not always easy for people to just shop somewhere else.

As it happens, I do have a choice of supermarkets - but there are all relatively small local ones, who tend to sell all the veg in packets. Doesn't matter if I buy different veg - it's the same problem! almost everything is wrapped up (which is another problem too of course). yes, I could get bus/bike to larger supermarkets on the edge of town, but not so easy every couple of days when there are shops very near, and for one person, it's easier to shop more frequently to stop stuff going off.

yes some things can be substituted, but loads of things come in larger packs really, and the recipes aren't as nice when you don't follow them properly - especially if you aren't a frequent or competent cook. Doesn't give much incentive to keep making things that way. So yes, for a number of things, a ready-to-cook dish probably does end up working out cheaper.

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 15:14

And it was 300g not 400g
link

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 15:06

@Katypp , not bossy at all. I'll admit to buying it is Lidl or Aldi sometimes, as it is cheaper. I don't shop there very often as they're not within walking distance. The £1.50 was for a tub in Tesco.

Baoing · 29/08/2022 15:06

Not entirely sure why a couple of pps are making digs about me

I find it bizarre that soneo e can't grasp that spending £26 to bulk buy olive oil on a £30 budget is unattainable, but maybe that's just me 🙄
The funny thing is, I do everything that is considered 'good' on here - I batch cook, I cook mostly from scratch and I bulk buy. But I am not blind to the fact that these options are not open to everyone, unlike some posters on here

Maybe it's because you keep popping back to tell anyone who is just trying to offer an alternative to your POV that they're wrong and not listening to you.

Loads of posters are actually posting useful stuff that flies in the face of what you think. That SHOULD be okay - threads evolve and people have different experiences and wisdom - but you keep wanting to drag everyone back to a narrow it-can't-be-done POV, and then actually getting fairly arsey with people who disagree with you, or offer something different. Who is that helping?

The eyerolls are obv great, too.

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 14:59

@QuattroFromagio , shop at a different shop then or buy something you can buy what you need. The packs are there to make you buy more.

You don't have to use things like cream cheese or creme fraiche -you can use a different recipe or use a substitute. You could use something like greek yoghurt

Katypp · 29/08/2022 14:55

@KirstenBlest with the risk of being accused of being bossy, the hummous was 69p, not £1.40

OP posts:
Katypp · 29/08/2022 14:53

Not entirely sure why a couple of pps are making digs about me.
I find it bizarre that soneo e can't grasp that spending £26 to bulk buy olive oil on a £30 budget is unattainable, but maybe that's just me 🙄
The funny thing is, I do everything that is considered 'good' on here - I batch cook, I cook mostly from scratch and I bulk buy. But I am not blind to the fact that these options are not open to everyone, unlike some posters on here. I am not advocating not cooking, I am merely stating that options to save money in the long run are no good if you have to go without in the short-term. I'm not sure the woman I wrote about originally would want to spend her £30 weekly budget on whole spices and a pestle and mortar!

OP posts:
caversham · 29/08/2022 14:39

Only when I fancy a snack. One can't always stomach a full swan, you know.

Baoing · 29/08/2022 14:29

I thought OP was cooking (and presumably eating) parrots

Is that just a middle class brag? Are you batch cooking parrots? Check your privilege.

Grin
Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 14:24

caversham · 29/08/2022 14:20

Should not skim read thread titles.

I thought OP was cooking (and presumably eating) parrots.

😂 I think most would be quite a pita to eat.

caversham · 29/08/2022 14:20

Should not skim read thread titles.

I thought OP was cooking (and presumably eating) parrots.

CherryGenoa · 29/08/2022 14:17

kavalkada · 29/08/2022 13:21

Thank you for little bit of common sense. This thread needed that, although everybody will probably ignore you.

Yes, anyone who can operate the internet to watch a YouTube video can learn how to cook a cheap and tasty meal from scratch if they want or need to. But it has to fit with someone’s life, budget and they need to have the motivation.

My working class grandmothers cooked delicious dinners when they were the age I am now, but they didn’t work out of the home and they had the time. They also didn’t have a choice as most convenience food didn’t exist. I cook from scratch most of the time because I enjoy it and I like particular tastes, but I switched gratefully to ready meals and quick stuff such as egg on toast when I was nursing a family member as I lacked time and headspace. Class doesn’t necessarily coincide with cooking ability.

Comedycook · 29/08/2022 14:17

Christmas food is a good example of when ready made is cheaper. I've costed up making a home made Christmas cake and Christmas pudding. So expensive...much cheaper to buy shop bought versions, even the posher makes.

QuattroFromagio · 29/08/2022 14:14

You can't often buy just what you need, though.

At my local supermarket ,I can only buy packs of 3 peppers, or 3 courgettes, for example. 3 onions. Tubs of mushrooms. Packets of creme fraiche or soft cheese or something that's far more than I need. Etc

And when you live alone, that's just too much. So I get out of the habit of trying to cook, and as a result, am not much good at it.

Yes I could try to use up spare creme fraiche or whatever, but when you've already made one recipe that lasts 4 days with it, you don't need to do it again. And I don't want to be finding things to make that I don't really need, like desserts or things to just 'use it up', as that's bad for my health too.

A lot of ready meals are just a piece of meat/fish with sauces on, ready to cook, much like you might make yourself, and you just put them in the oven to cook without having leftover veg, cheese, spices, herbs etc. I don't think it's that unhealthy really and it can certainly be cheaper.

glamourousindierockandroll · 29/08/2022 14:12

People say they bin fruit and veg - why don't they buy exactly what they need, or meal plan accordingly?

In fairness, it can be annoying to have to buy prepacked vegetables especially if you're a single person. I find that especially in the cheaper supermarkets like Aldi, there's not a lot of loose fruit and veg so you end up spending more on a kilo of carrots when you only needed 2-3. I used to prefer to get my vegetables from a market stall if I had time.

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 14:04

@AntlerRose , yes. She's one of those people who isn't quite as bright as most.
I think the meal deals can be a quick way of filling bellies, but they won't be cheaper than home cooking. I think a lot of people think fresh ingredients are more expensive than they are. The OP and the hummus is case in point IMO. A 400g tub of hummus is £1.50, the home made stuff I make is much cheaper.

People say they bin fruit and veg - why don't they buy exactly what they need, or meal plan accordingly?

Takeaways are really cheap where I live - it makes me wonder how they can be so cheap, but they are not nice. You can eat cheap food like instant noodles but they are not good for you.

ClaraZ · 29/08/2022 13:59

We can't afford to eat out so I try to recreate the experience at home. Cooking is a hobby of mine. I enjoy doing it.

ClaraZ · 29/08/2022 13:48

Absolutely! There are so many great cooking shows on tv there is no excuse for not being able to cook. Anyone who feels hungry is able to cook. My favourite tv chefs are Jamie Oliver, who I think is a genius because his recipes are simple, healthy, practical and delicious and you don't have to be cordon bleu trained to do them. Sometimes I see him make things (normally at the end of the programme) and I think, come on Jamie, you're just showing off there!! I couldn't make that!! I love the Hairy Bikers but I would say they are more "fancy" than Jamie. Nigella has some great recipes but she tends to use hard-to-find ingredients. Delia is my last resort, her recipes work but she is a tad boring. My favourite food writer is Felicity Cloake, I use several of her recipes regularly and I love that she's so meticulous in her research and first you have the pleasure of reading her and then you get to eat something delicious that you've cooked. She's for your day off, though :)

Swipe left for the next trending thread