Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 20:51

MachineBee · 29/08/2022 20:37

Great thread OP, highlight the thoughtless privilege of far too many.

Not only can some ingredients cost disproportionately more for some recipes than the quantity needed, but also the energy and equipment to cook it all is expensive- not to mention many in temporary accommodation have limited space. Try cooking a spag Bol in a bedsit!

Maybe people need to stop being obsessed with spag bols😳

If you have no space eintopf type dish is the logical course of action. You can cook loads in one pot and chopping board.

Why is everything in UK so hard

MangyInseam · 29/08/2022 20:49

FakingMemories · 28/08/2022 16:14

I disagree when it comes to bread, at least. I make all our bread from scratch. Even without bulk buying of ingredients (which I do as it makes sense for us), you can make a good loaf for less than the cost of a good supermarket loaf. You have to compare like for like.

Yes, I know you can get a loaf for around 40 pence at Tescos (the one that used to be value bread). But look at the list of ingredients.

Wheat Flour [Wheat Flour, Calcium Carbonate, Iron, Niacin, Thiamin], Water, Yeast, Salt, Preservative (Calcium Propionate), Emulsifiers (Mono- and Di-Acetyl Tartaric Acid Esters of Mono- and Di-Glycerides of Fatty Acids), Spirit Vinegar, Rapeseed Oil, Flour Treatment Agent (Ascorbic Acid).

When I make bread I’m not making the equivalent of a “value loaf”. Even my basic sandwich/toast bread is just 500 g flour, 12 g yeast, 15 g butter, a teaspoon of sugar and a teaspoon of salt. Plus water from the tap. That “value bread” is barely worthy of being called bread.,

Peoplecslways compare the cheapest, nastiest, preservative-laden item with a homemade one and say “it’s not cheaper”. But they are comparing apples and oranges.

It's not about comparing like and like at all. It's about what is the cheapest way to make the amount of money you have in your hand give you and your kids something to eat all week.

Which probably means something like the cheapest ramen noodles for lunches, the cheapest bread with peanut butter for breakfast, (though you might do oatmeal if you have access to cooking facilities and a bit more time,) and some frozen pizzas you pick up each day on the way home from work or the employment center.

Like for like doesn't enter into it.

Sarbears28 · 29/08/2022 20:48

I personally cook a lot from scratch and for me it does work out cheaper but that's because I kinda know what I'm doing and have a stocked cupboard and herb rack. It's cheaper to replace 1 item then buy a lot of herbs/spices etc. I'm also a sahm so I have time to prep and organise. A lot of people dont. Also a lot of people dont have the initial money to buy what's needed to cook from scratch or the ability. I find when I buy convenience for my family it works out more expensive.

BarbaraofSeville · 29/08/2022 20:46

*People do NOT need all this to start cooking at all. You need a pan, a wooden spoon, a knife, a heat source, and a few ingredients. You build your cooking kit as you go.

We have GOT to stop pretending that cooking is impossible for people. People round the world cook every single day, with barely anything to their names*

Exactly. It seems to be an almost uniquely British opinion that cooking is impossibly aspirational to the average person.

As well as building your cooking kit, you build your spices up the same way. You could probably buy everything you need for about 20 meals for under a tenner (frozen garlic and ginger, chilli powder, cumin, coriander, garam masala, turmeric, curry powder, paprika) so it would be cheaper than most ready meals in no time at all.

Obviously it's hard for people in bedsits with no money whatsoever but that doesn't apply to the majority of the population.

But, I have to ask, where can you buy hummus for 50 p? It's well over a pound just about everywhere now. Plus you can freeze it if you make it yourself, you don't need to eat it all in 2 days.

It's almost like some people don't want people to be able to constructively help themselves, the whataboutery we see on threads like this. I've seen posts on several occasions that even things like omelettes are too difficult or expensive to make as a reason why people 'have' to live on ready prepared food.

CantFindMyMarbles · 29/08/2022 20:41

luxxlisbon · 29/08/2022 20:31

*@CantFindMyMarbles
Your chickpea/hummous analogy doesn’t work though. You end up with 3 times the amount of the shop bought. So your comparison is with £1.50. Not 50p

Of course it works and this proves the point. When you are on a limited budget the minimum cost counts. If you can buy hummous for 50p why would you make 3 times as much for 3x the price when you don’t want or need that much hummous.

You’re purposely misrepresenting what I’ve said.

The OP is using this analogy and claiming it to be like for like with regards price. And…it’s not. The quantities are vastly different.

You could make hummous with only 1/3 of the tin if you wanted. Or buy a bag of dried chickpeas and use what you need.

Or freeze the excess.

either way…the analogy doesn’t work. Yes…it costs more. But produces significantly more produce.

rwalker · 29/08/2022 20:40

luckylavender · 29/08/2022 09:22

And people never factor in the gas / electricity costs which is a bug bear of mine

Shit food still needs to be cooked using gas and electric

MachineBee · 29/08/2022 20:37

Great thread OP, highlight the thoughtless privilege of far too many.

Not only can some ingredients cost disproportionately more for some recipes than the quantity needed, but also the energy and equipment to cook it all is expensive- not to mention many in temporary accommodation have limited space. Try cooking a spag Bol in a bedsit!

luxxlisbon · 29/08/2022 20:31

*@CantFindMyMarbles
Your chickpea/hummous analogy doesn’t work though. You end up with 3 times the amount of the shop bought. So your comparison is with £1.50. Not 50p

Of course it works and this proves the point. When you are on a limited budget the minimum cost counts. If you can buy hummous for 50p why would you make 3 times as much for 3x the price when you don’t want or need that much hummous.

PeloAddict · 29/08/2022 19:43

KirstenBlest · 29/08/2022 18:16

@PeloAddict , you drive to somewhere only a mile away? Shock

I've checked and it's 1.9 miles
So yes. Also there's no pavements and I don't fancy being roadkill. Usually get my shopping delivered and if I need a cucumber or something from Lidl I'm not pissing about walking 4 miles. I work FT and have chronic health issues

The town centre is 3.9 miles, I just checked that too

Pliudev · 29/08/2022 19:37

There's a load of worthiness tied into this isn't there? There are only two of us now and I have lots of time, but it really depends on quite a few factors. I'd say it would be cheaper to make hummous from soaked chickpeas and home made piazzas can be frozen successfully. I can't understand people buying 'budget' jars of pasta sauce when it's cheap and easy to make a big batch of tomato sauce and portion it. The freezer is your friend. But if my DCs still lived at home and I worked would I have time? I'm not sure.

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 19:20

Erm. People can cook nutritios food from scratch with 1 knife, something to chop on and pot above a fire. I am aure that majority of UK households have more that that....

Honestly, there doesn't have to be a but for everything

Baoing · 29/08/2022 19:16

But you have got to have quite a few things to start with

A decent basic knowledge of how to cook nutritious meals cheaply
A few good pots and pans and utensils
Enough fuel to cook with
Enough money for the initial outlay of ingredients (for example a cheap chilli con carne ready meal for one might be cheaper than the ingredients to make a batch of it)
A reasonably sized fridge and/or freezer to store leftovers in and containers or freezer bags

People do NOT need all this to start cooking at all. You need a pan, a wooden spoon, a knife, a heat source, and a few ingredients. You build your cooking kit as you go.

We have GOT to stop pretending that cooking is impossible for people. People round the world cook every single day, with barely anything to their names.

Sunnydayatthepark · 29/08/2022 19:09

Cooking from scratch can definitely be cheaper depending on what you're making and the quantity.

But you have got to have quite a few things to start with.

A decent basic knowledge of how to cook nutritious meals cheaply
A few good pots and pans and utensils
Enough fuel to cook with
Enough money for the initial outlay of ingredients (for example a cheap chilli con carne ready meal for one might be cheaper than the ingredients to make a batch of it)
A reasonably sized fridge and/or freezer to store leftovers in and containers or freezer bags
Some store cupboard ingredients

Cooking and meal planning is a life skill that not everyone has naturally. So for example the pp who mentioned pizza, well you can freeze pizza dough and you could easily use up leftover pizza toppings and cheese in other dishes throughout the week.

ScurryfungeMaster · 29/08/2022 19:01

I think it depends on what you're cooking obviously, I do tend to find that cooking from scratch is cheaper (with some exceptions obviously). But if you factor in the cost of fuel to cook with then it could end up being the same or even more expensive to cook from scratch vs heating up a microwave meal for example.

ellie09 · 29/08/2022 18:52

I think it depends.

I can batch make my lunches for work (I have a bigger lunch and smaller dinner) for around £1.30 per day. If I bought lunch, it would be at least £5.

I think the likes of making pizza, bread etc, it may be more expensive initially when buying the ingredients, but when you buy those in, they tend to do you a while.

I've stopped baking though as the cost of eggs isn't worth it anymore, may as well buy a pack.

Bard6817 · 29/08/2022 18:50

We’re trying the carnivore diet, mainly because we both suffer from auto immune conditions.

Have to say, we are saving money, there’s no wastage, packaging is minimal, we both feel so much better for it, and guess what…. It’s cheaper…. Steak takes about 4 mins to cook so energy wise it’s damn efficient.

Never eaten so well, or cheaply for some amazing, albeit a little repetitive.

AHG1234 · 29/08/2022 18:43

Oh yes Hummus comes from Tesco but when you are talking about a whole meal homemade is always the best for all the reasons you cite.

Baoing · 29/08/2022 18:42

Making pasta from scratch..... Not a chance, making a tomato base from whole tomatoes, fresh garlic etc..... My jarred spag bol is ready by time you've done that alone

I haven't commented on which would be ready to eat quicker. That's a completely different point. Confused

I replied to this:

Cooking from scratch requires knowledge, lots of kitchen staples already owned and alot of time which alot of people just don't have

I think it's a really unhelpful message to perpetuate.

BCBird · 29/08/2022 18:42

It is not something worth getting annoyed about in my opinion. I agree that it is better for our health to cook from scratch. I suppose it depends on the competency of the cook though. I don't think it is necessarily always cheaper.

Islandgirl68 · 29/08/2022 18:38

For me cooking from scratch is cheaper, I am talking a main meal. I find ready meals really expensive and make the same thing cheaper. Curry ready meals usually have 5 pieces of very small chicken bits. Each to their own.

CombatBarbie · 29/08/2022 18:38

Baoing · 29/08/2022 18:30

Cooking from scratch requires knowledge, lots of kitchen staples already owned and alot of time which alot of people just don't have

It doesn't have to, as people keep saying upthread.

Perpetuating this POV puts people off even trying.

OK so how long does it take you to make spag bol from scratch v the normal browning mince, adding chopped onion and a jar of sauce and boiling spaghetti.

Making pasta from scratch..... Not a chance, making a tomato base from whole tomatoes, fresh garlic etc..... My jarred spag bol is ready by time you've done that alone.

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 18:36

Totally agree. We are not talking professional masterchef level. Some people are making cooking sound so complicated. It's a basic life activity. Imho it's basically like cleaning or gardening. It can be very simple. It's just something you do.

Can someone actually say what that "skill and knowledge" entails when we are talking about non professional homecook level? Skill and knowledge that is not accessible to absolutely anyone with internet or library?

Vikinga · 29/08/2022 18:36

Homemade is cheaper I find. Yes you can buy a ready made alternative but with a fraction of the meat and veggies and full of filler crap.

Ready made soup compared to homemade for example. Super cheap ingredients

Baoing · 29/08/2022 18:30

Cooking from scratch requires knowledge, lots of kitchen staples already owned and alot of time which alot of people just don't have

It doesn't have to, as people keep saying upthread.

Perpetuating this POV puts people off even trying.

Baoing · 29/08/2022 18:29

If you have a few fresh herbs or vegetables left over, try dehydrating them. You can do this by simply chopping fairly finely and spreading on a piece of kitchen roll or oven paper.

I frequently dehydrate mushrooms, leeks and spring onions, thyme, mint and oregano. When they're completely dry, you can just let them rattle around in a jar until you need them.

A decent bit of the nutritional value is lost here, but it's better than nothing. You can then just shake whatever you need into a dish as it's cooking, add to instant noodles, etc.

Leftover stuff. No fridge, freezer, long cooking etc. required. Every bit of nutrition helps.