Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
MibsXX · 30/08/2022 08:57

Lunar270 · 29/08/2022 09:09

Although cooking is definitely not a middle class pursuit. I grew up poor as did my wife. We cooked from scratch routinely.

Things may have changed over the years, due to cheap processed meals, but cooking from scratch and poverty has been a thing for generations. All those cheaper cuts of meat and traditional dishes are all rooted in poverty. I still love liver, gravy, mash and greens but will add bacon nowadays.

Then the tv chefs made the cheaper cuts and simple meals into fancy expensive restaurant treats and the prices for pig trotters, livers, offal, etc soared beyond the lower incomes budgets..

etulosba · 30/08/2022 08:53

we eat shite right now have been for almost a year and have lost weight

I’ve always been sceptical of the people who claim that they can’t lose weight because they can’t afford the money/time or lack the skills/equipment to prepare “healthy” food.

You can lose weight and carry on eating rubbish. Just eat less of it.

Katypp · 30/08/2022 08:37

I think people dismiss how much things cost. It's all 'virtually free' or 'next to nothing' or 'costs pennies'. As I said earlier, I used to own a food business and did quite a few food fairs. I remember my mum being appalled at a stall charging £2 for a cake, as she was adament she could make a batch of 12 for the same price. When she worked it out, she was amazed at how much the actual cost would be. Because people tend to shop for the week, the unit costs of things get lost in the noise.

OP posts:
MibsXX · 30/08/2022 08:35

Fairyliz · 28/08/2022 16:16

Have you factored in the cost of new clothing when you go up three sizes eating rubbish?

we eat shite right now have been for almost a year and have lost weight, too much in fact.. the 2nd hand charity shop clothes that we bought 6 years ago on a splurge are now loose and hanging in ragged tatters on us.. am only slightly exaggerating there. I was recently refused a job interview because my shoes have cardboard in them to cover the gaping holes in the soles, and a bit of cardboard could be seen poking through.. apparently I was not making an effort..

MibsXX · 30/08/2022 08:23

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 28/08/2022 15:20

Yeah a nice simple easy lunch. EVERYONE always has those ingredients in their cupboard. Hmm FFS this place sometimes! Hmm

and the last place i worked had nowhere for staff to store their packed lunches... only a tiny locker in a warm cupboard.... not sure I'd wanna eat that after 6 hrs sat warm....

lollipoprainbow · 30/08/2022 08:07

Home cooked every day of the week and I work 60 hours, commute, have a dog and young son but food and eating healthily is a priority.

What do you want a medal ??

Cheli83 · 30/08/2022 08:05

I cook from scratch about 80% of the week. If you are referring to take aways cooking from scratch is decidedly cheaper. If you are referring to ready meals, then it's swings and roundabouts. I agree that cooking from scratch meals like Hummus, pizza and pasta can have an initially large spend and may require specialist equipment which can be rather costly. My parents were from the Caribbean they are now deceased, I was raised on Caribbean food and whilst I love cooking Caribbean food its something that I rarely do because of the I live outside London, so it can be hard to source Caribbean food like curry mutton or Ackee and Saltfish, the cost can be rather high (a simple dish like Ackee and saltfish with rice and plantain, whilst quick to cook 30 minutes would cost between £12 and £14 and would only be one nights dinner for a family of 4. Whilst spaghetti bolognese would cost closer to £6-7 and could be 2 night dinner for a family for 4 with salad and garlic bread and then theirs timing, cooking Caribbean from scratch could take anywhere from 2 hours say for Jerk Chicken, coleslaw, vegetables and rice and peas to 3 or more hours for curry mutton or Oxtail or soup. Cooking some meals from scratch feels like a luxury in terms of cost and time that I cannot always afford.

MibsXX · 30/08/2022 07:01

IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep · 28/08/2022 11:57

For Spaghetti bolognaise I have just worked it oit!

@Katypp Aldi prices:

cheapeast microwave meal is 75p for a 400gram meal

from scratch:
1kg mince
2 tins tomatoes 800grams total
1 tin 400grams green lentils (I always add to bulk it out)
1 pack 500gram spaghetti
Bit of garlic powered and mixed herbs

£4.68

this would make 2.2 kilos of Bolognaise sauce
PLUS the spaghetti. And a whole pack makes loads
If you said a pack of spaghetti serves 5 people (100g dried each obvs weighs more cooked )

It’s 0.93 pence per portion. BUT the weight of the bolognaise sauce per person (without pasta) weighs more than the whole of the microwave meal with the pasta.

so 4.68 plus 37p pack spaghetti, plus maybe 2 hrs give or take cooking time on my hob , roughly costing 3.94 ( pre payment meter no debt, cooker hob a year old) , thats 8.99 to feed one meal to a family of 5...... freezer is currently costing approx 87p a day ( its a bit old, no chance of affording a replacement, totally screwed if that goes) to run if feeding 2 and freezing portions.. My weekly food "budget" is between 12 and 25 ( on a really good week) this is after allowing 5 per day on meter, when it runs out it runs out.

5 x 75p ready blurgh meals microwaved all together for 4 mins ( approx 35p on meter ) , 4.10 total for one meal for family of 5, would be considered a luxury meal treat in our household and far far cheaper.

Truth is our budget doesn't even extend to that, hasn't done for well over a year.
Yes I can cook, my once well stocked store cupboard ran out halfway thru covid , it got used up to make shite food taste a little better. My collection of bits and bobs in my box of tricks made even scavenged supermarket binned half rotten veggies taste and look good in a meal... sadly i priced up the other day budget where possible items and would cost just over 100 pounds to replenish my box of tricks to get us through the winter alongside more scavenging.. which obviously I dont have so looking very bleak for us.
Current treat hot meal is value gravy powder made into a cup of "soup" with a slice of bread each! We are all getting very thin, always cold and hungry, bad skin and no energy

MibsXX · 30/08/2022 06:41

IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep · 28/08/2022 11:30

Maybe worth it if you want to eat humous every day for a week.

it’s definitely cheaper though for things like batch cooking spaghetti bol, when you compare to the amount you’d get in a microwave meal.

My electric hob is currently costing 1.97 an hour per ring for an induction cooker, thats not including the oven, this is on a prepayment meter, when the prices go up 80 per cent shortly cooking anything is no longer going to be viable even once a week. And if bread finally hits 2 pounds a loaf, cold meals might get interesting also

bluesapphire48 · 29/08/2022 23:17

If you said, "When people suggest it's always cheaper," or "When people argue it's always cheaper," I would think you were being reasonable, but when you say, "When people parrot it's always cheaper," I think you aren't respecting other people's point of view, and so I think you are being unreasonable. People may, in fact, have discovered it's always cheaper, or learned how to make food at home so it's always cheaper, and you need to give other people the benefit of the doubt.

Maybe you will learn something from them.

MangyInseam · 29/08/2022 23:00

JaneFondue · 29/08/2022 13:09

Yes, every suggestion is met with
You middle class ponce!
Chicken nuggets are cheaper
I hate lentils and will never, ever eat them
What, you expect me to buy five spice? How very dare you?
You must have a kitchen like Jamie Oliver and two Vitamixes
You probably don't work long hours
Nobody taught me
I hate hummus
You are a rich Tory ( ok I made the last one up).

I mean....it's getting a bit ridiculous.

I find it odd that Jack Monroe can make some godawful tarkari ( Hindi for a vegetable dish) from a can of chickpeas and people will praise her for being inventive, but apparently people who actually invented tarkaris are privileged.

middle class is probably not the right word, what people really mean is families with some stability and flexibility in budget which includes lots of working class families.

But the thread was about the fact that if you are really poor - which means likely not working class at all but what is sometimes called the underclass - you are probably not in that situation. You are instead in the position of portioning out ramen, tinned beans, toast with some sugar sprinkled on, you will be more focused on bulk than nutritional value, and you will be very motivated to spend the tiny extra you might have on something sweet or with a bit of fat. If it's all highly salted all the better because otherwise it won't be very palatable.

Danielle9891 · 29/08/2022 22:49

100% and the shops don't always sell things separately. One example was my salad I made the other day. Things such as spring onions, baby boils, potatoes salad and coleslaw and that went out of date before I could use the rest of it.

Dorisbonson · 29/08/2022 22:41

If you are comparing bland tasteless mass produced food to bland home cooked food I could agree with you. However it really doesn't take much additional cost to improve flavour and change taste.

Home cooked every day of the week and I work 60 hours, commute, have a dog and young son but food and eating healthily is a priority.

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 22:38

Prople are not born with basic cooking skills. It's not like I came out of mum and 3 days later after release from hospital I lay there at 11am watching her cook and chime in with "mother, I believe you should add a bit more caraway and paprika".

It genuinely sometimes sounds on here like people think cooking is something you are either born with or spend years perfecting before you can attempt sausage and bean stew...

Gingernan · 29/08/2022 22:37

I used to cook everything from scratch,and was a keen baker...when my kids were all at home,I was young and had tons of energy . I'm now 73 ,still working,don't drive so have to shlep my own shopping back in a granny trolley. Just oldest daughter and myself at home,we get up early for work ( me 4 am) no way am I going to exhaust myself more cooking more than the simplest food. It really isn't always cheaper.We do eat hummus and my daughter does make it but it does make more than we can eat.Who wants a vat of hummus,you can't freeze it!
I don't enjoy cooking anymore and have a teeny appetite.I joke that I'd love 'meals on wheels' that the pensioners used to get!
Oh! No ,almost never ever have take aways, too expensive.
Have cooked roasted veg in my airfryer.Quite a nice little alternative to the oven when cooking small amounts.

Baoing · 29/08/2022 22:31

I think chicken12 has actually just nailed the main point. People should be able to cook basic stuff to eat.

Yes, ready meal stuff is cheap.
Yes, sometimes it's handy.
No, it shouldn't be anyone's entire diet.
People need to eat nutritious foods.
Everyone needs to have basic cooking skills.

These five things can co exist.

Caelan2018 · 29/08/2022 22:25

I buy the the ready made family dinners in our local supermarket they have a butchers and kitchen there so all made fresh daily their chicken curry is fab and cottage pie I have 3 under 4 and they love then I cook the rice myself for the chicken curry .. they eat hot dinners most evenings sometimes they just wants sausages and beans or scrambled egg and brown bread. By yhe time I buy the chicken etc and get the time to Cook in the evening it's not worth the hassle

chicken12 · 29/08/2022 22:15

Depends but it would help people if they had basic cooking skills

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 21:49

Bubblebubblebah · 29/08/2022 20:51

Maybe people need to stop being obsessed with spag bols😳

If you have no space eintopf type dish is the logical course of action. You can cook loads in one pot and chopping board.

Why is everything in UK so hard

Spag Bol is a student classic. I never cooked it till university but it’s still one of my favourites.

Mangledrake · 29/08/2022 21:47

"I even made wine from used teabags. It tasted like oloroso sherry".

Tell us more please @Ishbel28 ?

MsPincher · 29/08/2022 21:45

Some things will be cheaper from scratch (eg bolognaise/ curry). Any quality food will be better from scratch. But I agree that lots of things won’t be. Trick is to mix and match.

However if you are making from fresh you need to be sure they will eat it - if they are fussy and don’t it will be a big waste.

Ishbel28 · 29/08/2022 21:31

You cook to eat to maintain energy. Processed foods leave you hungry later so are they really cheaper?

During the 1970s recession we were really poor, struggling from week to week despite graduate jobs. Store bought pizzas a luxury, chicken a rare treat. I still make 12 portions of food from a chicken out of respect for the bird (4 roast; 4 curry or pie; hearty soup with stock and scraps from carcass). Everyone we knew heated one room, used pressure cookers for economy, made their own beer and wine (we all loved a party). I even made wine from used teabags. It tasted like oloroso sherry.

AlviarinAesSedai · 29/08/2022 21:13

We don’t have either a decent greengrocer or 99p or £ store on my nearest high street.

BarbaraofSeville · 29/08/2022 21:10

But there's an awful lot of options between value instant noodles and £26 olive oil.

Of course, it's not always cheaper to cook from scratch, but it's also not the case that it's always impossible to do so. Plus being able to cook is probably the best way to be able to eat well on a budget. Because when you can, most processed food starts to look quite expensive in comparison.

ILoveMonday · 29/08/2022 20:57

Katypp · 29/08/2022 14:53

Not entirely sure why a couple of pps are making digs about me.
I find it bizarre that soneo e can't grasp that spending £26 to bulk buy olive oil on a £30 budget is unattainable, but maybe that's just me 🙄
The funny thing is, I do everything that is considered 'good' on here - I batch cook, I cook mostly from scratch and I bulk buy. But I am not blind to the fact that these options are not open to everyone, unlike some posters on here. I am not advocating not cooking, I am merely stating that options to save money in the long run are no good if you have to go without in the short-term. I'm not sure the woman I wrote about originally would want to spend her £30 weekly budget on whole spices and a pestle and mortar!

Agree with you completely.

I spend half my life in supermarkets comparing prices of foods and it's not always cheaper. A whole chicken in my local supermarket is between £10 and £15. Chicken breasts are £5/6 (basically disproportionately expensive). If I buy the Birdseye breadcrumbed Chicken Fillets they're £4 for a packet. If I buy 2 packets I have exactly what I need for the week and in my mind I've saved money from not buying food that I don't need. I find batch cooking overrated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread