Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
SallyB392 · 31/08/2022 16:31

I was thinking about young mums on low incomes. I was reading yesterday on FB a post by a young woman, a family of 6, and trying to make £4 stretch until the end of the week, she'd bought 2 loaves of bread, a few tomatoes, 8 hot cross buns, a bottle of squash and a bag of porridge of oats.

The menu for the next few days is beans on toast, a thin spread of jam sandwiches, oats and water to make porridge, hot cross buns as cheaper than fruit, veg stir-fry using left over veg. And 2 carrots, and so on.

With £4 there was no way she could buy protein for even one day to then cook from scratch. She is doing her best, their diet isn't the best, but her children hopefully will not be hungry.

The realities are that a big bag of frozen value chips, a big pack of frozen value burgers are cheaper than a big bag of potatoes, pack of mince, onions, (maybe breadcrumbs), grated carrot, 2 egg yolks, herbs, oil etc. And that tends to be the case across the board.

Fresh fruit is expensive, fresh veg is expensive, cheese, yoghurts, milk, eggs, meat, and fish are expensive and that's before we consider all the other Ingredients, and the cost of herbs. Spices etc.

And we haven't considered the cost of cooking. A tin of stewed beef is by far cheaper than buying fresh beef to be braised.

Starship951 · 31/08/2022 15:18

I think like for like or the amount you need to make can vary whether it works out cheaper or not.
Though, when I had a limited budget, I wouldn't have considered buying ready meals as I knew I could make the money go further by making food from scratch.
I did buy the odd pizza, frozen chips and fish fingers but that was pretty much it.

Bubblebubblebah · 31/08/2022 14:15

I think most said it is not always cheaper. It is sometimes consideably cheaper. Sometimes it is considerably more expensive.

Katypp · 31/08/2022 14:12

@SallyB392 that's exactly what I was talking about. There have been a few posters who have just popped on this thread to proclaim it is definitely cheaper to make your own, with nothing to back it up, then popped off again. That was what I meant when I said 'parrot', I meant always assuming home-made is cheaper without at any point thinking about it.
My gran was a great one for declaring 'when I think how much it wound cost me to make' every time she saw cakes, pies etc on sale, but that was the problem, she didn't think!

OP posts:
SallyB392 · 31/08/2022 12:01

There are lots of reasons why I cook from scratch, but they have nothing to do with cost.

Fresh foods prepared from scratch are NOT cheaper than fast / pre prepped foods. Price is very important nowadays, and that has to include the cost of cooking. I get really cross when I see (often young), mums being criticized for buying pre prepped food.

Nowadays it's not unusual for girls to become independent with little understanding of budgeting, and nutrition. They do their best, and should be given support not criticism.

Bubblebubblebah · 31/08/2022 08:52

I got few free boxes so I am surviving the meat😂
I know it's not up to taste of many but I found halal butchers to be great value. Never full of water so it doesn't shrink to half good price and just generally quite nice. Well the bunch I go to at least. Plus you can buy only what you need and they sell bones for soup which they also happily cut up. 😁

MintyBubbles · 31/08/2022 08:16

😁 Yes I’m not sure their meat is worth it, either. I try to think of it as a 3 for £10 style supermarket meat deal with a few added extras. I never pay full whack for a box. If you get a recipe involving mango, you can Chuck it with frozen bananas to make smoothies instead.

I think meat wise it’s only worth it if you’re mainly a household of vegetarians & cba to select meat. Plus I guess the longer you freeze it, the more cost efficient the investment.

Bubblebubblebah · 31/08/2022 08:03

You can get their recipes free online😁 I am not sure their meat is worth this, but I can see how it can make it cheaper the way you do it

MintyBubbles · 31/08/2022 08:00

Oh yes, and I never pay any extra for the frilly tecipes. Why do that? Just buy extra large prawns in Lidl, or whatever. The objective is to get as much food with as little money possible.

MintyBubbles · 31/08/2022 07:59

There’s a sneaky way to use Gousto to make it cost efficient, too.

There are only 2 of us here but I always get a box for 4 because it’s cheapest per portion and I always get the meat because it’s the most expensive part of the box.

Freeze half the meat & spend the veg out on vegetarian equivalents. Just aubergine or tofu - or courgettes, I grow my own.

Then a few weeks later when my dcs come home, I remake the recipes but using Lidl equivalent recipes. A box stretches to 5 portions sometimes, so I freeze any extra meals. Sometimes I even use the meat for totally different things. Last night my dcs has the chicken for Chinese chicken in tikka kebabs with red pepper.

Not sure if that makes sense, but I use Gousto boxes to create further ideas & not just stick to what they tell you to make. Deviant 😁

Bubblebubblebah · 31/08/2022 07:39

Only thing woth gousto is I am not keen on the meat quality. The portions could be slightly bigger with bit more veg tbh. But yeah i think it will be more than £10. I am getting one today I could look at costing it.

Mothership4two · 31/08/2022 04:00

Well generally it is cheaper to make from scratch but obviously that depends on the cost of the ingredients. Not sure what you would be annoyed about?

But yes there are very cheap budget items that are made in massive quantities that may undercut home cooking depending on where you shop . However, if you bought your tin of chickpeas from Lidl at 30p, didn't use tahini (which you can leave out) and blitzed up with ingredients you probably have at home (I do): water, oil, lemon juice, spice and salt, then it would be cheaper than the Sainsbury's one.

On a side note FYI if you cook the chickpeas first and then let them cool down before blending them they are much smoother.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/08/2022 03:13

Oh I must watch that. I suspected it was the case, the recipe boxes just look so expensive compared with buying the ingredients, especially if you choose the vegetarian options. We nearly always have in the 'specialist' ingredients or a perfectly satisfactory substitute too.

Mossstitch · 30/08/2022 23:56

@Kate0902900908 food unwrapped compared like for like last night on TV, the equivalent ingredients at a supermarket were £17 as opposed to £42.........your paying more than £10 for the convenience😬

SpinCityBlues · 30/08/2022 22:17

kateandme · 30/08/2022 22:01

We also need to stop being so snobbish over processed foods.that’s not helping people make different choices.we push people into a shamed and not good enough corner sometimes and that won’t encourage the masses to look after themselves or seek support.mental and emotional well-being are a lot to be said for cooking and making more nutritious choices.
some processed food aren’t not the felons some say they are.on balance in fact they’d be just fine. There are some extremes that don’t help.the diet culture clean eating blasting nugget bating that goes too far the other way.

You're not wrong. Asda's 'essential range' are doing cod cakes at 11p each (£1.10 for a bag of 10) which my kids would have eaten when they were young, with tinned peas, beans or spaghetti hoops. Those cod cakes are majority cod flakes and spud. A tin of spag loops in tomato sauce is 16p. Peas and beans similar.

Two DC sharing that is (each) 22p + 8p = 30p (plus energy costs obvs, and bread & butter and maybe another vegetable). OK it's not brilliant but it really is a lot cheaper than cooking it 'from scratch'.

Plus, the time element DOES matter. For a lot of female single parents their time really is money, as pp have pointed out.

Suzi888 · 30/08/2022 22:14

A work colleague said she has £15 a week left for food, for two people per week….. to me that’s pasta, soup, cereal, beans on toast, milk, forget Gusto etc!

kateandme · 30/08/2022 22:01

We also need to stop being so snobbish over processed foods.that’s not helping people make different choices.we push people into a shamed and not good enough corner sometimes and that won’t encourage the masses to look after themselves or seek support.mental and emotional well-being are a lot to be said for cooking and making more nutritious choices.
some processed food aren’t not the felons some say they are.on balance in fact they’d be just fine. There are some extremes that don’t help.the diet culture clean eating blasting nugget bating that goes too far the other way.

Kate0902900908 · 30/08/2022 20:55

This is the same argument I have with my sister. It's me and husband no kids yet.
We get gusto. Everything you need for 2 for 5 evening meals delivered to the door every Monday. £42. Everything you need, portioned out, just what you need very little issues with quality over 9 months and 50+ plus meals to choose from a lot at 10 min meals so super convenient.
I know I am paying for convenience by about £10 a week. But if I had to go to Lidl and Aldi (cheapest) I would have to drive to round buy more than I need blah blah so cooking from scratch might a majority of the time be cheaper but it does take a serious amount of effort and organisational skill. My grandmother had 13 children she was militant but she was a homemaker it was her actual vocation? We don’t have that luxury.

Bubblebubblebah · 30/08/2022 17:06

Same here. We make extra portions for freezer for busy days and then you have the quick and easy stuff to cook on a day.
For whatever reason I am also not able to make only 2 portions of roasted Mediterranean style veg... So I have often 2 in a freezer to which I can just then add fish or something.

But yes. It does depend what people eat. Lots of things have no point to batch cook as they take 30 min max anyway.

PeloAddict · 30/08/2022 16:56

@Bubblebubblebah yes exactly! I mean if I'm mashing potatoes I'm not faffing about making 1 portion of cottage pie or putting the oven on for that. Plus it saves energy as I just microwave it to heat up

On other days I will have omelettes, salads, jacket potato etc that are more single portion meals

Bubblebubblebah · 30/08/2022 16:53

PeloAddict · 30/08/2022 16:50

I'm single and I batch cook
I CBA trying to make 1 portion of cottage pie/lasagne/stew etc. Usually make 5-6 portions, put them in glass dishes and freeze them
Then I can just grab a "ready meal" out the freezer

Depends what you eat really

Some dishes really lend themselves to this, don't they. I think it's somethimes humanly impossible to cook 1 portion of things. Like rice.
Carefully, carefully, carefully... 16 portions😂

PeloAddict · 30/08/2022 16:50

petmads · 30/08/2022 15:22

It is for some things but i like to eat something different everyday for my evening meal i havent a need to batch cook theires only me and hubby no kids if hes working late he only wants something light so why make a big meal

I'm single and I batch cook
I CBA trying to make 1 portion of cottage pie/lasagne/stew etc. Usually make 5-6 portions, put them in glass dishes and freeze them
Then I can just grab a "ready meal" out the freezer

Depends what you eat really

CaptainBarbosa · 30/08/2022 16:39

petmads · 30/08/2022 15:22

It is for some things but i like to eat something different everyday for my evening meal i havent a need to batch cook theires only me and hubby no kids if hes working late he only wants something light so why make a big meal

I don't batch cook either, half would go to waste, it's only me and 8 year old DS, and my freezer compartment is just not big enough 🤷🏻‍♀️

My child however loves a freybentos pie, home made cornbeef and potato pie, sausage mash and gravy (which I do, make from scratch, sausages are store bought though, But the potatoes are peeled and mashed and the gravy home made) he likes gammon, egg and chips (again I just peel and chip the potatoes and against all fire safety, have a chip pan I know I know, shoot me now but they taste so good....

We will also have lavabread and fried bread with eggs, beans and bacon. Things like that.

In winter months we have more stews/cawl and I will make fresh bread rolls to go with them. I also make heavier starchy things like bara brith. Bara brith, butter and tea is one of our favourite suppers in the winter or even better some old fashioned bread pudding and a cuppa.

As you can guess I make a lot of traditional seasonal Welsh dishes, because I'm Welsh and it's all we've ever eaten because we've always been working class. But they are easy and cost effective to make from scratch.

He's easy to cook for, we get a variety and it's a mix and match of fresh from scratch and pre made. I won't make my own quiche for example, I just can't be arsed when I can buy one for a £1 and then serve with some fresh side salad and a small portion of olive oil, sea salt pasta.

I strike a balance according to my budget, and the time I have as a full time working lone mother 🤷🏻‍♀️

petmads · 30/08/2022 15:22

It is for some things but i like to eat something different everyday for my evening meal i havent a need to batch cook theires only me and hubby no kids if hes working late he only wants something light so why make a big meal

Crikeyalmighty · 30/08/2022 14:39

I forgot to add also, it's not always that easy to do tons of fresh homemade meals with a family- due to peoples comings and goings and often being picky!! Not every family sits down at the table to eat together together most nights. My H can't stand Indian food or lentils or eggs or red peppers (in fact quite a lot of things)- so lots of Indian stuff or omelettes or quiches are a complete no no.