Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 28/08/2022 12:03

if you are mega organised, meal plan every week, make in bulk and freeze etc then I can absolutely believe it would be cheaper.

however most of us don’t have the time or inclination to do that. Most of us work too!

TwoMonthsOff · 28/08/2022 12:03

@Katypp
pesto is another no brainer to make from scratch, due to cost/effort

FudgeSundae · 28/08/2022 12:01

I don’t think that’s what I thought people meant when they say “it’s cheaper to cook from scratch”. I think what I mean is that if I personally had a really small food budget (like I have at various times) I will eat very cheap homemade meals from e.g. a huge sack of 50p potatoes, half an onion and half a tin of 30p chopped tomatoes, total cost like 30p per meal. I don’t mean that the equivalent to a shop bought thing is always cheaper homemade. I agree if you want choice or a specific thing then some things shops do better.

notanothertakeaway · 28/08/2022 12:00

I agree

Home cooked food is better in so many ways, but I don't think it's the cheapest way to eat

sheepdogdelight · 28/08/2022 12:00

You're not comparing like for like though, are you (and your caveats are really you indicating that this is the case).

It don't doubt it's cheaper to buy a ready made lasagne than Iceland, than to make a lasagne from scratch but the the lasagne you make from scratch is not comparable to the Iceland one. To make a similar quality lasagne it would be cheaper from scratch.

Goldmember · 28/08/2022 11:58

I understand what you are saying op. I do a lot of cooking with base ingredients and enjoy it. My issue is with recipes that need a tablespoon of something and you'd have to waste a pot or or tin of something for that tablespoon.
I've never made pasta, the cost of eggs are not worth it and you are left with lots of egg white. Unless you have planned a pavlova for pudding it seems wasteful.
I have made pizza dough but the hours of proving are not worth the effort vs a ready made pizza. I have made lasagne but my god, the washing up alone is not worth it. Steak puddings and pies take so long to make. I make chicken nuggets, the kids prefer frozen.

Doormatnomore · 28/08/2022 11:57

Many moons ago when my darling pfb only ate things I made, had 10 fruit or veg a day and the full colour wheel he was ill and off his food and had medicine that needed to be take with food. My gran who crooked from scratch because that’s all she knew and had raised plenty of kids to adulthood advised me “they always eat chips”. I remember buying a sack of oven chips for £1. I spent weeks like an insufferable prig telling everyone that of course people would choose a sack of chips if they were on a tight budget like no one else had joined the dots.

IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep · 28/08/2022 11:57

For Spaghetti bolognaise I have just worked it oit!

@Katypp Aldi prices:

cheapeast microwave meal is 75p for a 400gram meal

from scratch:
1kg mince
2 tins tomatoes 800grams total
1 tin 400grams green lentils (I always add to bulk it out)
1 pack 500gram spaghetti
Bit of garlic powered and mixed herbs

£4.68

this would make 2.2 kilos of Bolognaise sauce
PLUS the spaghetti. And a whole pack makes loads
If you said a pack of spaghetti serves 5 people (100g dried each obvs weighs more cooked )

It’s 0.93 pence per portion. BUT the weight of the bolognaise sauce per person (without pasta) weighs more than the whole of the microwave meal with the pasta.

ovenproof · 28/08/2022 11:52

What about the Mumsnet chicken? I thought that fed a family of four for four nights?

PriamFarrl · 28/08/2022 11:51

I agree. I hate when I see recipes costed out saying 1tsp honey (or other ingredient) 2p, for example, when you can’t buy a tsp of honey by a whole jar. And that’s fine if you will be making the recipe loads or it’s a good store cupboard ingredient.

CherryGenoa · 28/08/2022 11:50

I agree with the OP, some ready made food is surprisingly cheap to buy and to heat up…but no one should be forced to live on food that is nutritionally poor that won’t support their health.

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:47

@Fixyourself you're missing the point. I said cheaper, I didn't say better, and I included lots of caveats to make my point clear.

OP posts:
FriendOfDorothyGale · 28/08/2022 11:47

It really depends on what you're cooking. Homemade food does usually tend to be tastier though.

If you have a cupboard full of herbs and spices and the other basics, Tinned tomatoes etc, it's definitely cheaper. But you also need to buy the tupperware to store and freeze it.

For someone who doesn't have the store cupboard staples, then I would agree.

I deffo cba making my own houmous tho.

IcedOatLatte · 28/08/2022 11:45

Fixyourself · 28/08/2022 11:43

And that’s why cancer rates and obesity are soaring!
Your body need whole foods and not processed crap!

That might be true but what has it got to do with the cost of home cooking?

alwaysfactor50 · 28/08/2022 11:45

@Katypp a 400g of chickpeas is 240g drained weight so not much difference at all from a tub of houmous!!

PeloAddict · 28/08/2022 11:44

Fixyourself · 28/08/2022 11:43

And that’s why cancer rates and obesity are soaring!
Your body need whole foods and not processed crap!

That's great but some people now can't afford it. Cost of living and energy prices? Confused
Fed is better than not fed, no matter what it consists of

chillipenguin · 28/08/2022 11:44

LionessesRules · 28/08/2022 11:40

The really cheap cooking suggestions also seem to assume a stocked store cupboard. Yes, you may only be adding 5p of herbs and spices, but they come in packets that cost much more. You need to be able to afford the initial purchase.

Agree, it has to be something you'll cook every week to be worth it

WyldeSwan · 28/08/2022 11:44

Also factor in energy costs of actually cooking the things from scratch, rather than reheating and the difference will slim down again.

But yes, where I can, I'd rather home cook meals.

IcedOatLatte · 28/08/2022 11:43

You also need to have all the equipment and knowledge to know what you're doing. That's not always the case

Fixyourself · 28/08/2022 11:43

And that’s why cancer rates and obesity are soaring!
Your body need whole foods and not processed crap!

LionessesRules · 28/08/2022 11:40

The really cheap cooking suggestions also seem to assume a stocked store cupboard. Yes, you may only be adding 5p of herbs and spices, but they come in packets that cost much more. You need to be able to afford the initial purchase.

Outlyingtrout · 28/08/2022 11:36

I think it probably is cheaper to cook everything from scratch but you'd need to have the money upfront to buy huge quantities of ingredients in bulk to make big batches. You'd need the room to store ingredients and freezers to store cooked food. You'd also need lots of time to do all the prep. You'd need a car to collect the bulk amounts of ingredients, or enough money to shop somewhere that delivers (Aldi and Lidl don't). You also need basic cooking skills and not everybody has these.

If you want to eat more variety than tinned tomatoes on toast, I believe for most people on low incomes nowadays their cheapest realistic option is to buy processed stuff.

lollipoprainbow · 28/08/2022 11:34

Totally agree it's more expensive and not to mention faffy, I just don't have the time to cook from scratch.

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:34

@IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep is it though? Weight for weight? You've said the ready meal portions are small. Could you cook the same amount for less money? People assume it will be cheaper but it's not always the case.

OP posts:
ouch321 · 28/08/2022 11:34

Yes but people are great at deceiving themselves.

It's not unusual for me, purely out of curiosity, to add up the prices of all the ingredients for a meal using my receipt, then divide it by the number of portions I get out of it to get a 1 person cost, and then compare it to the price of a one person ready meal. The price is often roughly thr same as the ready meal or sometimes more to do it from fresh.