Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
DrBrennerFan · 28/08/2022 12:40

I used to cook loads from scratch but arthritis has killed that.

Soontobe60 · 28/08/2022 12:37

FudgeSundae · 28/08/2022 12:25

groceries.asda.com/product/baking-jacket-potatoes/asda-british-fluffy-golden-large-baking-potatoes/24932 Is what I was thinking of. I used baked potatoes for most things - often cheaper and no peeling!

These work out at 56p a kg. Buy these, same potatoes, and you'd be paying 39.6p a kg
groceries.asda.com/product/white-potatoes/just-essentials-by-asda-white-potatoes/910003089142

lollipoprainbow · 28/08/2022 12:36

Christ isn't life too short to make your own hummous Confused

Lbushsgkm · 28/08/2022 12:35

With the hummus example I agree (although we get chickpeas for around 30p) – and if you’re on a budget the initial outlay on tahini (£4 min?) is costly. I think there’s also the time spent – if you’re busy and time poor too, sometimes that’s an extra cost to weigh up in itself.

For stuff like dhal and soup it’s massively cheaper to make yourself, and the volume you can produce and store in one go makes it economical time-wise.

I guess the issue is when people get smug about cooking from scratch and use it as a stick to beat others and feel superior! A 60p pot of hummus – it’s not exactly Mariah Carey’s rider is it?

gogohmm · 28/08/2022 12:34

@Katypp

Humous is cheaper to make - I shop in Lidl. Chickpeas were 35p this week, 4 lemons was 55p (use bottled to save more), tahini is £2, olive oil £3 but they last months. I paid 79p for humous last week there but a can of chickpeas will make a bigger quantity too.

Many scratch cooked meals are far cheaper IF there's 3+ people and especially if you have a freezer. There are things that I can buy cheaper shop bought but they are few and far between

Soontobe60 · 28/08/2022 12:32

Jack Monroe tweeted a photo of her shopping yesterday - spent just over £18 and claims she can cook 42 meals - 3 people over a week. Then about 5 tweets down the thread, she agreed that she used lots of her store cupboard and freezer ingredients. So yes, I could claim to cook a meal for thruppence but I’d have to raid the cupboards for most of the ingredients.

Cooking cheaply is all about savvy shopping and economies of scale. I’ll buy mince when its reduced, freeze it and then when I've stockpiled enough, make a huge batch of something like bolognese in my slow cooker, portion it into freezer bags and bung it in the freezer. I can probably get 10 portions for 50p a portion depending on how reduced the mince was. Last week, I made 50 child sized portions of a variety freezer meals using mince, chicken, beans as the bases, cost me £24 for all the ingredients apart from herbs. That’s 48p a portion.

Thighdentitycrisis · 28/08/2022 12:32

I think if you compare like for like as in your hummus example, it’s often not cheaper. However, in more general terms of planning a weeks menu and making it all from scratch, so mostly cutting out processed foods, it might be cheaper and will definitely be tasty and nutritious.

ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 28/08/2022 12:28

That's not a huge sack - thats 4 potatoes in a plastic bag! FudgeSundae

KatieBenz · 28/08/2022 12:28

Katypp · 28/08/2022 12:25

Oh dear. I thought I had made it clear in my first post that I am not comparing quality, health or wholesomeness, just price. Which of course, is the criteria you have to use when on a tight budget.
I KNOW homemade hummous will be much nicer and more wholesome with better ingredients, that's obvious. I am not comparing like-for-like, I am comparing cost-for-cost.
And pretty much all of the examples so far rely on an element of bulk buying and a store cupboard of herbs, spices, oil etc.
Yes you can make bolognaise cheaper but that assumes you can afford to fork out nearly a fiver for the ingredients, and are either prepared to eat it every night or have a freezer to store it in. It also assumes you have the cash flow to have most of your outlay frozen for the future rather than to feed your family now

Posted at exactly the same time. I think we are both saying the same thing.

FudgeSundae · 28/08/2022 12:25

IcedOatLatte · 28/08/2022 12:10

a huge sack of 50p potatoes

Out of interest @FudgeSundae where are you getting potatoes at that price? The cheapest ones in tesco yesterday were 99p and were neither huge nor in a sack, a normal plastic bag of wonkly potatoes

groceries.asda.com/product/baking-jacket-potatoes/asda-british-fluffy-golden-large-baking-potatoes/24932 Is what I was thinking of. I used baked potatoes for most things - often cheaper and no peeling!

KatieBenz · 28/08/2022 12:25

I agree, sometimes it’s cheaper to buy ready made. Where savings can be made is by batch cooking. This is much cheaper than buying several ready meals or convenience foods, but you need store cupboard staples, storage space (for dried goods and freezing) and of course, time. A lot of people simply don’t have that. Many people don’t have the financial means to buy in bulk. There is also the matter of knowledge. I grew up in a family where cooking frugally was the norm. A lot of people have never been taught how to cook from scratch or how you can make several meals from one piece of meat and a load of veg, carbs.

Katypp · 28/08/2022 12:25

Oh dear. I thought I had made it clear in my first post that I am not comparing quality, health or wholesomeness, just price. Which of course, is the criteria you have to use when on a tight budget.
I KNOW homemade hummous will be much nicer and more wholesome with better ingredients, that's obvious. I am not comparing like-for-like, I am comparing cost-for-cost.
And pretty much all of the examples so far rely on an element of bulk buying and a store cupboard of herbs, spices, oil etc.
Yes you can make bolognaise cheaper but that assumes you can afford to fork out nearly a fiver for the ingredients, and are either prepared to eat it every night or have a freezer to store it in. It also assumes you have the cash flow to have most of your outlay frozen for the future rather than to feed your family now

OP posts:
ProbablyPossiblyPerhaps · 28/08/2022 12:24

Badgirlriri it isn't cheaper if you buy pizza dough - that's not making from scratch! It is cheaper if you make your own pizza dough, in which case a base costs less than 10p.

I'm not judging - we buy ready made bases as the teens happily make their own pizzas using them but cba to make dough (and obviously if you do it properly with yeast and leaving it to rise instead of cutting corners and using baking powder/ self raising flour it involves waiting hours).

Often when people say they're cooking from scratch they aren't, and the "half way house" part prepared ingredients make the finished product more expensive than either a cheap processed ready made version or something genuinely made "from scratch".

Obviously genuinely making things from the basic ingredients requires a big store cupboard full of ingredients and is often much more time consuming and absolutely not a realistic option for people who are juggling full time work and extensive caring responsibility (especially if they don't already have the extensive well stocked store cupboard).

LindaEllen · 28/08/2022 12:20

If you're just buying ingredients to cook one portion then of course it's not cheaper - because most ingredients come in pack sizes enough to make many portions. But, if you have a decent store of dried food, and batch cook and freeze portions, it can be cheaper.

The thing is it's not only money that's worth something - your time is worth something too, and if you decide that a ready meal (for example) or a pre-made sauce saves you enough time to make the extra cost worth it, that's absolutely fine.

QuattroFromagio · 28/08/2022 12:19

Lots of people living alone have very small cupboard and fridge/freezer space, too, which limits storage of raw ingredients, all the leftover raw ingredients, the containers, the finished products etc. Add in the cost of the energy use, too.

I find a lot of ready meals quite good value. You can get Waitrose 'ready to cook' meals, used to be 3 for £10 though I think it's now 2 for £7.50, and they're not totally processed or full of crap - they're mostly stuff you'd use yourself, but just don't need in large quantities. For a similar price to the meat/fish/main veg, you also get the sauce or spices or coatings or whatever, and then just have to bung it in the oven. Same with the Cook meals.

You might make tastier ones yourself ,but I don't think I do! Cooking for one is a pain at the best of times, so a decent selection of ready meals can help. I do get a bit tired of the same ones repeatedly and wish they had a few more, but it's still not too bad.

I'd like to find some cheaper recipes that are easy to cook for one and don't take much time after work, but I don't think it's as easy as it might sound.

RealBecca · 28/08/2022 12:19

You also need to consider the recipe you are following. If it is a premium one then they want to recommend top ingredients so that it is the best version of itself. If you look at a basic online recipe or a book aimed at budget cooking you'll get a different recipe- because the aim is to make something palatable for dinner, not something to show off at a dinner party.

foghead · 28/08/2022 12:18

I know you listed your caveats but I just wanted to add that cooking from scratch is an investment in your good health.
The fresh homemade hummus will be more nutritious for sure, but it also has fresh garlic and fresh lemon juice both of which can help your body fight infections and keep your immune system functioning well.

If you're feeding a family, I think cooking from scratch does often work out cheaper. For a single person or couple, then maybe not.

mrcow · 28/08/2022 12:12

Last time I tried to make hummus it broke my food processor.

it wasn’t cheap!

Fireyflies · 28/08/2022 12:11

The cheap houmous won't be made from olive oil though - it'll have vegetable oil, almost no tahini and also quite a lot of water. So if you were following a similar recipe your can of chickpeas (240g drained weight, 60p) plus lemon juice (bottled, not fresh, 10p's worth), vegetable oil (2p), plus a couple of garlic cloves (6p) plus water and salt would give you about two tubs of houmous worth and only have cost you 78p - so around half the price. So if other things have similar mark ups (I think they do in average) overall you'd halve your food budget by cooking from scratch. Yes it is more work and requires a bit of cupboard storage.

IcedOatLatte · 28/08/2022 12:10

a huge sack of 50p potatoes

Out of interest @FudgeSundae where are you getting potatoes at that price? The cheapest ones in tesco yesterday were 99p and were neither huge nor in a sack, a normal plastic bag of wonkly potatoes

Luredbyapomegranate · 28/08/2022 12:09

I’d generally agree. (Although you can buy tins of chickpeas and lemons for less than you say, even now, and you’d get much more. Also not entirely sure 69p humous would have any noticeable amount of Tahini in it)

thebellagio · 28/08/2022 12:09

Energy bills will now play a huge cost as well. Take something like shepherds pie - you need the gas/electricity to make the mince and the mash then the oven to cook it afterwards. our smart meter already says if we use 2 hobs for 20 mins it costs about a pound just for that alone.

yet a own brand ready meal could cost something like £1.25 and then 2 mins microwaving cost. So infinitely cheaper.

RealBecca · 28/08/2022 12:08

Your example is wrong

Tesco chickpeas 60p 40p (usually on a 4 for 4 for 3 offer so usually 30p)+ lemon 30p a squirt from a bottle = 90p 50p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini sesame seeds or sesame oil.

If you do 3x tins of chickpeas (so approx £1.20 ingredients) you can fill 2 sandwich box Tupperware.

So the example you gave is cheaper to make your own.

And you can make substitutes. Unless you are using premium olive oil then sunflower will do just as well.

Branster · 28/08/2022 12:06

Hummus is probably a very good example and I agree. And it's a healthy food.
Natural Yogurt exactly the same.
Cheese, the same.
Smoked fish, the same (although smoked food is as healthy, but it probably compensates in case of fish).

Bread, not sure.

Other foods must be cheaper to cook from scratch in a gram for gram price comparison. How you work it out? No idea! There's cooking costs too, like using the oven, washing all utensils etc.

I prefer home cooked food for taste and health reasons, even the frozen meals from Cook are not as tasty as home made versions but I think they pass the health test. Regular ready meals from supermarket (including M&S) are not that great and I never use them.

When all things considered, it can be expensive spending so much time working out the cost of food shopping and cooking. I could be using that time working and earning money instead. Which is more enjoyable in my case.

In other countries, there is more acceptance that food is not cheap. People are used to spending a higher proportion of their income on food. And it tends to be more on fresh produce. I wouldn't think they are delighted to spend so much, but it has always been that way.
Maybe the UK will go the same way.

123Callie · 28/08/2022 12:05

Chinese food is designed to be cheap in terms of energy requirements and ingredients. Chop everything small to cook it quicker, only small amounts of meat, fish or eggs used. Inexpensive sauces and pickles used for flavourings.

It is really difficult though to eat that style every day if you have grown up with a different diet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread