Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
AllPlayedOut · 28/08/2022 13:59

Re young fussy eaters: my dad's policy was "you won't starve yourself" so even though he wasn't the best cook (he did his best), we could eat what was served or go hungry. And I never went hungry and food wasn't wasted. Leftovers went into packed lunch or dinner next day.

Well, some kids will go hungry and some will starve themselves.

AllPlayedOut · 28/08/2022 13:58

Tahini from 99p shop 99p

I'm envious of your 99p tahini. I've never seen it for that price here. It's usually around £3. Sometimes more.

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 13:57

said with the chickpea example, use the chickpeas for one receipe and use the water for another by thinking ahead and being resourceful. like what?
I can’t think of any use for the boiled chickpea water.

Celyn22 · 28/08/2022 13:55

Re young fussy eaters: my dad's policy was "you won't starve yourself" so even though he wasn't the best cook (he did his best), we could eat what was served or go hungry. And I never went hungry and food wasn't wasted. Leftovers went into packed lunch or dinner next day.

MerryChristmasToYou · 28/08/2022 13:51

Katypp · 28/08/2022 12:55

@MerryChristmasToYou @notacooldad But again, your examples assume people have time to shop around (supermarket, greengrocer) and have the money to spare to build up a store cupboard. Tahini and olive oil are expensive buys from a small shopping budget even if they are used up for something else

Greengrocer and 99p are in the high street. I can pick up the lemons and garlic from the greengrocer and then get the chickpeas and tahini from the 99p shop. i can walk from my house.
While I'm in the 99p shop I can also pick up falafel mix.
If I want salad, I could get it in Iceland.

This would probably be quicker than nipping to the supermarket.

Terfydactyl · 28/08/2022 13:50

MerryChristmasToYou · 28/08/2022 12:49

Chickpeas in World Foods section 3 for £1.
Lemons from greengrocer 6 for £1
Tahini from 99p shop 99p
Garlic 69p for 4
Olive oil - I don't bother with it, use a bit of the chickpea water if dry.

2 tins of chickpeas, juice from 2 lemons, 2 cloves of garlic or to taste.
4 tbsp of tahini.
Blitz with blender. Put half in freezer.

I'm not poor in either money or time, but I dont own a blender.
Assuming everyone owns a blender, has a freezer, is able to carry home 3 tins of anything along with all their other shopping is entirely predictable but useless for the really really less well off.

FWIW when I was a very very skint single parent I lived on 6p noodles, add hot water, stir and eat. My children got one tray meals like fishfinger and chips cos putting the oven and hob on was beyond our monetary means.

Christ I dont even like hummus, it just irks me when so many posters try to say how much better cooking from scratch is.
It could taste like the best thing ever ever ever made, it makes no odds when you cant afford to actually cook it.

Tabbouleh · 28/08/2022 13:45

Playing devil's advocate, people in v poor countries- India, China, Thailand, Vietnam- cook from scratch without freezers or even kitchens. On the side of the road over a fire. But I guess the way of life is completely different.

Hankunamatata · 28/08/2022 13:44

It's cheaper for me as cook for 6 and freeze left overs. If just cooking for me I'd say ready meals be cheaper

dworky · 28/08/2022 13:42

If it was true, it certainly won't be now!

feistyoneyouare · 28/08/2022 13:31

Thehonestbadger · 28/08/2022 13:22

It’s a much bigger picture than most give credit to which always annoys the hell out of me.

  • Budget. ‘I’d like to cut down a bit’ vs ‘I have £10 to feed my family for the week’
  • Quality/nutrition. Will kids actually eat ‘healthy food’? Fussy toddlers refusing stuff isn’t an option when you’re on the breadline. Dietary requirements…etc
  • Facilities. Do you have a oven/hob, a freezer? Room to store things? Maybe you’re sharing cooking facilities? Limited to a microwave.
  • Practicalities if you’re working 40 hours a week, can’t make ends meet, struggling, kids with additional needs… probably aren’t going to be living your best life and full of motivation.

Looking down on people struggling financially because they don’t ‘cook everything from scratch’ is small minded and presumptive. It unfortunately shines a light on a lot of unchecked privilege.

If you have a well equipped kitchen, ample freezer storage, time/energy and non fussy/restrictive dinners who want to eat well then yes you absolutely can do it on a low budget.
If you have poor facilities, low time/energy, fussy or restrictive eaters and no real motivation to eat healthily then it’s all around easier to eat low cost processed meals like frozen pizzas and beans.

Either way, extending judgment without empathy is shitty.

Well said. I've thought the same so many times when I've read judgey threads about cooking from scratch.

notacooldad · 28/08/2022 13:30

But again, your examples assume people have time to shop around (supermarket, greengrocer) and have the money to spare to build up a store cupboard
Why does it take longer to pick up a jar of say, tahini, in Asda than it does a pot of jam in the same shop?
My point was about meal planning and using the same ingredients multiple times saves money. If you are shopping surely it makes sense to buy the things that you are going to get the most value out to save money. A cheap ready meal will only be ate once but the ingredient such as olive oil will be used over and over again. As I said with the chickpea example, use the chickpeas for one receipe and use the water for another by thinking ahead and being resourceful.
Most people do seem to already have stuff in, even families where we do food drop offs and food bank runs for have some basics such as flour, marg, sugar salt.
I think the main problem is that for many years people have been getting by and buying what we like,the art of cooking cheap meals from next to nothing and not having any waste has been forgotten.

Thehonestbadger · 28/08/2022 13:22

It’s a much bigger picture than most give credit to which always annoys the hell out of me.

  • Budget. ‘I’d like to cut down a bit’ vs ‘I have £10 to feed my family for the week’
  • Quality/nutrition. Will kids actually eat ‘healthy food’? Fussy toddlers refusing stuff isn’t an option when you’re on the breadline. Dietary requirements…etc
  • Facilities. Do you have a oven/hob, a freezer? Room to store things? Maybe you’re sharing cooking facilities? Limited to a microwave.
  • Practicalities if you’re working 40 hours a week, can’t make ends meet, struggling, kids with additional needs… probably aren’t going to be living your best life and full of motivation.

Looking down on people struggling financially because they don’t ‘cook everything from scratch’ is small minded and presumptive. It unfortunately shines a light on a lot of unchecked privilege.

If you have a well equipped kitchen, ample freezer storage, time/energy and non fussy/restrictive dinners who want to eat well then yes you absolutely can do it on a low budget.
If you have poor facilities, low time/energy, fussy or restrictive eaters and no real motivation to eat healthily then it’s all around easier to eat low cost processed meals like frozen pizzas and beans.

Either way, extending judgment without empathy is shitty.

Celyn22 · 28/08/2022 13:18

It all boils down to what matters... time vs interest vs financial resource vs storage vs health etc.

I have fed 3 adults for £25 per week before, and I did put in initial time working out what I could make for that, but then I was on auto pilot for months. I was shopping primarily at Aldi and Lidl as they were within walking distance, and then I cycle to an Asian bulk store once a month to buy dried rice and lentils. It was not fun cycling uphill on the way back!

My mum grew up with a roast on Sundays, then the meat was continually evolving throughout the week with different dishes and veg served with it, ending with a stew on a Friday. Saturday was more 'eggs on toast' style dinner, then back to roast. I have no idea of the cost but I reckon that was quite resourceful.

Growing up, we only had an icebox in the fridge to preserve food so we ate lots of cheap things like cous cous (either a packet or natural and I'd add mixed herbs and salt) with veg (cheap supermarket veg chopped small and steamed). We also ate a lot of pasta with homemade tinned tomato sauce. I was hungry a lot, partly because I was growing but also because we ate a lot of carbs and not a lot of fat and protein which is less filling for me. So I think I ate more during this time which would financially add up to more.

Nowadays every month or two I do a big batch of hummus and freeze it, it's a staple in our home! When we find reduced greens in the supermarket I prepare a big batch of pesto, and freeze it to eat throughout the month. I dehydrate veg and fruit to eat throughout the year too, buying when I see them cheap. I worked out recently it costs £1.50 to dry 10 trays for 24 hours. We have the space for a dehydrator.

If we don't feel like cooking or don't have much time then we have a 'snacky' dinner with stuff from the freezer and pull out a few jars of gherkins, olives, crackers, hummus and pesto. It means we knock up a healthy cheap 'meal' in a minute, with the only washing up in that moment: plates and cutlery.

I enjoy cooking and the creativity I can put in, as well as enjoying playing with numbers and costs, so I do make meals based on nutritional needs, but I also earn very little money so it's all very cheap to make, and I do save to buy the better quality ingredients in bulk that I like to have. E.g olive oil £26 for 5l, 5kg tahini (can't remember the price)... it's a lot more to spend in one go, but it balances all the factors out for me. (Money,health,time,interest)

I am now pregnant and have had a few cravings for things like tortellinis... I bought a few meals with ready made things and I couldn't believe how much more money I spent when getting these things! I definitely couldn't afford to buy ready made things regularly.

Purpleforthewin · 28/08/2022 13:16

Some things can be made cheaper but there is also a lot of premade stuff that is really cheap as bulk made with cheaper wholesale ingredients

Redqueenheart · 28/08/2022 13:14

It is absolutely true for me.

I am vegetarian and the majority of what I eat is just vegetables, fruits, rice, tofu, noodles and pasta.

The only processed stuff I will add occasionally are things like fresh veggie burgers and sausages.

I think ready meals are too salty in general and taste incredibly bland. They've always seem like a waste of money to me.

Atmywitsend29 · 28/08/2022 13:12

Also, there's the cost of pots and pans. I have a basic set of saucepans from Wilko and one bent frying pan. I own exactly 1 roasting dish, 2 flat trays, and one ceramic dish. And half of those things are items DH moved in with me with, 5 years ago!

If I was to cook from scratch properly, every meal, it would be a massive financial outlay to purchase the necessary pots, pans, Utensils to do that.

And then purchase a bigger freezer to store food in. And enough tupperware to store it in.

Riapia · 28/08/2022 13:11

OP this is AIBU any opinions expressed on here are not necessarily those of the people posting them.

DarkDarkNight · 28/08/2022 13:11

It also assumes things you make will come out fine as well. I’m a shit cook, so things don’t always come out edible.

SirBarneyPlumsted · 28/08/2022 13:09

Making your own coleslaw is far cheaper.

carefullycourageous · 28/08/2022 13:09

TwitchyJerk · 28/08/2022 13:04

I'm all for cooking from scratch, but houmous, come on!!

My mum makes her own houmous. Slimming world version with no oil. It's pretty gross.

Homemade houmous (trad recipe with oil) is way nicer than bought houmous.

Cynderella · 28/08/2022 13:09

It's not ALWAYS cheaper, of course, but you have to compare like with like. My homemade pizza is not comparable to a £1 from somewhere, but even if I compared it with a better quality one, ready made may be cheaper factoring in energy.

Some things are definitely cheaper though - I'm about to make croutons from stale bread. Definitely cheaper. Making a sandwich or coffee at home will be cheaper. Same with smoothies.

SpinCityBlues · 28/08/2022 13:08

DrBrennerFan · 28/08/2022 12:40

I used to cook loads from scratch but arthritis has killed that.

Same here. I can barely get a tin of tomatoes open.

What can you manage? I eat a fair amount of soup.

carefullycourageous · 28/08/2022 13:08

In terms of getting calories in for £ spent, cooking is definitely not always cheaper. In terms of getting real food, I think cooking is overall cheaper. What a lot of people eat is not really food, it is ultra processed food and therefore is incomparable.

But when on a very low budget it is hard to cook from scratch due to equipment, fuel costs, time and other pressures.

I'm not judging anyone's choices but scientifically speaking some of the very low costs 'food' is really unhealthy and it is awful there is no option for too many people.

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 13:07

Not everyone is conveniently within a short walk or drive from budget places like Aldi/Lidl.

and driving from one place to the other to save few ££ on Groceries is a bit daft .

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 28/08/2022 13:06

Certainly won't be now leccy/gas costs through the roof..

Swipe left for the next trending thread