Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get annoyed when people parrot that it's always cheaper to cook from scratch?

638 replies

Katypp · 28/08/2022 11:24

Caveats: Home made food is usually:
A. Nicer
B. More nutritious
C: Made with proper ingredients that you can control
D: More filling
E: Not made with fillers, starch etc

But it's not always cheaper!

Time after time, when people post about food costs, the trope is always make it yourself, you'll save money. This post is in frustration after yet again, someone tripped it out on a budgeting forum. Someone commented that Tesco budget hummous is quite nice, to be told, as always, you can make it cheaper yourself.
You can't. Eastman's hummous 69p

Tesco chickpeas 60p + lemon 30p = 90p and that's before you add olive oil and tahini.

Yes I know you can soak your own chickpeas and buy in bulk at an Asian grocer etc, but that level of organisation for most people is beyond the effort of just picking up a tub on the weekly shop.

For the record, I am a very keen home cook and have also run a food business and written about food in the past. I enjoy cooking, but I am sick of people trotting out this line without thinking about it, especially on budgeting and money-saving forums.

OP posts:
TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 28/08/2022 14:32

🦜 cheaper to cook.
🦜 cheaper to cook,
🦜 cheaper to cook.

Who's a pretty boy then?

Mossstitch · 28/08/2022 14:29

Totally agree with @Skethylita have cooked from scratch since I was a child and brought up 3 boys, it is always cheaper even pizza, (as well as being a lot healthier than the cheap frozen ones that often aren't even real cheese, I used to work in the food industry and sold it!) pizza can be used as a vehicle to use up any little bits of leftovers thereby reducing waste too, nothing much has ever got wasted in my house. I make a big batch of dough (with my hands, bread machine really not needed) from half a bag of asda bread flour 50p, the left over dough from the first meal gets floured, put inside a bag and put in the fridge where it will happily live all week until you want another, break off a handful of dough (whether for pizza or some fresh bread rolls) and return rest to fridge. I've always been short of money until the last few years (over 60 and no mortgage now) but I still can't bring myself to waste anything.
I think the problem is more lack of skill or the interest in cooking, shopping and budgetting. People that aren't interested in that are not going to be motivated to do it and that is fair enough, their choice, but not right to use the argument that it is cheaper to feed their kids rubbish food, it's not! Even chips can be made cheaper and healthier by using real potatoes with a little spray of oil plus seasonings if required all shaken up in a bag to coat and cooked on a tray in the oven.

Tabbouleh · 28/08/2022 14:27

TroysMammy · 28/08/2022 14:24

Initial outlay is expensive but in the long run it can be cheaper. I make hummus and freeze it in small pots. When defrosted, and tastes the same as made fresh, there is no waste and no one use plastic is used either.

I make about 5 types of dahl, channa masala ( chickpea curry) or kidney beans. Keeps for 3 days in fridge or freezes in ziplocks. V cheap and nutritious.

I don't make my own hummus or bread.

clpsmum · 28/08/2022 14:25

It's not always cheaper it can be bloody expensive. I'm too poor to have morals I'm afraid!

TroysMammy · 28/08/2022 14:24

Initial outlay is expensive but in the long run it can be cheaper. I make hummus and freeze it in small pots. When defrosted, and tastes the same as made fresh, there is no waste and no one use plastic is used either.

watingroom2 · 28/08/2022 14:24

IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep · 28/08/2022 11:57

For Spaghetti bolognaise I have just worked it oit!

@Katypp Aldi prices:

cheapeast microwave meal is 75p for a 400gram meal

from scratch:
1kg mince
2 tins tomatoes 800grams total
1 tin 400grams green lentils (I always add to bulk it out)
1 pack 500gram spaghetti
Bit of garlic powered and mixed herbs

£4.68

this would make 2.2 kilos of Bolognaise sauce
PLUS the spaghetti. And a whole pack makes loads
If you said a pack of spaghetti serves 5 people (100g dried each obvs weighs more cooked )

It’s 0.93 pence per portion. BUT the weight of the bolognaise sauce per person (without pasta) weighs more than the whole of the microwave meal with the pasta.

Yours works out at less per portion if your portion size is the same.

Fatballs · 28/08/2022 14:22

I think somecfoodsa are relatively cheap to make up and cheaper than buying premade and clearly some arent

I agree with this. Generally, we cook from scratch but some things are just not worth the faff unless there is no easy/cheap option. I’d put bread in this category.

RedToothBrush · 28/08/2022 14:20

IvebeenUpAllNightNoSleep · 28/08/2022 11:57

For Spaghetti bolognaise I have just worked it oit!

@Katypp Aldi prices:

cheapeast microwave meal is 75p for a 400gram meal

from scratch:
1kg mince
2 tins tomatoes 800grams total
1 tin 400grams green lentils (I always add to bulk it out)
1 pack 500gram spaghetti
Bit of garlic powered and mixed herbs

£4.68

this would make 2.2 kilos of Bolognaise sauce
PLUS the spaghetti. And a whole pack makes loads
If you said a pack of spaghetti serves 5 people (100g dried each obvs weighs more cooked )

It’s 0.93 pence per portion. BUT the weight of the bolognaise sauce per person (without pasta) weighs more than the whole of the microwave meal with the pasta.

Just as an aside to that though, which would leave you feeling more full?

If you don't feel full and then go and eat something else in addition to the ready made bolognaise, it defeats the point of the exercise.

And thats my problem if I do have a ready meal bolognaise. I never feel satisfied after having one. The food science that supermarkets use, is about trying to get you to eat/buy more. Its very clever.

Thats were it does make it more cost effective to cook from scratch, but its often a hidden effect.

Terfydactyl · 28/08/2022 14:19

MerryChristmasToYou · 28/08/2022 13:51

Greengrocer and 99p are in the high street. I can pick up the lemons and garlic from the greengrocer and then get the chickpeas and tahini from the 99p shop. i can walk from my house.
While I'm in the 99p shop I can also pick up falafel mix.
If I want salad, I could get it in Iceland.

This would probably be quicker than nipping to the supermarket.

Fantastic for you. I dont have a greengrocers closer than a couple of miles. The pound shop or equivalent is another couple of miles.
So if it were me, I'd walk to the poundshop equivalent, then backtrack to the greengrocers, then as my nearest shop actually is Iceland just under a mile away I'd go there then home. I'd have walked around 8 miles carrying stuff for 4 miles of that and by the time I got home I'd have to go to work, more walking.

This is what I would have to do if i was skint, it's what i did when i was skint.
I can actually cook, am pretty decent at it. Even now I'm not that skint, I still only have a small under counter freezer and fridge. How much can you store in a little freezer which is also used to store bread and stuff?
What if I don't have the money to replace the fridge or freezer or the contents when it breaks? I've just 3 months ago had to buy a new fridge, the last one was only 6 years old. I can imagine the utter horror of someone ramming their freezer full of lovely homecooked batch cooked meals and the freezer fucks up.
What do you do then?

Thehonestbadger · 28/08/2022 14:19

@Celyn22

and yes ofc not every child has additional needs so this doesn’t apply everywhere BUT I’ve been really shocked at the increase in ASD toddlers since lockdown. It seems to be becoming much more common tbh. I suspect more and more parents are having to deal with it. Not something in a million years I thought I’d have to deal with and before anyone rolls their eyes and thinks it’s just me being ‘on of those parents’ (a disgustingly common response) I also have a neurotypical child of a similar age who I can and do frequently battle over food and win. They’re not fussy at all now really.

Missillusioned · 28/08/2022 14:18

Batch cooking and freezing relies on having the space for a decent sized freezer and the money to run it. Which many people don't have. Old freezers can be bought cheaply second hand but they are really greedy on power compared to newer models. Can cost around 25% of your household electricity bill.

Baoing · 28/08/2022 14:17

I've been pondering this lately, like millions of others. Part of the bigger picture is far we've removed ourselves from the provenance of our staple ingredients.

I buy flour by the sack from a mill. I make bread, pasta, cakes, biscuits, everything really, from sack flour. We grow a fair bit of our own food.

Both of these things now are sneered at as being middle class indulgences, but it's how I was brought up. It's how my grandmother and great mother fed their families. It's how people without much money fed their families.

In the war, people grew vegetables in their small background plots. People in apartments in other countries grow salad, tomatoes, herbs etc. on a windowsill or balcony. Anyone with a patch of dirt keeps chickens.

This food crisis is here for the long haul. It's NOT okay to sacrifice food quality for millions of people - long term, that's awful for health. But yes, the cost is cheaper.

More public land should be used for community growing projects - there are three near us, but in wealthy areas and everyone has bloody gardens. There should be land freed up to grow community crops so that people can eat FREE food, that's healthy and supports growing kids, in exchange for a couple of hours a month weeding, watering etc.

Food crops can grow quickly - it's not all an annual potato harvest. It can help people NOW and going into winter.

There's seed sharing projects as well, for people who literally can't afford to buy seeds. We need to move ourselves closer to how food is produced, locally and community by community, so that people DON'T have to choose between eating cheaply OR healthily.

Discovereads · 28/08/2022 14:17

YABU
Cooking MEALS from scratch is 99% of the time cheaper. That’s what people are talking about. Meals, not condiments, jams, or milking a cow and churning your own butter etc.

Making hummus isn’t cooking, so it’s a shit example.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 28/08/2022 14:16

Batch cooking is unhelpful if you don't have freezer space for it.

Again - so many more factors than the cost of the food

notacooldad · 28/08/2022 14:16

queenofarles thetecyou go!!
www.veganfoodandliving.com/vegan-recipes/the-25-best-vegan-aquafaba-recipes-you-never-knew-could-be-vegan/

I've made most of these and they are fab!

To be honest I thing we are getting hung up on hummus and chickpeas.
I think somecfoodsa are relatively cheap to make up and cheaper than buying premade and clearly some arent. You've just got to use common sense and make an informed decision on what you are eating and why.

IcedOatLatte · 28/08/2022 14:15

FudgeSundae · 28/08/2022 12:25

groceries.asda.com/product/baking-jacket-potatoes/asda-british-fluffy-golden-large-baking-potatoes/24932 Is what I was thinking of. I used baked potatoes for most things - often cheaper and no peeling!

Thanks for the link @FudgeSundae

You and I clearly have different understandings of the words “huge” and “sack”

That's 4 overpriced spuds 😜😮

Thehonestbadger · 28/08/2022 14:15

@Celyn22

Re young fussy eaters: my dad's policy was "you won't starve yourself" so even though he wasn't the best cook (he did his best), we could eat what was served or go hungry. And I never went hungry and food wasn't wasted. Leftovers went into packed lunch or dinner next day.

My opinion was always the same. Before I had children I was going to be no nonsense, you didn’t eat what you were given? Tough you’d just have to starve. Logic dictates a child will surely just eat eventually if they’re hungry enough….right?

Then I had an autistic toddler, and found out that some kids will absolutely starve themselves because they simply don’t have the neurological capacity to eat things they don’t recognise or can’t process properly. If you let them starve themselves, that’s negligent parenting and you will be prosecuted to the full extent of the law, rightly so. So suddenly you do have to pander to your child’s requirements and understand it’s a medical issue not just ‘they’re fussy’. You don’t have a choice in the matter and no one comes along to top up your budget accordingly. Sure you can fight it out with DLA but it’s gonna be a hell of a fight. I personally haven’t done this because we can afford to cater to DS and our HV told me how harsh the council have gotten denying thousands of ASD kids DLA because of budgets.

Tabbouleh · 28/08/2022 14:11

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 14:08

Playing devil's advocate, people in v poor countries- India, China, Thailand, Vietnam- cook from scratch without freezers or even kitchens. On the side of the road over a fire. But I guess the way of life is completely different.
yes and no, so many rely on street vendors,
plus spices to make even bland things like pulses taste delicious are usually much cheaper and can be brought in tiny quantities.

I think here spices are not prioritised, although they can last for years.

I agree with your last sentence. Spices are not prioritised! You can buy them in v tiny quantities in Indian supermarkets.

Fatballs · 28/08/2022 14:08

That's not true for hummus. One tin of chickpeas does not make more than buying a tub for less money.

The tub isn’t less money if you have to drive over twenty miles to buy it. If I run out of hummus between shops, I just whiz up a tin of chick peas.

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 14:08

Playing devil's advocate, people in v poor countries- India, China, Thailand, Vietnam- cook from scratch without freezers or even kitchens. On the side of the road over a fire. But I guess the way of life is completely different.
yes and no, so many rely on street vendors,
plus spices to make even bland things like pulses taste delicious are usually much cheaper and can be brought in tiny quantities.

I think here spices are not prioritised, although they can last for years.

WeepingSomnambulist · 28/08/2022 14:02

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 13:57

said with the chickpea example, use the chickpeas for one receipe and use the water for another by thinking ahead and being resourceful. like what?
I can’t think of any use for the boiled chickpea water.

Vegan meringues.

AldiLidlDeeDee · 28/08/2022 14:02

FudgeSundae · 28/08/2022 12:01

I don’t think that’s what I thought people meant when they say “it’s cheaper to cook from scratch”. I think what I mean is that if I personally had a really small food budget (like I have at various times) I will eat very cheap homemade meals from e.g. a huge sack of 50p potatoes, half an onion and half a tin of 30p chopped tomatoes, total cost like 30p per meal. I don’t mean that the equivalent to a shop bought thing is always cheaper homemade. I agree if you want choice or a specific thing then some things shops do better.

50p for a sack of spuds? Whereabouts do you live where they cost so little or did you just pluck that figure from the air?

Here it’s about €1 per kg of potatoes. Potatoes are not that cheap to buy these days. I’ve just checked and a large sack of spuds is €7.99 for 7.5kg Rooster potatoes from Supervalu. Even a bag of frozen skinny oven fries are now 80c in Aldi.

I agree with the OP.

People on a very low income can’t afford to buy fresh veg nor afford the electric needed to cook it. My son says where he lives in London, the local food banks won’t accept donations of fresh veg because their clients can’t afford to cook it.

The other assumption is that we all live near to a supermarket and can make use of their reduced price offers. My nearest supermarket is 7 miles away so I have to drive there. I stock up when I shop but I’ve got a large kitchen, two freezers and a large garage. People who live in small flats for instance, don’t have the space to stock pile food when it’s on offer.

Buying full price fresh food is very expensive.

WeepingSomnambulist · 28/08/2022 14:01

chillipenguin · 28/08/2022 11:26

But that usually makes tonnes of houmous. More than you'd usually get in a tub and it won't go off as quick. But yes I get your point.

That's not true for hummus. One tin of chickpeas does not make more than buying a tub for less money.

Things like bolognese sauce are like cheaper. One jar for £1 or buy ingredients and make a pot of it; about 5 jars worth for £3. But if you dont have that £3 upfront because you're on a tight weekly budget and cant bulk buy then you're going to get the £1 jar and spend more overall.

Skethylita · 28/08/2022 14:01

queenofarles · 28/08/2022 13:57

said with the chickpea example, use the chickpeas for one receipe and use the water for another by thinking ahead and being resourceful. like what?
I can’t think of any use for the boiled chickpea water.

It makes a great vegan egg white substitute, so can be used in baking, for example.

Skethylita · 28/08/2022 14:00

I think that there are people on here justifying buying readymeals unnecessarily.

Even as a student with £11 per week to spend on transport, hygiene articles and food altogether I cooked from scratch every day, because it was cheaper. And Halls facilities were not great - we used to have maybe one or two working hob rings, yes, an oven (which was gross, so rarely used) and fridge and freezer space was limited to one drawer each, as well as only one small hanging cupboard for all of our crockery and ingredients - so very limited storage. Plus, as we were starting out, we had very little equipment.

Everyone can build up a stock of herbs and spices over time. You don't buy five at once, but one every two weeks or so will easily amass a good amount of basic herbs and spices within half a year, even with replacement buying.

People here are saying that they would have to live on the same food for a week - well, no, with a fridge you can already stretch that to every other day and most things are freezable, so last for a good few months. Pizza is a great example. Pizza dough might, on paper, take a long time, but in practice you spend 3.5h out of 4 basically ignoring the dough as it proves. You wrap the portioned and rolled dough (we used to use bottles for that instead of rolling pins) into clingfilm - store it for a time you want a quick fix pizza. You use passata, salt, pepper and perhaps even some herbes de provence, simple cheddar cheese and there you have a decent, basic pizza.

We chucked everything leftover on it - from a tiny portion of chilli we had left from a dinner that week, some egg, some defrosted spinach and perhaps an egg, or more traditional bits like offcuts from bell peppers, the last two salami slices, the last rasher of bacon.

And if we look at traditional British food, so much of it was designed for cheap, wholesome food made with tiny bits of leftovers.

It is absolutely possible to make almost anything from scratch cheaper than buying ready-made, too. The lasgana example on the first page assumed 1kg of meat - you'd need a LOT of ready meals to get that much meat together; most barely have any in them. Most ready meals either have lots of water in them or lots of starch to give the impression of being more than they are.

It's also why they will leave you hungry again soon after, while a decent portion of something homemade will likely allow you to comfortably only have one or two meals a day without being hungry or nutritionally underfed.

The only argument there is here is that people don't have the skills, but that can and should be countered with access to the internet and therefore a world of free recipes, step-by step instructions, video guidance and even websites which will find a recipe for whatever random items you have left in your cupboard.

Sorry, it just doesn't wash with me, and I have been poor for many years.

Swipe left for the next trending thread