Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My elderly dad's neighbours are demanding money

159 replies

BruhWhy · 28/08/2022 07:05

About two months ago, some local kids set fire to my dad's fence that runs from the front of his house to the left, and joins onto his neighbour's fence that separates his and their back gardens.

It was terrifying for him, it spread and caught his wheelie bins alight and nearly set alight his mobility car and shed. The fire service had to attend to get it under control at 1am. Confirmed arson, the same kids had been doing it all week.

A few days after this happened he got a note through the door from his neighbour to the left asking him when he was going to replace their fence panel that was burned. He went to speak to them and told them that they'd have to wait a while because he's a disabled pensioner and he hasn't got fence panel money spare, they weren't happy but accepted it.

They've since come to speak to him three more times getting more irate each time because their dog keeps escaping through the damaged fence.

I don't think he should be replacing their fence panel AT ALL, it's their fence and it was damaged by arson, not my dad being careless, if it was my dad's fault I could understand but he didn't set it alight. This is all causing him massive anxiety.

I'm going to go round and speak to them Monday and tell them to piss off, but am AIBU? Is it his responsibility because the fire started on his property?

OP posts:
Brideandpredjudice · 28/08/2022 12:05

They're not just cheeky, they're arseholes. Tell them I'd they bother him again you'll report them for harassment.

UWhatNow · 28/08/2022 12:03

dworky · 28/08/2022 07:40

No they're not. Your house deeds clearly show which side fence is your responsibility.

Where we live all the deeds say they are party fences so 50/50. People have historically adopted ‘sides’ but that’s not the lawful position. Why would you just post on MN stating something like that as a legal truth when it isn’t universal? It’s not helpful.

TitoMojito · 28/08/2022 11:40

BruhWhy · 28/08/2022 07:17

Ok good, this seems to all back up what I was thinking, I was worried that because the fire started on his side they'd have a point.

I'm not sure if he has a crime reference number, I'll try to find out and then I'll give them that, cheeky fuckers.

It started on his property but it was arson. So NDN's fence was also destroyed by arson. Therefore the only people responsible here are the twats who started the fire, not your DF.

Flossflower · 28/08/2022 11:37

A similar case of responsibility was in our local paper many years ago. A lady with a thatched roof cottage had not insured her house. A fire from her neighbours house spread to her roof and burnt her house down. She did not have insurance as it is costly to insure houses with thatched roofs. She was trying to claim from her neighbour as the fire started from there. The court ruled she could not claim from her neighbour as it was her responsibility to insure her house.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 28/08/2022 11:35

I was worried that because the fire started on his side they'd have a point

If he'd been responsible for starting it they may well have done, but he wasn't so they don't

Knowing that HAs often slam new stuff in regardless of "who's fault it was", I suspect the neighbours are hoping they'll get a new fence on the back of this, but really the only people to take it up with are the insurers or the people who caused the fire ... and good luck with the second Hmm

PepperRed · 28/08/2022 11:34

You are right. Rarely 50/50 See deeds. If a T on your side of the fence then that is your side. Google for full details of how to tell.

NeedNotWantNot · 28/08/2022 11:26

Not his circus, not his monkey.

Outlyingtrout · 28/08/2022 11:23

It's nothing to do with your dad whatsoever. Some kids committed arson that damaged your dad's property and this neighbour's fence.

I'd send a letter before action and tell them that if they persist in their harassment of a disabled pensioner that legal action will be taken against them.

Arseholes.

shockthemonkey · 28/08/2022 11:19

Times like this, you wonder whether the NDNs are being extremely thick or are just disingenuous fuckers.

Their behaviour is outrageous and I hope you are able to set them straight!

Topseyt123 · 28/08/2022 11:19

By happened here, I meant in this instance, that OP is discussing.

Topseyt123 · 28/08/2022 11:17

Grumpybutfunny · 28/08/2022 10:17

Going to play devils advocate here but why was the fire started? Is their an on going issue with youths targetting your dad? Was it retaliation for something he has said/done? True random attacks are incredibly rare if I was the neighbour I would be thinking it was a deliberate attack on your dad in response to something, so would be rather annoyed about having to pay to replace a fence panel if wasn't involved in the dispute at all.

It's worth going to speak to them and ask why they believe it's your dads responsibility. If it's a true random attack it's a good opportunity to explain the circumstances to them and say unfortunately your dad can't afford to pay for the fence but will allow access etc when they come to get it fixed.

Rubbish! What on earth do you mean about "why was the fire started?" Did you miss the part where the OP explained that it was arson, kids set light to it.

Feral kids causing fires is not incredibly rare. I live in a nice area and it still happens here. There is no rhyme or reason to the stuff they vandalise and fire is just one of their methods. It absolutely is totally random.

This was a random act of arson by horrid, feral kids. It sadly isn't a rarity. It happened here to the neighbour's fence. Even though it may have been started from OP's Dad's side, that doesn't make him responsible for a random act of vandalism.

The fence belongs to the neighbour. They pay, and stop hassling an elderly man for money he doesn't owe and doesn't have.

AldiLidlDeeDee · 28/08/2022 11:17

Grumpybutfunny · 28/08/2022 10:17

Going to play devils advocate here but why was the fire started? Is their an on going issue with youths targetting your dad? Was it retaliation for something he has said/done? True random attacks are incredibly rare if I was the neighbour I would be thinking it was a deliberate attack on your dad in response to something, so would be rather annoyed about having to pay to replace a fence panel if wasn't involved in the dispute at all.

It's worth going to speak to them and ask why they believe it's your dads responsibility. If it's a true random attack it's a good opportunity to explain the circumstances to them and say unfortunately your dad can't afford to pay for the fence but will allow access etc when they come to get it fixed.

Devils advocate? More like the ramblings of a total numpty. 🤦🏻‍♀️

Presumably you live in a naice area so have zero understanding or compassion for those that happen to live in less nice areas where feral kids will cause a nuisance on a completely random basis.

The fire service had to attend to get it under control at 1am. Confirmed arson, the same kids had been doing it all week.

Also, what’s his financial position got to do with anything? You’ve assumed he’s piss poor because he lives in HA accommodation. Her dad could be a millionaire and he still wouldn’t be required to fix a fence that the bloody neighbours own.

WeAreTheHeroes · 28/08/2022 11:17

I think the neighbours are mistaken as to legalities rather than trying it on. I can well understand they don't want to have to pay for something that wasn't their fault. And obviously neither should your dad. Yes, go round and politely spell it out to them and mention your dad is already traumatised by what happened without them asking him for money to replace their fence.

Nanny0gg · 28/08/2022 11:13

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 28/08/2022 07:08

Fences are normally 50/50 but this should be agreed in advance and he doesn’t have to have a fence or agree to it.

No, they're not.
It should be on the deeds as to who owns which fence/s around their property

CoffeeWithNiles · 28/08/2022 11:08

Grumpybutfunny · 28/08/2022 10:17

Going to play devils advocate here but why was the fire started? Is their an on going issue with youths targetting your dad? Was it retaliation for something he has said/done? True random attacks are incredibly rare if I was the neighbour I would be thinking it was a deliberate attack on your dad in response to something, so would be rather annoyed about having to pay to replace a fence panel if wasn't involved in the dispute at all.

It's worth going to speak to them and ask why they believe it's your dads responsibility. If it's a true random attack it's a good opportunity to explain the circumstances to them and say unfortunately your dad can't afford to pay for the fence but will allow access etc when they come to get it fixed.

The OP says the same kids had been doing it all week. DH is a Fire Fighter and it’s not unusual for them to be following the same group of young arsonists around putting out fires until the Police manage to catch them.

What do you think the OPs Dad could possible have done that your think this level ‘retaliation’ is justified?

Faseeshes · 28/08/2022 11:07

Fences are usually one side per house. If it would have been his, regardless of how it got damaged, he would have been responsible. But as it's theirs, they are. End of really.

KyaClark · 28/08/2022 10:56

Your poor dad must have been terrified and instead of the neighbours doing what they can to help him, they're adding to his worries?

What absolute dickheads.

CoopsMalloops · 28/08/2022 10:56

Tell them to piss off.
they are chancing it bullying an elderly man.
Give them the crime number to pass to their insurer and then tell them the next time you talk to the police will be to report them for harassing your dad. 😡

Soapboxqueen · 28/08/2022 10:51

OP tell your dad's neighbours that responsibility for the fence rests with HA and that it's got nothing to do with your dad at all. If they argue, explain that repeated harassment of your dad will cause you to contact the police.

To pp's fences can either be shared responsibility or be allocated to each house. That's why everyone needs to check their deeds. Where I live it's far more common to have shared responsibility (range of home types and ages).

coodawoodashooda · 28/08/2022 10:49

BruhWhy · 28/08/2022 07:14

Definitely their fence, he's responsible for the right-hand fence. No buildings insurance, only contents, it's a housing association property so all outside work gets carried out by them. He's tried asking them to fix the fence panel but obviously they've said no because it belongs to his neighbour, and they own their house!

What horrible people

flawlessfilter · 28/08/2022 10:48

figmaofmyimagination · 28/08/2022 10:41

I’d go round and say you’ve spoken to the HA and a solicitor (there’s one up thread 😂 ) and both have said that neither your Dad nor the HA are liable to replace the neighbour’s panel, but here’s the crime number they will need to put a claim in with their own insurance.

Then ask them to deal with you in the future rather than your Dad as he is elderly, disabled and has been left distressed by this random attack, and that if they want to verify anything you can put them in touch with the HA if they need to discuss it further.

This 100%

At much as you can though approach the situation calmly despite them being twats.

flawlessfilter · 28/08/2022 10:46

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 28/08/2022 07:07

If you 100% sure that its their fence then no YANBU. Your poor Dad I hope he gets it sorted.

Doesn’t matter if it is OPs dads fence. It’s not his responsibility to ensure their dog doesn’t escape.

OP I’m sorry your dads going through this.

Greyarea12 · 28/08/2022 10:44

Of course he is not responsible for fixing their fence. He didn't start the fire, he therefore didn't damage their fence, so why would your Dad fix their fence?! How ridiculous. I wouldn't just talk to them, i would tell them straight, in no uncertain terms, that they are harrasssing and bullying an OAP and if it continues they will have more than their damn fence to worry about. Arseholes.

Mummyto3ginismyfriend · 28/08/2022 10:42

Re 50/50 responsibility of fences. We bought in a new build development (2nd owners) and our deeds clearly state that all boundaries are shared responsibility. Our last house built in 1930s had owners of each boundary. I think the shared responsibility is a newer build thing.

figmaofmyimagination · 28/08/2022 10:41

I’d go round and say you’ve spoken to the HA and a solicitor (there’s one up thread 😂 ) and both have said that neither your Dad nor the HA are liable to replace the neighbour’s panel, but here’s the crime number they will need to put a claim in with their own insurance.

Then ask them to deal with you in the future rather than your Dad as he is elderly, disabled and has been left distressed by this random attack, and that if they want to verify anything you can put them in touch with the HA if they need to discuss it further.

Swipe left for the next trending thread