Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Didn't realise dd is overweight

63 replies

heydorothea · 28/08/2022 01:15

NCed because I posted earlier in the week and I don't want to out myself.

DD's dad weighed her at his today and her BMI puts her at slightly overweight. She's very tall for her age, she's always been at the heaviest end of healthy weight for her height since she was tiny but relative to her height. She's now just into the overweight band. I feel like shit for not realising, her dad hasn't seen her for a few weeks so probably a better judge than I am. She struggles with body image as it is and I feel awful.

She's about the age I was when I started my periods and I remember my mother commenting I'd gained weight around that time. My childhood and weight are a whole other thread. I really don't want that for DD. WIBU to leave her be for now and see what happens? I don't want to draw attention to it, her dad does.

OP posts:
Goldenbear · 28/08/2022 07:59

Like others, I think it can be a tween thing, definitely don't weigh her. I have an 11 year old DD and am concerned the other way as she is very thin probably verging on skinny as are a few of her friends and I am concerned it is a peer pressure thing, definitely overheard an awareness of how clothes look (bit obsessive) and weight is spoken about where as it wasn't before but these girls are going in to year 7, starting secondary school which is probably something to do with it. I think it is a very difficult subject to address even subtley at this sort of age.

dizzydizzydizzy · 28/08/2022 07:54

My DD was overweight at the y6 health check. She started her periods in y7. She also grew and grew and grew at that time. Certainly by the end of y7 her weight was fine.

MsTSwift · 28/08/2022 07:52

Is if portion size? I’m sometimes taken aback by the large amounts other peoples kids are able to put away. I’ve been slammed on here before but I never graduated to enormous dinner plates we eat (me included) off slightly smaller size dinner plates. Result two beautifully slim teen girls.

NewerCurtains · 28/08/2022 07:45

I was about 12 when a family member first commented on my weight. It came from a good place as most of the female line in my family are overweight. The family member wanted me to avoid some of the difficulties it had caused her throughout her life.

For me, it became 'a thing' and almost overnight I became obsessed with 'good' and 'bad' food and was 100% convinced I was morbidly obese. In reality I was possibly 3 or 4lbs overweight - nothing that a bit of running round wouldn't cure. Now that I'm older and I do struggle with weight, I have this disproportionate nonsense in my head. I need to lose 2 stone but I'm convinced people are looking at me/judging me, when in reality they probably don't even notice. I feel I'd be able to lose weight so much more easily if it wasn't so deeply baked into my sense of self worth.

Please don't get into the routine of weighing her or making it 'a thing'. Just start subtly making good choices as a family, going for walks, eating less snacks or whatever changes you want to make. This is such a crucial age and the wrong input at this age can leave her with hang ups for the rest of her life. Focus on health and body shape, not numbers on a scale.

CecilyP · 28/08/2022 07:39

If she’s just in the overweight category, there isn’t too much to worry about. Did her dad tell you her actual weight? And do you now know her height? Can’t think of any problem seeing how tall she is - kids are generally interested in that. If you have
th figures, put them in the calculator for a child a year older and see if it still comes out as overweight. In the meantime, just watch what she’s eating and the size of portions being served.

OddsandSods · 28/08/2022 07:25

As others have said, it’s normal to gain a bit of chub before puberty. Don’t say anything to her and stop weighing her and look at her instead. In the next year she should get taller and slimmer again.

BMI is an odd tool. I was in top range of normal weight as a tiny size 8 (smaller then) in the 80s/90s. I would now look far too thin with a normal BMI. I have patients at work in normal BMI covered in thick body hair where they are too thin. It doesn’t work for everyone.

Get her dad to remove all the crap he’s feeding her- he can tell her it’s because he’s trying to get healthier and can’t have the temptation around. Watch portion sizes of higher cal foods and fill her up on fruit, veg, salad, protein.

hop321 · 28/08/2022 07:16

I'd take action by trying to reduce the snacks and up the exercise. More to set healthy habits for adulthood than anything.

Goldbar · 28/08/2022 07:14

It sounds like small changes to her diet and subtle increases in exercise should be enough to sort things out. Unless drastic intervention is needed, I would never mention weight to a child - it is for the parents to make sure that their children are a healthy weight. Kids don't need that burden. When she goes to secondary though, she'll have more control over what she eats so I'd have a chat about healthy diet with her (not mentioning weight).

girlmom21 · 28/08/2022 07:10

As the others have said, it's completely normal.

BMI is massively outdated too and the 'healthy' weight for me definitely makes me look too skinny.

Dolphinnoises · 28/08/2022 07:06

It is completely normal to pile on a bit just before puberty. In fact in Raising Girls the chapter on eating disorders (which Steve Biddulph hands over to two eating disorders specialists rather than tackle himself) says that parents freaking out when this normal event happens is a major trigger for eating disorders in girls. Just continue as you were and review in 6 months.

Peashoots · 28/08/2022 07:01

She shouldn’t be “pudgier” op, puppy fat is a myth.
you’ll get a lot of replies telling you to ignore it here-people are so used to seeing overweight kids they’ve forgotten what a healthy weight looks like.
you’ve done the right thing addressing it now. Obviously you’re right to be concerned about your daughters body image and self esteem. Make subtle changes now without her noticing-mindful if portion sizes, do some fun exercise tigether etc. good luck.

RedHelenB · 28/08/2022 06:53

butterflied · 28/08/2022 03:46

If he's worried about her weight, then maybe he should focus on her not eating too much crap while she's with him.

He's not, the OP is. Even getting him to weigh her.

Timeturnerplease · 28/08/2022 06:53

Loads of them do this around Year 5 or 6 of primary. They pile on weight and look chunky, then we (teachers) see them around locally once they’ve gone to secondary having had a massive growth spurt and looking tall and slim.

I’d personally be making sure you’re subtly educating her about nutrition and health, but not be overly concerned right now.

NumberTheory · 28/08/2022 06:46

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

No. To put on weight to a point where she’s over a healthy weight she would have to eat over a sensible amount (which it looks like she started doing).

If you are maintaining in the middle of a healthy range then you can eat a little bit more and, if it’s within a sensible eating range for you, you’ll gain a little bit but plateau still within your healthy weight range.

If you’re toeing the upper line with your weight, you’re toeing the upper line with how much you’re eating. Still a healthy weight, still a sensible amount to eat. But if your diet increases or exercise decreases or metabolism slows, etc., you’re pushed outside of the healthy weight. (And similarly with the lower end of the range and under eating, etc.).

Obviously there are lots of ups and downs when you’re growing. But the healthy weight range isn’t particularly narrow, if you’re generally more in the middle you’re much less likely to get outside it at all (medical complications aside).

cheshiredog · 28/08/2022 06:41

Just before puberty hits, most children put on a bit of weight, ready for a big growth spurt, so I wouldn’t worry. If you want to do something, just try and eat a little healthier as a family and try to go for a walk every night after tea. I wouldn’t mention it to her at all.

PotatoHammock · 28/08/2022 06:35

My usually fairly slim 10yo has also visibly put on weight over the summer. It's such a hard position for a parent. On the one side you've got all the medical professionals telling us about the "obesity epidemic" and how it's leading to serious chronic health problems. And on the other side, we've had the experience of growing up in the 90s/00s and many (most?) of us have pretty much lifelong disordered eating (which often presents as binge eating, so we're still overweight, but we've also got the mental health burden as well!)

I'm not planning to say anything out loud to my 10yo. I don't keep crisps, biscuits, cakes etc in the house as standard, but those foods certainly aren't banned if we're out or if we have guests.

HikingforScenery · 28/08/2022 06:08

I don’t think you should “leave her for now”.
By all means, don’t make a big deal out of it but I agree with implementing the recommended healthy lifestyle changes. It’s good for her log term to practise those habits, anyway.

Marvellousmadness · 28/08/2022 06:01

"She definitely hasn't 'piled on' weight but she probably is visibly pudgier."

So she HAS piled on the weight. You just frame is differently.

Putting her on the scales was a BAD idea
But talking to her about how she feels and also talking about her weight ISNT a bad thing. They way you TACKLE it will depend what impact it has on her. Talking about food or weight doesn't cause food/body issues. The WAY you approach is can cause issues.

Talk to her.

mathanxiety · 28/08/2022 05:46

You should not have asked her dad to weigh her.

You're going to cause all sorts of issues.

Tweens get puppy fat before a growth spurt and before menarche. I thought this was well known?

Foldinthecheese · 28/08/2022 05:33

This is very normal around the start of puberty. I haven’t followed him for a while, but the guy who runs Rebelfit on Facebook/Instagram wrote about how many girls get put on diets around this age, and it becomes the start of a lifetime of diets. Her hormones will be doing all sorts, and her body shape will be changing. Best to just keep her focused on being strong and healthy with a good balanced diet and plenty of activity.

Remaker · 28/08/2022 04:13

I wouldn’t put a big emphasis on the numbers. My DD was always very slim but around age 10 she put on a little bit of weight around her tummy. I just made sure that her meals were healthy and encouraged her to pursue anything active that she was interested in. Within a year she’d started a growth spurt, and the first signs of puberty. Then she slimmed down again. I would say the majority of her friends put on a bit of weight around the start of puberty.

Despite me never weighing her or having any idea how much she weighs (I still don’t) DD is still a bit more focused on her weight than I’d like and will sometimes skip meals if we don’t keep an eye on it. She’s now 16. I can’t imagine how much worse it would be if we’d made a fuss about her weight back then.

Foronenightonly22 · 28/08/2022 03:56

So her Dad feeds her loads of sh*t thenweighs your daughter??? Something not right there. I’d knock that on the head.

MintJulia · 28/08/2022 03:55

FatAnneTheDealer · 28/08/2022 01:35

I don’t think you should mention it. Just focus on making sure her diet is healthy but maybe on the slightly low sugar / fat side - just a little. And keep her active. But no obvious focus or comments.

This.

Don't make a fuss about it, as it really is no big deal at her age.

Just make sure she has a healthy diet when she's with you. Cook from scratch, lots of fresh fruit, veg, salad. Don't keep many snacks in the house and make sure she's active.

Do you do a sport together? Parkrun on a Saturday morning? A class or a swim after school? Even just walk the dogs? Ask her to help motivate you to stay healthy.

Sushi7 · 28/08/2022 03:53

heydorothea · 28/08/2022 01:53

She's 10. Her dad thinks she's piled on weight, but I don't think he would have thought that if I hadn't said anything. She definitely hasn't 'piled on' weight but she probably is visibly pudgier.

I don't know her exact height and I don't want to make a bigger deal of it by measuring her. But depending on that, she's somewhere between 91st and 94th centile for weight which is showing up as overweight on the NHS calculator.

You could remark that you think she’s a bit taller (which will make her excited) and then measure her height. You need to know her exact height so you can check which percentile she is. Your estimates put her high on the chart, but I wouldn’t mention food or weight in front of her because that leads to ED. Behind the scenes, ensure she is active and be mindful of her portions (obviously a tall 10 year old will eat a similar amount to an 12 year old but not the same amount as a man).

butterflied · 28/08/2022 03:46

If he's worried about her weight, then maybe he should focus on her not eating too much crap while she's with him.

Swipe left for the next trending thread