Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boyfriend bought me a £12 necklace for my 30th birthday

356 replies

Fairylights246 · 28/08/2022 00:49

I've been with my boyfriend for only 9 months, so not a long time I know. But I feel disappointed and sad by the lack of effort my boyfriend has shown for my birthday.

He got me a random joke card that had no relevance to us, and seemed like something he already had lying around. He got me a necklace that literally broke after 10 minutes of wearing it, it looked really cheap, and he told me it was from amazon...I found it and it was £12. Like what?? I don't understand why he has been so cheap?! He is very caring and affectionate, tells me everyday he loves me, but this has just felt so disappointing. We went out for a birthday meal and he suggested we pay half each.

He is not struggling financially, he has thousands in his savings, and often treats himself to new clothes, other expenses ect.

I don't know what to say to him, I don't want to upset him, but I don't feel very special and I feel crappy about the lack of effort, romance, and just general desire to make a fuss of me on my 30th x

OP posts:
JimJamJollyWolly · 28/08/2022 19:01

The vast majority of "advice" on this thread is just dreadful.

Moonlightandmusic2222 · 28/08/2022 18:13

Pipsquiggle · 28/08/2022 16:39

@RoundandRound123 OPs BF is not a puppy for crying out loud. He's a grown human being with agency.

I mean FFS, positive reinforcement for a thoughtless tight miser will only get you so far

@Pipsquiggle I find what you say very rude, OP asked for advice, a lot of people are telling her just to leave him even though she appears to love him. If you don’t like my advice, offer some other tips you think are useful. My advice means if she doesn’t want to leave him she has a way of getting the sort of relationship she appears to want. What’s wrong with that? It’s not like he doesn’t want to make her happy, he clearly does if the rest of her description is accurate, the mistake people make is that they guilt, shame and complain about the things they don’t want instead of appreciating and rewarding the things they do want. It’s a far more respectful dynamic than just being angry or sad when he doesn’t give her what she wants, miserable existence if you ask me. If you want something figure out a way to ask for it the right way and make it a joy for people to give it to you. It works, and it works with misers too - as you describe them.

I8toys · 28/08/2022 17:55

The meal thing is worse than the rubbish card/gift.

scoobydoo1971 · 28/08/2022 17:27

I am in a fortunate financial position of not needing help from anyone. However, if I had faced the life-changing accident I had in lockdown forcing me to go on long-term sick leave on an average income, then I would have expected a partner to more than pay his way. I don't think that is unreasonable if you have been with someone for a long time. I was on extended maternity leave years ago due to post-natal serious complications requiring extensive treatment, and the children's father did not expect me to pay half during that time. That is not expecting a partner to pay everytime you go out for a date or holiday, but recognising that there are some times in life when unexpected stuff happens and the other party needs to contribute more. It is just natural that people who are in serious relationships go with whatever life throws their way. But anyone stuck with a miser is going to find troubling times even more troubling if they discover they are expected to pay half in each and every circumstance. Not the sort of person I would keep around.

Pipsquiggle · 28/08/2022 16:39

@RoundandRound123 OPs BF is not a puppy for crying out loud. He's a grown human being with agency.

I mean FFS, positive reinforcement for a thoughtless tight miser will only get you so far

Livpool · 28/08/2022 14:31

Asking for half when it was your birthday meal is much worse than the necklace IMO.

Tightness is so unattractive

ANiceBigCupOfTea · 28/08/2022 14:27

If you'd said he took you for a really special meal, went for cocktails at a nice bar and just had a lovely evening (paid for by him of course) I would have maybe been able to see past the crap present, but nah. He sounds miserable and unromantic.

ColourMeExhausted · 28/08/2022 13:35

For my 30th birthday, my then boyfriend got me a third hand laptop that I later found out he got for free. He booked a meal out but not at the restaurant I'd told him I really wanted to go to. It was a rather dingy place and the cuisine was not my preferred choice, which he absolutely knew. The reason became clear halfway through, when he abandoned me at the table to meet with his drug dealer. Apparently he was in the neighbourhood that night, hence the choice of restaurant. We went Dutch on the meal. I wish I'd walked away that night.

For my 40th, my DH went above and beyond. He did everything I'd hoped for and it was a very special day filled with love.

My point is...you don't need to be with someone like this OP. Cut your losses, move on and be with someone who will make your next milestone birthday as amazing as you deserve it to be. I did and I've never looked back.

felulageller · 28/08/2022 13:04

He's just not that into you.

Words are cheap.

You are cheap to him.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/08/2022 13:00

@unbreakbroken
Op said it was his idea. I do agree op should think about talking to him first, that is, if he likes him enough to do so. I don’t think it’s awful trying to figure out how much the necklace cost. Perhaps op did that as she was thinking he was a tight wad and wanted to be proved wrong. In any case, I’d do the same.

BabyDreamers · 28/08/2022 12:55

He doesn't like you much obviously. Get rid.

YellowRoad · 28/08/2022 12:52

Looks like he doesn't think it's worth spending money on you.

unbreakbroken · 28/08/2022 12:44

I think it's unfortunate timing. It's the first birthday this girlfriend has had with him, and coincidentally, it's been a milestone birthday. You haven't had a chance to set expectations for a 'normal' birthday yet. Has he had a birthday whilst you've been together, or is that in the next three months? I.e. do you know how much of a fuss he does or doesn't make about his own birthday?

Stalking his present to put a price tag on it is pretty awful. £12, I would say, is a pretty cheap gift, but maybe that's normal in his family. What would be more interesting would be to compare how much he spends on your birthdays in comparison to, say, a sibling if he has one. And how much he gets, to understand what his expectations are for a celebration.

Going dutch on someone's birthday is not particularly generous either - but do you usually go dutch? Whose idea was the meal out, and who chose the restaurant (and was it more expensive than normal)?

Some people aren't birthday people. Before you chuck him, you need to figure out if he's just not a birthday person, or if he's not a your birthday person. The former is forgivable, and warrants a conversation about aligning your expectations. The latter is just selfish and mean.

Orangetreexherry · 28/08/2022 12:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

RoundandRound123 · 28/08/2022 12:26

@Fairylights246 if you want to hold on to him here’s what you should try. First, just forget about the 30th stuff, yes it’s crap and scabby but it’s done now.
Anytime he does anything vaguely generous, even accidentally, make sure you let him know how pleased and happy it makes you - every, single, time. Don’t punish him for getting it wrong (no hurt silences, no vailed complaints, no saying how thoughtless another man is for basically doing what he did).
If you want him to pay for meals make sure you let him make the decisions, say what/where you want if he asks by all means, but otherwise roll with it even if it’s not perfect. He really needs to develop a taste for pleasing you, the only way that will happen is if he feels good every time he’s getting “warmer”- and there’s a good chance he’s starting from a “cold” position so be generous in your enthusiasm. If he offers to pay for anything ever do not pretend you are happy to pay, just give him a big thank you.

Mean men are very annoying and sometimes soul destroying but if you think he really is loves you, he can be trained. It will take discipline and commitment on your part though, the main thing is to not focus on mistakes but instead reinforce anything he gets right. He most likely really wants to make you happy, you need to teach him what that looks like without demanding it, or setting him up to fail by expecting “too much” (it’s not too much but it’s probably too much for him currently)

Orangetreexherry · 28/08/2022 12:25

pinkyredrose · 28/08/2022 08:55

Looks like the boyfriend's arrived!

And we would probably have bought pearl necklace to the woman he actually loves

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/08/2022 12:14

@Marvellousmadness

maybe try and up and your standards

they are pitifully low

fuckblippi · 28/08/2022 12:06

C1N1C · 28/08/2022 06:55

While i DO agree that splitting a bill and the effort made is a bit underwhelming, I think there are a lot of selfish, shallow people in this post not looking at the bigger picture.

Too much effort is placed on birthdays, Valentine's days etc. They are the bane of many relationships because of all the people you see above. My wife is like that actually... she will happily spend massive amounts of money on extravagant gifts on my birthday or events, but ignore me every other day for the rest of the year. Kissing, hugs, any form of intimacy... all zero for the whole year (or if they do happen, they're done grudgingly), but I'll get a holiday on my birthday! Oral sex (apologies I've diverted it this way), is something pretty exclusively done for the recipient... it takes 5 minutes and is so so amazing, and she is really good at it... once a year! I've told her I'd take that even every few weeks than something she can solve with a credit card... even hugs and kisses... those daily small gestures that actually MEAN something.

So no, 100% disagree with all the media-influenced shallows above... if he makes you feel loved, cherished, happy, content and you get those butterflies when he enters a room, let a day of ball-dropping slide. Of course, he might not... (devil's advocate), and it could be that this is actually reflection of other disappointing personality issues, in which case, yes, he's probably not worthy of your affection... but on its own, as a one-off incident, for him to be chastised for this when 99% of the posters above haven't even asked about the rest of the relationship, is a tragedy.

I personally think it doesn't look good, but I'd would encourage you to weigh the relationship as a whole rather than judge on one day. Whether that weighing comes out favourably or unfavourably is another matter!

That is fucking rank.

MrsDrDear · 28/08/2022 11:49

OP you've posted before about this man, you've had issues from the start.

He just isn't the one for you, cut your losses.

FriendOfDorothyGale · 28/08/2022 11:31

Dump dump dump.

He is a tightarse, going halves on your birthday meal

Nanny0gg · 28/08/2022 11:21

Oh, and you might not want to upset him, but he doesn't care if he upsets you, does he?

HRTQueen · 28/08/2022 11:19

My experience with partner tight with money because he liked to be not needed to be

every time and I mean every time we went out for dinner, bought anything needed went on holiday he was moaning and penny pinching sucked the joy out of everything. At first I would laugh it was a joke within group of friends but soon it became embarrassing (always nipped to the loo when it was our turn to buy drinks) annoying and upsetting and then just miserable

just thankful I didn’t have children with him

Nanny0gg · 28/08/2022 11:18

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

He's not cautious, he's mean.

You can buy something really thoughtful without spending lots.

And he should have paid for the birthday meal

Nanny0gg · 28/08/2022 11:15

Fairylights246 · 28/08/2022 00:49

I've been with my boyfriend for only 9 months, so not a long time I know. But I feel disappointed and sad by the lack of effort my boyfriend has shown for my birthday.

He got me a random joke card that had no relevance to us, and seemed like something he already had lying around. He got me a necklace that literally broke after 10 minutes of wearing it, it looked really cheap, and he told me it was from amazon...I found it and it was £12. Like what?? I don't understand why he has been so cheap?! He is very caring and affectionate, tells me everyday he loves me, but this has just felt so disappointing. We went out for a birthday meal and he suggested we pay half each.

He is not struggling financially, he has thousands in his savings, and often treats himself to new clothes, other expenses ect.

I don't know what to say to him, I don't want to upset him, but I don't feel very special and I feel crappy about the lack of effort, romance, and just general desire to make a fuss of me on my 30th x

He's tight and thoughtless. I hate to think what Christmas will look like.

Any 'boyfriend' that wants to go halves on a birthday meal needs throwing back

CoraPirbright · 28/08/2022 11:10

We went out for a birthday meal and he suggested we pay half each.………..He is not struggling financially, he has thousands in his savings, and often treats himself to new clothes, other expenses

Before you mentioned the above in your OP, I thought that perhaps the poor bloke was a bit skint. However, this is significant. I am afraid that he doesnt see you as ‘worth it’. Throw this one back, OP.