Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I don’t singularly have the power to fuck up the ward?

184 replies

PeachPRC · 27/08/2022 23:50

disclaimer: I KNOW it’s ‘unreasonable’ to say the q word as a HCP. My question is whether or not it’s actually literally stupid of me to say that word, ignoring the superstitious element of it.

A relative has taken a place on a nursing course starting soon and it got me thinking about my own nursing degree many years ago.

as a student I made the hideous mistake of saying ‘it’s quiet this afternoon isn’t it?’ and had my head bitten off by multiple registered nurses (for non HCP; mentioning that ‘it’s quiet’ is a mortal sin because that apparently ensures that the ward will suddenly become unmanageably busy). I hadn’t realised until then that mentioning the Q word was an absolute no no and I laughed along and apologised.

this happened maybe 3 times (in different departments in 2 hospitals so no overlap of staff). Honestly, by the 3rd time, I said the Q word on purpose just to see the reaction of everyone else. Each time, I was scolded by the staff because they insisted that me saying that word would ruin the rest of the shift by somehow making it become very busy. I said it once at approx 9am and by afternoon still had a (until then very pleasant) nurse giving me filthy looks across the treatment room. The first time I said it as an ignorant student I was properly told off, almost shouted at, by experienced nurses.

I have nursed for approx 20 years and know now that no one should ever say ‘quiet’ but that’s only because you’ll have your face snapped off by other nurses/ doctors, not because I genuinely think the myth of invoking a bad shift is true. This post isn’t about the jokey ‘haha don’t say that word!’ colleagues, it’s about the staff that TRULY believe that saying a word out loud can ruin a shift. I’d love to hear the reasoning behind that!

To this day, I’m still so surprised that HCP GENUINELY believe that a colleague saying the word ‘quiet’ out loud can wreck the shift and I’d love to know if another HCP can explain why they think that?! I nearly didn’t bother posting this because I assumed I’d get lots of ‘OP don’t you dare ever say that again 😉’ posts, but I’m interested in responses from HCP who truly believe the Q word can destroy a good day. Because as far as I’m aware, that’s a ridiculous thing to think.

OP posts:
CoalCraft · 28/08/2022 05:16

I'll give the op a proper, non-goady answer. The TL;Dr is a phenomenon called "regression to the mean".

Basically, each ward has an average level of busyness, with some random variation around it. Some hours are quiet, some are very busy, and this is mostly down to chance. Therefore, if you have an hour that's on one of the extremes of the range, let's say it's very quiet, then statistically it's likely that the next hour will be less quiet. It might be average, it might be busy, it might just be slightly less quiet, but chances are it will be at least somewhat busier. Therefore, if someone remarks during a quiet hour that it is, indeed quiet, then it may appear that they've doomed the ward when things are less quiet the next hour. In fact, it was always going to get busier anyway.

It works the other way too - very busy hours are likely to be followed by less busy ones - so always make a point to say how busy things are, OP, and perhaps people will think you're blessed, rather than cursed.

Then again, explaining all this might make you come across as a bit of a tit, so maybe just don't say "the Q word" for the sake of social cohesion. It is annoying though; superstition grinds my gears.

Trivester · 28/08/2022 04:53

It’s a bit like when someone says they’re looking forward to autumn and others round on them as if they are personally responsible for the summer ending.

I don’t think think that there is a logical explanation but humans seem to be hard wired to think religiously. I find it fascinating to see the same traits that people reject in religious thought emerging in their politics.

stillherenow · 28/08/2022 04:41

I am off to Google the moon thing though, how interesting !

stillherenow · 28/08/2022 04:39

I've just started another thread about the grumpy and potentially kleptomaniac nurses on my DFs wards. Thanks OP now I'm marching in this morning loudly pronouncing 'ISN'T IT QUIET TODAY'

Punkypinky · 28/08/2022 04:34

I think OP this is a combo of people being a bit superstitious AND just being bloody shattered and fed up.

Your colleagues know it's not literally going to make it busier when you say 'oh it's quiet', but they are probably sitting there feeling knackered and pissed off with their job generally after the last 2 awful years.

Saying it casually when you KNOW how it's going to be perceived is just going to wind people up. It's like casually jogging over the line at the end of a marathon as others struggle to finish saying "I could run another 5 miles actually". Pointing out that you are fine with things being a bit more shit to people who are fairly near the end of their tether is always going to piss them off.

So what may have resulted in gentle ribbing in times gone by, sounds like it's getting a harsher response now because people are so done in.

Muddledminx · 28/08/2022 03:58

Been a nurse over 35 years. People who said the Q word. We would admonish them, but it was never seriously, and never be taken seriously. If it did get busy afterwards then the person who said it got a bit of ribbing but that was it. 'Well you know who's bldy fault that was!' Laugh. No biggie.

PeachPRC · 28/08/2022 03:38

As predicted the replies are full of superstition and anecdote which was the exact thing I said made no sense in my OP and asked respondents to explain logically. Which they obviously can’t

OP posts:
PeachPRC · 28/08/2022 03:35

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 28/08/2022 02:08

I work in a school. I once walked into the Nurse's Office and said "boy it's quiet in here today" and she was NOT happy with me. I know to never do that again. But its like when we are in our room and someone says "the kids are being good today (or quiet)" You know you just jinxed it LOL

you know you haven’t literally ‘jinxed’ it though: because jinxing isn’t an actual tangible thing

OP posts:
PeachPRC · 28/08/2022 03:33

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/08/2022 01:43

i knows it’s common. And I know it doesn’t go down well with people but my point is that I don’t get WHY otherwise intelligent people freak out at heating a word

Look, if it's quiet enough for someone to say the word, then it's unusually quiet. Which means according to regression to the mean, it WILL return to 'normal' or worse soon. So it will get busy.

It's also a community with a culture. I don't run around shouting MACBETH in theatres either.

FWIW I never say it either and I work in housing. In shelters, if anyone said it, we'd be knee deep in ODs and threats in ten minutes.

my point is that logic says you’d be knee deep in ODs anyway. No matter what. Surely you don’t think the utterance of a word affects that?!

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 28/08/2022 03:22

YANBU, real belief in any superstition by someone who is responsible for life or death situations is a bit alarming. Jokey adherence can be a good way to help create common bonds and cope with adversity (which, I hear from nurses, commonly comes in the form of far too much work to feel like you can provide a safe level of service), so I can see a point to it in that sense. But really telling someone off because you have an irrational fear of a word is unprofessional and really nasty.

MissTrip82 · 28/08/2022 02:35

I work in ICU and loathe the stupid bullying nonsense that goes on around a word.

If you’re stupid enough to think saying a word causes someone to arrest you’re too stupid to work in health care.

Twilightimmortal · 28/08/2022 02:29

As a patient I will now make the effort to say it when at appointments just to piss people off.

IdiotCreatures · 28/08/2022 02:08

It's the same on the admin side of things. God forbid someone says 'the phones are quiet today' almost guaranteed to make the next couple of hours will be one call after another.
And having come from a theatrical training background I still prefer saying break a leg to people rather than good luck.
But I also would never walk under a ladder or look at the moon ov r my shoulder in a mirror or hold a horseshoe pointing downwards.
I am really quite superstitious,.figure it can't do any harm but not really sure it helps either.

YesIReallyDoLikeRootBeer · 28/08/2022 02:08

I work in a school. I once walked into the Nurse's Office and said "boy it's quiet in here today" and she was NOT happy with me. I know to never do that again. But its like when we are in our room and someone says "the kids are being good today (or quiet)" You know you just jinxed it LOL

EddieHowesBlackandWhiteArmy · 28/08/2022 02:06

I’m doing a bank shift tonight and this is the genuine text exchange between my husband and I…

it makes no logical sense but I just can’t bring myself to do it. I’d never chastise someone super seriously over it though.

AIBU to think I don’t singularly have the power to fuck up the ward?
MrsFezziwig · 28/08/2022 01:53

Never heard it (hospital worker for over 30 years) in anything but a jokey context. So obviously our experiences have been different. But then I didn’t go round deliberately trying to wind people up using any particular word, hospital work is stressful enough without that.

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/08/2022 01:43

i knows it’s common. And I know it doesn’t go down well with people but my point is that I don’t get WHY otherwise intelligent people freak out at heating a word

Look, if it's quiet enough for someone to say the word, then it's unusually quiet. Which means according to regression to the mean, it WILL return to 'normal' or worse soon. So it will get busy.

It's also a community with a culture. I don't run around shouting MACBETH in theatres either.

FWIW I never say it either and I work in housing. In shelters, if anyone said it, we'd be knee deep in ODs and threats in ten minutes.

Designerenvy · 28/08/2022 01:41

malmi · 28/08/2022 01:08

Oh my god, people actually believe this stuff.

Educated people!

"Tempting fate" 🙄

Yes, educated people who have experienced the sudden surge/ influx of patients after that word has been uttered, on an otherwise calm day !

Changechangychange · 28/08/2022 01:38

JellyStoneS · 28/08/2022 01:21

Pah. That’s a rubbish study. So many limitations and it’s about microbiologists! 😂

What does a “not-quiet” microbiology shift look like? A really resistant klebsiella plus an E. coli? 🤣

(sorry microbiologists)

Designerenvy · 28/08/2022 01:38

I get it, if your having a nice quiet shift ( often rare) you don’t want to jinx it by saying it’s quiet …. Simple !

PeloAddict · 28/08/2022 01:31

@JellyStoneS sorryyyyyy Grin
I was out shopping once on a day off and someone just dropped in front of me. On the plus side there was a defib so I used it. The paramedic was a bit stunned when he turned up to find a successful ROSC

HoppingPavlova · 28/08/2022 01:21

Because they are always famous last words in my experience.

JellyStoneS · 28/08/2022 01:21

Pah. That’s a rubbish study. So many limitations and it’s about microbiologists! 😂

MrsFionaCharming · 28/08/2022 01:13

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31852676/

Laugh at them for their total lack of evidence based practice.

PeachPRC · 28/08/2022 01:12

malmi · 28/08/2022 01:08

Oh my god, people actually believe this stuff.

Educated people!

"Tempting fate" 🙄

🙃

OP posts: