Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think I don’t singularly have the power to fuck up the ward?

184 replies

PeachPRC · 27/08/2022 23:50

disclaimer: I KNOW it’s ‘unreasonable’ to say the q word as a HCP. My question is whether or not it’s actually literally stupid of me to say that word, ignoring the superstitious element of it.

A relative has taken a place on a nursing course starting soon and it got me thinking about my own nursing degree many years ago.

as a student I made the hideous mistake of saying ‘it’s quiet this afternoon isn’t it?’ and had my head bitten off by multiple registered nurses (for non HCP; mentioning that ‘it’s quiet’ is a mortal sin because that apparently ensures that the ward will suddenly become unmanageably busy). I hadn’t realised until then that mentioning the Q word was an absolute no no and I laughed along and apologised.

this happened maybe 3 times (in different departments in 2 hospitals so no overlap of staff). Honestly, by the 3rd time, I said the Q word on purpose just to see the reaction of everyone else. Each time, I was scolded by the staff because they insisted that me saying that word would ruin the rest of the shift by somehow making it become very busy. I said it once at approx 9am and by afternoon still had a (until then very pleasant) nurse giving me filthy looks across the treatment room. The first time I said it as an ignorant student I was properly told off, almost shouted at, by experienced nurses.

I have nursed for approx 20 years and know now that no one should ever say ‘quiet’ but that’s only because you’ll have your face snapped off by other nurses/ doctors, not because I genuinely think the myth of invoking a bad shift is true. This post isn’t about the jokey ‘haha don’t say that word!’ colleagues, it’s about the staff that TRULY believe that saying a word out loud can ruin a shift. I’d love to hear the reasoning behind that!

To this day, I’m still so surprised that HCP GENUINELY believe that a colleague saying the word ‘quiet’ out loud can wreck the shift and I’d love to know if another HCP can explain why they think that?! I nearly didn’t bother posting this because I assumed I’d get lots of ‘OP don’t you dare ever say that again 😉’ posts, but I’m interested in responses from HCP who truly believe the Q word can destroy a good day. Because as far as I’m aware, that’s a ridiculous thing to think.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ZombieLIfe · 28/08/2022 19:32

It’s a way of giving people the illusion of control over a situation they have no control over.

Like all superstition. It’s a psychological tool.

MacaroniBaloney · 28/08/2022 16:51

I work in a contact centre and the q word is banned there too.

minimadgirl · 28/08/2022 16:34

Someone said that word this morning at work, a lovely but naive hca, not what you want to hear when understaffed. Yup it's been chaos this afternoon (think the patients heard her say it though and decided to have some fun, not good on a mental health ward).
Happens everytime we are quiet, swear they literally sense it and decide we are being far too laid back and instead provide some work.

Full moons are far far worse though.

Sarahcoggles · 28/08/2022 16:22

@ArcticSkewer I just think that most of us would not try to deliberately antagonise people we're about to work a shift with , unless there was a specific and important reason. And I don't think wanting to wind them up and have a laugh is a good enough reason.
I had no idea I was unusual in this, but maybe I am.

JulesCobb · 28/08/2022 16:09

buzzing · 28/08/2022 00:12

And I can’t imagine being so ridiculous as to be offended by a word like quiet in the first place.

This. Is it purely superstition. Held firmly onto like it is real and important by people who have very little control over their day.

just ignore them. Or say your religion forbids superstitious nonsense.

ArcticSkewer · 28/08/2022 16:01

Sarahcoggles · 28/08/2022 14:07

I think there is some interesting human psychology in this thread. But it's not the irrational hatred of the Q word (of course it's irrational, we all know it is). The truly bizarre thing is why OP continued to say it, deliberately, knowing it would piss people off. In most normal human interactions the idea is NOT to piss people off. But OP strangely has the opposite motivation, and that is what is truly strange and actually quite pathological I think.

what an odd view of the human mind! I didn't realise most people try not to piss others off. you're probably thinking of a subset .. mainly young women

Sarahcoggles · 28/08/2022 14:07

I think there is some interesting human psychology in this thread. But it's not the irrational hatred of the Q word (of course it's irrational, we all know it is). The truly bizarre thing is why OP continued to say it, deliberately, knowing it would piss people off. In most normal human interactions the idea is NOT to piss people off. But OP strangely has the opposite motivation, and that is what is truly strange and actually quite pathological I think.

JellyStoneS · 28/08/2022 12:43

*cruelly = really

JellyStoneS · 28/08/2022 12:36

ChagSameachDoreen · 28/08/2022 09:16

But surely you understand that none of these events happened because someone uttered the word "quiet". They happened because that's what goes on at hospitals.

Well. Obviously. I’m not a complete moron, though I don’t work in a hospital. I work pre-hospital.

It’s just a thing. We have lots of silly things to help us get through the day. It’s decompression, camaraderie, team bonding. Like no one wants to work on a truck with the 666 call sign, or you don’t say the q word, or if you pass each other out and about you always give a little wave and if you do/don’t you’ll be ribbed for it, gently, no malice or bullying involved. The people commenting about intelligence etc don’t really understand. No one actually believes it to be true, though it can seem like it sometimes and I don’t cruelly believe the OP saying people have gotten that angry about it. I think there’s something else going on there.

Designerenvy · 28/08/2022 11:35

People are taking this way too seriously! The Q word is avoided at all cost in case you jinx an otherwise calm night!
it’s a superstition, it’s usually said in a jokey way …. It’s not science and we know that !
Sounds like OP was being annoying tbh and it was on purpose, that’s why colleagues got annoyed with her, I’m annoyed with her and never met her 😐

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 28/08/2022 11:22

SomePosters · 28/08/2022 10:19

Considering the sneering attitude you talk about your colleagues with Im not surprised you’re getting strong negative reactions from them.

You aren’t rejecting superstition because you’re smarter than them

You are rejecting the social connection of an in joke and alienating people

Exactly right.

SavoirFlair · 28/08/2022 11:12

This. It’s noticeable that nobody in this thread has experienced anything except jokey reactions, whereas OP, who goes out of her way to say it, meets genuine annoyance and anger.

are you British, @Changechangychange ?

(i am, for what it’s worth, but I have a good reason for asking).

hewouldwouldnthe · 28/08/2022 10:56

It's the same in the theatre with the word Macbeth, you'd respect that

Thefoxsays · 28/08/2022 10:43

I think because people may feel like they can't just 'enjoy' the quieter spells. If you have been run ragged all morning then your band 8 comes in and says 'oh it's quiet in here this afternoon'

  1. you will probably have a staff member moved elsewhere which nobody wants
  2. it looks as though you're having a lovely easy day, despite the mornings mayhem
  3. sometimes after running a ward on a wing and a prayer you just want to enjoy the nicer part of your day without people making comment on it! (And it's nearly nightfall which bring out all of the sun downing so you know peace and serenity won't last)

I would never mention anywhere being quiet - superstition or not. Let me enjoy it for as long as I can!

Also full moons are notoriously busy - no idea why but they are.

Changechangychange · 28/08/2022 10:41

EarringsandLipstick · 28/08/2022 08:06

I really doubt the irate response from your colleagues is due to their absolute belief in the power of the word 'quiet' when said at certain times / places.

I suspect it's much more to do with your demeanour & way of speaking, which on the basis of this thread, sounds really annoying.

This. It’s noticeable that nobody in this thread has experienced anything except jokey reactions, whereas OP, who goes out of her way to say it, meets genuine annoyance and anger.

I would laugh along with somebody saying the Q word ordinary. But somebody turning up to each shift and saying “hey it’s quiet! Did you hear what I said guys? Q.U.I.E.T! Quiet! Really really quiet! Qui-et!” just to get a reaction, would honestly get old after about five minutes, and I’d be telling them to shut the fuck up as well.

SmokyQuartz · 28/08/2022 10:36

Yanbu.

Ward sister was adamant no one said the Q word and used to shout if you did.

we used to say it’s dragging a bit instead 😁

CeeCee2022 · 28/08/2022 10:29

It might seem stupid to you but after working 20years in HC some of my worst shifts have happened after people have said the Q word in relation to the shift..... I don't know if its just that you relax too much when you think that about the shift or the expectation when you say it is that its going to continue!
I get that being trained professionals that following superstitions might seem silly but really after seeing some of what I have I don't know how you can not have some superstitions after working in this field. Also the banter between staff is sometimes the only thing that keeps you going during the tough times so I don't see the harm in it!!

SomePosters · 28/08/2022 10:19

Considering the sneering attitude you talk about your colleagues with Im not surprised you’re getting strong negative reactions from them.

You aren’t rejecting superstition because you’re smarter than them

You are rejecting the social connection of an in joke and alienating people

Getoff · 28/08/2022 10:15

I hadn't heard of this superstition before. Obviously it's stupid, and you'd hope medical professionals would be rational enough to see that.

Our brains do struggle to process randomness, and consequently we are naturally inclined to be superstitious. Superstition isn't stupidity, it's a natural response to randomness that reason needs to override. There was an experiment with pigeons (I think) in which small amounts of food were automatically deposited into their cage at random moments . The pigeons developed elaborate rituals to make the food come, based (I think) on what they thought they had done previously to cause the food to appear. I suppose it was the pigeon equivalent of a rain dance.

Suburbitonian · 28/08/2022 10:10

YANBU

It's statistical. If it is quiet now, it cannot get more quiet. It will either continue in the quiet state or get busier - reversion to the mean.

When it does get busier (inevitable really), anyone who mentioned quiet will be cited as the trouble maker.

blubberball · 28/08/2022 10:09

I was a student at a performing arts college. We went around the theatre saying MacBeth all the time, because we thought it was stupid. But I guess the stakes aren't very high in a college theatre production.

ImBoilingJackie · 28/08/2022 10:04

GetOffTheRoof · 28/08/2022 00:10

Oh come on, it's a huge superstition in medical fields, the emergency services and prisons etc.

Either assimilate or accept you will be roundly accused of being a dick.

This is a BIG DEAL in lots of places as well you know. It's in your power to not piss everyone off.

It's like repeatedly saying to a practicing Christian that there is no God. You'd have a point (if you don't believe) but you'd still be the dick.

Superstition I'd a loaf of old nonsense and nothing like someone's religious beliefs.

It's perhaps similar to saying "Macbeth" in a theatre, or saying that your child sleeps through the night. Either way it's ridiculous for people to be so upset by it.

Fraaahnces · 28/08/2022 10:02

The “Q” word is the healthcare equivalent of the “Danish Prince” to actors, or “G..d L..k” to opera singers. (We say “Toi, Toi, Toi!”)

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 28/08/2022 10:01

Replies aren’t “just superstitious “ though are they-you’re just ignoring them despite cut and pasting the response from @MrsTerryPratchett There’s also the response from @CoalCraft both of whom explain it well.
also-very glad I don’t work with you as you sound like an arsehole.

pogostickplastique · 28/08/2022 09:57

Used to be the same in security services. When anyone said the Q word it was pretty much guaranteed to kick off.

Then whoever had said it was on tea/coffee duty for everyone after that. Or sent to a gate hut to work alone for the shift as punishment 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread