Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hoarding and filthy house of mother

105 replies

Hoarding · 27/08/2022 21:10

My mum has always been a hoarder but it’s got significantly worse in the last 10 years. Hoarding newspapers, envelopes, food scraps (nothing is allowed to be thrown, everything will be reheated etc) tiny bits of string, foil etc. You get the idea. It’s got so bad to the point where the house is actually filthy, like properly gross (think fruit flies on literally everything, food remnants caked into the floor, maggots etc) Strangely some parts of house (the bits she doesn’t use basically) are vaguely tidy (but def not clean) like the living room.

She lives alone and to be fair used to have a cleaner but got rid of her about a year ago. I can safely say there’s not been any cleaning done on her part since.

Im pretty sure she’s got inattentive ADHD but I really don’t know how to help her.

for a bit of background into where her priorities lie, im
severely allergic to cats, luckily only if the hair gets in my eyes but my eyes basically completely close up and I get all wheezy. Well this has always been the case but we had 3 cats growing up. Yup, having cats was more important than my safety. There’s a long list of various things like that that have happened over the years.

Anyway, I’ve come down to stay with her for a week with my 2 kids as she’s always wanting us to come stay (but doesn’t actually want to engage with the kids) but my god, I’m scared for my baby’s health with the crap he’s accessing from the floor (he doesn’t crawl yet but he rolls around all over the place and obv everything goes in his mouth)

what I’m asking is AIBU for being really hurt by mum’s hoarding and filthy house? And if not, what can I do to help her? She’s well aware her house is filthy but she refuses to do anything about it.

YABU: her house is none of your business, leave her to it. Or actually try help her.

YANBU: that’s really out of order to treat you and your children like that.

OP posts:
Lulibee · 28/08/2022 15:54

You need to separate your feelings of hurt from the fact that she is seriously mentally unwell.

It surprises me you took your children there for a week knowing how she is.

She needs professional help but she needs to want to change. Focus your efforts on talking to her about this and try to leave your children with someone else when you visit.

If she does not see any issues, I’d be contacting social services and mental health charities for advice.

Until she agrees to help, nothing will change.

Elleherd · 28/08/2022 15:53

Op, I asked the questions to get a feel for the situation, and if others were aware or you're on your own with it. You’ve sort of answered that but it’s not clear if others know her kitchen is a hygiene issue and trust her to work around it, or if they have no idea and would run gagging if they knew?

If they don’t know, how do you think she would feel if they found out that’s what was going on?

If there are siblings then the future is potentially several people’s problem rather than only yours, as eventually all of you will potentially have to deal with the outcome. Part of why I asked, is looking at if you can do a more than one pronged approach.

I think you’re correct about potential paralysis, it’s common. Their situation gets out of hand and for many the answer is to do nothing, as everything feels pointless.
It isn’t, but IME it takes unrelenting energy and humour to get someone who’s hit pointless peak, to see it differently and work with you, especially if it's particularly dense or dirty.

The fact she’s not engaging with the children at the house but is outside it, is a huge pointer.
You’ve probably hit on something that she hasn’t had a great formative relationship with parents, but possibly not bad enough to know that and automatically treat her relationship with her own children very differently?
You and your children do appear to be able to have a relationship with your mum without them needing to stay there? At which point it becomes you wanting to be able to have them have a happy going to ‘stay with gran’ relationship. That may be possible, but not if you’re equally paralyzed by it all.

So you either have recognize it isn’t reasonable to inflict that level of poor hygiene on your children, or be ready to get stuck in and make it hygienic enough.

For me it would be both, but we are all where we are at any given time.
Outside of the magic wand answers, what would you like to happen here?

Elleherd · 28/08/2022 15:48

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/08/2022 12:23

No. It gives SOME sufferers "immense pleasure."
The moment of being able to keep or have your fix gives pleasure but very short lived pleasure.
It'san emotional hamsters wheel.
Others find themselves without any emotional reaction at all, and or filled with self loathing and disgust as they compulsively fill up the void.
Yet similarly to other addicts they either feel numb to the situation or their filled with disgust and self loathing.
That's the pattern of mh addiction.

I absolutely agree with you that addiction is often involved, but I don't agree with you that there is an automatic short lived pleasure.

It's assumed that there must be, because that's the model of addiction we understand, and tbf is the common picture with hoarders. But it isn't the only one.

One reason why hoarding is considered so difficult to treat is because we use models that make assumptions, and everyone must fit into the model.
Those who don't are then considered either deluded or not 'proper' hoarders, or the condition is untreatable.

The reason we don't try to treat hording using addiction treatments is because it's already been seen not to work.

I'm currently working with a CBT system developed by one of the notable experts in front line delivery. Someone I respect hugely and have high hopes about.
It is also based on a psychology model.

That model makes assumptions that everyone when they imagine their perfect room, decorated and furnished as they'd like, will experience a good feeling.

It's a very reasonable reasonable assumption, and came as an unpleasant surprise to discover I don't experience that at all.

I'm not a 'not proper' hoarder. The model isn't a 'bad' model.

Trying to force all elements of the addiction model onto hoarding, is as mistaken as trying to force all elements of the OCD model onto hoarding was.

SunnyD44 · 28/08/2022 15:05

YABU unfortunately it is her life.

My mum is the same and there is nothing I can do or say that will help her and I end up getting more stressed trying to do so as she pretends she wants my help.

I have just made it clear that I will not be bringing her DGC over at all whilst it is a hazard.

It may mean you see your mum less which is very unfortunate but you have to put yourself and your DCs first.

Remember it is a MH issue and to not take it personally if she’s choosing her crap over you and the DGC.

Sunnyqueen · 28/08/2022 15:00

Yeah nothing is going to be a good enough excuse for putting children, especially a baby in a house where there are rotting food and maggots. You are being extremely selfish and negligent there.

CPL593H · 28/08/2022 14:50

Hoarding · 28/08/2022 13:06

I think a lot of the problem is she’s become paralysed by it. She really enjoys cooking for others, baking stuff, jams, chutneys etc, and loves puzzles in newspapers but this means everything related to those things is hoarded.

and also, yes she does socialise and have people round for dinner etc etc so the bits in which people will be in is tidied and cleaned but everything that had been there just gets moved into another room (and the door shut) and like I said before, certain parts of the house are useable like toilets (theres 5 bathrooms, one of them is unusable due to it becoming a “storage” facility)

for those saying I’m being unreasonable because I’m exposing my children to the dirt and mess, it’s not that simple. I want my children to have a relationship with her and to be fair when we’re on outings away from the house she does actually engage with them. And I just feel sorry for her cos she’s on her own (divorced) so needs help with stuff.

and the qu about siblings, yes I’ve got several siblings, a few older and a few younger (I won’t be specific to avoid being identified)

OP, I'm honestly not having a pop at you, but your OP described really insanitary conditions and your concerns for your baby's health. It doesn't matter that some rooms in this (large) house are OKish, if that is the case, it's a safety issue. I honestly feel for you but backtracking to yourself won't help.

As for her dinner guests, Lord help them.

thenewduchessoflapland · 28/08/2022 14:46

She's in her 70's,mentally ill and alone in a 5 bed house.I'd consider selling the house and having her move into a residential home.

I did an afternoons work at one yesterday;it was lovely,it's wasn't a nursing home but one where the residents had a largish room with a sitting area and their own bathroom,there was communal dining room and TV lounge and a resident's kitchen for tea making/baking but the meals were provided by the main kitchen,there was a daily housekeeping team who also did the laundry and staff to monitor and help the residents.She'd be better off in a place like this,she wouldn't be able to hoard and it'd be clean.

LicoricePizza · 28/08/2022 14:19

Elleherd · 28/08/2022 11:21

You mention having MH problems of your own. If you’re also struggling with hoarding please don’t be ashamed to say so.

It adds to the situation if you feel you’re criticizing your mother for something you’re suffering from too.
I used to think what was happening to me was a punishment for not understanding and recognizing my mother’s suffering and just seeing her as hating motherhood and us, and stayed silent most of my life covering up what I grew up in, what was done to us, and her apparent coldness and lack of compassion.
I accepted it as my responsibility to hide what was happening, my fault when I was taken away, and partly my fault she died as a result. I always saw my addiction to cleanliness and order as just a rebellion against a dirty childhood.
I’ve never dealt with what happened and, in the end, following more sudden deaths and losses, it bubbled up as dysfunctional behaviors of my own. I didn't ask for it.
Only now am I recognizing that shame, is what has kept me firmly where I was.

Your children can enjoy visiting without staying, so I’m wondering if the issue is the expense of staying elsewhere?
Do the family and friends who want to meet 'when you're at mum's' know the conditions of the house?
Does she have visitors there?
Based on the size of the place I’m assuming it’s owned. Are you the only child?

Basically, are you effectively trapped keeping her secret?

If some of the rooms are useable do you think your mother would allow one room to be stripped out painted, and set up so you could visit and have your own catering facilities?

Is the bathroom toilet usable safely? Could it be made to be?

If she’d let you, are there others who would help you?

TBH if she’s in her 70’s and has no motivation for change this is only going to get worse unless there’s a way of putting things in place to keep the situation from further deteriorating.

I have reasonable self-awareness and quite a lot of knowledge, and have successfully helped other hoarders, but a) they have to want to be helped at some level, (even grumpily) and b) it doesn’t then let me fix myself.

I’ve worked on my issues, learnt lots about hoarding and how to change individual relationships with stuff, and would love to receive targeted counseling, CBT etc (am trying to use self-administered CBT) but if you don’t have the money for it, there is little of use out there. (unless you count the occasional insightful MN’er who I'm grateful to) so I can’t see your mum getting anywhere quickly. So you need a plan.

At the heart of that plan needs to be a rule of not allowing your children to be negatively impacted by it all. Protect your children the way no one protected you. It's the one thing you absolutely can do.

I'm on my way out (ironically to clean a hoarded home) but back this afternoon if you're interested in strategies.

This is really insightful & excellent advice OP

Brigante9 · 28/08/2022 14:00

Her house is unsafe for your dc. I can’t imagine why you would take them there. Don”t you think it’s too risky?

Sceptre86 · 28/08/2022 13:56

There isn't much you can do aside from talking to her, encourage her to engage with mental health services. You could hire a cleaner to come in once a week and not touch the storage rooms. So for example she just cleans the living room, kitchen and bathrooms. However your mum might not agree. I would refuse to take my kids there.

Aquamarine1029 · 28/08/2022 13:53

for those saying I’m being unreasonable because I’m exposing my children to the dirt and mess, it’s not that simple. I want my children to have a relationship with her and to be fair when we’re on outings away from the house she does actually engage with them.

Yes, it is that simple. You are putting your wants and you misplaced guilt above the safety of your own children. You are being woefully negligent.

gamerchick · 28/08/2022 13:50

Christ, go home man. You can't subject your kids to that.

Hoarding · 28/08/2022 13:46

I’m sure this is going to out me for anyone that knows me but basically childhood wise she was sent to full time boarding school at the age of 8 and from then onwards only saw her parents twice a year

OP posts:
felulageller · 28/08/2022 13:34

Hoarding disorder is usually rooted in past trauma.

What was her childhood like?

She needs therapy for that to tackle the problem.

Hoarding · 28/08/2022 13:06

I think a lot of the problem is she’s become paralysed by it. She really enjoys cooking for others, baking stuff, jams, chutneys etc, and loves puzzles in newspapers but this means everything related to those things is hoarded.

and also, yes she does socialise and have people round for dinner etc etc so the bits in which people will be in is tidied and cleaned but everything that had been there just gets moved into another room (and the door shut) and like I said before, certain parts of the house are useable like toilets (theres 5 bathrooms, one of them is unusable due to it becoming a “storage” facility)

for those saying I’m being unreasonable because I’m exposing my children to the dirt and mess, it’s not that simple. I want my children to have a relationship with her and to be fair when we’re on outings away from the house she does actually engage with them. And I just feel sorry for her cos she’s on her own (divorced) so needs help with stuff.

and the qu about siblings, yes I’ve got several siblings, a few older and a few younger (I won’t be specific to avoid being identified)

OP posts:
tonicwaters · 28/08/2022 12:52

I don't think anyone has been successful in "curing" a hoarding addiction. They might clear the place out and put most wanted items in storage etc. but the crap builds back up to fill the empty spaces in nearly every case.

If it were me, I would see the person not the house. They cannot see the mess at all, it's like a total blind spot. So keep your and your children's relationship with your mother but meet up outside of her house, bring her with you to a hotel, Air BnB etc.

I don't envy you, but you must look after your own mental health, and the health and well being of your kids too.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 28/08/2022 12:32

I agree with you. My dad starting hoarding stuff. Nothing with food on but just putting everything in a pile and when he died I sorted it all out. My db is a hoarder too and although he has got rid of some things it's still bad. My mum doesn't really like it and if she had a cleaner they wouldn't be able to get round

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/08/2022 12:23

No. It gives SOME sufferers "immense pleasure."
The moment of being able to keep or have your fix gives pleasure but very short lived pleasure.
It'san emotional hamsters wheel.
Others find themselves without any emotional reaction at all, and or filled with self loathing and disgust as they compulsively fill up the void.
Yet similarly to other addicts they either feel numb to the situation or their filled with disgust and self loathing.
That's the pattern of mh addiction.

Elleherd · 28/08/2022 11:21

You mention having MH problems of your own. If you’re also struggling with hoarding please don’t be ashamed to say so.

It adds to the situation if you feel you’re criticizing your mother for something you’re suffering from too.
I used to think what was happening to me was a punishment for not understanding and recognizing my mother’s suffering and just seeing her as hating motherhood and us, and stayed silent most of my life covering up what I grew up in, what was done to us, and her apparent coldness and lack of compassion.
I accepted it as my responsibility to hide what was happening, my fault when I was taken away, and partly my fault she died as a result. I always saw my addiction to cleanliness and order as just a rebellion against a dirty childhood.
I’ve never dealt with what happened and, in the end, following more sudden deaths and losses, it bubbled up as dysfunctional behaviors of my own. I didn't ask for it.
Only now am I recognizing that shame, is what has kept me firmly where I was.

Your children can enjoy visiting without staying, so I’m wondering if the issue is the expense of staying elsewhere?
Do the family and friends who want to meet 'when you're at mum's' know the conditions of the house?
Does she have visitors there?
Based on the size of the place I’m assuming it’s owned. Are you the only child?

Basically, are you effectively trapped keeping her secret?

If some of the rooms are useable do you think your mother would allow one room to be stripped out painted, and set up so you could visit and have your own catering facilities?

Is the bathroom toilet usable safely? Could it be made to be?

If she’d let you, are there others who would help you?

TBH if she’s in her 70’s and has no motivation for change this is only going to get worse unless there’s a way of putting things in place to keep the situation from further deteriorating.

I have reasonable self-awareness and quite a lot of knowledge, and have successfully helped other hoarders, but a) they have to want to be helped at some level, (even grumpily) and b) it doesn’t then let me fix myself.

I’ve worked on my issues, learnt lots about hoarding and how to change individual relationships with stuff, and would love to receive targeted counseling, CBT etc (am trying to use self-administered CBT) but if you don’t have the money for it, there is little of use out there. (unless you count the occasional insightful MN’er who I'm grateful to) so I can’t see your mum getting anywhere quickly. So you need a plan.

At the heart of that plan needs to be a rule of not allowing your children to be negatively impacted by it all. Protect your children the way no one protected you. It's the one thing you absolutely can do.

I'm on my way out (ironically to clean a hoarded home) but back this afternoon if you're interested in strategies.

Elleherd · 28/08/2022 11:07

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/08/2022 10:32

The lines are often crossed if not always IMO between MH and addiction it is not only a huge problem but it gives the sufferers immense pleasure whether they choose drugs, alcohol, food, hoarding, it's all about filling an internal hole in their soul.

Self satisfaction at a huge cost to others around them.

At 70 I doubt you'll change her though many people find the strength to overcome addiction and avoid triggers for the people they love, equally as many don't find the strength no matter how much they are loved.

No. It gives SOME sufferers "immense pleasure."
Others find themselves without any emotional reaction at all, and or filled with self loathing and disgust as they compulsively fill up the void.

If the condition was nice and neatly predictable that all hoarders are the same and do this, this way, and feel this as a result, we'd be a darn sight closer to finding one size fits all solutions.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/08/2022 10:32

The lines are often crossed if not always IMO between MH and addiction it is not only a huge problem but it gives the sufferers immense pleasure whether they choose drugs, alcohol, food, hoarding, it's all about filling an internal hole in their soul.

Self satisfaction at a huge cost to others around them.

At 70 I doubt you'll change her though many people find the strength to overcome addiction and avoid triggers for the people they love, equally as many don't find the strength no matter how much they are loved.

BatshitBanshee · 28/08/2022 10:28

I need to put my childrens health first but even as a 30-something year old adult I still crave my mums attention/love/affection

You're doing the same thing to your kids that your mother did to you with the cats. Putting them in harm's way because of your own selfish wants. YABU to go and stay there, knowing what it's like, put your kids in that situation and then complain about it.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 28/08/2022 10:13

There was a series on recently where Extreme Cleaners went into houses to clean. They didn't examine the causes of hoarding , it was more a "OMG how can this get into this state?" kind of voyeurism.

But one episode , the owner sat in the lounge , the EC were going through craft items . Everything she said "I need that" and snatched it back.
I recognised this in my Mum, everything I tried to remove she "needed" or "I use that" or "I;m going to sew that"

That was her thing , half sewn, things taken apart and nothing done to it but she "was going to sew it" (she never did)

BertieBotts · 28/08/2022 09:40

I can't answer your AIBU because it's more complicated.

Book an AirBNB to stay near her to visit. Don't stay in the house.

It's not unreasonable to find it difficult to cope with, but hoarding is basically a mentl illness. She's not doing it on purpose to spite you.

Boundaries help separate your relationship with her from your feelings about the way she lives.

CPL593H · 28/08/2022 09:34

Hoarding · 28/08/2022 09:19

so just to answer some questions…

she’s in her 70s, has had mental health issues for many years.

i too have mental health problems and have been seeing a therapist / counsellor for several years already.

some rooms in her house are totally fine (need updating as very dated but are usable) but other rooms are completely unusable (bear in mind it’s a 5 bedroom house so plenty of space to use for one person)

my kids do like her and enjoy seeing her and her cat etc and I always get pressure to come down especially from friends and family friends “let me know when you’re down at your mums and we’ll meet up”

@Hoarding you said in your OP that "I’m scared for my baby’s health with the crap he’s accessing from the floor". That surely trumps any enjoyment or pressure around visiting her, or seeing your friends and family (and it sounds like your baby at least is far too young to care one way or the other)

You can't fix this. She will resist any attempt to do so. Ask any social worker or MH professional who has spent years working with people who hoard how very difficult it is to help them to effect change. No one is saying you should not have contact with her, everyone is saying that needs to be done in a way that is safe for your children.