Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DDs friends fudging meet-up

160 replies

Menomama · 27/08/2022 14:06

There is a back story, but for now, I’d like opinions on this one incident only, as I’m obviously reacting based on everything, ever…

There is an event in town. It’s time specific (as in, between the hours of noon and 3 PM, but spread out throughout town, so not in one specific spot so many people around that there’s no chance to find someone unless you know when and where to look).

DD(10) and a couple of friends (also 10) planned to go together. Everyone of them lives on the outskirts of town, a couple of miles out, and very close to each other. DD was really excited. First time in town on her own, with friends etc.

I asked what time they’d be going. DD said they’d agreed to leave at 1. I asked if they were meeting up on the corner (where all three of their paths would cross, about 1,5 miles from town, so still quite a way) but she said no, they agreed everyone would set off from home at 1 and that they’d meet up by a cafe in town. I thought that was a bit odd (why not bike together?) but didn’t question it.

At noon, I was in town myself and bumped into the two friends. I said hi, they replied, but looked a bit sheepish and walked off. I’d already gone into a shop, but went back out again to ask if they were supposed to meet up already. One replied ”we said we’d meet here” and I replied I know, but that DD thought they were setting off at 1 so maybe she’d got the time wrong. ”We thought we’d come a bit earlier to avoid the heavy traffic around the parade” she said. I replied that was good thinking, and asked if DD was aware. The other one said ”we can call her”. I said lovely, went back in the shop and when I came back out she was on her phone. On the way home I met a flustered DD who told me one of the girls had called her to say they were changing the time.

I think they’d planned to go at the start of the event all along, and obviously biked together. Why they’d tell DD to set off more than an hour later, I don’t know. Whether they were even going to be around when she actually turned up or not, I’m not sure.

But I am fuming at the, in my view, bitchiness and heartbroken for DD who is excited and thinks they’re BFFs.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Vickstory79 · 27/08/2022 17:09

YANBU

She's 10 and even if they are the only two other girls in the village she's better off finding others elsewhere. Trust, honesty and kindness are important parts of friendship.

I would teach your daughter to be able to retract from the friendship totally. She should always offer a genuine and cheerful "hi" when she passes them at school BUT she should move on immediately to chat with others to make it clear she isn't wanting or caring for a response. This will give her back some control.

No hard feelings, just move on and probably next year she'll be friends with one of them again and they may not be friends with each other.

I have older children and in my experience once the parents are out of the picture, when they're older, these situations don't tend to happen.

Endlesslypatient82 · 27/08/2022 17:09

Op

Your DD seems to have had a tough time that you allude to in your back story.
i imagine you were really hoping this was the start of a solid friendship
these girls are 10. They were silly and thoughtless, but you seem to be very angry at girls that are very young. Your girl doesn’t seem to have any friends from what you have said. Has this always been the case or recent development?

Washermother33 · 27/08/2022 17:08

Your DD needs to be told the truth and encouraged not to rely on these 2 .. at the age of 10 you should still have time to help new friendships via play dates or pizza and movie nights

Menomama · 27/08/2022 17:06

@Endlesslypatient82 The event was spread through town, and during a specific time window. I knew that much. I also ”knew” (was told, by DD) that they were all leaving their houses at a specific time. As the girls made the arrangements themselves, I didn’t question the timing: only wondered why they would agree on a time to leave, but also NOT bike together. It seemed odd to me. However, to find out that the other two had a) left much earlier b) together c) to see the parade and avoid the traffic but d) specifically not told DD any of this, but actually lied about the timing I am not sure how I should or could’ve prevented this. The event was much more than the parade, but seems to me DD was supposed to miss that part. Of course, I could’ve gone with DD, dropped her off / picked her up… but that was not the point of this afternoon.

OP posts:
Peashoots · 27/08/2022 17:03

Festoonlights · 27/08/2022 16:51

By definition sharing secrets is also exclusionary bullying behaviour when misused

Exactly!

Endlesslypatient82 · 27/08/2022 16:56

Menomama · 27/08/2022 16:33

Couple of things: I understand why some of you are surprised at the age. We are, however, not in the UK. You’ll have to take my word for it, it is not a safety concern here, and in fact very normal for kids this age to be out without adults.

Also - the girls had arranged and agreed all this. Biking was part of it. I did question why set off later than the start but ”that was the agreement”.
Someone wondered why I didn’t look into the event myself - but I was there, at noon, as per my OP.

And, as with the back story: I am at the point where I am considering moving DD to a different school, in town… precisely to get away from this. But moving schools is a big decision and would obvioulsy also impact her commute etc. But this is why I wanted to know if AIBU on this occasion…

So if you had looked in to it beforehand and we’re there - did you not see the main event was before your daughter would even get there?

UniBallEye · 27/08/2022 16:56

Girls that age are a nightmare! My dad is mid,/late teen now & I would not go back to that age group for all the money in the world.

In my dd's case it was 1 girl who wanted to be the queen bee & control the orter2 & she was a nasty little bitch. I know that's a shocking thing to say but she really truly was

They grew up & grew out of it eventually but they're hard lessons for our poor dc on the receiving end of things. I wanted to do harm to that little madam. It still makes my blood boil thinking back

I would 100% encourage one to one events/ sleepovers with the other girl. You can bet your bottom dollar the bitch mother won't like it one bit. Tough.

Oddbobbyboo · 27/08/2022 16:53

Girls are a nightmare xx from my experience with my two…. Things change quite quickly.

Things will change when she starts secondary as they’ll be loads of children to pick from x I’ve got four children and had to navigate them all through different scenarios…… like this.

What I will say is that it hurts and angers us mums more than our children fortunately x

Festoonlights · 27/08/2022 16:51

Peashoots · 27/08/2022 16:45

@chillipenguin that they couldn’t talk about in front of their peer, best friend, kid the same age.
you’re being ridiculous. The reaching here to stick up for two kids who were being bitchy.
you must be a mean girl or have a mean girl daughter yourself.

By definition sharing secrets is also exclusionary bullying behaviour when misused

Peashoots · 27/08/2022 16:45

@chillipenguin that they couldn’t talk about in front of their peer, best friend, kid the same age.
you’re being ridiculous. The reaching here to stick up for two kids who were being bitchy.
you must be a mean girl or have a mean girl daughter yourself.

SmellyCat1985 · 27/08/2022 16:43

Embarrassingly I went through this in my early 20’s. Three girls, did everything together but the other two were obviously much closer. We would arrange to meet and they’d meet up before, sometimes both being late meeting me. I waited outside a nightclub at 11pm in the rain once alone. They also secretly arranged to move in together and only told me the night before.

I think growing up with this (we were friends at 10 too) has made my self esteem really low. I genuinely believed I was the boring one and deserved to be left out because I’m quieter than them and not as fun. I think you should encourage other friendships so she’s not as reliant on these two.

(Ironically they fell out massively when they moved in together and I’m now friends with them separately, but I’m very distant from both of them)

chillipenguin · 27/08/2022 16:42

Peashoots · 27/08/2022 16:41

Oh piss off, they’re ten 🙄 what personal matters??
op they were being mean. Not nice but I wouldn’t write the friendship off-girls of this age can be like this. Don’t mention it to DD. Hopefully the embarrassment of being caught will make them think twice in future.

Periods. Parents getting divorced. Fancying someone in their class.

Peashoots · 27/08/2022 16:41

chillipenguin · 27/08/2022 14:16

Maybe they wanted some time just the two of them together before meeting DD. They may have wanted to discuss personal matters without DD present.

Oh piss off, they’re ten 🙄 what personal matters??
op they were being mean. Not nice but I wouldn’t write the friendship off-girls of this age can be like this. Don’t mention it to DD. Hopefully the embarrassment of being caught will make them think twice in future.

perimenofertility · 27/08/2022 16:37

Gosh kids can be mean. As an isolated incident I'd say the two of them felt obliged to invite your DD but made arrangements in such a way that they knew she would be too late for the start of the event and might not easily find them and they'd have a great time together just the two of them.
With your back story info, perhaps the "two is best" girl's mother said something like "why don't you set off earlier and find menomama's dd later on".
Either way, it sounds like certainly in this incident your DD is the weaker link of the three and open to being let down.
I wouldn't mention to her that you saw them because it'll knock her confidence and she may have enjoyed the day or at least the first independent trip. But I'd do this that someone wrote upthread:
"Based on this opinion, I'd strongly encourage the friendship between the girl whose mother believes in the threesome being ok, and where possible not actively encourage the friendship between your DD and the girl whose mother believes in a twosome being sufficient.
She'll change her tune when it's her daughter being at the receiving end of the third-wheel comments/situations."

Festoonlights · 27/08/2022 16:36

YADNBU
I would move her, the small town thinking is cliquey and stifling as they grow older.

Menomama · 27/08/2022 16:33

Couple of things: I understand why some of you are surprised at the age. We are, however, not in the UK. You’ll have to take my word for it, it is not a safety concern here, and in fact very normal for kids this age to be out without adults.

Also - the girls had arranged and agreed all this. Biking was part of it. I did question why set off later than the start but ”that was the agreement”.
Someone wondered why I didn’t look into the event myself - but I was there, at noon, as per my OP.

And, as with the back story: I am at the point where I am considering moving DD to a different school, in town… precisely to get away from this. But moving schools is a big decision and would obvioulsy also impact her commute etc. But this is why I wanted to know if AIBU on this occasion…

OP posts:
TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 27/08/2022 16:32

I'm so sorry for your DD, I had similar in school and it really hurt.

morgenmorgen · 27/08/2022 16:25

Gosh, this thread has stirred up some memories. I was also in a similar situation in my very early teens - on the outside of a three, small school etc. Don't want to go into too much detail here but the whole thing drove me to a very dark place and I was affected by it for years. Please take seriously those who suggest strongly encouraging/nurturing other friendships outside of school - even if it means travelling further to visit friends or whatever. I so so wish my parents had done that for me as a lot of misery could have been avoided.

Endlesslypatient82 · 27/08/2022 16:23

Small village, so unfortunately not possible to encourage other friendships.

school? Clubs? Hobbies?

Endlesslypatient82 · 27/08/2022 16:22

They’re 10.

you truly have no idea what goes on between girls this age on a daily basis. The fluctuations are ridiculous.

i am surprised you didn’t look at the event more closely and see the timings given so young and her first time ever on her own

OurLipsAreSealed · 27/08/2022 16:19

DS now goes to a different school and stopped all communication with these boys.

Festoonlights · 27/08/2022 16:16

Stop trying to keep the three. The other mother has been clear she isn’t facilitating that, for sine stupid reason only known to her.
Be clear with dd why you are doing it, so she learns to stop investing in people that treat her badly. They will make many new friends in secondary school so don’t worry

NWQM · 27/08/2022 16:14

If she has had an otherwise good afternoon I can see why you don t want to upset her but as you say there is a back story I fear you may be best telling her

Ourlady · 27/08/2022 16:11

I’d want to punch that Mother who actively is trying to stop the three girls being friends. What a bitch!

familyissues12345 · 27/08/2022 16:10

Both of my sons had similar problems at this age. On both occasions it turned out to be one ring leader, who subsequently went off to a different secondary school a year later and then the friendship between the others became much stronger.

DS2's issues were much the same as your daughters OP, friends arranging to meet him then not being there/arranging to meet earlier. I wouldn't have minded so much if they played the "game" with all of them, but DS was always on the receiving end so it very quickly stopped being funny...