Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DDs friends fudging meet-up

160 replies

Menomama · 27/08/2022 14:06

There is a back story, but for now, I’d like opinions on this one incident only, as I’m obviously reacting based on everything, ever…

There is an event in town. It’s time specific (as in, between the hours of noon and 3 PM, but spread out throughout town, so not in one specific spot so many people around that there’s no chance to find someone unless you know when and where to look).

DD(10) and a couple of friends (also 10) planned to go together. Everyone of them lives on the outskirts of town, a couple of miles out, and very close to each other. DD was really excited. First time in town on her own, with friends etc.

I asked what time they’d be going. DD said they’d agreed to leave at 1. I asked if they were meeting up on the corner (where all three of their paths would cross, about 1,5 miles from town, so still quite a way) but she said no, they agreed everyone would set off from home at 1 and that they’d meet up by a cafe in town. I thought that was a bit odd (why not bike together?) but didn’t question it.

At noon, I was in town myself and bumped into the two friends. I said hi, they replied, but looked a bit sheepish and walked off. I’d already gone into a shop, but went back out again to ask if they were supposed to meet up already. One replied ”we said we’d meet here” and I replied I know, but that DD thought they were setting off at 1 so maybe she’d got the time wrong. ”We thought we’d come a bit earlier to avoid the heavy traffic around the parade” she said. I replied that was good thinking, and asked if DD was aware. The other one said ”we can call her”. I said lovely, went back in the shop and when I came back out she was on her phone. On the way home I met a flustered DD who told me one of the girls had called her to say they were changing the time.

I think they’d planned to go at the start of the event all along, and obviously biked together. Why they’d tell DD to set off more than an hour later, I don’t know. Whether they were even going to be around when she actually turned up or not, I’m not sure.

But I am fuming at the, in my view, bitchiness and heartbroken for DD who is excited and thinks they’re BFFs.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 10:57

Sorry you lost me op

but you were talking about ADULTS, so as soon as I saw that - I tuned out. Because your thread is about children!!!

Menomama · 28/08/2022 10:32

@Endlesslypatient82

OK. Imagine a scenario like this:
”I have been in my current job for a couple of years. I feel I am being excluded by two people in my immediate team. Sometimes they act nice and we plan projects together, sometimes I hear that I have been left out of important events. My line manager seems to have noticed this too.

I was told the line manager of one of the team members tried to get HR to split the team up as she feels ”people work better in pairs, and teamwork is impossible”. HR wouldn’t do this.

I love the actual job and get on well with people in other departments. I occasionally travel for work, but do the our location, mainly do joint projects with other departments over zoom, so on a daily basis I am confined to my immediate team.

I do of course, also have a family but as I work full-time, my relationship with my immediate team is dominating a big chunk of my time.

There’s an offer of secondment, to a bigger office but also with a longer commute and my duties would change considerably.”

Does that make it easier to understand?

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 28/08/2022 10:22

Thing is there is very little you can actually do and this will decrease as she gets older. She has to learn to navigate this herself. If these issues don’t resolve and she is repeatedly left out and is “whipping girl” of the group she needs to leave the group and find better friends. Honestly this is why I am a fan of really big schools these little rural ones with say 3 other girls make my blood run cold. In a larger school there are always other friendship. options.

Faeriepath · 28/08/2022 10:20

I disagree that Op needs to tell her dd what has happened or that she's 'onto' the other girls. What's that going to solve.? If it was me I would say nothing .

It does sound a difficult situation where there's a very limited friendship opportunities, perhaps moving schools would be the answer?

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 28/08/2022 10:19

I have experience of this sort of thing with DS2, who is now 13. He had, what he thought, was a tight group of 3 friends until he was 11. Another child joined the group and, deliberately in my view, started to exclude DS. Over time, they have dropped him completely. It is bloody heartbreaking.

I have frequently seen the 4 kids out and about as a group over the summer, while DS sat at home. He still seems to consider these kids his friends (other than the interloper
who he never liked anyway) but they are absolutely not. I am careful not to diss them in front of him. But will not organise any events with them (ie sleepovers etc). If he suggests something, I divert with alternative kids. I am hoping over time he will form new friendships, but it’s a long long process. All I can do is encourage him quietly…while fuming inside.

Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 10:17

My children don’t have local friends becuae don’t go to the local school

No biggie. Weekends they chill at home or we arrange getting together with friends (involves a few miles driving)

Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 10:16

No I don’t think explaining well

you are thinking about moving your child to a different school due to friendship issues. So if she does have school friendships that you are happy with - then why are you thinking about moving her?

As a parent it is sometimes difficult - but some people do struggle to make friends and I imagine very difficult for a parent to witness.

VioletToes · 28/08/2022 10:15

tillytown · 27/08/2022 21:42

Stop calling little girls bitches, what the fuck is wrong with some of you

👏👏 thank fuck someone else thinks this.

People can be arseholes, of both sexes ffs.

Did I read it right that your DD is 10? I can't actually get past that tbh. 10 seems too young to biking 1.5 miles on her own into a busy event.

That aside because you're obviously ok with it. You should have bollocked out the girls when you rumbled them. Let them know you're onto them and you'll pull them up on it. And then tell your DD. How would she feel knowing you 3 have this 'secret'.

Menomama · 28/08/2022 10:13

@Endlesslypatient82 I’m sure you are trying to help, and I appreciate your time and effort. But I also feel like either you are missing things that I have already posted OR you are, with gentle questions, trying to get me to see something I am missing. If it’s the latter, I am failing.

I answered yes to your question of ”does she not have any relationships that I am happy with the quality of”. I have also explained that these two girls are in school, the village and that there are not, on a daily basis, many other options AND that, for want of a better expression, this is sort of a ”captive audience” situation. But I feel like either I am not explaining it well or you are alluding to something which I am not getting.

OP posts:
CornishTiger · 28/08/2022 10:12

You need to tell your daughter that you saw them and what happened. I would not want them to tell her they had seen you and her mistrust them.

Just start with I saw x and y yesterday in town which prompted them to call you.

Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 10:07

Menomama · 28/08/2022 09:58

@Endlesslypatient82

Sorry to leave you hanging! Yes. But as she spends several hours a day, five days a week and most weeks of the year in school, it’s those friendships that have the biggest impact on her well-being.

I did also already explain that in this instance, DDs view of the quality and my view differ.

So at school… no friendships at all that you think are good quality?

Menomama · 28/08/2022 10:01

@diddl No. But that was also not the issue here.

OP posts:
Menomama · 28/08/2022 09:58

@Endlesslypatient82

Sorry to leave you hanging! Yes. But as she spends several hours a day, five days a week and most weeks of the year in school, it’s those friendships that have the biggest impact on her well-being.

I did also already explain that in this instance, DDs view of the quality and my view differ.

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 09:52

Op I have asked a few times but no answer

putting these two girls aside, does your dd have any friendships at all that you are happy with the quality of?

diddl · 28/08/2022 09:50

but these are 10 year old girls we are talking about. So I think we cut them some slack

I agree-I mean does it really matter if they wanted to meet first for a couple of hours?

Menomama · 28/08/2022 09:49

This thread has been useful in that it has made it clear people focus on different aspects, and that has also helped me see why I, for example, feel like it’s pointless even trying to discuss this with the ”only two can play” mother… and also how to maybe approach it with the other mother.

For example, I am not suggesting that DD should always be included and things should be done as a threesome: I have no right (or desire) to suggest such a thing. I also don’t agree with the principle of ”only two can play” (which of course, does rule out the option of ever doing anything as a threesome all together).

Of course the girls have every right to go where, when and how they want to. My issue here was with how they dealt with DD and also, what I should do with the information I have and DD doesn’t.

Sadly, it seems that this kind of behaviour is quite common and it’s heartbreaking (but important!) to read of the experiences many still carry with them in adulthood. That has given me a lot of food for thought, and that’s exactly what I want to avoid for DD.

While I could certainly have chosen a different and better word to describe the behaviour (which is what I was referring to and not the girls themselves, mind you!) I am also quite surprised by how many people dismiss exclusion (bullying) as sillyness or thoughtlessness and something either to be expected or considered almost harmless.

Please read again the posts from people who have experienced this themselves or had it happen to their DC. Also, be aware that there is research showing that bullying - in particular exclusion - can start way before children go to school. And that it is often calculated and deliberate.

Yes, children need adults to help them model and navigate relationships: that includes boundaries on what is and isn’t an acceptable or kind way of treating others (as well as of course, standing up for yourself and healthy self worth). This does not get solved simply by finding others to play with if you happen to be on the receiving end... and I know that’s not what most of you had in mind, rather opportunities for DD to develop and have experiences separately from these circles.

The worry is that some people may shut their eyes or shrug off suffering / bullying as something that is just ”part of life”.

OP posts:
Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 08:42

diddl · 28/08/2022 07:01

Maybe they just shouldn't have included Op's daughter at all if they didn't want to?

Agreed
This is what an adult would do (hopefully but many a mumsnet thread would suggest otherwise!)

but these are 10 year old girls we are talking about. So I think we cut them some slack

diddl · 28/08/2022 07:01

Maybe they just shouldn't have included Op's daughter at all if they didn't want to?

Endlesslypatient82 · 28/08/2022 06:40

Faeriepath · 27/08/2022 22:13

I can remember being aged 7 or 8 and my 'best friend ' organising it so that all the girls were sat together in the classroom with no space for me.
Of course little girls can be right bitches if they set their minds to it.
I was upset at having to sit on a boys table but actually found they were far more straightforward.

Are you honestly saying that in this instance these 7/8 year old girls were being “right bitches”?

SarahDippity · 28/08/2022 00:50

I tend to naturally recoil when people call young girls bitchy/bitches. At age 10 they are extremely immature and unable to rationalise decisions. The impact of this May indeed be hurtful but name-calling young girls is horrible. At that age, they don’t really have the confidence or assertiveness to collectively negotiate an inclusive plan. One ‘leader’ might propose a plan, and FOMO means others fall in. This does not make them bad people or botched. At 10, I would expect more adult involvement. My DD who is 13 still struggles to figure out group arrangements and I stay engaged to guide her. I’m sorry your daughter got left out.

AussieMozzieMagnet · 28/08/2022 00:39

Gosh, at 10 there’s no way my friends and I would have met without an adult present. And having an adult there would prevent a lot of this nonsense from happening.

As for a friendship of three, I thought that was normal.

And the mother who wants to split the group up is psycho. What it got to do with her? She needs to find some new hobbies (and friends of her own) and leave the children alone.

Mariposista · 27/08/2022 22:56

How horrible for your daughter OP. I remember the ‘mean girls’ and exclusion at this age, it is horrible and felt like the end of the world. She needs some nice new friends in secondary. I moved schools in year 6 and actually made friends with a few boys in my class (my previous school was girls only). They were brilliant and to this day I am great friends with both men and women. A mixed friendship group tends to mean less drama.

Faeriepath · 27/08/2022 22:13

I can remember being aged 7 or 8 and my 'best friend ' organising it so that all the girls were sat together in the classroom with no space for me.
Of course little girls can be right bitches if they set their minds to it.
I was upset at having to sit on a boys table but actually found they were far more straightforward.

tillytown · 27/08/2022 21:42

Stop calling little girls bitches, what the fuck is wrong with some of you

NickyChavan · 27/08/2022 20:55

I have a suggestion regarding the new school. Maybe ask the school you are interested in if they have any events/fetes /after school clubs that you can take DD too. She might meet other friends so the transition is easier.