Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for a price reduction following house survey?

27 replies

User174099 · 27/08/2022 12:51

Hi,

We are buying a Victorian mid terrace property in England for £475,000. It needs work doing to modernise it, which we accepted upon making our offer. However some issues have come back like windows needing to be replaced and asbestos which we didn’t fully anticipate but can accept with an older property needing modernising, and therefore do not intend to dwell on this.

On the other hand, we have been told we need to urgently remove the cement render from the back of the house as it’s causing all sorts of damp problems internally and it is has blown with cracks. We have had the wall assessed by a masonry contractor who has done a survey for us and the quote is £13,500 to remove the render, re-render in lime and limewash. Our building surveyor advised this work needed completing as a priority and as soon as possible. This is not something we had anticipated.

Our building surveyor didn’t value our property but we feel this is something we might want to go back to the vendor about regarding the purchase price. We are wondering whether to ask for £13,000 off, or maybe half an ask for around £6000 off. I feel very uncomfortable doing this and was very unimpressed when our buyer asked us for £2000 off our house due to a leaning chimney and we told him no and that he could pull out if he wanted as we had a lot of interest. It’s just a lot of work we had not budgeted for and had hoped it would be more like £5000…

OP posts:
Tiani4 · 27/08/2022 13:02

Yes you can use the survey report to negotiate price down, as they'll have same problem with every other buyer.
There's modernising and work on an old house that you can see, general upkeep stuff and something unseen like this render issue on back wall

Discuss with estate agents to advise vendor of this. I would expect to get at least £10000 off the agreed offer price.

I say that as someone selling my old house, I wouldn't except money off for things seen when they put in offer- but have a built in £10,000 in price that I can move a little if someone I didn't know about comes up. Id be glad to know (but sad to lose money on my house sale)

Whatevergetsyouthroughthenight · 27/08/2022 13:00

Two things:

  1. Would you be heartbroken to lose it for £13,500? If the seller refused, would you walk away?
  2. What will it be worth when renovations are finished vs the cost of the work?

I would do the sums - cost of house plus cost of renovations vs projected value. The house should have been priced to account for work needed. If the sums don’t add up, it’s overpriced so ask for a reduction. That’s not unreasonable.

If you’d be heartbroken to lose it then decide in advance how much you are prepared to pay for it and set that as your maximum. You should have some idea if people are queuing up to buy it at the same price or not and if you are risking annoying the seller so much that they will pull out.