Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think some Mumsnet advice is crap?

343 replies

Crapadvice · 27/08/2022 10:39

Lighthearted.

Lots of very good suggestions, kindness, support, not knocking anyone, just having a laugh here.

But there are a few tired old nuggets that keep finding their way onto threads.

Theres the super aggressive, over the top advice, like someone who is mildly annoyed with their husband has to SIT HIM DOWN. why does this always involve sitting him down, like a dog.

Ear plus or headphones as the answer to any excess noise. Does it not occur to people that we need to hear other stuff for a reason?

No, as in no is a complete sentence. No it isnt. I think my friend is a MNetter, I asked if she was free for coffee a couple of months ago. She said ‘no.’ I haven’t asked since!

what’s the worst advice you’ve seen on here?

OP posts:
Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:49

RoseAndRose · 27/08/2022 19:46

Conspicuous consumption was always a bit iffy, and is about to become close to taboo on both COL and environmental grounds.

You're right, but it doesn't seem to happen much with other high end items though. Designer handbag threads seem to attract a lot of criticism.

RoseAndRose · 27/08/2022 19:46

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:43

There was one poor woman asked for advice on S&B about treating herself to an expensive handbag. She came in for some stick, but the best one was a poster telling her to spend the money on a bench which could be donated to a park.

Conspicuous consumption was always a bit iffy, and is about to become close to taboo on both COL and environmental grounds.

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:43

There was one poor woman asked for advice on S&B about treating herself to an expensive handbag. She came in for some stick, but the best one was a poster telling her to spend the money on a bench which could be donated to a park.

Trying20 · 27/08/2022 19:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Annieisalright · 27/08/2022 19:39

Only some?

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 27/08/2022 19:33

I never forget the post where the OP was complaining their neighbour was using their outside tap to connect their hose and water their garden. A legitimate complaint, some posters were saying get a tap lock to prevent it happening in the future which seemed a good idea to me.

However, one poster was up in arms as they said that homeless person would not be able to use the tap for a drink.

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:27

Yes, @x2boys - not so much about sharing tips on reducing fuel bills, more about never heating the house and acting like they're in the Siege of Stalingrad.

Ameanstreakamilewide · 27/08/2022 19:25

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:14

Those "central heating is an unnecessary luxury" threads are just competitive Scrooge fests. The house never getting above 9°c? Wearing duvets and 5 pairs of socks? Come off it.

It's an odd sort of one-upmanship, really and reminds me of the Monty Python 4 Yorkshire Men sketch.

Similarly, whenever there's a wedding thread, they'll be people saying that they got married for half a crown, received only a jar of pickled eggs for a wedding present and yoinked in 2 random people in off the street to be witnesses.
And everyone said it was the best wedding they'd ever been to before or since!

I mean...🤷🏻‍♀️

x2boys · 27/08/2022 19:24

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:14

Those "central heating is an unnecessary luxury" threads are just competitive Scrooge fests. The house never getting above 9°c? Wearing duvets and 5 pairs of socks? Come off it.

I haven't read them but I imagine they are of a similar ilk to the competitive how little do you spend on your children at Xmas threads ,I don't mean people who can't afford many gifts but those that can but take great delight in being stingy .

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:24

ReneBumsWombats · 27/08/2022 19:22

I'm staying off the central heating threads. They're making my head explode.

They. Are. Insane.

Bubblebubblebah · 27/08/2022 19:24

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:14

Those "central heating is an unnecessary luxury" threads are just competitive Scrooge fests. The house never getting above 9°c? Wearing duvets and 5 pairs of socks? Come off it.

It made me understand why so many houses have mould issues

ReneBumsWombats · 27/08/2022 19:23

5128gap · 27/08/2022 19:22

The advice on S&B threads to 20 something women asking what they should wear to a hen do in a nightclub in a small town North of Watford.

What's the advice? And what 20-somethings are asking Mumsnet for advice on club wear?

ReneBumsWombats · 27/08/2022 19:22

I'm staying off the central heating threads. They're making my head explode.

5128gap · 27/08/2022 19:22

The advice on S&B threads to 20 something women asking what they should wear to a hen do in a nightclub in a small town North of Watford.

Maireas · 27/08/2022 19:14

Those "central heating is an unnecessary luxury" threads are just competitive Scrooge fests. The house never getting above 9°c? Wearing duvets and 5 pairs of socks? Come off it.

TheLostNights · 27/08/2022 19:13

Many on here like to be critical or unkind for the sake of it. Probably to get a power kick.

A580Hojas · 27/08/2022 19:13

SizzlerFizzler · 27/08/2022 14:53

if you're going to post a picture of your fanny I think it only decorous to warn people in the thread title. But I suspect shocking people is the point of some of those threads.

I think Mumsnet should just delete such posts. It's obvious they will attract unwelcome guests. Even if the poster is naieve but entirely genuine. Just don't allow it - not rocket science.

myyellowcar · 27/08/2022 19:08

Oh so much at the moment on money saving threads. Buy an ebike, join the national trust, grow your own fruit and veg, get chickens. It’s almost borderline as to what’s worse, that type of post or the posts that blatently state that central heating is an unnecessary luxury.

The ‘could be my partner be having an affair’ threads. Some of these he obviously is but some could be completely innocent misunderstandings and posters pile on to say he will definitely be guilty.

This sites USP is advice where whatever the situation the OP is at fault; neighbour playing loud music, pissed up your front door and slashed your tyres? You must have done something to upset them, you must be being too loud and they’re drowning out your noise. Maybe they’re stressed out, you should be offering to make them a cup of tea and walk their dog.

x2boys · 27/08/2022 19:08

Lollypop701 · 27/08/2022 18:54

I’m not a step parent but the responses are mad… starting point is the child is always right , the step parent knew what they were getting into aka my dsc is hitting my child and stealing money from piggy bank… response is your child should give dsc money as they are living with their parent and dsc must need money/ step parent should make sure dsc has absolutely everything they want- move out of house every weekend so dsc can spend alone time with parent. There’s always some lovely posts mixed in but the vitriol makes me sad.

Also if you are the step mother you are always in the wrong ,no matter how unreasonable the mother is being, she is a Saint and can never do any wrong .

Lollypop701 · 27/08/2022 18:54

I’m not a step parent but the responses are mad… starting point is the child is always right , the step parent knew what they were getting into aka my dsc is hitting my child and stealing money from piggy bank… response is your child should give dsc money as they are living with their parent and dsc must need money/ step parent should make sure dsc has absolutely everything they want- move out of house every weekend so dsc can spend alone time with parent. There’s always some lovely posts mixed in but the vitriol makes me sad.

MagpiePi · 27/08/2022 18:32

Arbesque · 27/08/2022 16:36

OP: AIBU to think my neighbour is a cf. She regularly parks across my drive, let's her kids trample across my flowerbeds, and yesterday verbally abused me because I asked her not to let her dog shit all over my lawn.

Answerr: She's probably stressed. You should offer to take her kids to the park, and get her shopping in on the way back.

Surely the OP should move house?
😁

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 27/08/2022 18:17

Of course some MN advice will be wrong or bad - MNers are ordinary people, and as fallible as the rest of society. This thread is like saying AIBU to think that some advice given by a stadium full of sports fans, or a concert hall full of gig-goers - or any group of people - may be crap.

When you have a lot of people, giving advice on a large number of widely differing topics, it cannot all be correct, just by the law of averages.

x2boys · 27/08/2022 18:15

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 27/08/2022 18:13

Poster a short while ago about siblings coming to birthday parties, the OP said they couldnt afford more as they were at max budget for the party.

Advice given was for her to hire a minibus to transport only the invited kids to the party, neglecting the fact that would add a small fortune to the budget already

Oh that thread was ridiculous, people were tying themselves in knots about how other parents might not understand, that an invitation for one child means just that.

Allthegoodnamesaregoneffs · 27/08/2022 18:13

Poster a short while ago about siblings coming to birthday parties, the OP said they couldnt afford more as they were at max budget for the party.

Advice given was for her to hire a minibus to transport only the invited kids to the party, neglecting the fact that would add a small fortune to the budget already

x2boys · 27/08/2022 18:12

The men haters can get very extreme, there was a thread a while ago saying ,that if little boys aged four/five only wanted to play with boys they were clearly misogynistic,,never mind that some girls of the same age only want to play with girls of course.

Swipe left for the next trending thread