Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want DH to take this job?

57 replies

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 10:14

We are currently TTC. His current job has excellent paternity leave benefits.

He has been headhunted for a new job which would (a) pay up to triple his current salary and (b) better stimulate him mentally.

We currently earn about the same, but I have zero chance of getting such a high paying role anytime soon (or probably ever!) in my current career.

With the cost of living crisis, it seems a no brainer to take the higher paying job. We are not struggling, but (like pretty much everyone) we need to make cutbacks somewhere. We might never have a baby, so it seems silly for him to hang on in the current job where one of the few benefits is the paternity leave. On the other hand, I know the new job will be less flexible in other non-declared ways (more work expected outside core hours/ less flexibility over when he goes into the office). Again, more of an issue if there is a child.

It might be that the most financially sensible option for us if he takes the new job and we do have a baby would be for me to be a stay at home mum, or at least cut down to part time. I have mixed feelings about this, but I suspect I will feel differently if I’m in the situation with a baby and it feels sensible to have that as an option, so I am not sure why I am so against the new job.

DH is also quite fundamentally against not doing things ourselves (himself!) like having a cleaner/ getting people in for DIY/ sending laundry out, but we would probably be able to compromise on some of these if he does take the job.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dmask · 28/08/2022 08:47

Mosso · 28/08/2022 08:07

I love DH to pieces but no way would I have wanted him home for 6 months. I met loads of friends at baby groups and he would have been sat at home like a spare part.

Tell him to take the job

I think he should take the job, but I disagree with you on the leave. We did shared parental and had a few months of overlap. We both loved it, took trips away etc. he went to baby classes on his own with no bother at all. I don’t think the OP should rule out shared parental leave. You can take a year off between you and with holidays you can make it last longer. I did the first stint, then we did joint leave, then he did three months on his own, then another month joint. It was great and we are both completely equal in terms of parenting now, mental load included. I would highly recommend to anyone!

mjf981 · 28/08/2022 08:31

60 to 180?! That is one hell of leap. Its a no brainer - take the new job.
What does he do?

Mosso · 28/08/2022 08:07

I love DH to pieces but no way would I have wanted him home for 6 months. I met loads of friends at baby groups and he would have been sat at home like a spare part.

Tell him to take the job

Velvian · 28/08/2022 07:46

Have you said that you won't think badly of him if he doesn't take the higher paying job?

Velvian · 28/08/2022 07:44

If you are comfortable financially, I think he should stay in his current job. Work/life balance is incredibly important.

NumberTheory · 28/08/2022 07:39

I like to think it’s less selfish than just me wanting more time with him/more non-financial contribution towards the household, but it’s very hard to be subjective.

I don’t think these concerns are selfish. You’re talking about what sort of life you’ll lead as a couple. This is somewhat fundamental. And he may not have really thought about how, if he isn’t putting as much effort into the relationship, that means either the relationship suffers, or he relies on you to pick up the slack he’s dropped.

But you both also need to consider how much your current financial trajectory will support if you want kids. And whether your relationship would suffer because of money issues (which are one of the biggest causes of marital breakdown).

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 18:11

NumberTheory · 27/08/2022 16:58

I think this bit about work-life balance might be more relevant than paternity leave.

Without being at all jealous you can be concerned about how a much higher paying (higher flying, more all encompassing, higher stress?) job and much bigger pay disparity might impact you as a couple, whether you have kids or not.

Is this, perhaps,, about DH seeming more ambitious now and turning attention towards work that has previously been focused on you and your future together?

I think this is definitely the main factor. I like to think it’s less selfish than just me wanting more time with him/more non-financial contribution towards the household, but it’s very hard to be subjective.

When DH and I first met he was in a very high pressure job at a level where he had very high earning potential but on his junior salary and the extra hours he was working meant he was on practically minimum wage (although a reasonable salary). He made the decision (entirely his own) to move to a role with a much better work-life balance but less career advancement opportunity on the same pay, and consequentially was much happier. I feel like he forgets how tough it was in his previous role BUT this time he will have adequate compensation which will surely make a huge difference.

I really am struggling because he has asked for my opinion, and rationally it sounds like a no-brainer, but I remember how miserable he was in his previous job AND how happy he was when he found out about the paternity policy.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 27/08/2022 16:58

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 12:09

Good to know I was right in thinking IABU.

I’m just so reluctant for him to sacrifice his current work-life balance. And I’m definitely not jealous, but I think I am a bit scared about tipping the balance of our relationship, and worry that I would feel inferior as the significantly lower earning partner. (To note: DH would NEVER make me feel like that, and I would never judge other couples in this way, this is just my own feelings of inferiority.)

I think this bit about work-life balance might be more relevant than paternity leave.

Without being at all jealous you can be concerned about how a much higher paying (higher flying, more all encompassing, higher stress?) job and much bigger pay disparity might impact you as a couple, whether you have kids or not.

Is this, perhaps,, about DH seeming more ambitious now and turning attention towards work that has previously been focused on you and your future together?

Clarinet1 · 27/08/2022 16:48

I think the increase in earnings is so good that he should take the job on the understanding that he frees up quality time for both of you by spending some (probably quite a small amount) of the increase on help around the place. Also, given that it may take a while before you are on maternity leave, perhaps take the opportunity to build up funds for him to take some additional unpaid paternity leave.

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 16:30

Help87 · 27/08/2022 16:22

I thought you had to share anyway? He can only take what you dont?

maternityaction.org.uk/advice/shared-parental-leave-and-pay/

That is shared parental leave - which is great, and should be available in his new role - BUT his current job gives 6 months at full pay, regardless of what the other parent takes. So he could take 3 months at either end whilst I am also on maternity leave.

OP posts:
Help87 · 27/08/2022 16:22

I thought you had to share anyway? He can only take what you dont?

maternityaction.org.uk/advice/shared-parental-leave-and-pay/

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 16:16

wibblywobblybits · 27/08/2022 13:33

Am I missing something?! Unless his current paternity pay is 200% his salary then financially you'd better off if he took the new job regardless of the paternity pay from the old job?

Unless the real question is whether the higher pay is worth the sacrifice in work / life balance? The paternity pay is totally irrelevant

It’s not just the pay, it’s being able to take it. DH can currently take 6 months paternity at full pay, and a potentially negotiable 6 months unpaid. We are fairly confident the potential new job will not give him a year off (paid or unpaid) - although we probably couldn’t afford for us both to take a full year anyway.

OP posts:
WitTanks · 27/08/2022 14:58

I think it's a no brainer to take the job, really

Blossomtoes · 27/08/2022 14:43

LakieLady · 27/08/2022 14:04

If the pay increase is that good, you can use some of it for a doula, a cleaner and anything else that will make your life easier with a newborn!

This. All of them will be more use than he will!

custardbear · 27/08/2022 14:38

In reality it only needs one of you to be home with your baby. It's a good salary hike and you'll need it with family and cost of living going through the roof.
He'll have time with family, just not so much - take good holidays together and enjoy the extra money!

Bobshhh · 27/08/2022 14:27

I mean, we're trying to conceive and I'm currently applying for a job that might add 20% on because I'm worried about the cost of living so you would be insane to turn this down.

Lindy2 · 27/08/2022 14:23

Sorry - it posted too soon.

DH had 2 weeks paternity leave and took 2 weeks paid holiday so had a month off after baby was born.

Although it was nice having him around I honestly couldn't wait for him to go back to work, once the 4 weeks was over, so that I could settle into a proper routine with baby.

He should take the job. 3 x his current salary would be much more worthwhile longer term IMO.

Lindy2 · 27/08/2022 14:21

DH had 2 w

CheshireSplat · 27/08/2022 14:14

Do you know what his new paternity leave entitlement is or is it buried in a policy he hasn't seen yet?

Can he negotiate a decent paternity leave package as part of his package before he accepts the job? It's incredibly important from an equality perspective so these conversations are good for society not just individuals. He could use this to demonstrate that he is keen on inclusion and diversity and may look an even more attractive candidate.

In my experience the more senior someone is, the more flexible they can be. As I became more senior I had no problem nipping off for a couple of hours for sports day, or dentist or physio etc without having to take any annual leave, as I was equally flexible with 7am and evening meetings.

LakieLady · 27/08/2022 14:04

If the pay increase is that good, you can use some of it for a doula, a cleaner and anything else that will make your life easier with a newborn!

faithtrustandpixiedust · 27/08/2022 13:45

I'd also be thinking longer term, if you want to go back to work when you do have children your likely going to need paid childcare at some point, which a higher salary will obviously soften the blow on.

SpongeBob2022 · 27/08/2022 13:36

I would take the job. It's not even a tough decision for me. Paternity leave is so short term.

If/when you have children then do start as you mean to go on. You both need to be happy with/compromise on working arrangements, flexibility, money etc. So don't be pressured into working or not working and make sure things like cleaning are fair (outsourced if necessary).

wibblywobblybits · 27/08/2022 13:34

BuenoSucia · 27/08/2022 10:32

Is this your PFB? In which case - given you’re loaded, you’ll be back here in a year saying you don’t want to go back to work, can’t bear to be parted with wee Artemis and you have no financial worries.

try to look further than 3 week'sPL.

Ew how rude are you!!!!!

NoSquirrels · 27/08/2022 13:33

If he’s bored with work he needs a challenge.

He can always trade back down to his family-friendly job in the future if he hates it and you resist ‘lifestyle creep’ i.e. live well below your means.

Being bored with work is a bad thing. Being able to go to the gym at 5.30 doesn’t make up for feeling unfulfilled.

Encourage him to take it.

wibblywobblybits · 27/08/2022 13:33

Piggieinthemiddle · 27/08/2022 10:14

We are currently TTC. His current job has excellent paternity leave benefits.

He has been headhunted for a new job which would (a) pay up to triple his current salary and (b) better stimulate him mentally.

We currently earn about the same, but I have zero chance of getting such a high paying role anytime soon (or probably ever!) in my current career.

With the cost of living crisis, it seems a no brainer to take the higher paying job. We are not struggling, but (like pretty much everyone) we need to make cutbacks somewhere. We might never have a baby, so it seems silly for him to hang on in the current job where one of the few benefits is the paternity leave. On the other hand, I know the new job will be less flexible in other non-declared ways (more work expected outside core hours/ less flexibility over when he goes into the office). Again, more of an issue if there is a child.

It might be that the most financially sensible option for us if he takes the new job and we do have a baby would be for me to be a stay at home mum, or at least cut down to part time. I have mixed feelings about this, but I suspect I will feel differently if I’m in the situation with a baby and it feels sensible to have that as an option, so I am not sure why I am so against the new job.

DH is also quite fundamentally against not doing things ourselves (himself!) like having a cleaner/ getting people in for DIY/ sending laundry out, but we would probably be able to compromise on some of these if he does take the job.

AIBU?

Am I missing something?! Unless his current paternity pay is 200% his salary then financially you'd better off if he took the new job regardless of the paternity pay from the old job?

Unless the real question is whether the higher pay is worth the sacrifice in work / life balance? The paternity pay is totally irrelevant