Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mums know and understand their children better than anyone else

104 replies

Asaturdayinthe90s · 27/08/2022 08:59

This is true, isn’t it?

It sometimes bugs me, the advice or way of parenting Dh does or the way my mum or sil advises/approaches things

Aibu to think the mother knows and understands her child more than anyone else and knows what they need/what’s best for them?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
londonlass71 · 27/08/2022 21:11

No I think mum's can decide what they feel is best for their kids but I don't think they know them in every single situation all the time.

Annieisalright · 27/08/2022 21:11

Definitely not

So YABU

I think it's fair to say parents know their child's temperament best

But anything further than that is you wanting to sound important

BogRollBOGOF · 27/08/2022 21:11

aloris · 27/08/2022 16:28

I think mothers usually spend more time with their kids than other people, even if the kids are in childcare all day. Also, mothers are usually the primary caregiver in the sense of being the one responsible for managing the childcare, interacting with doctors, teachers etc. So the teacher may see different behavior when the child is at school, but the teacher isn't privy to the child's medical history or details of the family history. The doctor knows the child's medical history but does not know how they are getting on at school because he/she is not interacting in detail with the child's teachers. The mother is usually the person who is being given (and who is mentally collating) all the disparate information from all the people who are providing different aspects of the child's care.

In addition, a big one (I think) is that when the child is sick, it's usually the mother who is caring for him/her. When the child is sick, they get sent home from school so the teacher is not observing their sick behavior. If they see the doctor, he/she will only observe their behavior long enough to make a diagnosis and treat, but will not be around to observe all the other things the child does when sick.

So from all that viewpoint, I think the mother is getting the most complete information.

How mothers use that information is variable. Some mothers are good at using the information and others selectively ignore information they don't want to hear. But I think in most cases (unless the father is the primary caregiver in the family) it's the mother who is the ultimate destination of information about the child. For that reason, although it's fine for in-laws to give input, I think they need to do it with the understanding that the mother will take it under advisement and that the mother does not have an obligation to obey the in-law/ neighbor/ best friend,/random lady on the train who thinks the mother is clearly wrong based on 2 minutes of observation. I know some commenters are saying there are areas where they have seen a mother do something clearly wrong, but sometimes the mother's action is being motivated by specific information not known to an outsider. (That could even be medical information. Recall that if you aren't one of the parents then the parents have no obligation to communicate their child's private medical information to you.)

But I wouldn't say that a mother "knows the child best." I think that comes with unspoken connotations that a mother knows her child better than the child him/herself. That can be used, even by well-meaning, kind mothers, and even unintentionally, to limit the child's potential by essentially creating a self-image that the child cannot (is not allowed to, or is incapable of) step outside the box of the mother's image of that child. When a child is little then a mother has to use her information to fill in the blanks of what the child cannot communicate. But as the child gets older I think it's important for mothers to step back a bit and explicitly acknowledge to the child that they are their own person and get to decide the boundaries of their own potential.

This post sums it up well.

I've worked a lot with children and seen the way they can "switch" their personality in different settings. DS2 does this and his school personality is very different to his home personality. Having helped in school and an extra-curricular, I've seen it in action. I do listen to what other people say about him (them).

I have the opposite issue with DS1 who masks a lot with his autism. Just because he superficially looks like he copes, it doesn't mean that he is actually coping at all. People don't tend to "see" the way his autism affects him unless he knows them very well and he feels free to express himself.

DS2 has had some recent health issues and while his measurements were OK at that point, he was not being his usual Tiggery self and that needed pointing out; that's the level that the expression tends to work on.

Children's personalities get more complex and sophisticated with age. They also get more able to vouch for themselves. Generally mums tend to be the role that has the biggest picture. They also have their own biases and filters too.

noclothesinbed · 27/08/2022 21:09

No. Mums are controlled by emotion. They can't see when the child is playing theM. They can also struggle to be firm and follow through with discipline because they want to pacify and give the child what they want all the time. Child carers who love the child but can also follow through with strict boundaries are best for children because the emotion is not as strong to want to please the child all the time.

oceanbleu · 27/08/2022 20:57

Definitely not. I'm a big believer in toddler DC having as many stable loving people around him. DC is extremely close to his aunt who has taken care of him for us on a childcare basis and sometimes she can know his needs better than me. Also, looking at my mother, as perfectly pleasant our relationship is, I don't believe she ever really understood me. So I disagree.

Atmywitsend29 · 27/08/2022 20:52

I think it depends what it is about.
And very much depends on the mother.
My mother cared very little or knew very little about me.

I know my son incredibly well. Better than I know any other person.
However when it comes to his education, his teacher knows world's more than me. When it comes to serious health issues, a paediatric doctor knows more than me.

SarahAndQuack · 27/08/2022 20:51

Asaturdayinthe90s · 27/08/2022 08:59

This is true, isn’t it?

It sometimes bugs me, the advice or way of parenting Dh does or the way my mum or sil advises/approaches things

Aibu to think the mother knows and understands her child more than anyone else and knows what they need/what’s best for them?

This is why DP and I were buggered from the get-go. Two mums both believing we're right. Grin

To be serious, I think mums are socialised to feel far more guilt about getting things wrong than dads are. And, like it or not, typically, in a heterosexual couple, the mum will be doing more of the care for a small child than the dad, so the mum will inevitably know some things better.

I think it really is just socialisation, though. I don't think being a mum gives you magic knowledge. Equally, though, I dislike the fashion for pretending that caring for a small child is totally trivial and doesn't involve acquiring detailed knowledge about that small child. Of course, someone who has spent hours and hours with a baby will be better able to tell why it's crying than someone who hasn't; someone who has done the morning routine with an eight-year-old every day will be better placed to spot when the child is ill than someone who's only seen them getting ready for the day once in a blue moon.

MajorCarolDanvers · 27/08/2022 20:48

My DH is just as capable a parent as I am.

saraclara · 27/08/2022 20:48

Nope. For as far back as I can remember (so maybe about 3 or 4 years old?) my mum hasn't known or understood me. I sometimes think she barely knows me at all. And I can very clearly remember thinking that when I heard her talking to other people about me as a child. We see what we want to see, often.

And yep, sometimes my late husband was absolutely on the ball about my DC s when I wasn't.

XelaM · 27/08/2022 20:45

Nope. My dad is the best father anyone could ever wish for and A LOT more sensitive and attuned to things than my mum who is a very black/white person. I have a great relationship with both my parents but if I needed to confide in someone or needed help I would always call my dad over my mum. Always

RudsyFarmer · 27/08/2022 20:44

I definitely know my kids better than anyone else because I am heavily involved with them and rarely away from them. Not all mothers are able to be so present though so I wouldn’t say it’s a given.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 27/08/2022 20:39

See this is the kind of thing that made me feel like a useless mother when DC were younger. I couldn't understand their cries. Another asd mum says only she can get her DC to do certain things because she's their mum. Ds' 1-1 is far better than me at getting him to do stuff.

ILoveMonday · 27/08/2022 20:32

Well balanced parents know and understand their children. How many parents project their own issues on to their kids though? I think it might be quite a big number.

WhenWhyHow · 27/08/2022 20:26

Compared to who and what exactly?

A580Hojas · 27/08/2022 20:14

No of course not! There are some people who are not cut out to be mothers. There are terrible mothers out there right now and there have been throughout history. It's a complete nonsense to say mothers always know best. How can you even think this?

AuntieStella · 27/08/2022 20:11

It depends, I think, very much on the age of the child.

I think something would be wring in the family dynamic if the mother and the father (in two parent families) were not the 'experts'

But as they grow, then other influences and confidantes appear, especially during the teenage years.

And I agree with PPs that when issues do arise, the view of the well-acquainted outsider can be more perspicacious than a parent who's in the thick of it

Kite22 · 27/08/2022 20:04

YABU and massively oversimplifying.

Crankley · 27/08/2022 18:18

Except for those who don't.

Redqueenheart · 27/08/2022 18:16

Nope.

My mother was one of these toxic people who should never have been let anywhere near a child, including her own daughter.

dannydyerismydad · 27/08/2022 17:46

I think instinctively we know when our children aren't quite right. But we don't know how to make them better either.

Goldbar · 27/08/2022 17:44

Spikeyball · 27/08/2022 15:23

I don't think knowing your child best and knowing what is best for them are the same thing which is why we listen to the views of professionals when making decisions but there are certainly professionals whose views I respect and take into account of more than others.

I think this too. Knowing your child best doesn't necessarily mean that you are always the best at parenting/caring for them.

For example, I can usually tell why DC is acting in the way that they are acting when misbehaving and generally do believe in behaviour as communication. But my DM has a point that sometimes, no matter how you are feeling, you just have to do as you're told. So it doesn't matter if DC is out-of-sorts, anxious or finding something boring, sometimes they just have to do things anyway. Whereas I probably verge on being too soft sometimes because I understand and like to validate DC's feelings if I can. It's a question of balance, and DC's perfect behaviour at nursery (where the staff are lovely but firm and there are always clear expectations) versus that at home definitely shows that I as DC's mother don't always get it right.

CaptainBarbosa · 27/08/2022 17:40

I know mine, but more along the lines of I know what an absolute sly wind up merchant borderline psychopath he can be, he can charm the birds from a tree.

Despite his angelic blonde curls, surfer tan and bright big blue eyes and dashing looks. He's not the angel everyone perceives him to be 🙄

He's 8, is very good at socially acceptable answers and pulling the wool over teachers eyes.

There was 2 incidents where they wanted to do "restorative practice" with him, said it usually takes up all play time because the children need time to develop mature answers and understand.

I said you can try but I'd just keep him in at play time for the full time as punishment, because all he's going to do is feed you a pack of lies in less than 10 minutes so he can finish, be admired for being a empathetic and forward thinking child and then be let out to play.

Well they went against my advice and then at school pick up said, how marvelous and mature his answers were and he was back outside playing withing 5 minutes....

They did it again on the second one, and it was like the penny dropped. He was lying to them and charming them, they rang me to say they didn't thing "restorative practice was right for him" ....I did try and warm them 🤦🏻‍♀️

He's a swine...he will go far in business though I imagine as a salesman or I'll be stood in the dock in crown court one day saying "yeah he did have that Ted Bundy grace about him growing up your honour" 😳

pd339 · 27/08/2022 17:34

Maybe when they're young, but almost certainly not when they learn to have their own mind!

GazeboLantern · 27/08/2022 17:21

A parent can know their child inside out but they don’t know their child within the context of other children, comparing to the wider population.

Correct.

Sceptre86 · 27/08/2022 17:20

Dh and I are equal in able to recognise what is normal behaviour for our children and what isn't. So for instance we both know that when our 5 year old gets tired he will get ratty and shriek. The difference is that I act before it gets to that stage whereas if we have friends over for example dh won't pop the kids to bed but will carry on enjoying himself. I would arrange for them to come in the afternoon so it wouldn't be an issue.

I'm not sure if I instinctively know better as my dh has always been an equal parent. What I would say is that I work in healthcare and have no qualms in asking for a second opinion or taking the kids back to the doctors for a second or third time whereas dh thinks a drs word is gospel.

I have had instances where my eldest was upset due to teething and my mum wanted to take over and calm her down. I let her have a try because you never know but ultimately she wanted me and I was able to calm her. Sometimes people think because they've had a kid or 4 that makes them a parenting expert, it really doesn't. It shows you can manage yours but all kids are different and involved parents know their own best.