Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder whether a GCSE remark can go down as well as up?

36 replies

WhatIsThisPlease · 27/08/2022 07:30

Sorry, posting here for traffic really.

Has anyone ever had a grade go down after having a paper remarked?

DD was one mark off a grade 7 in combined science and school have said we should get it reviewed/remarked to see if they can find an extra mark.

DD (via the medium of TikTok) has decided there's a chance she could lose marks and end up with a grade 5.

She'd have to lose 17 marks for this to happen.

Has anyone ever experienced this? Is it very likely? Wondering whether to just stick with the 6.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bristolparent123 · 06/09/2022 17:17

I suppose it depends what your kids goals are , for example if they want to study medicine at cardiff then gcse grades are taken into account , ( see below ) if you are 1 mark off an 8 , in this case, then best to go for a remark in my opinion , as you’ll get an extra “point “which may make all the difference if you don’t do so well at a level .

extracted from cardiff university requirements for a specific course

GCSEs

9, 8, A* = 3 points

7, A = 2 points

6, B = 1 point

A-level

A* = 3 points

A = 2 points

The cut-off score for interview varies each year as it will depend on the competitiveness of all the applications.

Degree (minimum GCSE and A-level grades required)

27 points in total

The maximum points you can achieve are 27. The cut-off score for interview varies each year as it will depend on the competitiveness of all the applications

Bristolparent123 · 06/09/2022 16:04

I suppose it depends what your kids goals are , for example if they want to study medicine at cardiff then gcse grades are taken into account , ( see below ) if you are 1 mark off an 8 , in this case, then best to go for a remark in my opinion , as you’ll get an extra “point “which may make all the difference if you don’t do so well at a level .

GCSEs

9, 8, A* = 3 points

7, A = 2 points

6, B = 1 point

A-level

A* = 3 points

A = 2 points

The cut-off score for interview varies each year as it will depend on the competitiveness of all the applications.

Degree (minimum GCSE and A-level grades required)

27 points in total

The maximum points you can achieve are 27. The cut-off score for interview varies each year as it will depend on the competitiveness of all the applications

mushroom3 · 06/09/2022 10:19

Teachers can request to look at the scripts. You should check whether the subject teacher has looked at the scripts. The school has applied for review of marks for one of my son's English Lit and one of his English Lang papers and I think this is on the back of their view of the scripts as they are not doing it for his friend who got the same marks. For my older children a subject went up 2 marks and a grade on a review and we've had 2 no movements. This was before teachers could request and access the scripts for GCSEs.

Frazzled2207 · 27/08/2022 12:46

Theoretically yes but not if she was one mark off a 7

Momo2403 · 27/08/2022 12:44

If it is one mark off the next grade boundary definitely worth putting in for a remark. There is a risk it could go down but it is highly unlikely that it would impact on the grade overall. If you are still worried ask for the paper to be reviewed first. I don’t think the school have an agenda, they will just want the student to get the best grade possible.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 27/08/2022 12:42

balalake · 27/08/2022 12:35

Good that it does not affect A level or other sixth form choices. I'd be concerned at why the school is pushing for this, whether there is some agenda they have.

Well quite. It'll look good on their stats won't it. I imagine they've been through all the papers and made this suggestion to anyone a couple of marks off a grade higher. It's not them having to fork out though is it!

As I said before, if they have what they need then it just seems such a pointless waste of money

balalake · 27/08/2022 12:35

Good that it does not affect A level or other sixth form choices. I'd be concerned at why the school is pushing for this, whether there is some agenda they have.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 27/08/2022 12:21

TwinkleToesStrikesAgain · 27/08/2022 11:56

The subject DS is one mark off an 8 is art which was teacher assessed this year (the exam was removed from the final assessment). Is it still worth asking for a remark? The school hasn't said anything (and I'm assuming it's closed now until term restarts - DS will be going to a different college for 6th form).

Not an art teacher but I would think, based on how it was done in our school, that the art portfolios would have been marked by the teacher and then moderated by the exam board. Generally, if a teacher wants to appeal an NEA mark, they have to appeal the whole cohort, not just individual students, and to do that they have to get permission from each individual. Moreover, the teacher is only likely to want to appeal if their marks were adjusted down by the moderator - was that the case?

In my subject, for example, the NEA was marked by class teachers, moderated by the department and our marks upheld by the board. So I am not going to appeal them as I would be saying that I wanted to appeal my own marking and the moderation process we did as a department, believing it to be wrong despite the board upholding it, which would be ridiculous!

When we mark the coursework, we have no idea what the final grade boundaries will be - it’s just bad luck that your DS’s portfolio ended up being on the wrong side of the 8 but his art teacher would have had no knowledge of that when marking it.

TwinkleToesStrikesAgain · 27/08/2022 11:56

The subject DS is one mark off an 8 is art which was teacher assessed this year (the exam was removed from the final assessment). Is it still worth asking for a remark? The school hasn't said anything (and I'm assuming it's closed now until term restarts - DS will be going to a different college for 6th form).

WhatIsThisPlease · 27/08/2022 11:56

Thanks everyone for all the replies.

I was of the "what have you got to lose" attitude and was very much prepared to send it back. But some of these stories have put me off and now I'm wondering whether to bother. She doesn't need a 7, we just thought it would be nice to go from 6/6 to potentially 7/7.

It's school who are pushing for the remark. We didn't even know what her mark was until her teacher rang and told her. She wishes he hadn't bothered!!

OP posts:
Addicted2LuvIsland · 27/08/2022 11:37

Or she could just accept her mark. Somes you win sometimes you lose, even if it is by a small amount. I wouldn't be too worried about GCSE's. A levels yes - esp if there was a conditional offer.

BadGranny · 27/08/2022 11:27

As long as the grade isn’t essential to progress to A level, I suggest you give your DC the £40 or so that a review of marking would cost, and give them the choice to pay for a review or use the money for something else.

Pantoufle23 · 27/08/2022 11:25

Sorry meant to add, i think the teacher can look at papers first to decide if any worth remarking? Though of course I realise that’s additional work for them.

Pantoufle23 · 27/08/2022 11:23

Also wondering - 1 mark off a 9 in Maths. 28 marks to lower grade boundary. Doesn’t need a 9 but obviously she’d like one given how close it is. Not yet asked school but they haven’t mentioned it. Thoughts?

VBF · 27/08/2022 10:21

Techer here- it can and does go down. A remark just sends the whole paper to be double checked but I have seen it go down more or stay more times than go up. If she doesn't need the next grade I would leave it, if she does I would risk it. Unlikely to drop to a 5 but I have seen people go down a grade, more often it is only a few marks but I advise all mine (maybe wrongly) if you have the grade you want and you need for the next step in journey then don't worry too much.

VerifiedBot2351 · 27/08/2022 10:15

Yes it can. We sent a paper back for re-marking a few years ago. The student was expecting to get a six, and had got a five. The re-mark came back at a four.

denvi · 27/08/2022 10:07

Definitely put in for a remark if they are only one mark off the next grade. It may well go up. Highly unlikely it will go down 17 marks! What do you have to lose?

caringcarer · 27/08/2022 10:02

I used to advise my students if they were within 3 marks of a higher grade boundary it was worth a remark. About 35 percent went up. None went down a grade although an odd script went down 1 or 2 marks but kept same grade

TwinkleToesStrikesAgain · 27/08/2022 09:58

Do you need to push for this as the parent or does the school do it? DS is one mark off an 8 doesn't need at 8 in this subject and he doesn't want to ask for a review (he's pissed that someone might think that a 7 isn't good enough).

I don't want to be that parent who won't accept their kid's ability.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 27/08/2022 08:53

It is worth asking for a review of the marking although they won’t be looking to ‘find an extra mark’. If the review determines that the original examiner applied the mark scheme incorrectly, the marks will be changed (either up or down). The best chance of getting the extra mark in a science subject is if the review finds that the original examiner marked a question incorrectly (so say DD put ‘heart’ which was the correct answer but the examiner marked is as incorrect in error).But if Examiner Smith gave a long essay-type answer 17/20 and Examiner Jones would have given it 18/20 as a matter of subjective opinion, the mark won’t change because the original examiner was within tolerance.

sparepantsandtoothbrush · 27/08/2022 08:35

Does she need a 7 for any particular reason? The only circumstances I'd bother getting a remark is if they were a few marks off a grade they actually needed to move on to post-gcse courses

Walkley18 · 27/08/2022 08:29

Yes. My daughter's gcse double science, 4 marks off a pass, which would have meant two extra gcses (year pre covid), re-marked, went down by 5 or so marks, felt even more rubbish.

lanthanum · 27/08/2022 08:25

Undertheoldlindentree · 27/08/2022 07:49

This is interesting, I'm sure when the arrangements for the 2022 exams were published there was something to say anyone so close to a grade boundary would be lifted to the next grade.

But in that case, the grade boundary would effectively have been reduced by 1.

PupInAPram · 27/08/2022 08:25

Undertheoldlindentree · 27/08/2022 07:49

This is interesting, I'm sure when the arrangements for the 2022 exams were published there was something to say anyone so close to a grade boundary would be lifted to the next grade.

No, there wasn't. Could you have misunderstood?

yotyot · 27/08/2022 08:23

Your daughter can first request copies of her exam scripts via school. She can show them to her teacher who would advise whether it is worth getting a review of marking or whether there is any risk involved. Copies of scripts are free from AQA and Pearson (although the school might charge a small admin fee).