Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A money one. Advice needed.

67 replies

Montasaurus · 26/08/2022 22:05

A few months ago I came into a significant sum of money. Enough to change mine and my DH’s life and help others too.

No one other than my DH knows about this and he has no immediate family. I have decided I am going to gift my siblings an amount each but my dilemma is this…

My parents. Backstory is they are extremely grabby/some may say greedy. Neither have any friends/family relationships outside of our immediate sibling family due to this. They are well off - multiple homes etc but are very odd with money - say things like ‘oh everything should be fair’ but act the complete opposite. An example of this is my mum’s dad died ten years ago, all of us grandkids were left a sum of money each and I have never received mine - told I would waste it (I am 44 with a career, mortgage etc that I have done by myself).

My question is… what do I do? If I don’t gift them anything, all hell will break loose. A part of me wants to ask them for the inheritance/other things nicely one last time to see if anything changes/test them and then decide. As I say, no one in my family knows about this money I have come into and my parents would only need the money to say buy another holiday or property.

AIBU?

YANBU - gift them nothing.
YABU - they are still your parents. Help them.

OP posts:
Aubree17 · 27/08/2022 13:37

Ask your parents what happened to your share of the money. I'm so shocked at this.

I'm Guessing your siblings need the help and your parents don't. You don't need a justification for giving a gift but if your looking for one there it is.

Augend23 · 27/08/2022 13:33

Sswhinesthebest · 27/08/2022 09:50

Love the idea for the nephews and nieces.

But really unless it’s multi millions you’d be better off investing it and then using the passive income to pay into a fund for them. Don’t deplete your lump sum. Use that to generate an income. I’d see a financial adviser if I were you.

This sounds like a good idea to me.

I always have mixed feelings about the age at which money should come out of trust.

I think if it can be used for something sensible before 25 then it's fine but e.g. I was a very sensible/overly frugsl teen and saved and saved so had enough (with some money from my grandparents on top) for a deposit at 22. If I hadn't been able to use it til I was 25 I would have been paying rent unnecessarily for an extra 3 years.

But I do also see the worry about them not being sensible with it!

SilverDragonfly1 · 27/08/2022 13:16

Put whatever you might have given your parents into savings as their will may well also not be fair, even if you do give it to them. Doesn't sound like they'd think twice about leaving one or more children or grandchildren out if they felt like it on the day they made the will...

HannahSternDefoe · 27/08/2022 12:49

Siblings are a mixed bunch but will say something. No secrets in our family remain that way for long.

For this reason alone, I would give them nothing. You can't trust them not to tell your parents.
You can leave each of your DNs a sum in your wills.
Please get professional financial and legal advice before you do anything.

SquishyGloopyBum · 27/08/2022 12:43

I would invest that money in getting counselling op. It's all kinds of wrong that you are even considering giving your parents money given how they treat you.

I would also get legal advice about the will. Your father isn't legally allowed to withhold it.

Sswhinesthebest · 27/08/2022 09:50

Love the idea for the nephews and nieces.

But really unless it’s multi millions you’d be better off investing it and then using the passive income to pay into a fund for them. Don’t deplete your lump sum. Use that to generate an income. I’d see a financial adviser if I were you.

Houseplantmad · 27/08/2022 09:39

crystalls · 26/08/2022 22:45

If i came into a significant amount of money suddenly. I would only gift to those who i know would do the same for me. If you was owed inheritance and refused it by these people then why should they get money from you?

This ^

ninjafoodienovice · 27/08/2022 09:37

The trust for your nieces and nephews sounds like a great plan but word of caution - please don't let them have it when they are 18. I would say 25 is a much better age. Money too young can be a recipe for disaster.
I'm sorry your family is so toxic

Montasaurus · 27/08/2022 09:14

@RandomMess you have hit the nail on the head here. Toxic is our middle name! Competitive, infighting etc etc.

Great idea about nieces and nephews. I have five of them - love them dearly, even though their parents can be difficult. I’ll have a look into a trust, brilliant idea and far better for everyone. I could then keep it secret until their are 18/21/25?

OP posts:
rumred · 27/08/2022 09:12

Give some to charity as their contribution. They don't need it, lots of people and animals do however.

AhNowTed · 27/08/2022 08:48

It would need to be Euromillions type money before I'd considered giving large chunks of it away.

And then only to those I'd be confident would reciprocate.

cabansunset · 27/08/2022 08:42

Quite honestly I wouldn't give any of your family anything.
Your siblings stood by and witnessed you not getting your inheritance from your grandparents while accepting theirs.
Nah...not nice.

Daisy95 · 27/08/2022 08:37

Have you actually come into enough money to help your siblings?
Mortgage paid off, pensions topped up so can retire at 55, decent savings pot, do you have/want children (school funds), money for holidays/new cars for your lifetime?
I definitely wouldn't be helping my parents out especially if they have multiple properties.

honkeytonkwoman38 · 27/08/2022 08:37

I'm not sure why it's even a dilemma. They wouldn't get a penny off me!

Sarahcoggles · 27/08/2022 08:37

Do your siblings need the money? It sounds as if you're all quite rich.
I wouldn't give any to your parents, especially as they're breaking the law by not releasing your share of the other inheritance (I wouldn't let that lie by the way). And if your siblings can't be trusted to keep quiet, I wouldn't give them any either. I'd keep some and give some to charity.

RandomMess · 27/08/2022 08:32

You could set up a trust fund to benefit all your nieces and nephews in the future - perhaps you could have a property portfolio or similar? It's a way of skipping your siblings but future generations benefit.

RandomMess · 27/08/2022 08:31

Your mother was vile towards her IL then keep the money yourself and honour your grandfather's wishes.

Your mother can reap what she sows.

It sounds like you have a toxic nuclear family and you will be damned by all of them no matter what you do.

Verbena1 · 27/08/2022 07:26

Possibly impractical, but could you give the money to your siblings anonymously, eg through a solicitor? You could honestly say you had received money too. Obviously you shouldn’t give your parents anything.

FollowYourOwnNorthStar · 27/08/2022 07:24

If I woke up in your shoes, and was facing this issue I would use the money to do the following, in order:

  1. use the money to secure my and DH’s future - all debts paid off, mortgage paid off, pensions topped up, 6 month emergency fund filled, both of us financially able to retire between 50-55 (if wanted), or to cut down to part-time days or a less well-paying job from 45- onwards, to enjoy a more balanced lifestyle. This also includes replacing any old fixtures/fittings in the home that would need replacing before retirement - new boiler, solar panels, new cars, energy efficient appliances etc etc.

  2. use the money to secure my children’s futures. Education (school and university) paid for, generous house deposit for each one. Before I gave any away, I would want to make sure I was giving 50% house deposits to my children.

Achieving both these things shouldn’t look ‘flashy’ to outsiders. Doing them is good financial sense and if you are careful about it, no one would know you had come into money. Even your children - the money to them should come with strong financial lessons about saving to match the value of the deposit handed over and not needing a job at uni, therefore your ‘job’ is studying and getting better grades etc.

  1. Now I would set aside enough for 2 family holidays each year. One big, one smaller

  2. Then money in investments creating a second passive income, so not just wages.

  3. Now I would consider helping family/friends. But how much is realistically left? I’d think about it, and wait until there is a need and then step in. Perhaps give all nieces and nephews £2000 on their 18th birthday towards driving lessons or uni costs. Perhaps the same as a lump sum to a family member (incl parents) on a significant birthday (50th, 75th etc).

But I wouldn’t tell anyone where you got the money.

No amount you give them would be enough, they would always want more and be annoyed at you for it.

Montasaurus · 27/08/2022 07:02

Sorry in my original post - it was dad’s dad that died and left the money. Sorry to confuse.

OP posts:
Montasaurus · 27/08/2022 07:00

Father was executor of the grandfathers wishes. My grandmother is still alive but very elderly.

Money given to father but kept.

There is a long history here - and I don’t want it to be too outing. Basically we haven’t spent much time with that side of the family due to my mothers behaviour towards her ILs, not until we were adults and it was too late. The idea that DM now is spending their money after spending the last 30 odd years saying awful things about them and trying to get us (her children) to hate them is beyond the pale.

Siblings are a mixed bunch but will say something. No secrets in our family remain that way for long.

OP posts:
Danikm151 · 27/08/2022 03:56

Anonymous donation to siblings?
tell your parents you came into a little windfall and take them for dinner? They still got something then

bridgetreilly · 27/08/2022 03:45

all of us grandkids were left a sum of money each and I have never received mine - told I would waste it

Who was the executor? Because this is illegal.

I would not be giving parents anything in these circumstances and if they complain, explain that you were going to give them £xxx but that cancelled out what they owed you from your grandfather’s will, so you saved them the trouble.

Catmummyof2 · 27/08/2022 01:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

buckeejit · 27/08/2022 00:59

Agree to give them nothing. They don't need it. Be canny with gifts iro tax. I might be swayed to gift siblings if they keep it from parents. They sound hard work.