Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Liz Truss as PM will mean a Labour government?

259 replies

VicToryA · 26/08/2022 20:13

I am no fan of this so-called Conservative government (thanks to Brexit and lockdowns, both of which I detest). So I suppose I'm a lifelong centre-ish Conservative with a desire not to have a bunch of loony lefties in control, but with no real political home at the moment.

Given a choice between Truss and Sunak, I would have to choose Sunak. I know, though, that it will end up with Truss as PM.

AIBU to think this will mean a Labour government and years in the political wilderness for the Conservative party?

OP posts:
luckylavender · 27/08/2022 08:42

Bollindger · 26/08/2022 20:38

Have you read the news reports?
Even main stream news think KS is a joke and Labour are AWOL as a party.
No policys people can get behind, no leader and no way forward.
If JC failed to win with all his support, unless a miracle happens It will be Tory.
Also Labour's always offered tax cuts and extra money, oh yes the Torys will be doing that.. on top of that no Labour Govenment has ever got into power when the UK is in crisis. Plus they don't really get 2nd terms.

Have you looked at the Polls? Starmer miles ahead. And the media you quote is the right wing media. Balance is everything.

Alexandra2001 · 27/08/2022 08:41

Bollindger · 27/08/2022 08:38

Well I think it is even funnier that you think that wishful thinking will get a Labour victory.
Mumsnet is very liberal in views and so out of touch with reality politically speaking. BINO was so funny as a thread, there were about 5 of us that could see the future and they were trying to put the people that disagreed down just like on this thread. How did that go for you?

A 15pt lead, as we go into at the very least a recession, is grounds to believe, that after 12 years of doing (and i quote) "Bugger all", this very damaging self serving govt is on its way out.

But a week is a long time in politics.

luckylavender · 27/08/2022 08:41

Malie · 26/08/2022 20:29

Sadly however bad this government appears, is the opposition gets in, things will degenerate.

Based on what? That's a straight out of the Daily Mail comment if ever I saw one.

Alexandra2001 · 27/08/2022 08:38

Please name one policy that the Labour Party are advocating that is 'loony'?

Lisa Nandy thinks that it's right that child rapists can be incarcerated within women's prisons. Granted, the law that allowed it to happen was passed under the May government but at least her successors have started to backpedal, rather than pushing on

So Nandy's private musings but a Tory legislated policy.

The Tories back pedalling (if they have) hasn't actually changed the law.... so we have the far right blaming Labour for a Tory policy introduced 5 years ago and showing no sign of being changed by a tory Govt and thats the best you can find for a "loony left" policy... laughable.

All Govts would have supported Ukraine and try to remember that for 11 years prior to Putins invasion, the Tories refused point blank to sell or supply any weapons to Ukraine.

Johnson saw an opportunity and went hell for leather for it, fortunately it was also the right thing to do but he didn't do it for because of that.

Bollindger · 27/08/2022 08:38

Well I think it is even funnier that you think that wishful thinking will get a Labour victory.
Mumsnet is very liberal in views and so out of touch with reality politically speaking. BINO was so funny as a thread, there were about 5 of us that could see the future and they were trying to put the people that disagreed down just like on this thread. How did that go for you?

basilmint · 27/08/2022 08:32

It will depend on how Truss manages, and that may depend on who she has around her.

Given that the list of potential Truss cabinet members contained names such as John Redwood, Ian Duncan-Smith and Suella Braverman I wouldn't hold out much hope. It was suggested she might put Kemi Badenoch in education, who suggested schools should save money by not offering extra-curricular activities and cutting non-existent support staff. She has her hands tied by needing to stuff the cabinet with Brexit supporters because this is supposedly all that matters, even though Brexit is apparently "done". Perhaps they will advise her to carry on suggesting that the President of France is an enemy as she did in a recent hustings. As Foreign Secretary she really has got the hang of this diplomacy thing so that bodes well for her as PM.

brianixon · 27/08/2022 08:26

Before we get to a GE in 2024 we shall have turmoil within the Party. Different factions will form power blocks and try to push separate policies. ERG for one.
Longer established MPs with some Remain sympathies for another.
It will be hell.
Meanwhile Labour have to agree a convincing manifesto. Not rehash the old one.
It won't be peace and love on that side of the house either.

Endlesssummer2022 · 27/08/2022 08:23

Boy Tory HQ is going into meltdown this morning. Genuinely laughed out loud reading Bollidgers increasingly desperate ranting to try and convince us all that Labour are unelectable.

This thread appears to be designed to dishearten potential/swing voters. If Labour is starting to climb in the polls, the Tory’s have to mount a multifaceted campaign to sow doubt and limit this because once voters think Labour has a strong chance they will want to be on the ‘winning team’.

balalake · 27/08/2022 08:04

The people of the United Kingdom, or at least enough of them, can be taken in by a 'red scare' or the idea that the SNP will hold the balance of power and dictate terms, or any one of a number of other strange notions. So whilst I have no expectation of an 80 seat Tory majority again, not banking on a Labour government or even the Tories not being the largest party again.

Other things to bear in mind are the plans for ID when voting, and some Tory voters may just not vote, instead of voting for someone else.

Endlesssummer2022 · 27/08/2022 07:52

This government isn’t Conservative its UKIP in all but name. Farage has crowed that many of his supporters joined the Conservatives to get this exact result. Now we are all suffering under an ultra libertarian Darwinian fantasy government. We are all fucked until they are removed.

AlecTrevelyan006 · 27/08/2022 07:51

I’m not a Tory voter but even trying to be objective I don’t think it matters now whether Truss or Sunak is the PM. The best case scenario for this over the next couple of years is that things will be a bit shit. The most likely scenario is that things will be very shit.

so by the time of next general election, people will simply want to try something different. As long as Labour don’t do anything monumentally stupid they should end up either in power or at least the largest party - I think a Lab / Lib Dem coalition is a possibility

malificent7 · 27/08/2022 07:50

I think Kier Starmer seems like an intelligent, level headed man. The media is mostly Tory isn't it? Hence no labour leader will be seen in a good light.

Dragonsmother · 27/08/2022 07:48

None of the current political parties are fit for purpose.
We are in this mess under a TORY party.

I blame stupid media like Daily Mail for false stories, misinformation and stirring up shit storms.

Sack the lot of them. We need a coalition govt to get us through this mess.

Bollindger · 27/08/2022 07:34

Can we think of some policys Labour can adopt.
Park and ride for hospitals, valet parking if your disabled, free bus service and staff parking area, then they build on the hospital parking areas flats to house hospital staff.

Bollindger · 27/08/2022 07:24

I don't think the Energy Crisis is a good policy to base an Election on.
Putin is not going to win his war, and once he goes, Energy Prices should drop more.
The new PM will have to help people Now, not in 3 years time and won't just grandstand, but actually have the power to do something.
Traditionally Labour gives away things look at how Tax Credits and Children's Credits increased so more babies meant more money if you were Unemployed. That untill the rent cap people were being give money to rent massions.
The Torys want to make work pay more, than benefits.

Malie · 27/08/2022 07:20

It’s very funny when you comment how useless this opposition has been - and anyone with an IQ of over 35 can see that surely - and someone calls you a ‘Tory boot licker’. What planet are these people on? 😀

Nat6999 · 27/08/2022 03:10

Looking at the videos of Keir Starmer speaking in the last couple of days about the energy crisis, he has changed. He is now speaking like a Prime Minister, he is speaking with more authority & confidence, I don't know if he has had some kind of training but he is speaking much better & the way he is speaking instills more confidence. The priorities he is saying about the energy crisis say more than anything the Tories aren't saying because let's face it we haven't heard anything but hot air from them.

Teddeh · 27/08/2022 02:41

If you're saying the next election will be decided based on which specific person is leader of the Conservative Party - e.g., Sunak would win but Truss would lose - I think you're oversimplifying a very complex situation. People may be catastrophising now, but it's not hard to imagine Liz Truss (or Rishi Sunak) as PM once that person already IS PM.

Labour need to focus on WINNING a majority of seats in a general election (or at least more seats than the Conservatives) by getting voters to vote for them, not just hoping their opponents lose their majority because voters turn against them.

CactusBlossom · 27/08/2022 02:06

The Tories have done more than enough damage.

Video example

They deserve to be out of power.

TenRedThings · 27/08/2022 02:01

This Tory governments policies only make sense if you understand that the aim is to destroy Britain as we know it and loot any remaining public assets whilst everyone is reeling from the economic mayhem they've instigated.

MarshaBradyo · 27/08/2022 01:53

I don’t know, people on both sides seem very certain they will win

I wouldn’t call it yet, a lot depends on external factors - ie Ukraine war

StoneofDestiny · 27/08/2022 01:46

I think that's almost impossible to come back from, many people would prefer to vote for someone they think is a liar or even incompetent than someone they think despises them

If that was true we will never have another Tory Government again. Or do you really thing Rees Mogg, Liz Truss, Boris Johnson, Sunak and Patel give a shit about working class people? You do realise they are trying to make it illegal to protest, strike etc...........

StoneofDestiny · 27/08/2022 01:40

but you need to ask yourself what have Labour done for this country? Ever? Erm, that would be nothing

oh dear. Extreme ignorance. No wonder we get Tory Governments like this shower

To name a few things achieved by Labour Governments:
Council Housing
Social Security
NHS
Public ownership of key industries
Decriminalisation of Homosexuality
Ending the Death Penalty
Outlawing Racial Discrimination
Equal Pay Act
National Minimum Wage
Good Friday Agreement
The Open University
Civil Partnerships
Equality Act
Human Rights Act
Climate Change Act
Cancelling Debt of Poorest Countries

Look at how many have been driven to braking point by Tory Governments. Look at our NHS. Look at how The Good Friday Agreement is in a perilous state because of Johnson's betrayal and deceit. Ever tried to get a Council House?

MangyInseam · 27/08/2022 01:19

NotABeliever · 26/08/2022 22:11

@User135644 I agree that Brexit was a huge factor in 2019 and gave the Tories the landslide.
But the working class still vote Tory because it's aspirational - thought of course they're unaware of being targeted by the right wing media.
Add to that, Keir Starmer not being a particularly charismatic leader and the distrust with Labour's front bench especially because of "I'm afraid there is no money" DM headlne from 2010.

I wouldn't underestimate the fact that the working classes know that most of the LP despises them and thinks they are embarrassing.

I think that's almost impossible to come back from, many people would prefer to vote for someone they think is a liar or even incompetent than someone they think despises them.

MangyInseam · 27/08/2022 01:03

I think it's much too soon to tell. It will depend on how Truss manages, and that may depend on who she has around her.

And somewhat on luck as well, what happens in the world in the next two years.

But it also will depend on what the Labour Party does. They don't seem to have any intent of showing the voters any respect.

Truss certainly doesn't have the charisma of Boris, so she will be on more of an even platform with Starmer in that area.