Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours homeschooled kids play out ALL day. AIBU?

266 replies

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 19:26

Long time lurker, first time poster. Looking for a bit of advice if possible.

We live in terraced housing in a family area, so since Summer holidays started most of our neighbours kids have been out playing in their gardens during the day, which is absolutely fine, it's Summer holidays so that's to be expected. But even when the new term starts next week, the children who live next door to us will STILL be playing out.

The family moved here in March(?), they have 2 children who I assumed weren't old enough for school yet, but in a recent chat with the parents we found out they are, in fact, homeschooled.

They're out in the garden from about 10am-8pm every single day. They're not the type of children who scream and shriek, which I appreciate, but it's the constant chattering/playing noises for 10 hours every day, and not having a moments peace in my own garden (or when my windows are open, for that matter!). They have breaks in-between, which I assume is for food, but then come straight back out again. This has been ongoing since the day they moved in.

It's the fact that this is going to be an all-year round thing, not just school breaks/holidays that's bothering me. I understand they are entitled to use their garden as they please, but aren't we (and the rest of our neighbours) entitled to some peace every now and then?

We're not particularly familiar with the parents, we've only chatted with them in passing a handful of times, so my husband and I haven't raised this with them. And we don't know if this is even an issue we're entitled to raise.

If we did mention this to them, what could we say without coming across as offensive to their kids?

OP posts:
JamesWebb · 26/08/2022 21:21

OP, are they really, really in their garden for 10+ hours a day, 7 days a week? Because that’s actually quite amazing, I wish my young children could amuse themselves for that long together outside every single day, and I bet a great many of us would love to know what their parents secret is - especially if they are just chatting and playing rather than shrieking and yelling. What are they actually doing? Playing make believe games? Sports? Climbing trees or on play equipment?

Namenic · 26/08/2022 21:21

@wherearebeefandonioncrisps - I’m pretty sure private schools and academies don’t have to follow the national curriculum. At the ages of 5 and 7, playing all day seems fine. The amount of time you need to spend in dedicated ‘learning’ is quite small with homeschooling compared to school because you can personalise what kids learn (to whatever level they are at - rather than a class of 30). Plus - some homeschoolers will have a philosophy of learning through play.

onlythreenow · 26/08/2022 21:21

You are unbelievable OP. I had three children living next to me for years, and I loved hearing them outside and often told people how nice it was to hear them playing outside instead of being on screens all day. They swam in their pool, kicked rugby balls (sometimes hitting my fence) and climbed trees (and sometimes onto my garage roof). Admittedly they weren't home schooled, but they were outside after school - even in winter when it was dark - and all through the holidays. The family also had a dog which barked whenever I went outside. They are grown now, and the oldest one sometimes has parties with loud music. Not once have I felt the need to complain, and it certainly didn't stop me enjoying my garden.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 21:20

Not your business.
You want silence, move far far away from everyone else.

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:20

PestoPasghetti · 26/08/2022 20:56

I find it very hard to believe home schooled children are at home all day every day. Surely they go on days out, or even just to local playgrounds/round to friend's houses/on walks/to the supermarket/to the library?

I don't know, I don't track their every movement, but with how long and how often I hear them for I can't imagine they go out very much. But I'm fully aware that's none of my business.

OP posts:
ddl1 · 26/08/2022 21:20

If they were being super-noisy and shrieking all the time, I could see your point. But just playing and chatting is what children do. You don't have a right to absolute silence even if you would find it more comfortable.

Also, even though they are homeschooled, they may to some extent keep the same holidays as other children, and may spend more time indoors and/or on educational activities away from home after term starts. And as weather becomes more autumnal and it gets dark earlier, they will naturally reduce their time outdoors. And you will presumably have fewer open windows when it's not summertime (and an unusual heatwave).

You could use noise-cancelling headphones?

Luredbyapomegranate · 26/08/2022 21:19

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:14

Right. So do I. But not for 10 hours a day everyday for the past 6 months and indefinitely. You can act as self-righteous as you like, but it definitely would bother you. Hearing the sound of anyone, child OR adult, for 10 hours a day would annoy any normal person. I don't believe anyone saying it wouldn't.

Many people would find it annoying, but so is the traffic outside my house.

It’s not an excuse to pretend you are worried about their education and call the council, not that that would work,

Seriously buy some earplugs. The foam ones. From Boots.

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/08/2022 21:18

You've got two choices really.

Go round and ask if they can keep the kids indoors a bit more so you get some quiet garden time - you risk looking like an arsehole, and probably your neighbours won't be taking in any parcels for you from now on.

Or, you can just STFU, ignore them, go sit in your garden, do what you like and leave them alone.

Thats it, take your pick.

They're living their lives and doing nothing wrong so, make yourself unpopular or don't.

You could live next door to me - my dogs are in and out all day, they bark at shit going by, yell at pigeons and squirrels sometimes - if they're not out there are 10 zillion small birds whizzing around and arguing over the bird feeder which, even though its my bird feeder, gets on my tits somedays (I had a bad day earlier in summer with tooth ache and I yelled at a family of Great Tits - BIRD MOMMA, YOUR CHILDREN ARE FUCKING ANNOYING, SHUTTUP..., which worked, birds don't argue back)... I have my doors open, I listen to music, you probably wouldn't like that either.

And all of that is also normal, and not a noise nuisance. Just life.

LondonWolf · 26/08/2022 21:17

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:09

I'm a bit perturbed by some of the responses on here.
All school aged children must have access to the National Curriculum.
Playing in the garden all day and every day is not acceptable.
I appreciate that it's still the summer holiday in England but homeschooling is not an excuse to let children play all day.
A dear friend of mine homeschools and must provide evidence and must adhere to certain rules.

If school aged children are not not at school , during term time and are playing in the garden for 10 hours a day then the LEA would be very interested.

Pretty much everything you said is wrong.

bellac11 · 26/08/2022 21:17

Home educators do not have to provide proof of anything. They can choose not to engage with the home checks (although as others have pointed out that appears to have been scaled back to nothing or a phone call if you're lucky)

LondonWolf · 26/08/2022 21:16

The legal obligation on the LA is once a year but it wouldnt surprise me that children havent been seen or heard of for years now.

When "statements" were transferring to EHCP, my local authority "lost" DS for four years. Till that point I always did the visits and annual meets because I found it easier to do so and have proof of engagement for future reference. I decided to wait and see how long before we heard from them. After four years we got the standard letter inviting us to apply for secondary as ds was leaving primary...he was 15 by then. Then there was a big flurry of trying to pretend they'd never lost him. Ridiculous carry on.

FarmerRefuted · 26/08/2022 21:16

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:14

Right. So do I. But not for 10 hours a day everyday for the past 6 months and indefinitely. You can act as self-righteous as you like, but it definitely would bother you. Hearing the sound of anyone, child OR adult, for 10 hours a day would annoy any normal person. I don't believe anyone saying it wouldn't.

You don't have any recourse to complain though. It's not classed as noise nuisance or antisocial, it's part and parcel of communal living so your options boil down to 1, suck it up or 2, move.

Gagaandgag · 26/08/2022 21:15

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:09

I'm a bit perturbed by some of the responses on here.
All school aged children must have access to the National Curriculum.
Playing in the garden all day and every day is not acceptable.
I appreciate that it's still the summer holiday in England but homeschooling is not an excuse to let children play all day.
A dear friend of mine homeschools and must provide evidence and must adhere to certain rules.

If school aged children are not not at school , during term time and are playing in the garden for 10 hours a day then the LEA would be very interested.

Hi sorry but you are actually wrong.

Parents have no obligation to use the National curriculum at all!

She has literally no idea what education the family are providing. There are so many ways to learn other than the standard

And I was a primary school teacher before I home educated my own children!

FarmerRefuted · 26/08/2022 21:14

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:09

I'm a bit perturbed by some of the responses on here.
All school aged children must have access to the National Curriculum.
Playing in the garden all day and every day is not acceptable.
I appreciate that it's still the summer holiday in England but homeschooling is not an excuse to let children play all day.
A dear friend of mine homeschools and must provide evidence and must adhere to certain rules.

If school aged children are not not at school , during term time and are playing in the garden for 10 hours a day then the LEA would be very interested.

Home educators don't have to follow the national curriculum, they have to provide "an education" but it doesn't have to be one mandated in the NC.

And as per my earlier post, when you strip out all of the faffing about and the maneuvering involved with marshaling 30+ children around, it is very easy to condense the actual education portion of the school day into a very short period.

During lockdown my DC did the full range of school work on offer and still were only sat at thr table doing lessons for around 2-3 hours a day maximum.

SillySausage81 · 26/08/2022 21:14

Angelinflipflops · 26/08/2022 20:45

So you're at home all day but don't want them to be? Could you go to work?

Good question!

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:14

Rocketpants50 · 26/08/2022 21:08

My goodness how wonderful, children playing, that's exactly what they should be doing. I absolutely love hearing all the children playing in their gardens.

Right. So do I. But not for 10 hours a day everyday for the past 6 months and indefinitely. You can act as self-righteous as you like, but it definitely would bother you. Hearing the sound of anyone, child OR adult, for 10 hours a day would annoy any normal person. I don't believe anyone saying it wouldn't.

OP posts:
Namenic · 26/08/2022 21:13

OP - I think you’re being unreasonable. Yes - you may not like the sound of them chatting - but it’s part of living in A terraced property. It’s like the constant traffic noises if you are near a road or whatever. traffic may increase over time, unanticipated. Personally I see these noises as part of living in a city/town. If people want somewhere quiet - maybe a rural location is better?

LondonWolf · 26/08/2022 21:10

The local home ed officer can ask for an annual report. Assuming the children are old enough.

And the parents don't have to give one.

You sound like a right misery OP.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 26/08/2022 21:10

A couple of places people can stay for free:

  1. In your own lane
  2. Out of other people’s business

They are acting legally and enjoying their property. If you don’t like hearing them - move.

At their age, playing out from 10am is absolutely fine. Homeschooling is not school. Intentionally so.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:09

I'm a bit perturbed by some of the responses on here.
All school aged children must have access to the National Curriculum.
Playing in the garden all day and every day is not acceptable.
I appreciate that it's still the summer holiday in England but homeschooling is not an excuse to let children play all day.
A dear friend of mine homeschools and must provide evidence and must adhere to certain rules.

If school aged children are not not at school , during term time and are playing in the garden for 10 hours a day then the LEA would be very interested.

Rocketpants50 · 26/08/2022 21:08

My goodness how wonderful, children playing, that's exactly what they should be doing. I absolutely love hearing all the children playing in their gardens.

Gracelynn · 26/08/2022 21:02

I am glad our lovely neighbours don't complain about our children's noise. We home school and spend a lot of time outdoors. Our 4 kids don't scream or shout but sometimes I do worry about noise levals. I sometimes ask neighbours is we are too loud. A lot of our neighbours hang out outside too, as well as tiny gardens we have a shared grass green area and drying green. Sometimes we bring maths, history or copyworkbooks outside as the kids like to sit beside the guiniea pigs. We also garden, do woodwork, skate and do some art outside.

Some of our neighbours even join in with the home schooling, one stopped by to help with maths, she saw from the path my daughter was struggling with a maths topic and said, "let me help you" and came in and sat down on the step with my child. By the time I'd poured her some tea my child was very happy to have finished the task and have understood the topic much better! It was so lovely. A retired biology teacher often helps too, just as and when he decides to pop by.

Semi regularly other home schooling families visit for shared games, art or geography lessons and we can have between 6 and 14 kids in the tiny house or garden!

I think we'd possibly worse than your neighbours!

elizzza · 26/08/2022 21:02

Sorry, cross posted with your last post OP - glad you’ve realised that calling the council was ridiculous.

Angelinflipflops · 26/08/2022 21:02

I'm guessing you're retired?

Londonactive · 26/08/2022 21:01

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 19:54

What's wrong with simply making an inquiry? If everything is above board then there should be no problem surely?

I'm sorry, but this is pure spiteful. You don't give a damn about their learning, you're doing it so that you can use your garden in silence. That would be a very nasty thing to do.