Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbours homeschooled kids play out ALL day. AIBU?

266 replies

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 19:26

Long time lurker, first time poster. Looking for a bit of advice if possible.

We live in terraced housing in a family area, so since Summer holidays started most of our neighbours kids have been out playing in their gardens during the day, which is absolutely fine, it's Summer holidays so that's to be expected. But even when the new term starts next week, the children who live next door to us will STILL be playing out.

The family moved here in March(?), they have 2 children who I assumed weren't old enough for school yet, but in a recent chat with the parents we found out they are, in fact, homeschooled.

They're out in the garden from about 10am-8pm every single day. They're not the type of children who scream and shriek, which I appreciate, but it's the constant chattering/playing noises for 10 hours every day, and not having a moments peace in my own garden (or when my windows are open, for that matter!). They have breaks in-between, which I assume is for food, but then come straight back out again. This has been ongoing since the day they moved in.

It's the fact that this is going to be an all-year round thing, not just school breaks/holidays that's bothering me. I understand they are entitled to use their garden as they please, but aren't we (and the rest of our neighbours) entitled to some peace every now and then?

We're not particularly familiar with the parents, we've only chatted with them in passing a handful of times, so my husband and I haven't raised this with them. And we don't know if this is even an issue we're entitled to raise.

If we did mention this to them, what could we say without coming across as offensive to their kids?

OP posts:
hattie43 · 26/08/2022 22:11

@EdwinaMonsoon

I think you're getting a really hard time here OP but I'm not surprised given some of the characters on MN. I think everyone has a right to enjoy some peace and quiet in their own home . When you have immediate neighbours it should be a balance between what suits everyone .
Id not be ringing anybody but I would be knocking their door to explain how 10 hrs of noise is just too much everyday and could their be a compromise. It's not realistic to expect the children not to play in their garden but could the hours be limited . It's a starting point .

RisingSunn · 26/08/2022 22:09

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:26

I don't know why people are jumping to accuse me of having malicious intentions. I said in my first post that my husband and I aren't sure if it's our place to say anything, and asked for advice on how to raise the issue with them, if possible. I didn't immediately say I'm reporting them, that's an unfair accusation.

It’s the fact that you would even CONSIDER contacting authorities about this family that haven’t done anything wrong. It certainly comes across as very malicious.

Baoing · 26/08/2022 22:09

Wow, I didn't think anyone else would be in the same situation. It's SO hard to explain to people, isn't it?

Oh ffs. This is insane.

I'm sorry that you're also going through this

Is this for real??

I haven't read such whining, self-indulgent crap in ages. Get a grip. You're not 'going through' anything.

Is there anyone in your life who might talk any sense into you?

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 26/08/2022 22:07

GoldenGorilla · 26/08/2022 19:50

We home schooled for a while. Playing outside is a completely valid way of learning, especially for young children and the local education team will have no issue with it at all.

They are entitled to make noise in their garden, and you have no entitlement whatsoever to silence.

hope that helps.

Presumably that's with an adult actually teaching them something though?

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 22:06

Boredsoentertainme · 26/08/2022 22:00

Oh op I’m cringing for you so hard, my toes genuinely curled a little.

It’s so bad when you can’t afford to live distant from others and don’t want to have to listen to little children playing, but finances force you to be in their vicinity.

do the lottery, you never know.

Again another wild assumption. Why do you assume I can't afford to live anywhere else and am struggling financially?

I love my house and the area I live in, I raised my family here and have been here for over 25 years. It would just be such a shame to have to leave the place I love so much because of a new neighbours unusual habits. But such is life, I guess.

OP posts:
Boredsoentertainme · 26/08/2022 22:04

Is there any way you can work to afford not living in a terrace op? I think this is the solution for you. You need to aim for detached without neighbours so close. Terraced living is notorious for hearing neighbours so is not good for someone such as yourself.

Marotte · 26/08/2022 22:04

Wrong bold, should have said: I also have to sit indoors with windows shut when in work calls (so that people outside or neighbours with their windows open can't hear them) or if I want to read a book in near-complete quiet.

Marotte · 26/08/2022 22:02

I also have to sit indoors with windows shut when in work calls (so that people outside or neighbours with their windows open can't hear them) or if I want to read a book in near-complete quiet. I think that that is normal behaviour and on the work calls, you need confidentiality even if you don't mind the background noise.

I sympathise with the OP in that there are some types of noise that really bug me, not the same ones as her, and it can be really difficult, but there is nothing actually wrong with these children being in their garden and it's rather an entitled-sounding thread.

whatwouldAnnaDelveydo · 26/08/2022 22:01

I had a couple of elderly neighbours that used to spend the whole summer in the garden drinking wine and playing dominos. Click clack, click clack, ALL DAY LONG. It was annoying to me, but what could I say? "Please, don't enjoy your summer because i don't like the noise of wine glasses and domino pieces?"

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 22:01

magaluf1999 · 26/08/2022 21:49

My neighbour is exactly the same.

Its so hard to explain to someone else. They aren't doing anything wrong as such. But its the fact it NEVER lets up and they never go out. I also have to sit indoors with windows shut when in work calls or if i want to read a book. Its mostly chatter and playing and they are well behaved nice kids.

They also have bi fold doors and i can hear every conversation they have indoors too as their voices do seem to carry a bit.

I do still sit outside but i sit with my back to them and wear noise cancelling headphones.

The plots arent tiny and we are not in a terrace but i dont understand why they dont live on a small holding in the middle if nowhere to make as much noise as they want. It seems a strange choice to live in the burbs if you are outdoorsy to that extent.

Wow, I didn't think anyone else would be in the same situation. It's SO hard to explain to people, isn't it?

It's such a difficult situation when you've lived somewhere for so many years and your daily life gets disrupted so much by a new neighbours unusual routine. I'm sorry that you're also going through this.

OP posts:
Boredsoentertainme · 26/08/2022 22:00

Oh op I’m cringing for you so hard, my toes genuinely curled a little.

It’s so bad when you can’t afford to live distant from others and don’t want to have to listen to little children playing, but finances force you to be in their vicinity.

do the lottery, you never know.

ShedHead7 · 26/08/2022 21:59

And think of all that vitD and fresh air they are getting, I bet they are healthy little souls!

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 21:59

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:37

You're taking such an aggressive attitude on this thread, this thread was started simply to ask for some advice.

So you read what I posted about not having experience with home educating, didn't realise they don't have to follow a schedule/curriculum, and understand now with this information that a council inquiry would be ridiculous, and you still proceeded to go back and quote the previous post to call me nasty names? Right then. Makes sense.

I don’t believe you OP.
Nobody’s kids are outside for that long, every day.

Ans the fact that you would have considered involving the authorities is appalling.

You seem to be a malicious, vexatious neighbour.

Get a hobby.

Kanaloa · 26/08/2022 21:57

jennakong · 26/08/2022 21:36

Um, when is the actual schooling going on?

Children even of 4/5 are in class for five hours a day, I realise that it's a lot of play-based learning in the FS, but school is normally an indoor thing, surely?

No, I don't think you're being unreasonable, I know that my neighbour was exasperated with the noise my 8 and 10 year old during the first lockdown, which was an awful time really when they had nowhere else to play. Tempers do get frayed when people are stuck side by side constantly. I get pissed off with the constant noise of gardening tools, radios, barking dogs etc and prefer the colder weather because it is so much quieter!

It doesn’t matter that children of 4/5 are in class for x amount of hours. And there’s no ‘schooling’ going on. That’s the entire point of home educating. If traditional school based learning is what these parents want then they have access to that for free in this country.

Home educators don’t just recreate a classroom in their living room and try to imitate a classroom environment. They may be unschooling or similar. The goal isn’t to have your child sit pretending they’re at school otherwise you might as well be at school!

ShedHead7 · 26/08/2022 21:56

No op, not everyone gets annoyed by the sound of kids playing, even if it is all day, especially If they aren't screaming or screeching, which your neighbours aren't. They sound like they are happy content kids. If they are not out before 10am I would presume they have some formal learning for a couple of hours in the morning, when they are fresh and receptive.
But as others have pointed out, you don't actually care about their education. Just yourself.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 26/08/2022 21:55

So many ridiculous posts at the moment. This is one of them.

In the avoidance of doubt, YABU to describe not-loud kids in their own garden as 'not a moment's peace'. Go inside for an hour yourself if it bothers you.

Baoing · 26/08/2022 21:54

The OP said homeschooled children. Children who are within sight and hearing far more than children going to school

What difference does that even make?? We have about six under 5's near us. They're out all the time, of course they are!

Would the noise suddenly become intolerable because they decide to homeschool? Why is it fine for up to 4/5 years old but not afterwards? Homeschool makes not a jot of difference.

Is the OP ticking the dates off on a calendar until children SHOULD got to school? Possibly, I suppose.

TonksInPurple · 26/08/2022 21:53

Hope for your sake you don’t end up with a childminder on your other-side they are also outside all the time!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 26/08/2022 21:52

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:37

That may be so but I'm going by my friend who has homeschooled all four of her children and has regaled me with all of the hoops that she is obliged to jump through.

Spending eight till four , unsupervised, just playing , is accessing no curriculum whatsoever.

Nowhere has the OP referred to whether the children are unsupervised or not. Most siblings at 5 & 7 wouldn’t be able to entertain themselves for 10 hours straight outside without any adult direction or support to manage disagreements, guide aspects of the activity etc so I’d assume that at least some of the time they are playing they will have an adult’s input to scaffold their learning and help them link educational concepts to their experiences.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 26/08/2022 21:52

EdwinaMonsoon · 26/08/2022 21:43

I don't struggle with hearing outside noise, that's why I live here, I have no problem with the area. I haven't had any problems with neighbours or their children for all the years I've lived here, it's just this one particular family that have recently moved in and their unusual routine.

The problem with these threads is people are so quick to twist words and make accusations that simply aren't true. But that's the nature of aibu I suppose!

I had a feeling you'd say something like this, but the fact is that you talked in your OP about being entitled to some peace. With multiple neighbours in earshot, which is going to be the case in a terrace, that is simply not a reasonable or legitimate expectation. They could all only be out for a few hours each day and there still never be a time when you got 'peace'. When there wasn't the noise of talking, children playing etc audible.

You thinking you could live in a terrace in what you describe as a family area and yet reasonably expect the absence of these noises is inherently unreasonable. Having been fine in the area thus far is purely luck, given this attitude. But if you think you're entitled to time outside not hearing these ordinary and reasonable noises, something like this was always a risk.

Soapboxqueen · 26/08/2022 21:51

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 26/08/2022 21:37

That may be so but I'm going by my friend who has homeschooled all four of her children and has regaled me with all of the hoops that she is obliged to jump through.

Spending eight till four , unsupervised, just playing , is accessing no curriculum whatsoever.

It would depend where your friend lives as to what she had to provide but in England it is fairly minimal.

Nobody here, including the op, actually knows what is and is not being provided so it's pointless speculating.

BlodynGwyn · 26/08/2022 21:51

You don't give a wild rat's arse about their curriculum/education. You want them gone. Maybe even taken from the parent's care. The parent's should start having the children practice instruments everyday - maybe drums or trumpets.

I couldn't stand to live next door to other people and that's why I live miles from everyone else. You need to do the same.

Marotte · 26/08/2022 21:50

The chattering/playing noises non-stop for 10 hours a day, it's exasperating.

Sounds delightful to me. Small children enjoying the out of doors without shrieking or otherwise being excessively loud. Wonderful, what life is all about. Sounds as though they are having their own private Forest School.

Go inside and close your windows then? I cannot imagine why you think you have any entitlement to a garden so quiet that children aren't even allowed to play nicely near it? I don't have a garden but when I did, I could hear all sorts in it: traffic, cows, farm machinery, children playing in the park nearby , in the street, in their gardens, adults doing DIY, vans beeping as they reversed, bin men, adults enjoying their gardens or just talking in them, the list endless, lorries and ambulances going past the end of the road. All completely normal.

OTOH if they really don't look as though they are having any kind of even informal learning, and are just being left to their own devices completely all day every day, that might be another matter as in their educational needs may not be being met and you can make a call if you really suspect that may be the case. But be wise to the fact that homeschooling for small children definitely does NOT need to look anything like sitting at a desk learning the National Curriculum.

DysonSphere · 26/08/2022 21:49

Baoing · 26/08/2022 21:32

I think a lot of people on here don't have experience with living next door/in close proximity to homeschooled children, so wouldn't understand my dilemma unfortunately

Oh for goodness' sake. They are just CHILDREN. It's NOT a 'dilemma.'

Don't be so utterly ludicrous. Do you seriously think that people don't live next door to children? That no one can POSSIBLY imagine that incredibly unusual situation?

I haven't read such ridiculous, intolerant crap in years.

The OP said homeschooled children. Children who are within sight and hearing far more than children going to school.

I don't understand the defensiveness. Part of living in close proximity to others is learning to negotiate and compromise. When you Home ed, you realise how much the world is set up for children not to be seen and heard all the time and you can't blame the OP being used to this existence and not expecting or wanting to hear significant child noise nearly everyday.

Much as I loved my own children. I wouldn't have been wanting to hear other children's noise all the time either.

magaluf1999 · 26/08/2022 21:49

My neighbour is exactly the same.

Its so hard to explain to someone else. They aren't doing anything wrong as such. But its the fact it NEVER lets up and they never go out. I also have to sit indoors with windows shut when in work calls or if i want to read a book. Its mostly chatter and playing and they are well behaved nice kids.

They also have bi fold doors and i can hear every conversation they have indoors too as their voices do seem to carry a bit.

I do still sit outside but i sit with my back to them and wear noise cancelling headphones.

The plots arent tiny and we are not in a terrace but i dont understand why they dont live on a small holding in the middle if nowhere to make as much noise as they want. It seems a strange choice to live in the burbs if you are outdoorsy to that extent.