Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

that Russia flaring off gas is a sick joke

55 replies

LargeDeviation · 26/08/2022 13:26

It really sticks in the throat seeing Putin burn off gas just to avoid delivering it to Europe. Not only is it a massive waste, the soot from the flares will fall on the Arctic and exacerbate the polar ice cap melting.

Yes, Michael Fallon was totally inept closing down even the small gas storage facility we have, and generally governments going back decades should have built more strategic storage facilities for oil and gas which can be filled up when the price is low.

But I think too many people are forgetting that the real cause of the huge rise in gas prices is Putin's pathetic war, and he is deliberately using his position in the European gas market to try to dampen support for Ukraine. If his tactics work and we lose the political will for supplying Ukraine with weapons and aid, this game will be played not just this year but again and again and again.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Suzi888 · 28/08/2022 19:01

Agree with @RealBecca the future is bleak.

Humans are like cockroaches.

RealBecca · 28/08/2022 14:45

LargeDeviation · 26/08/2022 13:51

@RealBecca There is a huge difference in environmental impact between flaring it at source, and burning it when I'm cooking on my stove. When I use gas on my cooker I don't (directly) cause polar ice caps to melt.

My point was really that the planet is on course for total devastation as a direct result of how many human beings are living. The behaviour is an additional and avoidable part of the problem, sure. But in terms of time, how much faster is this accelerating the devastation by? A day? A week?

Humanity is, or arguably has already, set course to destroy everything. In a matter of a few generations. Look at biodiversity, insect populations. It hideous. It's happening. We can moan about it and we can take direct action but ultimately unless there is a bigger profit in not harming the planet, nothing will change.

Our childrens future is already ruined. I cant even imagine our grandchildren lives. Putin alone didnt cause that.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2022 11:07

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

A well thought through and written post (better than mine).

The options as I see are :

A) a protracted proxy war with support for Ukraine in which further economic misery and lives are lost in both Ukraine and Europe.

B) a negotiated peace deal

MrsOwainGlyndŵr · 27/08/2022 09:44

LargeDeviation · 26/08/2022 13:52

@chillipenguin Well they could send it to Europe as they were contracted to do, but that wouldn't serve Putin's evil agenda.

Europe don't want to buy it though.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 27/08/2022 09:16

Russia controls something like 14% of the global gas resource. If the market/system has been allowed to get to the stage where a 14% reduction in supply cannot be replaced relatively quickly, either by increasing supply from other gas producing nations or by reducing demand, then the system was unsustainable and broken.

Russian withdrawing access to their natural resources was always on the cards from the moment Europe decided to try and encourage the democratically elected pro Russian government to severe ties with Putin and then supported their opposition in otherthrowing them when that didn't work.

It can't have come as a surprise that Russia would limit access to their resources and we've had a minimum of 8 years to plan how to limit the impact of losing Russian gas, I mean one of our first moves after the invasion was to enforce sanctions on them in the hope of fucking their economy, did we honestly think Russia wouldn’t do the same? I can't believe not one a single person in any European government thought to ask the question what happens when Russia shuts off the gas? The fact that this apparently wasn't considered speaks volumes about the ineptitude of our leaders.

On a more general point about the war I don't agree with those saying we have to continue to support Ukraine.

We don't support other regions such as Tibet or Hong Kong in their fight against occupation because we don't want to upset China. We don't appear to be actively trying to destabilise and dipose of other pro russian / Russian leaning governments such as Belarus or Kazakhstan because it's not worth the effort. And we actively support the illegal invasion and occupation of other countries when it suits our needs, no moral rights or wrongs to consider when we do the invading apparently.

All of the above are political choices and supporting Ukraine as we have is a political choice we've made that isn't working. We need to either drop support and remove sanctions against Russia or fully commit to war against them and accept the consequences of doing so.

A prolonged seige via proxy war against Russia will only result in extended misery and suffering for millions and millions of people in Europe and I don't believe Western European populations have the capacity or fortitude to outlast the Russian population when it comes to dealing with the impact of sanctions against each other. Russia is just too resource rich and it's population too used to hardship for that to work. When it comes to a game of chicken we in the West will 100% blink first so why extend the wait?

1dayatatime · 27/08/2022 08:17

"OK, sorry. So not his fault that the war started, just his fault that it won’t end any time soon, despite the fact that Russia currently controls far, far more of Ukraine than just Crimea and is showing no signs of giving up any of that.

you’re also assuming that him saying he wants Crimea back isn’t just an opening negotiating tactic."

++++

Again not Zelensky's fault that the war won't end anytime soon.

That fault lies with the west in particular Biden and Boris Johnson who have both publicly declared that they will support Zelensky both politically and militarily to achieve whatever war aims Zelensky has. France is alone in continuing dialogue with Putin in the hope of a ceasefire/ peace deal.

Russia is getting militarily mauled in Ukraine and wants a negotiated peace. The problem is with unequivocal support from Biden and the UK, Zelensky has no incentive to compromise on any peace deal which pragmatically is what is needed here.

Otherwise the war will just go on and on as per the Afghanistan and Iraq conflicts.

1dayatatime · 27/08/2022 08:08

hellsbells99 · 26/08/2022 21:30

Time Putin was assassinated

Whilst dictators tend not to be removed in peaceful ways or live comfortable retirements.

If Putin was indeed removed then it is most likely that he will be replaced with someone with a similar mindset and approach to Ukraine.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 26/08/2022 21:51

1dayatatime · 26/08/2022 21:42

@MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife

"You what? So all this is Zelensky’s fault? Somehow he forced Putin to invade the rest of Ukraine because he wasn’t gracious enough about them annexing Crimea. Interesting take."

+++

No this is all very much Putin's fault, I don't know where in my post that you read I was suggesting this is somehow Zelensky's fault?

It is however a stated war aim of Zelensky to have the return of Crimea to Ukraine in order to have a peace deal. He and Ukraine are entitled to have whatever war aims they wish.

However in my opinion that is an unrealistic war aim that the Russia will hand over territory that is 65% Russian population and has been part of Russia for 217 years out of the last 240 years.

Also in my opinion I do not support the destruction of Europe's economy, the impoverishment of its people and excess deaths this winter as a result of unaffordable energy bills all in support of that unrealistic war aim.

OK, sorry. So not his fault that the war started, just his fault that it won’t end any time soon, despite the fact that Russia currently controls far, far more of Ukraine than just Crimea and is showing no signs of giving up any of that.

you’re also assuming that him saying he wants Crimea back isn’t just an opening negotiating tactic.

1dayatatime · 26/08/2022 21:42

@MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife

"You what? So all this is Zelensky’s fault? Somehow he forced Putin to invade the rest of Ukraine because he wasn’t gracious enough about them annexing Crimea. Interesting take."

+++

No this is all very much Putin's fault, I don't know where in my post that you read I was suggesting this is somehow Zelensky's fault?

It is however a stated war aim of Zelensky to have the return of Crimea to Ukraine in order to have a peace deal. He and Ukraine are entitled to have whatever war aims they wish.

However in my opinion that is an unrealistic war aim that the Russia will hand over territory that is 65% Russian population and has been part of Russia for 217 years out of the last 240 years.

Also in my opinion I do not support the destruction of Europe's economy, the impoverishment of its people and excess deaths this winter as a result of unaffordable energy bills all in support of that unrealistic war aim.

hellsbells99 · 26/08/2022 21:30

Time Putin was assassinated

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 26/08/2022 21:24

Isitsixoclockalready · 26/08/2022 20:13

It is awful but if we give in then he'll have us over a barrel. It's giving into blackmail and next time he'll be empowered to do exactly the same.

Yep. It's laughably naive to think Putin is going to make nice and play ball if he's allowed Ukraine. This boil needs to be lanced now.

sst1234 · 26/08/2022 21:19

ChillyFloss · 26/08/2022 14:17

This^^
Who benefits from a massive hike in the wholesale cost of gas? That would be Russia, who are now selling their newly expensive energy to India and China (piped to the East via the newly completed pipeline in Sakhalin...which Shell UK helped Putin to build). But sure, just keep throwing money at a unwinnable war rather than engage in diplomacy or compromise. After all, that worked so well in Iraq and Afghanistan. 🙄

Seeing a pattern? All we need to do is follow the money.

This is realpolitik, not some good vs evil battle.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 26/08/2022 21:16

1dayatatime · 26/08/2022 21:06

@Isitsixoclockalready

Heronimo
I'd rather the UK stopped supporting Ukraine. Id rather Putin than these massive bills.

It is awful but if we give in then he'll have us over a barrel. It's giving into blackmail and next time he'll be empowered to do exactly the same.

+++

Actually I don't think there will be a next time. Firstly Russia has received a massive military mauling in Ukraine and really isn't in a position to try an take the whole of Ukraine let alone invade anywhere else.

Secondly if there is no thing the Ukrainian crisis has taught Europe is that they are over dependent on Russian gas, something to be fair the United States has been warning against for 30 years but was dismissed as post Cold War warmongering and anti Russian.

Thirdly you can bet that post this crisis every European nation is going to focus on renewables and energy security and not being dependent on Russian gas.

Lastly Zelensky's stated aim is the return of Crimea to Ukraine. Ukraine is made up of 65% Russians and was part of Russia from 1783 until 1991 when it was independent until 1995 when it was forcibly abolished by Ukraine and incorporated into Ukraine Until 2014 when it first declared independence from Ukraine and then through a disputed referendum reunified with Russia.

So in short - is it reasonable that we all suffer from unaffordable energy bills and double digit inflation just so Zelensky can have Crimea back when out of the last 240 years it has been independent for 4 years, Ukrainian for 19 years and Russian for 217 years? Oh and it's populated by 65% Russians?

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimea

You what? So all this is Zelensky’s fault? Somehow he forced Putin to invade the rest of Ukraine because he wasn’t gracious enough about them annexing Crimea. Interesting take.

1dayatatime · 26/08/2022 21:06

@Isitsixoclockalready

Heronimo
I'd rather the UK stopped supporting Ukraine. Id rather Putin than these massive bills.

It is awful but if we give in then he'll have us over a barrel. It's giving into blackmail and next time he'll be empowered to do exactly the same.

+++

Actually I don't think there will be a next time. Firstly Russia has received a massive military mauling in Ukraine and really isn't in a position to try an take the whole of Ukraine let alone invade anywhere else.

Secondly if there is no thing the Ukrainian crisis has taught Europe is that they are over dependent on Russian gas, something to be fair the United States has been warning against for 30 years but was dismissed as post Cold War warmongering and anti Russian.

Thirdly you can bet that post this crisis every European nation is going to focus on renewables and energy security and not being dependent on Russian gas.

Lastly Zelensky's stated aim is the return of Crimea to Ukraine. Ukraine is made up of 65% Russians and was part of Russia from 1783 until 1991 when it was independent until 1995 when it was forcibly abolished by Ukraine and incorporated into Ukraine Until 2014 when it first declared independence from Ukraine and then through a disputed referendum reunified with Russia.

So in short - is it reasonable that we all suffer from unaffordable energy bills and double digit inflation just so Zelensky can have Crimea back when out of the last 240 years it has been independent for 4 years, Ukrainian for 19 years and Russian for 217 years? Oh and it's populated by 65% Russians?

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crimea

Phrenologistsfinger · 26/08/2022 20:21

Suzi888 · 26/08/2022 20:00

Once again, humans destroy their habitat. We are like a plague.

I agree. Sadly, it is also the habitat of every other living thing that we are destroying, life that is potentially unique to this one planet. The harm humanity is causing is incalculable.

MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 20:14

I didn’t realise it was excess not being used

Still upsetting to hear about

He’s a pain for the whole world to deal with

Isitsixoclockalready · 26/08/2022 20:13

Heronimo · 26/08/2022 19:47

I'd rather the UK stopped supporting Ukraine. Id rather Putin than these massive bills.

It is awful but if we give in then he'll have us over a barrel. It's giving into blackmail and next time he'll be empowered to do exactly the same.

Isitsixoclockalready · 26/08/2022 20:12

UrslaB · 26/08/2022 14:02

I agree Russia has o be opposed simply because failing to do so means giving them the green light to expand further into other small european nations and it will embolden them to play games with oil and gas supply for political advantage.

I see it as the wake up call that making ourselves dependent on fossil fuels, especially those supplied from outside our borders is absolute idiocy.

The UK governments lackluster efforts to diversify and move the country to renewable energy sources has been pathetic. The beauracracy involved in opening new wind farms, and tidal energy is hampering efforts. Government needs to inetervene and massively streamline the process so that more wind farms can be built and expanded as quickly as possible. Also, electric network for cars need to be massively expanded. Been talking about it for twenty years but the roll out has been a snails pace.

Taxation on oil and gas manufacturers profits should be implemented and used to offer massive discounts and grants on heat pumps and solar panels for consumer market. That should have been happening for the last 20 years but again...governemnt incompetence and token measures.

No one seems to see the self reinforceing cycle of the Tories saying they will cut tax...but the first ones they talk about cutting are green levies. That's just kicking the can down the road.

Even then the infrastructure is lagging behind. I went two years ago to change from oil heating to a heat pump. It was looking to be a difficult and expensive process. Just before the purchase the company who sells them advised me to check that the electricity network would support a heat pump. Was appalled to be told by electric comapny that no, the electric grid in my area wouldn't support a heat pump. I would have to wait for the area to be upgraded..with no estimates of when that would be. Or pay ten grand to have a step up generator insalled at my house to supply the consant higher power such a heat pump would need. I was already putting myself into debt to make the witch just at the cost of the heat pump, I could never have afforded the extra ten grand.

New build houses should have heat pumps and solar panels as standard by law.

Alas, while government elite are reaping huge dividends from their own investments into oil and gas, that will never happen.

Yep, totally agree with that.

Suzi888 · 26/08/2022 20:00

Once again, humans destroy their habitat. We are like a plague.

Heronimo · 26/08/2022 19:47

I'd rather the UK stopped supporting Ukraine. Id rather Putin than these massive bills.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 26/08/2022 19:39

We have had years and years to invest properly in renewables. More gas is not the answer if we want to see the next century.

Awakened22 · 26/08/2022 19:36

We only have ourselves to blame for becoming so dependent on Russia for gas. It meant pre-war there were no sanctions that had any real impact as Russia had the upper hand with threatening to retaliate against sanctions by turning off the gas.

Eeksteek · 26/08/2022 19:20

Saz12 · 26/08/2022 14:12

As much as I loathe Putin, there has always been propaganda, PR etc to persuade the populace of the enemy to give up, or that the effort is not worth while.
Flaring excess gas off at a time when the UK has just had an enormous price hike is exactly what Russia would do to erode our support of Ukraine.
We banned Russia from sporting events, took away the oligarchs expensive toys, etc not because it would help Ukraine but to make Russian citizens feel less inclined to support the war.
Both sides do this, in all wars.

Yeah. It’s just Putin flexing, isn’t it? A PR thing. And yes, he has it all his way. No one can invade Russia, so he’s safe. He’s got a thing about Ukraine he’s indulging, and can’t be opposed because of the UN thing and is indirectly reminding the West that they need Russian energy. So when the Ukraine is defeated (and how can they not be, if no one can help them?), he’ll have made the west a bit more amenable to whatever it is he wants in future. A little bit more careful to keep Russia happy. He doesn’t care what ordinary people want, Russian or not, because Russia isn’t (as I superficially understand it) a real democracy. So he doesn’t have to keep the people happy. The Tories don’t care either, but they have to look like they do, or they won’t get voted back in. So we pressure our government over energy prices on Puitn’s behalf, so they’ll negotiate with Russia and Putin can sell us cheaper energy that can make money for Boris et al and Putin, even though neither Putin nor the Tories give a flying fuck about whether or not we can afford to be warm, because none of them count us as real people. Just units of production. If it goes on long enough and people start dying here, someone will crack to stay in power, won’t they?

gatehouseoffleet · 26/08/2022 15:20

The whole war is causing massive pollution, not to mention the nuclear risk.
I wish we would put a tenth of the effort into forcing negotiations that we do into slinging in more arms. And I also wish we had no isolated re. sports, arts etc. We need to keep communications open with ordinary Russians, we need them to continue to want what the west and democracy has to offer

I agree - I think the hysteria going on at the moment about visas for Russians is also misplaced. They are not responsible for Putin, it's not like they have free and fair elections is it?

PinkButtercups · 26/08/2022 14:57

GoneWithTheWine1 · 26/08/2022 13:39

And the war isn't causing unneeded massive pollution?

It's just a joke. Need to stop funding and being involved in a war that isn't ours. Been going on for years. They are all war/pollution criminals.

👏🏼

Swipe left for the next trending thread