Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and SIL over-stepping

63 replies

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 12:14

My brother and SIL are great with my kids and it's nice however, they have a tendency to over-step with my eldest.

They have done things like planning days out or particular activities for her birthday and speaking to her directly about it instead of me. I had planned the same thing but because they told her and I was keeping it a surprise I had to cancel. SIL said she used to always do this with her Mum (yes, so maybe consider that I, as her Mum may have wanted to do it)

Inviting her to spend the day on a specific day without asking me - again we had plans which I couldn't cancel so DD wasn't happy with me because I said no and it would need to be another day.

Buying things that aren't age appropriate. Expensive make up is one example, DD was 9 at the time and other than a teeny bit of blusher for a party etc she wasn't allowed to wear make up.

The latest is suggesting she could maybe join them on holiday - that is a flat no.

There are others but this is the basic gist of it. It's nice that they want to spend time with her and clearly adore her but I want to be consulted BEFORE they speak to DD because if it doesn't suit or I say no she just assumes it's me spoiling her fun. I also have 2 children and it's clear they favour the eldest but it has in the past upset my youngest (who has done nothing wrong, she's just 6 compared to her 11 year old sister so probably viewed as more work). She's felt left out at times so I've had to make some decisions based on that also.

I've asked they go through me but it's been ignored. I've told eldest DD that the holiday thing was probably just said in a "it would be fun way" rather than a plan but I actually think they are testing the water.

Am I being silly or do I need to tell them to back off a bit?

OP posts:
Runningslow · 26/08/2022 14:02

db doesn’t

ILoveRumblyRabbit · 26/08/2022 14:02

And agree about the fairness thing, they all go or nothing. I regularly take all 6 of my nieces and nephews out alone. It's cruel to leave anyone out, especially if it's the same child over and over.

Runningslow · 26/08/2022 14:02

I wonder if your sil wants kids but your doesn’t.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 14:00

alphons

Oh I completely agree.

She kept the makeup, I just had a say on when a how and when it was used (for dress up rather than a family party kind of thing). It's not something I would even bring up it was just an example. I really don't split hairs over the little things, it's the bigger ones that I'm more concerned about and trying to fizzle out.

OP posts:
5zeds · 26/08/2022 13:59

I had a sibling who favoured one. It caused problems with self esteem for the less favoured one and was very upsetting all round. Get angry, this is horrible.

ILoveRumblyRabbit · 26/08/2022 13:59

I'm the Auntie amongst both my brothers DC and DSS. I have the luxury of being able to spoil my nieces and nephews and enjoy doing so, but any suggestions are always made to the parents privately well in advance to make sure it isn't clashing with their own and any exciting plans are left to the parents to reveal to their kids so any excitement is associated with their mum or dads authority. It's a bit sneaky and unnecessary for SIL to try and undermine your place, it's not a competition. Definitely have a word and give them some new boundaries to work with otherwise it may be a no to any future plans with them.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:56

In a couple of years none of you will be as cool as her mates anyway so you will all be ditched unless needed for money

Well this is true 😆

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 26/08/2022 13:55

I’d just tell them explicitly that kids are not for playing “Mummy’s and Daddy’s” with, and that they need to back right off. It’s a bit creepy, tbh.

Runaway1 · 26/08/2022 13:50

They are creating conflicts between you and your dd, and potentially between your dd and her sibling. I’d definitely have a calm chat thanking them for the kind thoughts of these treats but that they need to come to you first and include both children.

alphons · 26/08/2022 13:50

I agree with the general gist of other posters, but one thing: I don’t think you can ask DB and SIL to seek prior approval of gifts. I think she can accept them all, but you as a mother have a right to quietly remove them saying “these aren’t age appropriate, I’m your mother and have responsibility for you”, and perhaps save them for another day. Or return them with a suggestion of something that would be more age appropriate. Some adults without children in their lives aren’t even aware of the array of “stuff” out there, they only have their own adult frame of reference.

Things like too-expensive make-up though: I would feel the same way as you and probably react similarly. Also, make-up goes off. But take a long view: does it really matter? She’s just being spoiled a little by her aunt and uncle. That’s okay, and you can counter balance at home. If we’re talking an Apple Watch for an 11yo though: not age-appropriate, won’t go off, can be held back for a few years or returned to DB/SIL in favour of a Fitbit or something.

Have said all that, the impact this is having on your youngest is a completely different issue that is worth having an open conversation with your brother and SIL about. I personally PILs go as far as both-or-neither (except for Eg outings which aren’t age appropriate). Do they actually want to harm the younger child? Because that’s what they probably don’t realise they’re doing.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 26/08/2022 13:49

At the same time as outlining you need to be consulted say that they need to spend equal time with both girls, not necessarily together or the same activity but if Lily goes to the ballet with them one week it is Mia's turn next time to go to soft play. Then you can have time with just the other one.

In a couple of years none of you will be as cool as her mates anyway so you will all be ditched unless needed for money 🤣.

BreatheAndFocus · 26/08/2022 13:46

I can understand your concerns, OP. She does sound like she’s playing parent with your DD. You’ve asked her to run things past you first and she’s ignored you on purpose. I’d never in a million years do that with my nieces. It’s up to the parents and all requests should be run past the parents first with no mention to any DC involved. That’s commonsense.

I’d distance myself from them a bit, and if they asked why I’d tell them. It’s disrespectful, undermining and interfering quite frankly.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:43

Thanks everyone, I think I'll have a chat with my brother and also with eldest DD to explain that if they do try and make plans she really needs to say that they are best to ask me and also explain I'm not out to ruin her fun but some things just aren't practical or possible.

If it happens again after that it'll just be a flat no.

OP posts:
MerryChristmasToYou · 26/08/2022 13:42

It's downright unfair on DD2.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:41

I've definitely limited the one on one time to only birthday treats or if it's a Christmas gift but I did overhear SIL making plans with DD and I said something along the lines of, "oh it wouldn't really be fair on DD2". I had thought that would be enough to make it clear but apparently not so.

It could be that DD1 has picked up the holiday thing wrong but I doubt it. I wouldn't let them take both even if they asked, they are great at the fun side but they would cope well when it comes to rules and the mundane day to day aspect of children (even on a fun holiday). It's also too long and would impact on our own family plans.

OP posts:
Natty13 · 26/08/2022 13:38

I've always had the rule that anyone who tries to organise things with my children without talking to me about it first its an automatic no. End of. People really do soon learn to talk to your first if they want to spend time with your kids, it keeps everyone in their lane and allows you to veto things that don't suit.

chillipenguin · 26/08/2022 13:35

mbosnz · 26/08/2022 12:23

My Mum had a policy that if we asked her if a friend could sleep over, or we could sleep over at theirs, in their presence, the answer was a flat no. The basis was that we were clearly trying to manipulate her into saying yes, by making it too awkward to say no. We were trying to railroad her.

I would speak to your DD, and to your brother and SIL separately, explaining to your brother and SIL that unless you have been asked and already approved any gift or plan, the answer will be a flat no, for similar reasons. I would be telling your DD that you've had that discussion, what the new policy was, so that she knows for future reference as well.

Yup go with this

forrestgreen · 26/08/2022 13:32

Definitely what was said upthread about asking you first or it'll just be a no.

But also if they're not treating your children the same then I'd stop it all now

FriendOfDorothyGale · 26/08/2022 13:28

I would be approaching from the angle of it's not fair to your younger child.

I would be so upset if any of my siblings did this with me if I had more than 1 child.

My siblings who have more than one child, I have only ever treated both. No way would I make a fuss of one and not the other.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:14

And also the issue of them excluding her little sister who doesn't understand why her Aunt and Uncle take her big sister out to do these things and don't do anything with her one on one.

OP posts:
CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:13

I have no problem with them loving her and doing things with her. I just would like to be consulted before they speak to her about it so I can arrange it for a suitable time or have the chance to say "we actually have the same thing booked so she can't come sorry".

OP posts:
CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 13:11

DD knows she needs to ask me but it's more that I'm viewed as the bad one ruining her fun if I have to say no for any reason.

DD has a hobby that SIL had as a kid and has in the past said she wants to take her to certain weekend things and I've said she's more than welcome to join us however, she has never come and I think that's because she wants to be the only one there. I adore my SIL but I do find it a bit weird, it's like she wants to play parent her if that makes sense?

I do worry a bit about the coming years where DD starts to manage her time herself. I don't want to lose her to them which I know sounds silly but I do feel like they will butt into her life when I'm no longer gatekeeper and can't hold them at bay a bit. I guess it makes me a little sad to feel like we might be ditched in favour of a fun Aunt and Uncle.

OP posts:
Whatsonmymindgrapes · 26/08/2022 13:11

Love*

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 26/08/2022 13:08

I can see why it’s annoying but if someone wanted to live my child this much I’d be letting them

girlmom21 · 26/08/2022 13:04

I would definitely speak to them but also let DD know that all plans have to be run by you first