Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Brother and SIL over-stepping

63 replies

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 12:14

My brother and SIL are great with my kids and it's nice however, they have a tendency to over-step with my eldest.

They have done things like planning days out or particular activities for her birthday and speaking to her directly about it instead of me. I had planned the same thing but because they told her and I was keeping it a surprise I had to cancel. SIL said she used to always do this with her Mum (yes, so maybe consider that I, as her Mum may have wanted to do it)

Inviting her to spend the day on a specific day without asking me - again we had plans which I couldn't cancel so DD wasn't happy with me because I said no and it would need to be another day.

Buying things that aren't age appropriate. Expensive make up is one example, DD was 9 at the time and other than a teeny bit of blusher for a party etc she wasn't allowed to wear make up.

The latest is suggesting she could maybe join them on holiday - that is a flat no.

There are others but this is the basic gist of it. It's nice that they want to spend time with her and clearly adore her but I want to be consulted BEFORE they speak to DD because if it doesn't suit or I say no she just assumes it's me spoiling her fun. I also have 2 children and it's clear they favour the eldest but it has in the past upset my youngest (who has done nothing wrong, she's just 6 compared to her 11 year old sister so probably viewed as more work). She's felt left out at times so I've had to make some decisions based on that also.

I've asked they go through me but it's been ignored. I've told eldest DD that the holiday thing was probably just said in a "it would be fun way" rather than a plan but I actually think they are testing the water.

Am I being silly or do I need to tell them to back off a bit?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RandomMess · 26/08/2022 18:29

You also need to point out that the favouritism is damaging to both DC.

It's not healthy for the eldest to be so favoured even though in the here and now she loves it!

billy1966 · 26/08/2022 16:32

I don't think this is coming from a place of jealousy at all, it's coming from a realisation that these people have zero respect for OP, her husband or their wishes.

Respectful, responsible people absolutely go through parents first and they do NOT exclude another child constantly.

Their needs being met is their sole focus.

The holiday is just more of it.

I disagree with thanking the profusely for their disrespect of your wishes.

I do agree that the expectation that this will fade as the teen years is not a given at all.

I would say that teens love being treated.

Two girls here, they love love love, lunches, brunches, mini spa days, shopping for clothes/make up, concerts....basically anything that you are prepared to spend money on them for.....they aren't fussy😁.

So I most certainly think this could carry on.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 16:14

That said I think it's a bit of a red herring because they've never tried to discuss it with me only eldest daughter

OP posts:
CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 16:13

So, the holiday would require time of school which is where the hard no came from. They have never spent more than 24 hours with either child and a week holiday during term time certainly is not appropriate.

In all honesty even out of term time I wouldn't be comfortable with this arrangement, They very much pander to her And I have no doubt that the novelty would wear off quickly.

The long and short of it is I don't trust them to be responsible enough To look after her properly.

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 26/08/2022 15:58

I think the 4 of you (both couples) need to sit down to discuss. Express much appreciation first - it needs to be a shit sandwich, then what I would say is:

Asking me or DH first is a hard rule. Your ideas are lovely but we have to make sure things don’t disrupt our family life / upset little Dd / or double up on things we were planning as a family. DD1 is old enough to understand this, so we’ve also explained it to her.

We’d love it as a family if some of your time and generosity could be spread out to DD2. We understand at 6 what she can do is more restricted, but as parents we have to manage sibling jealously and she is starting to be a bit forlorn that she isn’t getting to spend time with you in the same way.

BUT -

OP while I think your SIL is being slightly selfish in treating your daughter like a fun mini-me, I think you do also need to check when you are being overprotective, perhaps for reasons of jealousy. I can absolutely see there are things you want to do as a nuclear family or as a mum, but I can’t for example understand why in principle DD couldn’t go on holiday with them - it could be a really good growing up experience for her.

In just a couple of years you will be much less able to police the relationship so you want to stay part of it than put yourself outside it. I think the PP who said in a few years she won’t be interested in any of you is wrong - teens often love aunt type figures who can provide experiences they can’t afford and a window into grown up life.

It can be hard to swallow when you are doing all the hard work and a fun aunt / godmother sweeps in showering treats in the manner of a Disney dad. But actually these engaged adults provide a lot of deeper value for kids, in a world where extended families are no longer the norm.

Doggydarling · 26/08/2022 15:52

I'm coming at this issue as the daughter/niece. My aunt and her partner behaved like your db and sil, they spent years overindulgencing me while almost ignoring my siblings, they'd no children of their own and really wanted all the fun easy bits of having a child, as I grew up it continued, right up to when I was getting married and my aunt insisted on paying for my wedding dress, as she aged she became very jealous of my relationship with my parents and really tried to come between us, she used everything she could to have me fall out with my parents, thankfully I eventually seen through her and went no contact but wasted years on her, don't let this happen to your dd, get in between them now before your dd hits her teens, please stand your ground for all your sakes.

SuperCamp · 26/08/2022 15:40

You need to be very plain and direct.
”it’s lovely that Dd gets to have good times with her aunt and uncle, but really, It is important that you always speak to us first. It’s causing issues when I have to say no, because we already have plans, it causes issues between her and her brother, and sometimes it spoils a surprise. She’s a child; you need to check with us before you speak to her, each and every time. Thank you”

Kitkatcatflap · 26/08/2022 15:33

Bloody hell Mbosnz that is inspired, I shall be nabbing that tip for myself. Thank you very much.

Good luck OP.

Changechangychange · 26/08/2022 15:31

They are treating your DD like a toy - picking her up when they want to do fun stuff with her (with absolutely no regard for you or DD2), and leaving you with the actual parenting. It isn’t “love”, as a PP described it, it is selfishness.

You definitely need to put your foot down. I would actually be less worried about them continuing to undermine you when she’s a teen, as I expect she will be less cute then and SIL will have got bored of playing Mummies.

frazzledasarock · 26/08/2022 15:20

I think you’ve been too accommodating here.

as well as doing the if you ask dd before me it’s always going to be a no.

with regards the birthday surprise, I’d have told DD outright well your aunty had spoilt it as that is what I’ve got you. Then I’d have taken her on my booking and left your brother and SIL to cancel their plans. I would not have cancelled my plans because it was a surprise. I’d have bigged up our plans together and made a huge deal of going as a family etc.

and also make clear to your dd you will be taking dd2 out as you’re not all going to be sitting at home whilst she’s off having fun with her aunt and uncle, but that’s the risk of going out with them she’ll possibly miss out on days out with you and her dad and sister.

SeaToSki · 26/08/2022 15:18

I would be reading the riot act with them. She is 11 and everything should be run by you first. I would be blocking them on your DDs phone (if that is how they are getting to her without checking with you first) and having a hard conversation with them both setting out some iron clad rules.

They are teaching your DD that she doesnt have to listen to her parents as ‘other adults’ have priority. That all well and good while the other adults are well intentioned, but what happens if someone shady invites her somewhere, and off she trots because she is used to not having to run it by you first.

And then there is the favouritism issue as well as the contrast with their ‘Disney parenting’ and your ‘actual parenting’ which just sets DD up for family conflicts and unhappiness just as she is entering the tricky teenage years

billy1966 · 26/08/2022 15:10

Good for you for posting.

Should you feel yourself weaken about asserting yourself, think how furious you will be in a couple of years when it is all out of your hands and these people are having the best of both worlds and you are bad cop and clashing with your child as you try and parent her.

billy1966 · 26/08/2022 15:05

How will you feel if a them and you dynamic arises during the teenage years and you in the big bad cop role while aunty sympathises with her and rubbishes your decisions.

Stop these people openly undermining you now whilst your have a chance.

Two years from now and the choice will be out of your hands.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 15:05

No it shouldn't have and honestly the only reason it did is because DD was so excited. I was gutted.

Thanks for your post, it's definitely given me a bit to think about in how to handle it effectively so it puts a firm stop to the way things have been.

OP posts:
billy1966 · 26/08/2022 15:01

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 14:48

billy1966

You're right. It's crept in though. I will deal with it.

I don't think they mean it maliciously, I think they are just a bit blinkered and yes they can be a bit selfish, it probably is about their enjoyment more than anything else.

I do mean it kindly but you need to come at this from whats best for you and your child.

Because their influence, arrogance, and presumptuous in thinking they have rights over your child may well come back to bite you hard.

Will fun aunty be sticking her nose in and disagreeing when you try an lay down boundaries as your teen gets older.

My friend and her younger sister had a huge falling out when her 16 year old wanted to go to a festival for a weekend with friends and my friend was having none of it.
Her sister told her that she was being mean and should let go the reins a bit and chill....in front of her daughter.

My friend was so bloody furious with her completely unasked for opinion on her parenting decision.

Her sister apologised when she realised just how furious her sister was but things have not been the same between them since.

What if aunty thinks drinking alcohol is ok and you don't?

You have given someone who doesn't respect or care about YOUR boundaries a huge position of influence over YOUR child.

Start pulling back, firmly.

The birthday outing should NOT have gone ahead with them.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 14:48

billy1966

You're right. It's crept in though. I will deal with it.

I don't think they mean it maliciously, I think they are just a bit blinkered and yes they can be a bit selfish, it probably is about their enjoyment more than anything else.

OP posts:
MarinoRoyale · 26/08/2022 14:45

I’d tell them they either treat both children the same in terms of treats/one-on-one time or they see neither. Your youngest DD will be picking up that they’re playing favourites not in her favour and that can be devastating for self esteem.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 14:43

I'm sorry you went through that.

It's definitely lessened but more because of my actions. They are still trying to make the plans and I'm just blocking them in reality so I guess I need to tackle it head on at the source.

I don't want them to think it's just because of youngest DD though, I think if I'm going to have the conversation I need to tackle the full issue which is also that they aren't taking myself or my husband into account. I maybe need to tell them that I had to cancel my birthday plans with DD because they got in their first and that actually that isn't ok.

I'm not very good at instigating difficult conversations in my private life, irony being I basically have difficult conversations for a living. I find it easier to respond to a specific situation rather than raise the issue as a whole. I will though because I know it needs addressed as the dealing with each individual thing at the time doesn't seem to be working.

OP posts:
Iceballoons · 26/08/2022 14:41

All of this is so disrespectful towards you.

I agree all plans need to be run past you first….try to explain to dd in an age appropriate way if you can.

I think you need to tell them this as well. It’s nice that they want to be involved but you are the parents so all plans run past you first before mentioning to dc and your other dc must be regularly included too so as not to feel left out.

if it continues after that, I’d look at reducing contact with them. They sound a bit crazy, I don’t know of anyone who would behave that way with someone else’s children even if they are family!!

billy1966 · 26/08/2022 14:38

BreatheAndFocus · 26/08/2022 13:46

I can understand your concerns, OP. She does sound like she’s playing parent with your DD. You’ve asked her to run things past you first and she’s ignored you on purpose. I’d never in a million years do that with my nieces. It’s up to the parents and all requests should be run past the parents first with no mention to any DC involved. That’s commonsense.

I’d distance myself from them a bit, and if they asked why I’d tell them. It’s disrespectful, undermining and interfering quite frankly.

I agree with this.

I actually don't think they are that nice at all.

They complete ignore your request and repeatedly exclude your younger child.

Kindly meant OP, but your boundaries are very poor.

You really should not be tolerating such interference in your parenting.

The best of both worlds comment is striking, this is all about THEIR needs being met by one of YOUR children.

I wouldn't have tolerated this for a minute.

I would take firm action now.
This is only going to go one way during the teen years with aunty buying her clothes, make up, concert tickets and happily edging you out whilst she has the best of both worlds.

She could care less about you and your relationship with YOUR child.

I am not suggesting for a minute a respectful relationship isn't lovely or that your child is your procession, but they do not care about anything but their needs being met.

Absolutely not on IMO.

Treemouser · 26/08/2022 14:37

it does sound like it will be a difficult conversation but if you come from the younger daughter angle and they still carry on I'd take a very dim view and perhaps be forced to put a stop to it. I'd give them a chance to change first though.

My mother had a best friend who loved taking my older sister out for treats and never once did anything with me. I can still remember the horrible feeling wondering why she didn't like me, what was wrong with me and so on. I wish my parents had taken some action, or validated my feelings, rather than glossing over it to save awkwardness (not saying you are glossing, just that's what they did and it made it worse that it wasn't even acknowledged properly).

mbosnz · 26/08/2022 14:30

To me, loving someone else's child means being respectful as their role as the parents - the ones doing all the hard yakka, and supporting that, rather than undermining it. So, asking if it's possible to do such and such, rather than arranging it and presenting it as a fait accompli, supporting and enhancing sibling relationships, rather than playing favourites, being aware and respectful that Mum and Dad want to be the ones to do the special events, buy the special presents, and being very careful not to tread on those very well earned toes! Asking whether a gift is appropriate, or maybe they could suggest something more appropriate, if not. . .

A child isn't a plaything, or a pet, and I would never thank anyone for treating mine as such.

perimenofertility · 26/08/2022 14:22

Every time you have to say no to your DD I would make it clear to her that the reason you are saying no is because aunty and uncle have not arranged it with you. Make it obvious it's their fault not yours, don't become the bad one!
Then every time they ask to do something with older dd I would only agree to it if an arrangement is also made for younger dd - doesn't have to be the same thing, but should be similar timeframe. I'd be strict that either both girls get a treat/outing or neither of them do.
It's lovely they are so invested as aunty and uncle, but set your boundaries.

Penguinfeather781 · 26/08/2022 14:08

The “best of both worlds” comment would really really get my hackles up. No, you absolutely don’t get to play at being a parent with my child and you don’t get to push in and grab the “best bits”. Of course you can have a great relationship with children that aren’t your own, but it’s not a parental relationship and it’s really not possible to have all the lovely bits of having children without any of the responsibilities. My family and friends are more than welcome to special time with my children, I’m thrilled they have loving adults in their lives, but DH and I expect to be respected as their parents. And I expect equal effort with both children.

I think you need a very blunt conversation OP.

CoorieIn · 26/08/2022 14:07

Runningslow it's actually more the other way around.

Thankfully DD2 is young enough that we've fudged over it for the most part and made a big fuss of her but then the flip side is DD1 feeling left out of family plans. Like we waited for her to be away to do something really fun that she also would have liked to do with us.

Latterly it was noticed a couple of times by DD2 which is when I really put my foot down. She's an awesome wee kid and I don't want her feeling left out by them.

OP posts: