Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it possible as a state school parent to emulate a private school education & how would a motivated one start?

278 replies

Superspender · 26/08/2022 12:05

This thread is triggered from all the recent press about the Cambridges & Lambrook press.. Basically the press are harping on about the time spent outdoors etc, surely parents can do this for free etc.. Out of interest how can a motivated parent who can't afford private school emulate a private school education? Please be kind!

OP posts:
dottiedodah · 26/08/2022 13:42

I think some state schools are outstanding. My old primary in london taught French at 9 , had trips abroad chess club and lots of sport..my sons secondary school had sport every day ., trips skiing and USA, and my son loved it .and thrived had a tutor .went to rg uni and did well

fyn · 26/08/2022 13:41

An organisation that I’ve found that helps to give children confidence is Young Farmers. It mixes across social groups as you get everybody from the local estate owners children to the farm labourers children. You don’t need to know anything about farming really!

They do a huge variety of activities, some obviously farming based but also things like public speaking training and competitions, drama performances, rural crafts, ski trips, cultural exchange trips and balls.

byvirtue · 26/08/2022 13:41

My mother was privately educated but as a teacher was against private education. That said I think she replicated the extra curricular aspect of private school fairly well for me so I was able to get a job post university where 90% of the intake was privately educated, I also married someone who was privately educated.

Things I did as a child:
Ballet (exams)
Rainbows, Brownies, Guides
Swimming (exams)
Music (theory, exams, various instruments, junior orchestra)
Travel (UK and abroad)
French lessons (primary school)
Tutors (GCSE)
Sports clubs (school holidays)
Regular theatre trips, mostly Ballet
Took me to relevant museums/historical places of interest eg.learning about the tudors took me to Hever Castle
Took me to expensive restaurants, behavioural expectations were set out in advance.
Corrected my language, everyone I went to school with had a local accent I was good at mimicking it but it wasn’t really tolerated at home.
Paid for me to go on extracurricular school trips abroad.
Never said no to buying me books. I read a lot and it was always encouraged.
University discussed from an early age.
Talked a lot to me about my future, (professional) jobs I could do and what I would need to achieve at school to get there
Incentivised me to work hard at school ( especially secondary school where working hard was not “cool”).
Generally very supportive, eg. Buying art materials/books when I was really interested in drawing/painting

Holly60 · 26/08/2022 13:37

I would say yes a lot of it is cultural capital and the people they mix with.

So pay for private Latin lessons

Get boys into cricket or rugby not football. Girls find a hockey or lacrosse. Also horse riding

Get them skiing.

Visit lots of culturally rich places.

Holiday every year even if it's camping in France.

Debate clubs and lectures is a great idea.

It's a language you want to teach them to speak.

longestlurkerever · 26/08/2022 13:37

In my area there is quite a lot out there if you look hard. I'm on my way to fetch my daughter from songwriting camp (free for some reason) and theatre camp (£100 for a week which paid for with childcare vouchers). This summer they have also done woodcraft camp (£100 a year) and tennis (free) and watersports (£100 a year) all subsidised by the council. They're not well advertised though - I do quite a bit of internet research and share everything I find on the class WhatsApp group and others do too. We've also done the free museums. It's not the same as private school but then I think their state school education brings a lot to the table as well.

Eeksteek · 26/08/2022 13:36

Hollyhead · 26/08/2022 12:56

@Anewdayanewdawn I agree reading is important, I have 2 dc who are good readers for their ages but simply not interested, it actually pains me as i was and still am a keen reader. It’s not screens either - they’re restricted and I’d say have a healthy relationship with them, they’d both literally rather roll around saying their bored than reading a book!

Me too. Houseful of books and the bloody kid hasn’t voluntarily opened one for years. AND her bloody teachers praise her reading level and wide range of knowledge. I think it’s because we travel and generally do things (or did, until she hit 11 and practically refused to be seen with me!).

eatingapie · 26/08/2022 13:36

Also I think the contacts thing is a bit overrated unless you are literally at Bedales, Harrow, Eton etc. you’re not moving with the big shakers in a rural market town 6th form 😂

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 13:36

MsTSwift · 26/08/2022 13:28

Not sure the buying access to suitable families works for teens - those pesky kids all socialise together state and private in our small city 😁. They are entirely interchangeable to the naked eye!

🤣

Tbh, I think parents are misguided if they go private with the intention of buying a "better" peer group. I remember being horrified at 18 when my gap year friend told me about all that they had got up to at her big name boarding school, it made my state comprehensive friends seem very tame indeed! And two of our local private schools are well known for having significant problems with drugs, while another got a lot of negative publicity for racist bullying. There will be good and bad kids in any school, and you're better off giving your kids the values to stay away from them than trying to buy them a problem-free peer group.

eatingapie · 26/08/2022 13:34

Also I always come across like a doom monger about private schools on threads like these - so with the caveat that I have already said they are very diverse - the lack of pastoral care my friends experienced in one private school was absolutely shocking. It was a while ago now but locally there is not reason to think it’s changed much and it all seems to get hidden under the ‘competitive spirit’ banner. It was way, way beyond the level of bullying I have seen tolerated in the state sector. Also SEND provision is just as patchy as in the state sector 🤷🏻‍♀️

jellybeanteaparty · 26/08/2022 13:31

Anything that helps with confidence and develops a love of learning. Agree that hobbies that can be competitive or require speaking/debating/performing can be useful. Experience of as wide range of things as possible.

MsTSwift · 26/08/2022 13:28

Not sure the buying access to suitable families works for teens - those pesky kids all socialise together state and private in our small city 😁. They are entirely interchangeable to the naked eye!

Etinoxaurus · 26/08/2022 13:25

Where do you live? Harder to do in Middlesbrough than London or Winchester 😟

XingMing · 26/08/2022 13:25

My child attended both state and private schools. The education received at the two state schools was mainly social, because the academic standards were woeful. The social ease acquired from meeting all sorts of people, across the whole spectrum, is of immense life-long value.

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 13:25

XingMing · 26/08/2022 13:19

LAMDA is good for public confidence, and achieving a distinction at Gold level adds nearly as many UCAS points as a good fourth A level grade.

The real bonuses of private education is @mdh2020 point that there is a competitive element so pupils work to be among the high flyers, and there's no tolerance of disruption.

The real benefit of state education for my dd has been that she has learned to define her successes not in terms of how she has performed in comparison to other people, but rather in terms of whether she has fulfilled her own potential. And she has also learned that there might be many reasons why kids may be disruptive, and to have a little empathy for people who might not have had the same advantages that she has.

Ultimately, it boils down to values at the end of the day, and what you consider to be most important.

eatingapie · 26/08/2022 13:24

Private schools are very different from each other so you have to identify what you think you want - in the town where I grew up we had three ; one was for sporty not- that - bright kids (as we would have thought at the time!) one was academic but pretentious (and my god did that school fuck up the young men who went there - bitter experience) and one was for the ‘arrivistes’ as it were and it was pointlessly exclusive. My state college got more into Oxbridge than those combined.

I think it’s worth asking what you want out of your children a education overall, ie. Do you want confidence and resilience, in which case sport/drama/dance etc could extend that or do you think the option of going to Oxbridge would be the best outcome in which case read and keep reading. Or do you want them to have a more holistic education, outdoors, various non- academic options and be happy in school above all? This seems to be the Lambrook selling point. Tbh I think the last one of the one you are least able to replicate in a state school, sadly. Average performing, bit hippyish but conservatively so, outdoorsy schools seem to only exist in the private sector these days ☹️ I guess take up as many outdoor pursuits as you can afford if that’s what you want.

Maireas · 26/08/2022 13:22

XingMing · 26/08/2022 13:19

LAMDA is good for public confidence, and achieving a distinction at Gold level adds nearly as many UCAS points as a good fourth A level grade.

The real bonuses of private education is @mdh2020 point that there is a competitive element so pupils work to be among the high flyers, and there's no tolerance of disruption.

Do you think most state schools tolerate disruption? Or do we do our best to be inclusive of all students whatever their personal, social and educational issues?

absolutelyknackeredcow · 26/08/2022 13:21

Absolutely agree @Anothernamechangeplease -

XingMing · 26/08/2022 13:19

LAMDA is good for public confidence, and achieving a distinction at Gold level adds nearly as many UCAS points as a good fourth A level grade.

The real bonuses of private education is @mdh2020 point that there is a competitive element so pupils work to be among the high flyers, and there's no tolerance of disruption.

absolutelyknackeredcow · 26/08/2022 13:19

Not a stealth boast but we could afford to go private but don't because we don't agree with it.

We live in a diverse part of London, the children have gone to a state primary. They have outside learning all the time, at least twice a week, there is compulsory chess, huge range of clubs, and a focus on cooking alongside the academics.
Both children swim, do drama, play a musical instrument and do Brownies / Guides out of school.

But critically, we both have interesting jobs so the children are exposed to lots of different experiences.

I don't really think of trying to emulate private school experience, but I do think about raising confident happy children who have the opportunity to follow their interests

Anothernamechangeplease · 26/08/2022 13:17

Ineedtoletgo83 · 26/08/2022 13:10

Honestly as PPs. But you’re buying the people. Living in an affluent area I see great State schools but the Private schools still have a different ‘class’ of people. Although I’d say in our area it’s a lot about choices as well.

i think main issue is at secondary school. Move to a good secondary school area is your best bet and do music and sport outside of school. Vary the people you mix with too from all levels of society if possible .

The different "class" of people is exactly why we chose state over private in the end. DD has learned so much more as a result of not being in that very narrow socio-economic bubble that tends to dominate in private schools.

Ineedtoletgo83 · 26/08/2022 13:10

Honestly as PPs. But you’re buying the people. Living in an affluent area I see great State schools but the Private schools still have a different ‘class’ of people. Although I’d say in our area it’s a lot about choices as well.

i think main issue is at secondary school. Move to a good secondary school area is your best bet and do music and sport outside of school. Vary the people you mix with too from all levels of society if possible .

solarbirdscalm · 26/08/2022 13:07

No school suits all children!

solarbirdscalm · 26/08/2022 13:06

You are asking the wrong question. It should be how do I give my children the best possible education. Just because you pay for private schooling doesn't necessarily make it better than the state version, it just means it's more socially exclusive. My son's state secondary is very like the private school I went to and the selective grammar DH went to. Bigger class sizes yes, and architecturally the building is less attractive, but that's about the only obvious difference. There are some great state schools and there are some crap private schools, and school suits all children even if it does great for most of them. Offer enrichment at home definitely, but don't do it in a wierd attempt to copy a private school education.

crosstalk · 26/08/2022 13:06

I would, if you can, encourage public speaking or drama. It does give kids confidence.

mdh2020 · 26/08/2022 13:05

Make sure you read to them even in yr6
encourage them to read
talk to them about current affairs
do science/ nature study with them
take them to galleries, exhibitions, theatre if you can
encourage them to have enquiring minds

what they miss out on is being in an environment where everyone is bright and working hard. DS thrived on the competition.
the one thing that private education does buy is self confidence. DS also came away with a group of friends , literally, for life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread