Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it unusual for young children to have strong relationships with grandparents?

66 replies

bluebottle1 · 26/08/2022 10:14

I saw a post last night on Facebook from a parenting/baby group I'm in, not something I engage with but I was interested to read this one. There was a post from a SAHM with a partner with who away and the post said that the in laws had offered to have her 2 year old daughter to allow her to have some time to herself. In the post she said she didn't have children for her to palm them off on other people to look after them and it was her job to look after the child 24/7 no matter if some days are a bit tough. There was hundreds of comments saying that they all agreed with this and that they had also never spent anytime away from their children and they had never stayed with grandparents or spent much time with them. Majority of it was related to children 1-4 rather than young babies. Apparently this is modern parenting and young children only need there mum, dad and a few friends. There was only one comment I read amongst the hundreds that suggested it might be a good idea to get the child looked after in preparation for nursery.

I also have a partner who works away and by Friday I definitely need a break and hand DS over to DP to do the majority of parenting over the weekend. I think I would burn out otherwise. I'm due back to work next week after maternity leave and my almost 11 month old will be spending 2 days a week with my parents or DP's mum when she is off work.M, the other day he will be with a childminder. I don't have the best relationship with MIL but she is a good grandparent. Is this really uncommon now? Do your children spend much time with grandparents? Obviously this question is for those who have reasonable parents/in-laws not those who are totally in-interested in there grandchildren. I was thinking about it last night and I don't know why but seeing the hundreds of comments has now got me feeling guilty almost as if this is totally unusual and that I shouldn't feel like I need a break. I had a lovely relationship with my grandparents growing up so wouldn't prevent my son from having the same. Don't get me wrong DS has never had a night away from us and we don't plan on that anytime soon but for a few hours I didn't think there was an issue.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OnaBegonia · 26/08/2022 14:16

Only on MN have I come across these parents who never slow their kids to stay with family and won't leave a 16yr old alone for an hour.

Cinnamonandcoal · 26/08/2022 14:10

My daughter is spending this week with my parents in law and my son will be staying with my parents tonight.

What's not to like?!

Lcb123 · 26/08/2022 13:48

Depends totally on the children/parents/grandparents, and other factors like how close grandparents live, but I honestly think it's so nice if care can be shared, if it works well for everyone! Mum having a break will surely benefit the child as they will be rested and energised when the child comes back

Mommabear20 · 26/08/2022 13:47

Personally, I think it is mine or DH responsibility to look after DC 24/7, and we cringe when we have to ask for childcare (medical appointments etc) BUT if GP want and ask to have them, fine by me! I love that my DC have a good strong relationship with their GP! There's a big difference between taking responsibility and being controlling IMO.

greenvelvetcouch · 26/08/2022 13:33

To be honest I only know one person who has lots of help from their parents with their child, because they still live in the same village we grew up in and so does her parents. All my friends and family with young children live at least an hour away from their parents/in-laws so don’t have regular childcare. Obviously some see grandparents for visits more than others and I don’t think physical proximity is a barrier to children having close relationships with grandparents (from my own experience.)

I often wonder if it’s a class/education level identifier these days - if you move away from home for uni and never go back because you get graduate jobs in cities and stay there for at least the early child rearing years, you don’t have grandparent support. Most of my friends and peers are in this group and in the same situation as us. I love it though, wouldn’t want to raise my child with our extended families all on the same street.

Jayne35 · 26/08/2022 13:20

My Mum first had DD overnight when she was 2 weeks old, and she stayed regularly with my parents as a child. Mum is now a widow and she and DD (who is 25) are like best friends, when we go away they share a room and regularly spend time together. I don't feel that it has hurt my relationship with DD in any way.

mdh2020 · 26/08/2022 13:09

DD stayed with my parents overnight once she slept through at about 6 months. I’m afraid I was always happy to leave them with their grandparents and when they were a little older we did lots of sleepovers. I think children need relationships with other adults. DS and I are extremely close and I have great, strong bonds with GC

Celia24 · 26/08/2022 13:09

I had a very close relationship with my grandparents. My parents divorced when I was young and my mother relied on them while she worked.

I went to their house after school until I was 12.

To be honest when my grandad died it was like losing another father in a way.

Dilbertian · 26/08/2022 13:04

So, my parents will have their dgc pretty much any time. I know they'll be spoilt rotten and experience things I may not give them.

My ILs OTOH have babysat twice in over 20y, and the first time a grandchild stayed over night without us was ds when he was at uni.

My dh was confused by my parents' willingness, even eagerness, to help out, just as I am confused by my ILs cool detachment.

Fe345fleur · 26/08/2022 13:02

I really wish my DD had more GPs and other family to spend time with. Not necessary for help with childcare, more that it would be good for her development. My DSD is a very well rounded kid and I think some of that is from spending time in a big loving family, with GPs, aunts, cousins etc. She is comfortable with and can relate to different types of people.

Dilbertian · 26/08/2022 12:58

Maybe this attitude reflects peoples relationships with their own parents/grandparents.

My parents emigrated, so we grew up 1000s of miles from our grandparents and extended family. Nonetheless, one set were as involved as possible in our childhoods and my parents did not hesitate to let us stay with them whenever possible. But there was a big difference between the two sets of grandparents, one set being far more hands-on and welcoming than the other. And the child of the more distant grandparents was much closer to their in-laws than to their parents.

Children thrive on having lots of people to love, cherish and safeguard them.

hummerbird · 26/08/2022 12:50

We all enjoyed that both GP from both sides were willing to have our darlings.
They had a different life. We lived in a large village so nearly always in the car.
My DPs lived in a small city and were taken into town on the bus. Were able to go on buses by themselves when old enough. Shopping was partly a market whereas we went to local sop or Superstore.
These sound small but when 3 or 4 a big green bus is an adventure.
As they say "it takes the village".

BaileySharp · 26/08/2022 12:30

DD loves going to her grandparents. They do some childcare for me abd she even sleeps over sometimes. I even have had family babysit when she was a very young baby! I think some people get a bit weirdly self sacrificial on this. It's takes a village and I'm happy for my family to help out. She has a wonderful bond with them as a result. How could it be bad?

UWhatNow · 26/08/2022 12:24

We made sure our children had a great bond with their grandparents and I think it’s a bit of an own goal for parents to restrict that. Children bloom and thrive around the love and attention of extended family. Why would you want to stunt that by never letting grandparents spend one-to-one time with your kids? And the bonus is that you get must needed respite even if it’s only an hour to yourself or time to do the big shop in peace? Seems a backward or thick philosophy to me. Or trying to cover up for poor family relationships?

StaunchMomma · 26/08/2022 12:16

Unfortunately lots of us have parents who are still working and there's no way I'd allow them to use their only time off to look after grandkids.

I spent most weekends at my Nan & Grandad's as a kid and absolutely loved it but my Nan was a SAHM and didn't work from the time of having her first child. My Mum only gets Sundays off and she needs it to chill and do chores.

My friends' kids who stay with grandparents only do so if they are retired, really.

ancientgran · 26/08/2022 12:05

I spent lots of time at my grans when I was young, my kids were very close to my mother and 4 of my 6 GC are very close to me, spend lots of time here and one lives with me. If circumstances allow I think a GP/GC relationship is a very valuable thing, obviously it isn't always possible and that is OK as well.

Sswhinesthebest · 26/08/2022 12:00

My grown up kids have amazing relationships with their Gp’s. I was a sahm but they had them for occasional night/weekends, for the sake of their own relationships as well as giving us much needed time for a break and as a couple.

Woodandsky · 26/08/2022 11:54

When my kids were little my parents lived a long way off and for various reasons we didn't really trust DH's parents to look after them (smoking, 'who needs a carseat' kind of comments). But I did work 3 days a week so they did get to see other people and I got a 'break'. I also felt that it was my job to look after them every second I wasn't working, it was exhausting.

Now that I'm a grandma I look after my 2 year old grandson once a week overnight as do his other grandparents. I can see how much he gets from that and how the 3 sets of people that look after him really add so much to his life and feel that my kids (and I) missed out. His parents are quite young and his mum has a disability so for them to have a break and just be young people too is great for them.

So yes I think contact with extended family can be great for everyone.

NatMoz · 26/08/2022 11:51

Maybe it's different for SAHM but when i return to work from maternity in December, my parents will look after baby 1 day a week.

We're going on holiday tomorrow and my parents will be there too and they have insisted on spending time with baby. We might even get our first meal out just the two of us since baby was born!!!

ILoveYoga · 26/08/2022 11:49

I grew up with two very different sets of grandparents. But both enjoyed having us as children come and visit on our own. I loved my time with them so much so that my one grandmother and I were more like very close friends as I became an adult. We would book theatre together, shared hobbies and travelled together just us two. She was a hoot. Loved her dearly and so happy I got to know her as a person (when I was an adult). Those early years really laid the ground work for our ult relationship.

miss her dearly.

Spikeyball · 26/08/2022 11:44

My ds adored his paternal grandparents. They were not able to look after him on their own beyond him being very young because of his additional needs and their increasing ill health but I know his grandfather in particular got a lot of joy out of being with him. They are both sadly no longer with us.

Danceswithkids · 26/08/2022 11:42

findingsomeone · 26/08/2022 11:13

I think your conflating different issues. 'Is it unusual for children to have strong relationships with GPs?' No. But do children need to be looked after regularly alone by their GPs to have strong relationships? Also no.

I had strong relationships with my GPs and I only saw them once every three months because they lived three hours away.

This. People acting like grandparents can only have a good relationship with their kids if they also do childcare is also just a way of justifying their choice to need childcare.

My kids have a fantastic relationship with their grandparents, love them to bits, visit all the time, go on holiday together, video call them when we can't see them etc. But my parents have never done 'childcare' for us or had the kids stay overnight without me also staying overnight. It's just not necessary.

lizziesiddal79 · 26/08/2022 11:33

Yes, our daughter sleeps over at both sets of grandparents and her aunt/uncles. I would say it increased after age 3 or 4 though.

bluebottle1 · 26/08/2022 11:31

It's great to hear others with children who have a lovely relationship with their grandparents. I thought I'd struggle going back to work but now I feel ready and confident knowing he is going to be well looked after, I also feel like it will make our days off more special rather than me taking it for granted.

OP posts:
Ragwort · 26/08/2022 11:30

My DS had/has a wonderful relationship with his DGPs ... they didn't live near but are still very close. They couldn't do routine childcare due to being 250 miles away but would host us and visit us. They would come and stay if we needed babysitting to attend a wedding for example - if it was convenient for them, I would never expect it. It's such a special relationship and even now at 21 DS will go out with my DM (90!) for lunch and invite her to watch his cricket matches. We are just arranging a weekend away to visit him at Uni Grin she's looking forward to it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread