Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL Anniversary upset - have we done wrong?

83 replies

CharChar91 · 26/08/2022 09:08

For context, approx 2 years ago my MIL cheated on her husband of 38 years with an old flame from Malta on a 2 week lone 'holiday'. The next January she announced she was going to move there with him. Broke FIL's heart, obviously. Large house was sold (their retirement fund) and she took well over half the money. She went, she's been flitting back and forth between her two lives since.
Family is ruptured, there are a lot of big feelings and arguements. FIL has done amazingly well but being in love with her and the laid back man he is he allows her to stay with him when she's 'home' (he even gives up his bed for her and sleeps in the spare, single bed). He bought a 'doer-upper' cash with his money and has gone back to work to top up his state pension to live and fund renovations.
Divorce proceedings were started, neither have signed the final paperwork yet but it's not openly discussed.
Shock, the grass wasn't greener. MIL has broken up with new man (following his prostate cancer and subsequent undiagnosed depression) and returned. She's staying with FIL.
They came round for lunch on Saturday, awkward but we just leave the subject as the elephant in the room to avoid conflict. We all had a nice time. It happened to be their wedding anniversary but for obvious reasons we didn't say anything, despite MIL making a point of the dste.
My partner went round yesterday to see MIL. She was upset that we didn't mention or celebrate??/mark the occasion. Partner laughed out loud in disbelief. She was cross and it's another way her children don't appreciate her/respect her etc etc.

He came home and spoke to me last night and we can't see that we were in the wrong? If we had mentioned it on the day would that now have been an awkward and disrespectful thing to say?
So fed up of the whole situation and subsequent drama for 2 years, it's so draining.
Have we been unreasonable for not acknowledging their anniversary?

OP posts:
SammyScrounge · 26/08/2022 11:20

KyaClark · 26/08/2022 09:22

She probably wants to come back and pretend it never happened.

I agree. She's obviously trying to be the centre of family life again and celebrating the anniversary would be a proof that you all felt the same . It wouldn't occur to her that you might see your father as her victim and celebrating the anniversary as hopelessly distasteful . Someone should put her straight

Zilla1 · 26/08/2022 11:20

She could be completely delusional in convincing herself she's done nothing wrong and/or trying a process of enforcing the reality she wants - if she convinces you about her anniversary and marriage then she can convince her husband they are still married and he should halt the divorce. Steve Jobs' reality distortion field though this can be breached by laughter and incredulity hence she can escalate with anger. Continue encouraging your FIL to divorce and on better terms and ask him if he'd had the prostate cancer whether he'd have been dumped or worse, divorce delayed so she'd have the whole of his estate? Have not read the thread but presumably she's always been self-centred?

Floralnomad · 26/08/2022 11:19

The MIL is crackers and the FIL is a mug. YANBU .

AmyDudley · 26/08/2022 11:15

Anniversaries are to celebrate a marriage and therefore marriage vows. She broke her marriage vows.
And you earn respect, by decent behaviour, cheating is not decent behaviour. Trust and respect are privileges that she will have to work very hard to win back if she is to integrate into the family again.
IMO if you bugger off, cheat on your husband, fuck up your family and cause huge amount of hurt, financial hardship and general mayhem, then if you decide to come back you come back with your tail beteen your legs asking for forgiveness, not demanding anniversary celebrations and respect.
She needs a big dose of self awareness - what an embarrassing fool she is.

Luredbyapomegranate · 26/08/2022 10:57

Why would you give two hoots what this woman thinks? Focus onsupporting your FIL

Brideandpredjudice · 26/08/2022 10:52

To be honest I couldn't have anything to do with her personally

REP22 · 26/08/2022 10:48

Your partner was spot-on. That would have been my reaction too. To have mentioned it at the time would have been crass and insensitive. Probably also deeply distressing to an already wounded FIL. I feel so sorry for him, and for you and your partner. Just awful.

If it wasn't for FIL, I would suggest going no (or very low) contact with MIL. There is likely to be plenty more hassle of the bat-guano sort to come. Look out for further affairs, online dating (both discreet and al-fresco varieties) and detailed descriptions of things she's "treated herself to" from Ann Summers and Lovehoney. Trust me, there is no scouring pad on Earth strident enough to scrub those mental images from your mind... I'm sorry.

All you can really do is quietly support and be there for FIL and not engage with MIL's nonsense. But you have most certainly not done wrong.

Best wishes to you.

MsRosley · 26/08/2022 10:48

AnnaFri · 26/08/2022 09:54

Tbh that's almost as weird

That you don't know when your own parents wedding anniversary is

Confused

I don't even know when my own wedding anniversary is. Not everyone is obsessed by marking their bloody wedding!

MsRosley · 26/08/2022 10:45

Has your MIL always been a batshit gaslighting narcissist?

MulberryMoon · 26/08/2022 10:44

Laughing like your husband did is the only appropriate response really

Namechangehereandnow · 26/08/2022 10:43

Honestly I’d be telling her straight, no more elephant in the room. It needs to be mentioned to enable you all to move forward.

Mum/MIL we know you’re back, what you did was unforgivable, dad/FIL may accept it be we won’t. We respect dads decision to have you back in his life, but we can’t return to how things used to be. You do you, we’ll do us. 🤷‍♀️

Wombat27A · 26/08/2022 10:36

Yep, you can't win here. Whatever you did or didn't do would be wrong.

It's classic "nothing to see here, la, la, la". It's verging on gaslighting, possibly.

MeridianB · 26/08/2022 10:36

You and DP are completely in the right. And you can show Shirley Valentine this thread if she doesn't believe you.

Your poor FIL - it would be lovely for him to meet someone who really cares for him and can brighten his life.

Has DP ever questioned his mum's behaviour with her? Is she getting away with being selfish because everyone's too polite to say anything or has your FIL asked people to leave it? I'd be worried she will put off the divorce, casually move back with FIL, then do the whole thing again in a year from now with someone else.

Mumspair1 · 26/08/2022 10:35

Nah she is a nasty, vile piece of scum for doing that and deserves nothing. In fact she should be grateful that her children even have anything to do with her. Great that your dp laughed in her face. Unbelievable how people who do things like this think the world still revolves around them.

MILLYmo0se · 26/08/2022 10:34

'no Mum we dont respect you, you use men and ditch them when you think you have a better offer, and you dont care what the fallout is for your children in the midst of it all. Stop looking for respect when you have demonstrated that you have none for any of us' 😏
Your FIL isnt going to sign the divorce papers is he

Bonheurdupasse · 26/08/2022 10:32

Lobelia123 · 26/08/2022 10:10

Shes so obvious. Her affair crashed and burned and now she just wants to go back to the safe comfortable old life where everyne adored and respected her, and you're all supposed to work with her to build up the fiction of perfect mum again who is the centre of the family and family life, completely disregarding the part she played in blowing it all to hell, humiliating and hurting her husband, making a fool of herself and destroying the financial security it took a lifetime to build. Unfortunately for her you are not idiots and didnt play along so she can rugsweep.

This OP.

Also just out of curiosity - how come she got well over half the money? Did she put in more assets over time? I thought the general rule was 50/50.

Pamlar · 26/08/2022 10:31

How awful for you and the rest of the family.
I hope you are able to avoid or distance yourself from her.

EL8888 · 26/08/2022 10:27

She is being totally unreasonable. Her behaviour has been dreadful. Poor FIL. I would give it to her straight. Why should you respect her terrible and disrespectful behaviour?

Topseyt123 · 26/08/2022 10:26

Crikey, your MIL sounds like an arse. She also sounds spectacularly dim and delusional.

Of course you weren't being unreasonable not to mention the anniversary. I think your partner handled it perfectly, laughing at her.

I'd be tempted to tell her that her shitty behaviour has earned her contempt rather than respect, and I'd possibly also tell her that it was tough if she didn't like hearing the truth.

DiscontinuedModelHusband · 26/08/2022 10:24

it sounds to me a little like she doesn't really realise the consequences of her decision properly.

even if FIL also wants things to get back to how they were, MIL still needs to have it made clear that what she did caused a huge impact in all your lives (particularly FIL), and that she's going to have to work extremely hard to prove herself to you all again.

if she's genuinely embarrassed and remorseful (which she might be, despite this behaviour), she'll know what to she has to do.

if she's not, making it clear how you all feel is still the right thing to do.

hewouldwouldnthe · 26/08/2022 10:23

She sounds a bit of a narcissist (me, me, me, all about me). Just support FIL and ignore her shit.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 26/08/2022 10:12

You absolutely did the right thing. It's called tact, you have it and she doesn't. In those circumstances, it was absolutely correct to say nothing unless they themselves brought it up.

You are not telepaths. You had no idea how she would have taken a reference to it, or how your FIL would and why risk spoiling a delicate get-together?
If they had you would probably have offered polite congratulations.

What a drama she is creating. It is a sad situation for your FIL tho.

I think her comments to you illustrate that you should be very confident in your own judgement, which seems sound, when you are dealing with her and avoid being drawn into future issues that you don't agree with.

Crappydoo · 26/08/2022 10:10

Of all the CFs she really does take the cake. YABU for not recognising her services for CFuckery! Is she actually for real? Ghast well and truly flabbered. I'm only assuming the 1% that said YABU did it by mistake

Lobelia123 · 26/08/2022 10:10

Shes so obvious. Her affair crashed and burned and now she just wants to go back to the safe comfortable old life where everyne adored and respected her, and you're all supposed to work with her to build up the fiction of perfect mum again who is the centre of the family and family life, completely disregarding the part she played in blowing it all to hell, humiliating and hurting her husband, making a fool of herself and destroying the financial security it took a lifetime to build. Unfortunately for her you are not idiots and didnt play along so she can rugsweep.

caringcarer · 26/08/2022 10:08

Your poor fil. Mil sounds horrible.