Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL Anniversary upset - have we done wrong?

83 replies

CharChar91 · 26/08/2022 09:08

For context, approx 2 years ago my MIL cheated on her husband of 38 years with an old flame from Malta on a 2 week lone 'holiday'. The next January she announced she was going to move there with him. Broke FIL's heart, obviously. Large house was sold (their retirement fund) and she took well over half the money. She went, she's been flitting back and forth between her two lives since.
Family is ruptured, there are a lot of big feelings and arguements. FIL has done amazingly well but being in love with her and the laid back man he is he allows her to stay with him when she's 'home' (he even gives up his bed for her and sleeps in the spare, single bed). He bought a 'doer-upper' cash with his money and has gone back to work to top up his state pension to live and fund renovations.
Divorce proceedings were started, neither have signed the final paperwork yet but it's not openly discussed.
Shock, the grass wasn't greener. MIL has broken up with new man (following his prostate cancer and subsequent undiagnosed depression) and returned. She's staying with FIL.
They came round for lunch on Saturday, awkward but we just leave the subject as the elephant in the room to avoid conflict. We all had a nice time. It happened to be their wedding anniversary but for obvious reasons we didn't say anything, despite MIL making a point of the dste.
My partner went round yesterday to see MIL. She was upset that we didn't mention or celebrate??/mark the occasion. Partner laughed out loud in disbelief. She was cross and it's another way her children don't appreciate her/respect her etc etc.

He came home and spoke to me last night and we can't see that we were in the wrong? If we had mentioned it on the day would that now have been an awkward and disrespectful thing to say?
So fed up of the whole situation and subsequent drama for 2 years, it's so draining.
Have we been unreasonable for not acknowledging their anniversary?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
forrestgreen · 26/08/2022 19:34

Next time say loudly 'it's a WEDDING anniversary, you can't celebrate that after you left for a year..!' And look at her like she's crazy (cos she is!)

billy1966 · 26/08/2022 19:24

AnneLovesGilbert · 26/08/2022 19:07

what I personally think is that the family should butt out and it's between her and your fil how they should proceed (or not) in their relationship

When you start airing your dirty laundry in public and kick off when they won’t celebrate a sham anniversary you lose the right to privacy.

Absolutely agree.

ErinAoife · 26/08/2022 19:16

Did her husband take her back? And in this case maybe they have decided that her affair did not exist and therefore their wedding anniversary is on.aa

AnneLovesGilbert · 26/08/2022 19:07

what I personally think is that the family should butt out and it's between her and your fil how they should proceed (or not) in their relationship

When you start airing your dirty laundry in public and kick off when they won’t celebrate a sham anniversary you lose the right to privacy.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/08/2022 18:27

Mintchervilpurslane · 26/08/2022 13:22

I am going to go against the grain here and say that your mil might be a hideous narcissist but there are two sides to every story in a long marriage , and while she sounds like a rl version of Bridget Jones's mother, she may have had legitimate reasons for being unhappy in her marriage, which prompted her recent poor behaviour. On the one hand it is great that your fil is laid back but living with an eternally passive man isn't always easy. I am not saying her actions were right but when pps refer to her "upsetting the family" what I personally think is that the family should butt out and it's between her and your fil how they should proceed (or not) in their relationship. Whatever you may think of her, she was married to your partner's father for 38 years, and surely that counts for something? I would not recommend a renewal of vows as every single couple I know who has done this has split up a year or so afterwards. If your dp had a problem with her protesting about not mentioning their anniversary, then he should have had the balls to say something then and there. Other than that, I would leave them alone to sort out their marriage in private.

I kind of agree @Mintchervilpurslane - but MiL has made your sensible approach impossible by demanding that her children congratulate her on her wedding anniversary, & then being performatively "upset" that they were too embarrassed to do so.

Mintchervilpurslane · 26/08/2022 13:22

I am going to go against the grain here and say that your mil might be a hideous narcissist but there are two sides to every story in a long marriage , and while she sounds like a rl version of Bridget Jones's mother, she may have had legitimate reasons for being unhappy in her marriage, which prompted her recent poor behaviour. On the one hand it is great that your fil is laid back but living with an eternally passive man isn't always easy. I am not saying her actions were right but when pps refer to her "upsetting the family" what I personally think is that the family should butt out and it's between her and your fil how they should proceed (or not) in their relationship. Whatever you may think of her, she was married to your partner's father for 38 years, and surely that counts for something? I would not recommend a renewal of vows as every single couple I know who has done this has split up a year or so afterwards. If your dp had a problem with her protesting about not mentioning their anniversary, then he should have had the balls to say something then and there. Other than that, I would leave them alone to sort out their marriage in private.

IncompleteSenten · 26/08/2022 13:03

Tell her you gave her marriage the amount of respect she has.

Zilla1 · 26/08/2022 13:01

Some people might find your MIL worthy of enormous respect for the sheer front of expecting everyone to ignore what she's done and and shaping her new narrative where whe's the heroine of her story while being unfaithful and taking most of the assets, arranging the 'holiday' while married and expecting everyone to pretend to believe they met by accident, dumping the BF when he developed cancer and trying to return to the FIL, all the time putting herself ahead of everyone else. Many psychopaths, sociopaths and narcissists would respect her absolutely during the annual get together.

startfresh · 26/08/2022 12:52

Whatwouldscullydo · 26/08/2022 09:15

Personally I believe wedding anniversaries are only something that matter to the married couple. Theres no need fir anyone to acknowledge or celebrate.

I mean wow your married . What's that got to do with me...

She sounds like a massive attention seeker amd you were right not to feed that.

Exactly this. I wouldn't mention my in laws anniversary - I don't even know the date of it. Same with my parents.

Anniversaries only matter to the couple.

Rowen32 · 26/08/2022 12:32

Oh my gosh, definitely not.. How could you in any capacity have wished them a happy anniversary? And have it not come across as a dig or sarcasm or making fun of the past. You were totally right to not bring it up, I'd be going right back to her and asking her is she having a laugh, does she really think a happy anniversary is warranted given what's happened and if she doesn't feel respected maybe there's a reason for that? Respect has to be earned.

Cindie943811A · 26/08/2022 12:32

Tell her she is back to square one.
Previous years don’t count — they need to renew their vows to start the clock ticking again.

Noodlesmumm · 26/08/2022 12:27

Apologies I pressed you are being unreasonable by mistake. You are definitely NOT being unreasonable. MIL sounds rather spoilt and entitled

MrsDrDear · 26/08/2022 12:23

She's a spoilt cow. FIL should tell her to GTF instead of pandering to her. He needs to get the divorce finalised pronto.

I would in no uncertain terms tell her to her face she's a selfish woman who has took the piss and it needs to stop. She'd get a sulk on but so what.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/08/2022 12:16

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 11:49

Your partner also needs to ensure that his father's finances are water tight in case she decides to make off again, especially if they are still married. Hopefully the money he rescued from family home is safe and the doer-upper is in his name alone, maybe encourage him to complete the divorce as she is clearly just using him as a money-pot.

Yes - it's obvious that she's using him for convenient & free accommodation.
Poor FiL.

KettrickenSmiled · 26/08/2022 12:15

She was upset that we didn't mention or celebrate??/mark the occasion. Partner laughed out loud in disbelief.
Well done that DP!

She was cross and it's another way her children don't appreciate her/respect her etc etc.
Ha ha MiL, good one! We appreciate & respect you just as much as you appreciate & respect our dad.

He came home and spoke to me last night and we can't see that we were in the wrong? If we had mentioned it on the day would that now have been an awkward and disrespectful thing to say?
Of course you're not in the wrong. MiL is a selfish brat who wanted you to paper over the cracks so she can feel better about herself. Who knows how FiL might have felt if you've done so? Awkward & disrespected, * would hazard. Like everyone's totally comfortable with MiL taking him for a ride.

So fed up of the whole situation and subsequent drama for 2 years, it's so draining.
If the silly bitch raises it again - do a DP & laugh full in her face. Long, & loud.

What's done is done, & it's your in-laws marriage & their choice of whether to now be together again. But she can't expect people to pretend it didn't happen, that FiL isn't wounded, or that he has had to abandon his retirement due to her.

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 11:54

She can't just pretend that the last 2 years hasn't happened and waltz in and play happy families

But women like her do exactly that, they seem to think that because she's changed her mind the whole family must worship her. My SIL left her husband twice because he worked too hard and was too interested in material stuff, she did her flit with most of the 'stuff' though! Eventually, after two splits and a divorce they got back together and at a family funeral she acted like Bobby Ewing, the last few years hadn't happened at all!

JudgeJ · 26/08/2022 11:49

Ponoka7 · 26/08/2022 09:11

I think that your partner should have been honest with her. Unless FIL is there, then you shouldn't be tiptoeing around her.

Your partner also needs to ensure that his father's finances are water tight in case she decides to make off again, especially if they are still married. Hopefully the money he rescued from family home is safe and the doer-upper is in his name alone, maybe encourage him to complete the divorce as she is clearly just using him as a money-pot.

3peassuit · 26/08/2022 11:47

She sounds awful. Your father in law sounds extremely tolerant. I would encourage him to crack on with the divorce and concentrate on his own happiness and well-being.

SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 11:46

CharChar91 · 26/08/2022 09:47

Thank you all for validating our feelings. It's been playing on my mind all night. I feel like we can't 'win' whatever we do/don't say/do. Not that there will ever be any winners in this situation!

Is your husband scared of his mum? In his place I'd have replied "there's a fucking good reason I didn't mention the anniversary..."

Seaweed42 · 26/08/2022 11:45

The best answer for this type of person is rather than defend yourself or refer to the content of the discussion say:

"It sounds like you think I have done something wrong."

and see what happens.

That tends to disarm them, because they see themselves as lovely kind caring sensitive people. They cannot see the emotional manipulating that they are doing.

Getting angry with them only adds fuel to their 'victim' drama where they think of themselves as the recipient of other people's poor behaviour.

That gentle accusation can work well because you are letting them know how how they are coming across. And they aren't aware of how they are coming across because they are steeped in the drama of their own hurt feelings.

CatherinedeBourgh · 26/08/2022 11:44

MsRosley · 26/08/2022 10:48

I don't even know when my own wedding anniversary is. Not everyone is obsessed by marking their bloody wedding!

I think it's really important that other members of the family should remember our wedding anniversary.

We rely on their whatsapp congratulations messages to remember to congratulate each other.

This year the messages arrived overnight (time zone differences) so dh and I had to casually say 'happy wedding anniversary' to each other the following day...

MiniCooperLover · 26/08/2022 11:42

Yep, she's spent all her money and is back for FIL's share ..

AdoraBell · 26/08/2022 11:34

Absolutely YANU. She sounds like DH’s first wife, moved out with one of the men she was shagging and turned nasty when DH met someone (me).

I think your FIL should continue with the divorce.

Arbesque · 26/08/2022 11:30

She sounds as if she's in denial about her terrible behaviour and all of the hurt she's caused.
She needs to wake up and face reality.⁶

Zilla1 · 26/08/2022 11:26

If you want to have fun, OP, help FIL schedule a party to celebrate his divorce being finalised.