Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We Must Endure High Bills. Proud

312 replies

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 07:45

AIBU to be proud of Boris Johnstone-in this matter-when said, while visiting Ukraine on their Independence Day, that we must endure high bills as remember that Ukraine are paying in blood.

I was worried about the soaring cost of bills-power/food but this made me stop and pause.

Aibu to think that we should all write down what he said and put it on the fridge to remind ourselves that it will be worth it. We're doing it for Ukraine and it is worse for them.

hashtag. Proud to Pay for Ukraine

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 26/08/2022 13:34

OP,

A few people have called you a troll but many of us have taken you seriously and given you reasoned replies. So I don’t disagree with point (2) of your latest reply. I also don’t love people trying to guess your personal circs, although you show such a lack of empathy that I understand the temptation.

But (3), (4) and (5) completely fail to engage with the reasoned arguments people have made with your original post. They are both over egged and off point. Can you offer us a higher quality response?

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/08/2022 13:32

Novum · 26/08/2022 10:36

Windfall tax would be a large element.

Could also get the Fraud Squad in to look to the missing PPE and Track and Trace billions.

hangrylady · 26/08/2022 13:28

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 07:58

FFS!
Look it up before you imply I've made it up.
Google his name+Ukraine+price rise+endure.
It was covered everywhere from ITV to Daily Telegraph.

Then, when you read it for yourselves drop the "piss-taking" comments and say if it makes you proud-will bring some comfort of not.

For me, it makes me proud and will bring some comfort. AIBU

I suspect you have enough money to suck up the higher prices. If this is the case you're a massive dick.

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:27

Fair enough, @MarshaBradyo The point is the same if expressed more fully

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 13:25

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:08

For the hard of thinking at the back of the room:

I am proud that, as a country, we are prepared to endure hardship, in order to help Ukraine win a war against Russia.
I am also proud that we are sending weapons to help her.
I am proud that we can see images-like the ones shown on the BBC website today-that show Russia burning gas in order to 'punish' us and say we don't care.
I am proud that we are not demanding that we stop helping Ukraine in order to save ourselves hardship.

We are helping Ukraine and it will cost. That's a fact.

It is possible to disagree by saying:
we shouldn't be helping her, when it will be hard for us
we shouldn't be proud of the fact we're helping because it smacks of self-congratulation when Ukraine are paying in blood-even though Ukraine have given a medal to our PM for saying we will endure hardship for as long as they endure bloodshed.
it's good that we are helping and prepared to personally pay but oil companies should be paying extra too

Responses I expect from the hard of thinking:

  1. You're probably a multi-millionaire (because no-one but a rich person could agree with putting up with hardship to help Ukraine.)
  2. You are a troll (cheap insult from the dense)
  3. You are proud that people will die here (just plain stupid and deliberately mis-understanding or maybe genuinely misunderstanding, who knows!)
  4. Fucks and Blinds (from the professional splutterers and a good measure of them from others who, sadly, only know how to show disagreement in that way.)
  5. It is nothing to do with Ukraine (from those who don't read-or understand-the news)

I did think it sarcasm initially but the thread expressed a different way may have got a different response

People may not have agreed with these points but it may not have been so full on

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/08/2022 13:24

Endlesslypatient82 · 26/08/2022 09:45

Bloomin heck. He was on holiday!

He's been on holiday for the last 3 years

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:24

What are your "various sound reasons" for disagreeing @Thedogscollar

Do you think we should stop helping Ukraine because it means hardship?

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 26/08/2022 13:23

Endlesslypatient82 · 26/08/2022 09:44

You’d think the UK was Siberia the way some mumsnetters seem to view our winters

They are cold enough for people to freeze to death in. A permafrost isn't required for mortality.

Without heating homes will not only be cold, they will become damp. Vulnerable people - the elderly, children, people with many disability will become very ill - many of them long term.

Homes will deteriorate - the fabric of the buildings will be damaged - which will lead to further problems.

People will literally be sitting in the dark if they can't pay the bills: no telly, no radio, can't read, do a jigsaw, play board games, fill a hot water bottle. Kids won't be able to do homework - but that doesn't matter because many schools are seriously considering closing for at least some of the winter months to save on energy bills. Those children whose parents still have to go out to work will be left to God and good neighbours much of the time - how many will have accidents, perhaps lighting candles for light/warmth? How many will be lured into the homes of predators with the promise of a hot meal and a TV programme? How many will simply suffer, and this vile govt doesn't give a bugger?

SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 13:22

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:15

Bingo! There we have a tick for one of the gormless responses I expected.

Name calling and pretending to be affronted. Exactly the sleight of hand a troll would use. Proud of you, kiddo. 😘

Thedogscollar · 26/08/2022 13:21

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:08

For the hard of thinking at the back of the room:

I am proud that, as a country, we are prepared to endure hardship, in order to help Ukraine win a war against Russia.
I am also proud that we are sending weapons to help her.
I am proud that we can see images-like the ones shown on the BBC website today-that show Russia burning gas in order to 'punish' us and say we don't care.
I am proud that we are not demanding that we stop helping Ukraine in order to save ourselves hardship.

We are helping Ukraine and it will cost. That's a fact.

It is possible to disagree by saying:
we shouldn't be helping her, when it will be hard for us
we shouldn't be proud of the fact we're helping because it smacks of self-congratulation when Ukraine are paying in blood-even though Ukraine have given a medal to our PM for saying we will endure hardship for as long as they endure bloodshed.
it's good that we are helping and prepared to personally pay but oil companies should be paying extra too

Responses I expect from the hard of thinking:

  1. You're probably a multi-millionaire (because no-one but a rich person could agree with putting up with hardship to help Ukraine.)
  2. You are a troll (cheap insult from the dense)
  3. You are proud that people will die here (just plain stupid and deliberately mis-understanding or maybe genuinely misunderstanding, who knows!)
  4. Fucks and Blinds (from the professional splutterers and a good measure of them from others who, sadly, only know how to show disagreement in that way.)
  5. It is nothing to do with Ukraine (from those who don't read-or understand-the news)

Your going to need another shovel for that hole you're digging.

You've got your response, the vast majority disagree with you for various sound reasons. You are either being deliberately obtuse in not understanding them or just wanting an arguement.

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:15

SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 13:10

For the hard of thinking at the back of the room: [blah blah blah]

Honestly, as trolling attempts go I can't fault your effort. Lots of posts, and not short ones either!

Bingo! There we have a tick for one of the gormless responses I expected.

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 26/08/2022 13:14

@MissHavershamJoinsTinder

You can be pleased with the UK's response to Ukraine but still be horrified at the price cap hikes and the lack of action in dealing with them.

If we nationalised energy production, so that the private companies also paid their share, then i would agree with your sentiment.

Alexandra2001 · 26/08/2022 13:11

Applesonthelawn · 26/08/2022 12:07

The biggest mistake was made by Merkel in allowing German energy supply to be so concentrated on Russia, which emboldened Putin to invade, thinking the EU is so economically fragile that any threat to Germany industrial energy supply would trump Ukraine's sovereign rights. You want to blame anyone, blame her (although I think it's pointless to think in those terms of blame).

The handling of Covid is also part of the problem but there was so much complaining about locking down too late etc. and it seems like a much less obvious error.
Windfall tax is the only way to go at this point. And frankly, planning for a very cold winter.

Thats a ridiculous theory.

Russia after 1991 was considered a partner, one we went into space with, one that would be fine to buy up large parts of London, fund our political system, buy Chelsea FC!

If Germany hadn't had NS1, where would it have got its energy from? and what would that have meant for global energy prices? and if Germany/EU had been taking all the gas from Norway, where would we have got ours from?

We promised to guarantee Ukraine's security, Russia invaded the Crimea, we did nothing... that is what made Putin think he could take the rest of the country and in recent history, had we put a 40k strong NATO force in Ukraine last year, as many in the Tory party wanted too, Putin probably wouldn't have invaded.

SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 13:10

For the hard of thinking at the back of the room: [blah blah blah]

Honestly, as trolling attempts go I can't fault your effort. Lots of posts, and not short ones either!

MissHavershamJoinsTinder · 26/08/2022 13:08

For the hard of thinking at the back of the room:

I am proud that, as a country, we are prepared to endure hardship, in order to help Ukraine win a war against Russia.
I am also proud that we are sending weapons to help her.
I am proud that we can see images-like the ones shown on the BBC website today-that show Russia burning gas in order to 'punish' us and say we don't care.
I am proud that we are not demanding that we stop helping Ukraine in order to save ourselves hardship.

We are helping Ukraine and it will cost. That's a fact.

It is possible to disagree by saying:
we shouldn't be helping her, when it will be hard for us
we shouldn't be proud of the fact we're helping because it smacks of self-congratulation when Ukraine are paying in blood-even though Ukraine have given a medal to our PM for saying we will endure hardship for as long as they endure bloodshed.
it's good that we are helping and prepared to personally pay but oil companies should be paying extra too

Responses I expect from the hard of thinking:

  1. You're probably a multi-millionaire (because no-one but a rich person could agree with putting up with hardship to help Ukraine.)
  2. You are a troll (cheap insult from the dense)
  3. You are proud that people will die here (just plain stupid and deliberately mis-understanding or maybe genuinely misunderstanding, who knows!)
  4. Fucks and Blinds (from the professional splutterers and a good measure of them from others who, sadly, only know how to show disagreement in that way.)
  5. It is nothing to do with Ukraine (from those who don't read-or understand-the news)
OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 26/08/2022 13:00

ohholyday · 26/08/2022 10:01

That sounds great but where do you think that money would come from?

Windfall tax, lower inflation = lower debt interest (as Sunak didn't take out interest rate insurance against this)
More money in the economy = less businesses going bust = more tax take.

Plus Govt has had a large windfall itself on fuel duty and VAT on energy.

A better Q would be "what happens if we do nothing at all?"

CuntyMcBollocks · 26/08/2022 12:26

I thought this was a sarcastic post by the OP at first, but am shocked to find that they really think like this!

Yes, OP, we should all be so grateful and proud that we are already struggling to feed ourselves and our children and are having to to decide which basic commodities to forgo in favour of another, and now face the bleak prospect of having to make non-existent funds stretch even further.

Bluebellsunderthetrees · 26/08/2022 12:14

cooliebrown · 26/08/2022 11:53

we're not experiencing price rises because Russia has invaded Urkraine, we're experiencing them because the oil and gas companies are taking huge huge profits

You need to read a little more about Russia, Saudi, Iran, UAE and Opec if you think there is no link between our response to Ukraine and as to why the oil and gas companies can make such huge profits just now.

Thedogscollar · 26/08/2022 12:08

@MissHavershamJoinsTinder
Your naivety and ignorance of what is about to hit this country over the next few months is nothing less than staggering.

How anyone cannot see BJ and his government for the utter charlatans they are after everything that has gone on in his reign is seriously worrying for the next GE.

You come across as entitled and plain stupid. Read the room but I fear this is beyond your capabilities.

Applesonthelawn · 26/08/2022 12:07

The biggest mistake was made by Merkel in allowing German energy supply to be so concentrated on Russia, which emboldened Putin to invade, thinking the EU is so economically fragile that any threat to Germany industrial energy supply would trump Ukraine's sovereign rights. You want to blame anyone, blame her (although I think it's pointless to think in those terms of blame).

The handling of Covid is also part of the problem but there was so much complaining about locking down too late etc. and it seems like a much less obvious error.
Windfall tax is the only way to go at this point. And frankly, planning for a very cold winter.

cooliebrown · 26/08/2022 11:53

we're not experiencing price rises because Russia has invaded Urkraine, we're experiencing them because the oil and gas companies are taking huge huge profits

CurzonDax · 26/08/2022 11:48

No, I'm not proud. I'm absoluteky disgusted by his comment.

I am not disgusted, and am happy, that we are supporting Ukraine, and sending more money to them.
But his comment was absolutely disgusting.
"Rich man makes vile comment about people poorer than him having to suck it up, while he receives medal."

DH and I both work full-time, own our own house, no children (but trying, athough I'm worried about having a child, and affording one right now). Our earnings place us 'above average', and I am freaking out about the increases (and the fixed rate on our mortgage runs out in June - still beyond 6 months, so we can't lock in a new deal now, and fixing before June will cost us £11,650 - next time, we are going for a mortgage with a more flexible early exit fee).

We are lucky. There are millions in a much worse situation to us, and yet my anxiety is going through th roof. Truss has said she'll lower taxes - to what, income tax to 19%. That will reduce my tax bill by around £10-15 a month - not going to make a dent in my energy bill (yet will cost the treasury billions a year).

Johnson has said that it's not his decision, and up to the new PM to decide what to do, yet he can give more money to Ukraine this week? I don't object to the money being snt to Ukraine, but it just shows that Johnson is once again, picking and choosing what he does to help. "This makes me look good, and gets me a nice shiny medal, so I'll do it. This sounds complicated, so I'll leave that one for someone else."

His whole attitude is vile, but neither Truss nor Sunak will be any better.

Endlesslypatient82 · 26/08/2022 11:38

Ukrainian children can go jump if it meant my children ever seriously suffering. Thankfully I don’t envisage them “seriously suffering”, more like bloody chilly or a bit sweaty as I’m forcing them to layer up at home!

5128gap · 26/08/2022 11:31

Cyclemarine · 26/08/2022 10:48

It’ll be interesting to find out her situation.

My guess is she has children and a partner who works full time, while she is a SAHM or works part-time …and possibly her children are a bit older.

I'm going for 60s, wealthy partner, SAHM but now children grown up so looks after the home, giving plenty of time to exonomise by making her own wine and jam and a blanket to 'snuggle' in when the thermostat goes down a notch.
Looks back nostalgically at the time when she 'struggled' when young. Had to have her mothers old sofa because they couldn't afford new like they seem to have to have these days. Orange crates for side tables and bare lino in the spare room while hubby took six extra jobs so they could save up. It was character forming and they were grateful.