Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy don’t pay or what else

312 replies

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

OP posts:
amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 26/08/2022 08:22

MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 08:12

Martin Lewis isn’t advising this so if you think he has a point generally I’d take his view on this too

Encouraging people to do this will harm them more than anyone else

Hello! If you watch the interviews you can tell Martin Lewis is a bit sheepish as he says this.

Look at his body language etc. He obviously doesn't want to tell people to do something that is effectively illegal, but realistically you know he was thinking "I mean what else can people do, and realistically they can't go after several hundreds of thousands of people at once".

He hasn't mentioned it since, which is telling.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:19

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:17

Frances way or working it out was because they predominantly produce energy from nuclear power and the state owns 80% of EDF

Yep, absolutely right.
This too and they appear to be
mor me progressive (or ignorant - depending on your view) along these lines/

Nuclear energy is massively under utilised and we will need to start looking at this.

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:17

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 08:05

👍🏻 That’s a shame - was naively hoping if France could work out a way to not have an energy crisis there might be something the uk government could do to alleviate the current desperate situation many families find themselves in.

Frances way or working it out was because they predominantly produce energy from nuclear power and the state owns 80% of EDF

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:12

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 08:10

Becayse - fairly obviously - if enough people refuse to pay it will force the government to take action - like they did with the poll tax. We are paying far more than most of Europe - we're being taken for mugs because our government is too spineless to stand up to the energy companies.

So naive!

What’s the government going to do to a wholesaler offshore??

Please tell me.

The only way they can help people is via tax relief or some such support which means we still pay for it, just not directly in the form of bills.

Do people realise that ‘the government should pay’ means that WE pay??

MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 08:12

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 08:10

Becayse - fairly obviously - if enough people refuse to pay it will force the government to take action - like they did with the poll tax. We are paying far more than most of Europe - we're being taken for mugs because our government is too spineless to stand up to the energy companies.

Martin Lewis isn’t advising this so if you think he has a point generally I’d take his view on this too

Encouraging people to do this will harm them more than anyone else

lightand · 26/08/2022 08:11

Already a bit out of date after three weeks, but this gives some idea of the global[though Europe seems to be worst hit?] nature of the high electricity prices worldwide?

www.electricrate.com/data-center/electricity-prices-by-country/

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:11

MoodyTwo · 26/08/2022 08:10

So my DD last year was £80 (for both) it then was £160 this year, they asked to put up to £350 as I fixed in July.
I have moved it to £250 for now as I am still in £400 credit, once I get into negative in winter I'll then up it to the amount I actually use each month, I'll just track my smart meters.
I don't mind paying what I use however I then think it will make me think more about my use age and then I will use less and need to pay less ...

Similar to what I do. I am with Shell and they let you control your DD

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 08:10

Beecham · 26/08/2022 00:01

Really don't understand how not paying your bill would help anyone else?

Becayse - fairly obviously - if enough people refuse to pay it will force the government to take action - like they did with the poll tax. We are paying far more than most of Europe - we're being taken for mugs because our government is too spineless to stand up to the energy companies.

MoodyTwo · 26/08/2022 08:10

So my DD last year was £80 (for both) it then was £160 this year, they asked to put up to £350 as I fixed in July.
I have moved it to £250 for now as I am still in £400 credit, once I get into negative in winter I'll then up it to the amount I actually use each month, I'll just track my smart meters.
I don't mind paying what I use however I then think it will make me think more about my use age and then I will use less and need to pay less ...

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:10

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:04

Because Germany was anti nuclear and drunk on Russian gas, they are worst impacted by this as they have little alternative.

It’s irrelevant.

The whole market is affected - not just those who bought from Russia.

We bought very little from Russia but look what’s happening here.

Simple supply and demand, not hard to understand.

There is less gas around in the market for wholesale, so prices have gone up across the board. Basic economics.

Buying or not from Russia doesn’t mean that you aren’t affected because there is less gas available to everyone so wholesalers charge more.

Do people understand that we bought very little from Russia, but look at what is still happening?

lollipoprainbow · 26/08/2022 08:07

@PasTrop is clearly a troll

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 08:05

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:57

They are.
It’s just not as bad and remember energy supply is largely nationalised, stamp/tax is collected differently and forms huge subsidies etc so they are paying more, albeit via a different route. Not as much as UK, it’s true.

Its all there for reading if you want to learn more.

👍🏻 That’s a shame - was naively hoping if France could work out a way to not have an energy crisis there might be something the uk government could do to alleviate the current desperate situation many families find themselves in.

CherryGenoa · 26/08/2022 08:05

If the government doesn’t intervene as the French have, vulnerable people will get sick or die from the cold and send the NHS into free fall this winter. Good luck getting an ambulance out when your parent has a heart attack. Small and medium businesses will collapse, creating mass bankruptcies and joblessness. People with no assets and no key meter will run up huge debts they cannot pay. We are in for the mother of all recessions without intervention. Mass action will happen regardless, and it may well be violent when enough people have nothing further to lose.

The OP is asking quite reasonably what we can do before it comes to this. I think a lot of people are like me, if there’s a general strike or huge protest, they will join in. I can afford my energy but will act in solidarity with those who cannot and those who will lose businesses or loved ones.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 26/08/2022 08:05

^*
Exactly and why is France not having an energy crisis??*^

Would people stop using France as an example? The freeze on gas price increases and cap on energy costs comes to an end at the end of the year. Then it will increase sharply. Macron has told the French people it's the end of abundance and there are tough times ahead. EDF is also suing the French government for £7bn, if they win, where do you think that money will come from?

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:04

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:59

Well Germany has installed thousands of wood burners into domestic premises this year in anticipation of a hard and told customer to try and use this method where they can.

So there’s something in it.

Because Germany was anti nuclear and drunk on Russian gas, they are worst impacted by this as they have little alternative.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:02

And please don’t tell people not to burn wood when the alternative may be to freeze to death.

Emissions, right now, mean fuck all when China and India keep doing what they’re doing. Greener is better, but being alive is better than dying from cold irrespective of the immediate impact on the environment.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:59

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 07:56

👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👊🏻

Well Germany has installed thousands of wood burners into domestic premises this year in anticipation of a hard and told customer to try and use this method where they can.

So there’s something in it.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:57

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 07:55

Exactly and why is France not having an energy crisis??

They are.
It’s just not as bad and remember energy supply is largely nationalised, stamp/tax is collected differently and forms huge subsidies etc so they are paying more, albeit via a different route. Not as much as UK, it’s true.

Its all there for reading if you want to learn more.

lightand · 26/08/2022 07:57

jetadore · 26/08/2022 07:42

You said, All in the same predicament, to a lesser or greater degree. Partly depending on what their governements are doing about the similar situations.

Our government is doing nothing of significance. I’m asking what I can do to force them to do something. Still waiting for an answer (from anyone, not just you). Are people pleased by the current situation (judging by many on this thread, seems like yes), or is there anything I, we can do about it. Queue hundred posts reframing the problem in interesting and provocative ways, zero actual suggestions other than to not not pay under any circumstances and whatever you do don’t try to protest, good god no.

Other countries dont seem to have come up with much either.

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 07:56

Ushkin · 26/08/2022 01:31

If you aren’t happy with the cost get a word-burner and paraffin lamps, or move in with family, or just use less.

Great suggestions! Except that wood burners are associated with significant health risks and are an environmental disaster; not everyone has family they can conveniently just move in with; and many people are already using the bare minimum. Any other pearls of wisdom?

👍🏻👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👊🏻

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:55

Baker90 · 26/08/2022 07:52

I said that was what the idea was behind the other part of the movement. I didn't say factual as I've not done huge amounts of research into. Just giving people the option of fully researching the general premise.

But interestingly we are wary of our usage anyway. Will be even more so this winter. The fixed quote we've been given, even when calculating on worst case forecast increases, is over double what our usage would be in the next year. I think people need to be at the very least conscious of fixed rates not necessarily being accurate, and if paying monthly for what you use is a better option then it should be considered.

I don't think it is right to not pay, at the end of the day it is like others have said, it would be like shoplifting - but equally money is better sat in our pockets than energy companies who are quite literally making record profits and making statements like they have too much money and they don't know what to do with it.

What other part of what movement?

So much cryptic stuff on here.

Go to independent persons who knows their onions and start there. Not paying bills and cancelling DDs (which often form a contract by default and may affect your rate) is not good advice without research.

Farmmum77 · 26/08/2022 07:55

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:12

So why did the prices double last year before the war in Ukraine? Why aren't the government sorting out our country so we have our own supplies so we don't have to rely on other countries. Its all excuses

Exactly and why is France not having an energy crisis??

SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 07:54

Funny/enraging to think that just a week ago Truss was bragging about getting rid of solar fields.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 07:52

Go on OP. Cancel your DD and see what happens.

You realise even Martin Lewis says not to do this don’t you?

Baker90 · 26/08/2022 07:52

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 06:39

So much of what you’ve posted here is wrong!

You don’t have to pay over the year monthly in even bouts, of course not.

But most people find a consistent mothly bill much easier to manage than £170 pcm for a few months when is warm, being ramped up to a potential maximum of £550 pcm when it’s colder and after the cap has been risen.

Unless they keep it to the side and put it onto a savings account.

Ombudsman don’t just fine energy companies because someone has moaned. Look it up. The Jack Monroe school of advice is plain wrong.

What are all these complaints meant to actually be about anyway???

I said that was what the idea was behind the other part of the movement. I didn't say factual as I've not done huge amounts of research into. Just giving people the option of fully researching the general premise.

But interestingly we are wary of our usage anyway. Will be even more so this winter. The fixed quote we've been given, even when calculating on worst case forecast increases, is over double what our usage would be in the next year. I think people need to be at the very least conscious of fixed rates not necessarily being accurate, and if paying monthly for what you use is a better option then it should be considered.

I don't think it is right to not pay, at the end of the day it is like others have said, it would be like shoplifting - but equally money is better sat in our pockets than energy companies who are quite literally making record profits and making statements like they have too much money and they don't know what to do with it.