Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy don’t pay or what else

312 replies

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

OP posts:
Getoff · 26/08/2022 09:15

I do support option 2 in one version: I would be fine with the government paying subsidies of any size deemed appropriate to household where someone is claiming Universal Credit.

This is the only version of "other people pay" that I think is acceptable. I don't approve of the £66 a month subsidy for everyone government has already promised.

Getoff · 26/08/2022 09:12

They hysteria "what will you do if they put the bills up to 20K" is overdone. You are not compelled to consume any amount of electricity or gas. At worst you arguably have to pay the standing charge, anything above that is optional.

If a pint of milk was £50, I would or more likely would not buy it, what I would not do is steal it.

This is nothing like the poll tax, which was just one of many ways of collecting money for the govenment, and the payment of which did not entitle you to anything specific in return. This is a payment for goods you actually consume, and if you don't pay your bill, then someone else is going to have to pay it for you.

There are three options for dealing with increased bills

  1. You pay for what you use
  2. Other people pay for what you use
  3. You use less
Pick one, there are no other possibilities.

(To clarify option 2, if the government pays that means taxpayers pay. If the money is taken from corporations then either their shareholders or customers pay, depending on the exact details. People like to nominate "government" or "big companies" as the source of an infinite pool of funds to solve any problem, without acknowledging that any money taken from either will ultimately come out of pockets of other individuals.)

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 09:12

One time before all this started, I rang up my old supplier and told them I was moving and going with a different supplier

And I highly doubt this version of events to be honest, although maybe during Covid you got away with it.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 09:10

Sunnyqueen · 26/08/2022 09:03

I completely agree with you op but people are just too wet in this country to do anything that might carries a risk or shock horror - Illegal!! keels over and dies
@Quincythequince

You’ll get a ccj, a big fine and a higher tarried ultimately.

You can’t use things and not pay for them.

Do you understand that???

One time before all this started, I rang up my old supplier and told them I was moving and going with a different supplier. They closed the account. For 18 months I carried on living in my house not paying anything, didn't get cut off, no bills, no ccjs, no prepayment meters installed, no contact from anyone (other than a massive refund in error from old supplier of everything I'd ever paid them previously about a month after they'd closed the account) eventually I got paranoid they'd catch up with me so I phoned a different supplier and told them I'd just moved in a week ago. 🤣🤣🤣No one caught on. Should have kept stum.

Lucky you, although you are thief - you realise that yea?

Bur you’re assuming they won’t backbill (it happens) and of course your unpaid energy used doesn’t dent their profits, other consumers just end up paying.

Bravo to you 🙄

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 09:08

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 09:02

*For people who need help, the ones you are trying to help so you say, cancelling their DD is not going to work.

You cancelling your DD isn’t going to work.

My DD went from £140 per month to £400 per month, my smart meter showed we were actually using around £150 per month plus £30 standing charge. They currently have £380 in credit on our account. Tried speaking to the supplier about our account to no avail, said they had worked figures out based on previous usage.

I did stop the DD to force them to have another look - and to actually have a conversation about it. They immediately cut the DD to £300 and it looks like it’ll actually land somewhere around £250 to balance out summer and winter use. Then we’ll have to renegotiate again come October.

I don’t think nonpayment is effective in the long term, but it can prompt them to actually engage in a discussion about reasonable payments.

With a smart meter, that’s fair enough.

You can document your usage. But it will go up in the winter (assuming you don’t beat your house in the summer months) and also because the price caps will go up.

Like I said, some people prefer to pay evenly to manage their money better rather than pay variable amounts each month if they’re on a budget.

And if having £400 sitting on credit prices such a financial problem for some (and I know it might) where are they going to find the extra money for fuel when they need it in a few months.

You are lucky your supplier didn’t change your tariff (or did they? Have you checked).

Shell gives customers control over their DD so you can vary it by month if you want to. Not all of them are as generous and this is presumably because they know people won’t be able to pay at some point.

Not paying anything and not engaging because you want to protest, is very different to your scenario.

Sunnyqueen · 26/08/2022 09:03

I completely agree with you op but people are just too wet in this country to do anything that might carries a risk or shock horror - Illegal!! keels over and dies
@Quincythequince

You’ll get a ccj, a big fine and a higher tarried ultimately.

You can’t use things and not pay for them.

Do you understand that???

One time before all this started, I rang up my old supplier and told them I was moving and going with a different supplier. They closed the account. For 18 months I carried on living in my house not paying anything, didn't get cut off, no bills, no ccjs, no prepayment meters installed, no contact from anyone (other than a massive refund in error from old supplier of everything I'd ever paid them previously about a month after they'd closed the account) eventually I got paranoid they'd catch up with me so I phoned a different supplier and told them I'd just moved in a week ago. 🤣🤣🤣No one caught on. Should have kept stum.

Damnautocorrect · 26/08/2022 09:03

I’m not comfortable with the government subsiding the share holders and CEO’s of essential services.

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 09:02

*For people who need help, the ones you are trying to help so you say, cancelling their DD is not going to work.

You cancelling your DD isn’t going to work.

My DD went from £140 per month to £400 per month, my smart meter showed we were actually using around £150 per month plus £30 standing charge. They currently have £380 in credit on our account. Tried speaking to the supplier about our account to no avail, said they had worked figures out based on previous usage.

I did stop the DD to force them to have another look - and to actually have a conversation about it. They immediately cut the DD to £300 and it looks like it’ll actually land somewhere around £250 to balance out summer and winter use. Then we’ll have to renegotiate again come October.

I don’t think nonpayment is effective in the long term, but it can prompt them to actually engage in a discussion about reasonable payments.

Clavinova · 26/08/2022 08:57

if France could work out a way to not have an energy crisis

There is clearly an energy crisis for some sectors in France:

Le Monde
Energy crisis: French businesses brace themselves for the worst.

www.lemonde.fr/en/economy/article/2022/07/19/energy-crisis-french-businesses-brace-themselves-for-the-worst_5990714_19.html

Rural French communes forced to cut services due to rising energy bills.

www.thelocal.fr/20220404/rural-french-communes-forced-to-cut-services-due-to-rising-energy-bills/

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 26/08/2022 08:55

*You’ll get a ccj, a big fine and a higher tarried ultimately.

You can’t use things and not pay for them.*

This sums it up. If people really want to end up with a shit credit rating, go ahead. Don't encourage others to do so or complain when people won't.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:50

Remove your meter and use not gas at all (you will have to remove it btw as you will pay the standing charge otherwise)

That’ll learn ‘em

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:49

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:43

They have been trying to move away from gas yes. Not doing a great job.

I’m all for genuinely thinking increasing our nuclear energy options here.

Yep unfortunately the green lobby here and abroad hates nuclear. Yes it’s not great but it’s better than burning fossil fuels. Green lobby in Germany stoped new reactors being built and caused them to be wedded to Russian gas and now are having to burn more coal. Spectacularly backfired that.

people seem to see things in black and white and not in step change compromise. Yes only doing a small amount isn’t as good as doing a large amount but, so all steps may get you there when one large step isn’t palatable or possible

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:47

jetadore · 26/08/2022 08:41

To advocate cancelling a direct debit is way beyond the pale and the thought of being considered a credit risk is simply horrifying but simply popping over and assassinating Putin would solve all our problems, after all deposing dictators has worked out so well in the past. Fucking cloud cuckoo land.

You’ll get a ccj, a big fine and a higher tarried ultimately.

You can’t use things and not pay for them.

Do you understand that???

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:46

jetadore · 26/08/2022 08:41

To advocate cancelling a direct debit is way beyond the pale and the thought of being considered a credit risk is simply horrifying but simply popping over and assassinating Putin would solve all our problems, after all deposing dictators has worked out so well in the past. Fucking cloud cuckoo land.

WTF are you in about??? Are you on glue?

For people who need help, the ones you are trying to help so you say, cancelling their DD is not going to work.

You cancelling your DD isn’t going to work.

What part of that don’t you get???

loudbat has summarised how this all works very well above.

You realise two things are causing this don’t you 1) Covid and 2) The war.

Russia is also suffering because of Putin, so yes, you can be sure asasination attempts will be made.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:43

lightand · 26/08/2022 08:35

The Uk has been going away from certain types of energy for 30 years.

No quick fixes at this point.
Unles someonelese knows different?

They have been trying to move away from gas yes. Not doing a great job.

I’m all for genuinely thinking increasing our nuclear energy options here.

jetadore · 26/08/2022 08:41

To advocate cancelling a direct debit is way beyond the pale and the thought of being considered a credit risk is simply horrifying but simply popping over and assassinating Putin would solve all our problems, after all deposing dictators has worked out so well in the past. Fucking cloud cuckoo land.

OP posts:
lightand · 26/08/2022 08:36

jetadore · 26/08/2022 08:33

Yeh, so I was right when I said
you’re saying as a collective we can’t/shouldn’t do anything in the face of a global problem?
then wasn’t I? Not in the slightest ffs.

Oh my.

I cant explain things any clearer to what I have already said.
Nor will I to you at this point.

lightand · 26/08/2022 08:35

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:30

Indeed.
So let’s see what, in the grand complex schemes, they can do.

People need to Just remember that there is a shortage at the moment…profits will be made when demand outstrips supply.

Basic economics.

Alternate fuel sources and readying those is a much better option for us long term.

I’m not pre nuclear energy per se, but many are so opposed to it, conversations don’t get off the ground.

They have a museum in the NL for visitors to see how nuclear energy works and to explain it first hand!

We need to start finding alternate sources now.

The Uk has been going away from certain types of energy for 30 years.

No quick fixes at this point.
Unles someonelese knows different?

loudbatperson · 26/08/2022 08:33

Thing problem with cancelling your direct debit is that the unit costs are more when you pay on receipt of bill. Even if you are a fixed rate tariff, that tariff will have rates for paying by DD and higher rates for paying on receipt of bill.

Your overall bills will be higher if you switch to receipt of bill compared to direct debit. Receipt of bill tariffs are generally even higher than prepay/PAYG.

In the long run the do not payment movement is not going to help people who can't afford their bills, it's just going to cost them more.

Reducing usage is the only way to reduce your bill and also show the producers that the price is too high.

Prices (for fuel and all types of products and services) are carefully calculated based on how many units will sell and how much profit is generated at that price point. In every case you can plot these values on a graph and you will see higher prices increase profit up to a point. Once you hit a certain cost, you sell fewer units and profits decrease.

Using less due to the unit costs will have a greater impact on the producers. However in the case of fuel the market is global, so we hVe very little power as people in other countries are willing to pay more, keeping the profits going.

jetadore · 26/08/2022 08:33

lightand · 26/08/2022 07:57

Other countries dont seem to have come up with much either.

Yeh, so I was right when I said
you’re saying as a collective we can’t/shouldn’t do anything in the face of a global problem?
then wasn’t I? Not in the slightest ffs.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 26/08/2022 08:33

amijustparanoidorjuststoned · 26/08/2022 08:22

Hello! If you watch the interviews you can tell Martin Lewis is a bit sheepish as he says this.

Look at his body language etc. He obviously doesn't want to tell people to do something that is effectively illegal, but realistically you know he was thinking "I mean what else can people do, and realistically they can't go after several hundreds of thousands of people at once".

He hasn't mentioned it since, which is telling.

Hello to you too ;

Imo the negative impact will be with those who don’t pay. It won’t be an effective protest but it will harm them personally.

Also it’s a supply issue, people choosing to self ration this drastically eg if on pre payment will be doing what other countries are enforcing. Not sure at what point you get moved to pre payment if you don’t pay but when that happens it just equals no supply

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:30

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:23

However some of the offshore oil and gas is issues licensees by the UK (ie in the North Sea) so there are some mechanisms which can be used, and a good chunk of these are now owned by pension companies, private equity and even the Chinese state

Indeed.
So let’s see what, in the grand complex schemes, they can do.

People need to Just remember that there is a shortage at the moment…profits will be made when demand outstrips supply.

Basic economics.

Alternate fuel sources and readying those is a much better option for us long term.

I’m not pre nuclear energy per se, but many are so opposed to it, conversations don’t get off the ground.

They have a museum in the NL for visitors to see how nuclear energy works and to explain it first hand!

We need to start finding alternate sources now.

RudsyFarmer · 26/08/2022 08:27

For those using France as an analogy for maintaining reasonable energy costs - they primarily use nuclear power from their nuclear power stations.

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 08:23

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:12

So naive!

What’s the government going to do to a wholesaler offshore??

Please tell me.

The only way they can help people is via tax relief or some such support which means we still pay for it, just not directly in the form of bills.

Do people realise that ‘the government should pay’ means that WE pay??

However some of the offshore oil and gas is issues licensees by the UK (ie in the North Sea) so there are some mechanisms which can be used, and a good chunk of these are now owned by pension companies, private equity and even the Chinese state

Redqueenheart · 26/08/2022 08:22

I think the ''just pay'' types are really naive.

  • For many people like pensioners, the disabled and those on low incomes that simply won't be an option.
  • Also they forget the bigger picture: if people stop being able to consume as normal and stop going to restaurants, bars, shops, hotels, theatres and so on because they have no disposable incomes whatsoever then the whole economy collapses
  • Small businesses are also seeing their utility bills go up and that means many will fold, especially as they were already battered by the Covid crisis.

We have reached a situation where this is no longer just about whether someone can pay their bill just by managing their finance a bit better.

This is a general catastrophe that needs serious intervention...

Only the British would be meek enough to allow things to have got to this stage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread