Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy don’t pay or what else

312 replies

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

OP posts:
lightand · 26/08/2022 15:46

Well, if with old 6

lightand · 26/08/2022 15:45

Wont it be two out of 3 still on old tariffs?
[people fix for 3 years, and still two years left to run, if you see what I mean?]

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:42

lightand · 26/08/2022 15:22

They are not expected to stay high no. This pricing information is out there months and months before it hits Joe public. They have a good idea now what prices will be in April and have done for some time,

Well yes and no.
Part the reason 10 or whatever energy companies went bust was because they have been massively caught out.
There are people who will still be on old tariffs for a couple of years yet.

Absolutely. The smaller providers didn’t hedge properly, and then the war happened. Bad business rather than lack of clarity. Of course fixed tariffs are great - provided you weren’t on a dozed tariff with a provider that went bust. New providers don’t have to honour that.

So if you fixed with 1) one of the big six before this all kicked off and 2) have years left to run (will be a very small minority of places) you’ll be less affected.

Those numbers are few and far between though.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:24

PAYG tariffs are high.
Better to get into trouble once younger cut back as much as you reasonably can, and then ask for a payment plan, rathe than not paying.

Monthly bills and PAYG are both more expensive than DD tariffs. Please listen when people tell you this.

lightand · 26/08/2022 15:22

They are not expected to stay high no. This pricing information is out there months and months before it hits Joe public. They have a good idea now what prices will be in April and have done for some time,

Well yes and no.
Part the reason 10 or whatever energy companies went bust was because they have been massively caught out.
There are people who will still be on old tariffs for a couple of years yet.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:19

lightand · 26/08/2022 14:49

High energy costs likely to go on for years or longer I would have thought.

Structural issues been a long time in the making.
Some people been warning for decades.

Now chickens have come home to roost.
Or run out of road for the can kicking.
You choose.

They are not expected to stay high no. This pricing information is out there months and months before it hits Joe public. They have a good idea now what prices will be in April and have done for some time, but now the MSM are picking up in it, it all seems sudden. It’s not.

And It is expected to drop again, although to what and when, I don’t actually know.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 15:16

RobertaFirmino · 26/08/2022 14:40

You won't get cut off if you don't pay. Regardless of season, the energy company can and will apply for a warrant to enter your home and install a PAYG meter though.

I do agree with not paying by DD though. You're effectively paying an estimated bill in advance. You won't be getting any overpayments back either - the money will rest in THEIR account (not yours) and eventually be credited to your final bill should you move or switch supplier.

Well yes. Same principle. Cut off from normal supply so you have to pay in advance.
They don’t remove you from the grid no, but if you’ve no money, the impact on you is the same.

Then you will be taken to court to pay and end up with costs and a fine.

lightand · 26/08/2022 14:49

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 13:27

This energy crisis is down to our government's failure to invest in energy infrastructure and security and the public who kept putting them in power

This! Absolutely this. There is no quick fix here people. None. We are screwed tbh. Successions of Tory governments have fucked it for everyone. And even if you’re a true blue voter who has in other ways benefitted, you’re getting screwed like so many others now. They haven’t planned because they didn’t care. The war and Covid haven’t helped.

The smartest thing you can do is drastically try to reduce your usage where you can so you pay less. And if you are using more than you can afford, even doing this; using the bare minimum, then go to your energy company and show/tell them and see what they can do. Don’t refuse to pay for what you’re using. There is no way out of that at all.

High energy costs likely to go on for years or longer I would have thought.

Structural issues been a long time in the making.
Some people been warning for decades.

Now chickens have come home to roost.
Or run out of road for the can kicking.
You choose.

loudbatperson · 26/08/2022 14:47

Can anyone come plain how switching to a more expensive method of payment is going to help people whose bills are increasing.

By opting to move from direct debit to pay on receipt of bill or pre pay meters, you are choosing to have a higher unit cost, as a protest to the prices going up.

The direct debit spreads the payment and every 6-12 months (depending on company) any credit that is built up can be refunded. Yes you may pay slightly more in some months than you use, and maybe you will need to get a refund sometimes, but overall by switching from direct debit you are choosing to have higher bills.

Proudboomer · 26/08/2022 14:45

the money will rest in THEIR account (not yours) and eventually be credited to your final bill should you move or switch supplier.

but they are not allowed to make a profit of credit balances and some energy firms pay interest on credit balances. I am with ova and balances over your minimum payment are paid between 3 and 5% interest depending on the length you have been with them.

plus you have the fact that you get a better rate paying by direct debit which is usually around 5% lower than other tariffs.

Proudboomer · 26/08/2022 14:42

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 12:10

The government could set up a national company which provided power at cost of production rates and they could reopen some closed North Sea sites to increase supply. The government could cap prices at sustainable levels - we are paying well above the odds and there is no justification for standing charges rising. You're naive if you think companies do anything other than charge what they can get away with - the government's role is to step in when the market is out of control

There are no big ptofits in the actual retail of gas and electricity. The big profits are being made on the wholesale market by the producers so the only way any government can con to the price is by the country being energy self sufficient which we are years away from being. That means if the government set up its own nationalised energy company they would still have to buy that energy on the wholesale open market and after the fisco of the buying of the PPE I would hate to see how they could cock that up. The wholesale sellers are not going to sell it to them any cheaper than the commercial buyers can buy it at so it would still be massively expensive.

The North Sea after 50years of use is mostly oil left and it isn’t even oil that we can refine so 80% of it gets sold offshore. We could massively invest in North Sea oil shale gas but even if that happened it would need billons of investment and years before we get any return so wouldn’t help now.

We have already lost around 30 energy retails as they didn’t allow for the masssive increase in wholesale costs and went bust so we now pay increased standing charges to cover the monies lost when they went bust as everyone with a credit balance had to retain that credit balance so that now needs repaying. If more energy companies go bust then we will be paying even more.

RobertaFirmino · 26/08/2022 14:40

You won't get cut off if you don't pay. Regardless of season, the energy company can and will apply for a warrant to enter your home and install a PAYG meter though.

I do agree with not paying by DD though. You're effectively paying an estimated bill in advance. You won't be getting any overpayments back either - the money will rest in THEIR account (not yours) and eventually be credited to your final bill should you move or switch supplier.

Jayne35 · 26/08/2022 13:50

I cancelled my direct debit but I'm not going to stop paying, Eon contacted me to ask why I cancelled and said that I need to set up another DD but I refused, this was about 4 months ago when my fixed term ended. I was told that the DD is more that we use because it's to prevent us getting into debt in the winter, I said I'm perfectly capable of managing my own finances and would prefer savings to be in my account, not theirs.

I always pay on the day I receive the bill. This month was £114 for gas/electric, my DD would have been £246 per month! I know it's going up again soon so I am putting extra in the bills account in preparation.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 13:48

If anyone is interested read @ ELPinchbeck on Twitter.

You will get full explanation here on what can be done now (it’s not what you think) and an explanation of what has happened and why.

Way better information than all these SJWs on Twitter who haven’t a clue and simply have an axe to grind with the Tories (don’t we all…)

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 13:31

Theluggage15 · 26/08/2022 13:16

The number of people who seem to have zero understanding of basic economics and the structure of the energy supply industry but seem to think they know how to easily solve the problem is unbelievable. All over social media too. ‘Just nationalise the companies’. Which companies? How? What difference would that make?

I know. And it’s very frustrating to read too, because whilst it doesn’t help us in the moment, it’s important people get exactly why this is happening.

Germany has been affected way more than us. Poland, the NL…it’s a Pan European (at the very least) problem which will start to become a global problem.

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 13:27

This energy crisis is down to our government's failure to invest in energy infrastructure and security and the public who kept putting them in power

This! Absolutely this. There is no quick fix here people. None. We are screwed tbh. Successions of Tory governments have fucked it for everyone. And even if you’re a true blue voter who has in other ways benefitted, you’re getting screwed like so many others now. They haven’t planned because they didn’t care. The war and Covid haven’t helped.

The smartest thing you can do is drastically try to reduce your usage where you can so you pay less. And if you are using more than you can afford, even doing this; using the bare minimum, then go to your energy company and show/tell them and see what they can do. Don’t refuse to pay for what you’re using. There is no way out of that at all.

Theluggage15 · 26/08/2022 13:16

The number of people who seem to have zero understanding of basic economics and the structure of the energy supply industry but seem to think they know how to easily solve the problem is unbelievable. All over social media too. ‘Just nationalise the companies’. Which companies? How? What difference would that make?

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 12:55

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 12:10

The government could set up a national company which provided power at cost of production rates and they could reopen some closed North Sea sites to increase supply. The government could cap prices at sustainable levels - we are paying well above the odds and there is no justification for standing charges rising. You're naive if you think companies do anything other than charge what they can get away with - the government's role is to step in when the market is out of control

Good god! This is painful to read.

The companies aren’t ‘charging what they can get away with’ that’s the point of the cap. Do you get that??

Without the cap, it would be so much more.
You realise energy companies (not wholesalers, companies) went bust because they didn’t hedge properly and it became unaffordable right?

Where is the government to get this power from? Who will they get it from
(Even if they set up a company). You think a wholesaler is going to say ‘ for you sir. Special price’ Or are they going to sell it to the government at the rates as everyone else.

Are you aware that this is a wholesaler problem, not so much as as energy supplier problem?

Please do some research.

You can’t just open a company to sell a resource more cheaply when there is a supply problem. And even if they could, do you really think it would be that simple.

Aishah231 · 26/08/2022 12:10

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 08:12

So naive!

What’s the government going to do to a wholesaler offshore??

Please tell me.

The only way they can help people is via tax relief or some such support which means we still pay for it, just not directly in the form of bills.

Do people realise that ‘the government should pay’ means that WE pay??

The government could set up a national company which provided power at cost of production rates and they could reopen some closed North Sea sites to increase supply. The government could cap prices at sustainable levels - we are paying well above the odds and there is no justification for standing charges rising. You're naive if you think companies do anything other than charge what they can get away with - the government's role is to step in when the market is out of control

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 12:00

@Scepticalwotsits I’ve already checked my year round usage, and the current DD reflects the cost of our monthly winter usage so we’re paying the same amount in summer as we do in winter, when our DD in winter covers the cost of our usage in winter.

Basically for 7/8 months in summer they charge us £400/month when we actually use around £180 on average per month. In winter they charge £400/month which looking at our predicted usage and tariff is about right assuming we don’t lower our usage (which we will). 7/8 months at a £200 over pay per month isn’t an insignificant amount of money to sit in someone else’s account given we’re not predicted to be underpaying in winter.

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 11:52

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 09:02

*For people who need help, the ones you are trying to help so you say, cancelling their DD is not going to work.

You cancelling your DD isn’t going to work.

My DD went from £140 per month to £400 per month, my smart meter showed we were actually using around £150 per month plus £30 standing charge. They currently have £380 in credit on our account. Tried speaking to the supplier about our account to no avail, said they had worked figures out based on previous usage.

I did stop the DD to force them to have another look - and to actually have a conversation about it. They immediately cut the DD to £300 and it looks like it’ll actually land somewhere around £250 to balance out summer and winter use. Then we’ll have to renegotiate again come October.

I don’t think nonpayment is effective in the long term, but it can prompt them to actually engage in a discussion about reasonable payments.

Thing is though typically the way DDs are set is you over pay in summer and underpay in winter with the balance built up. Cutting the DD in summer leaves you exposed massively in the winter, plus companies are trying to balance additional costs that will be Incured due to rising cap by putting up DDs. now. Without sitting down and checking your usage your KWH price and average consumption at each point in the past few years just cutting your DD could spectacularly backfire when you get handed a whopper of a bill.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 26/08/2022 11:50

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 09:21

How about we build our on nuclear power stations instead of relying on other countries and being to held to ransom? The government won't do that though as it goes against the green agenda. What is the point of the government?

Opposition to nuclear has fuck all to do with a "green agenda". Many environmentalists support nuclear as an energy source due to its low emissions and relative sustainability. Others oppose it due to concerns about how the waste would be handled, which is a perfectly valid concern especially when you look at how poorly/unsafely water/oil/gas industries have been run.

The main opposition to nuclear has always been a) a reluctance of our governments to invest in infrastructure, b)NIMBYs, and c) the general populations unfounded belief that nuclear power plants are ticking time bombs just waiting to go into meltdown at the slightest issue.

However it's irrelevant anyway as we can't just magic up a fleet of new nuclear power stations tomorrow (or even within the next decade). This energy crisis is down to our government's failure to invest in energy infrastructure and security and the public who kept putting them in power.

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 11:31

I'd rather put an extra jumper on than consider sex work tbh but each to their own.

An extra jumper won’t help cook your tea or heat your water.

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/08/2022 11:30

And if having £400 sitting on credit prices such a financial problem for some (and I know it might) where are they going to find the extra money for fuel when they need it in a few months.

Its not that it causes me a problem, I’m very fortunate that I’m financially ok so far, but if that continues over the next three months until our energy use does go up they’ll be holding near enough £1,000 of my money and the current £400 per month DD will cover my winter usage. Charging me a monthly amount all year round on the basis of winter usage isn’t ok.

They haven’t changed my tariff to a pay per usage one yet, we’re still negotiating the direct debit amount. I have no objection to paying energy bills, I do object to them taking money from me that will sit in their account rather than mine. The whole point of having a smart meter is to monitor my energy costs and adjust usage/budget accordingly - that doesn’t work if they set a DD at twice the amount just because they can.

I didn’t realise you can change the direct debit amount on the website though - they haven’t told me that in my conversations with them, so I’ll set up an online account and have a look.

ZooMount · 26/08/2022 11:22

Vecnasnurse · 26/08/2022 09:18

I'm going to pay £300 per month and the rest will just have to accrue as debt. Once prices go down or divine intervention steps in, I'll start paying off the debt.

I'm a single mum, no family and an ex that doesn't pay a penny. I work full time and get UC top up. I just can't afford £600 per month, there's literally no where I can squeeze it from.

If my plan doesn't work and they push me onto prepayment meters that I can't afford to top up, then I guess I'll have to look at sex work ☹️ I can't really see another way out at this point.

I'd rather put an extra jumper on than consider sex work tbh but each to their own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread