Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy don’t pay or what else

312 replies

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

OP posts:
Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:19

wenevernewthis · 26/08/2022 02:17

it's a form of protest.

Exactly. If everyone did the same thing, what could they do? They'd have to be more reasonable

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:19

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:10

Why would the government possibly try to seize foreign companies just because you are annoyed at your energy bill?

More to the point, have you any idea how ridiculous that plan is? What exactly do you imagine would happen if we tried to “seize”
the assets of US and EU companies drilling hundreds or thousands of miles from the UK?

You need to stop having fantasies and start to work out how you plan to afford to heat your home.

One I froze my tarriff last year on a rate well below current rates, two I’m a very low usage household so heating my house will not be an issue and my bills are affordable for at least the next two years.

also I didn’t say let’s just seize them. You use the threat of nationalisation to try and leverage either windfall taxes, or better rates from companies which are extracting gas and oil in the North Sea under licenses issued by the uk government. I was responding to a PP who said they would delist if you wind fall taxed them. If they do at that point a government could size the assets

also as the PP meantioned RDs and BP have generally wound down in the North Sea.

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/jul/29/foreign-control-of-north-sea-oil-licences-threatens-uks-net-zero-goal

as such it seems a large portion are owned by equity funds and foreign countries including china. This is where the reference to Nasser and the Suez comes in

wenevernewthis · 26/08/2022 02:17

Beecham · 26/08/2022 00:01

Really don't understand how not paying your bill would help anyone else?

it's a form of protest.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:16

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:07

So, other than complaining on the internet, what’s your plan?

Mine’s simple enough, I’ll pay the bill, but if I think it’s too much we’ll spend much of the winter in the home in France where very little heating is needed.

This isn't about 'me' or 'my family' this is about everyone. I am in a fortunate enough position that it won't be castrophic for us BUT that's beside the point. If you went to the shop and a pint of milk suddenly cost £50? Would you buy it? Oh course mot, because its ridiculous. The same thing here with energy

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:12

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:10

You didn't answer the question though. Would you be willing to pay £20,000 for energy IF the energy companies demand that price? Would you think that's reasonable? There are lots of families with elderly realities and others with small children that can't afford extortionate pricing. Is it just too bad for them?

I did answer the question, it’s up there, above your post.

And yes, why not? If I use £20,000 of energy of course I’ll pay for it, why wouldn’t I?

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:11

*relatives

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:11

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:07

Oh I know it’s not that simple, and I will admit I don’t know all the companies which a currently drilling in the and and used RDS and Bp as proxies for this.

yes they would likely delist, but we could then sieve the assets. It’s no different to madder seizing the suez.

it’s not a palatable option at all, ut the issue lies with a lack of proper taxation, or public ownership of fields a poor financial management of the revenues, a lack of energy security to wrap around this.

Norway has statoil which is state owned and the Norwegian policy is to own 50% of all drilling liecenses.

*North sea and used RDS… And Nasser not madder

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:10

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:07

Oh I know it’s not that simple, and I will admit I don’t know all the companies which a currently drilling in the and and used RDS and Bp as proxies for this.

yes they would likely delist, but we could then sieve the assets. It’s no different to madder seizing the suez.

it’s not a palatable option at all, ut the issue lies with a lack of proper taxation, or public ownership of fields a poor financial management of the revenues, a lack of energy security to wrap around this.

Norway has statoil which is state owned and the Norwegian policy is to own 50% of all drilling liecenses.

Why would the government possibly try to seize foreign companies just because you are annoyed at your energy bill?

More to the point, have you any idea how ridiculous that plan is? What exactly do you imagine would happen if we tried to “seize”
the assets of US and EU companies drilling hundreds or thousands of miles from the UK?

You need to stop having fantasies and start to work out how you plan to afford to heat your home.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:10

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:04

Ah, you are one of them?

No, climate change is not BS,

You didn't answer the question though. Would you be willing to pay £20,000 for energy IF the energy companies demand that price? Would you think that's reasonable? There are lots of families with elderly realities and others with small children that can't afford extortionate pricing. Is it just too bad for them?

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:07

Flapjacker48 · 26/08/2022 01:53

@Scepticalwotsits Your post shows a gross lack of understanding of a.) the reserves and ease of extraction of oil/gas in the north sea and b.) Shell/BPs role in the north sea.

The north sea is a tiny part of shell and BPs business (they sold most fields off as they became more depleted and harder to work).

If BP/shell are subject to huge extra taxation (or nationalisation) they will simply de-list in London and move abroad.

In the 1970s when Heath was PM, he had the chairmen of BP/Shell in Downing street and pleaded with them to help the UK with cheaper energy - they were not able to do so and this was when, at least in BP's case, the Government OWNED a huge part of the company!

Oh I know it’s not that simple, and I will admit I don’t know all the companies which a currently drilling in the and and used RDS and Bp as proxies for this.

yes they would likely delist, but we could then sieve the assets. It’s no different to madder seizing the suez.

it’s not a palatable option at all, ut the issue lies with a lack of proper taxation, or public ownership of fields a poor financial management of the revenues, a lack of energy security to wrap around this.

Norway has statoil which is state owned and the Norwegian policy is to own 50% of all drilling liecenses.

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:07

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:48

Can't you see it's going to get to a point where they'll charge you whatever they want. £20,000 per year? Is that OK?

Climate change is BS, its another bandwagon to support the rise in costs. Did you know the amount of carbon dioxide in the air actually increases when the weather is warmer. It is not the carbon dioxide in the air that makes the temperature increase. I don't know how you can gelieve humans are able to affect the climate. I'm sorry but you are a lost cause

So, other than complaining on the internet, what’s your plan?

Mine’s simple enough, I’ll pay the bill, but if I think it’s too much we’ll spend much of the winter in the home in France where very little heating is needed.

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:04

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:48

Can't you see it's going to get to a point where they'll charge you whatever they want. £20,000 per year? Is that OK?

Climate change is BS, its another bandwagon to support the rise in costs. Did you know the amount of carbon dioxide in the air actually increases when the weather is warmer. It is not the carbon dioxide in the air that makes the temperature increase. I don't know how you can gelieve humans are able to affect the climate. I'm sorry but you are a lost cause

Ah, you are one of them?

No, climate change is not BS,

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:02

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 01:59

I’m sorry but you are wrapping two separate things together. Climate change isn’t a hoax or con, unless you are talking a con going across generations and hundreds of thousands of scientists including peer reviewed studies and empirical data.

the current prices are due to geopolitical situation, unrestrained capitalism and market forces. We buy oil and gas in a global market. Russia has cut gas to the Eu by 90% f what it had at this point last year. That means more demand for less supply hence prices going up an producers make the most of this and gauge.

Ountries which have either state owned producers, or have rules about supplying their cou try first and have ample storage are better placed as are majority nuclear powered countries (hence why France is doing better than Germany) The UK has none of these, poor storage resulting in us being at risk of any price e shocks. Energy security has been woefully lacking in the UK

This isn’t some con to move us to green tech, but poor decisions by multiple governments in regards to energy security. Blaming something else is the exact reason we ended up with brexit because the eu made all these laws that were enforced on us, and when unpopular blame big bad eu, even when the uk had ratified the legislation without raising issue or comment, nor had engaged in the legislative process.

The previous posted mentioned climate change, hence why I addressed it

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:00

So basically we are being held to ransom at the hands of a terrorist? It's the same thing isn't it? The energy companies are the terrorists and we are thier hostages?

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 01:59

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:48

Can't you see it's going to get to a point where they'll charge you whatever they want. £20,000 per year? Is that OK?

Climate change is BS, its another bandwagon to support the rise in costs. Did you know the amount of carbon dioxide in the air actually increases when the weather is warmer. It is not the carbon dioxide in the air that makes the temperature increase. I don't know how you can gelieve humans are able to affect the climate. I'm sorry but you are a lost cause

I’m sorry but you are wrapping two separate things together. Climate change isn’t a hoax or con, unless you are talking a con going across generations and hundreds of thousands of scientists including peer reviewed studies and empirical data.

the current prices are due to geopolitical situation, unrestrained capitalism and market forces. We buy oil and gas in a global market. Russia has cut gas to the Eu by 90% f what it had at this point last year. That means more demand for less supply hence prices going up an producers make the most of this and gauge.

Ountries which have either state owned producers, or have rules about supplying their cou try first and have ample storage are better placed as are majority nuclear powered countries (hence why France is doing better than Germany) The UK has none of these, poor storage resulting in us being at risk of any price e shocks. Energy security has been woefully lacking in the UK

This isn’t some con to move us to green tech, but poor decisions by multiple governments in regards to energy security. Blaming something else is the exact reason we ended up with brexit because the eu made all these laws that were enforced on us, and when unpopular blame big bad eu, even when the uk had ratified the legislation without raising issue or comment, nor had engaged in the legislative process.

Flapjacker48 · 26/08/2022 01:53

@Scepticalwotsits Your post shows a gross lack of understanding of a.) the reserves and ease of extraction of oil/gas in the north sea and b.) Shell/BPs role in the north sea.

The north sea is a tiny part of shell and BPs business (they sold most fields off as they became more depleted and harder to work).

If BP/shell are subject to huge extra taxation (or nationalisation) they will simply de-list in London and move abroad.

In the 1970s when Heath was PM, he had the chairmen of BP/Shell in Downing street and pleaded with them to help the UK with cheaper energy - they were not able to do so and this was when, at least in BP's case, the Government OWNED a huge part of the company!

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:52

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 01:30

There are a solution but it’s unpalatable for the government.

1 nationalise the North Sea gas fields, prioritise gas to uk at a reasonable rate, store some sell any excess if there is any at market price to none uk consumers. If we are having brexit it damn well use what time slither of benefits we could get from it.

yes BP and RDS will scream, offer them option one or option 2 sell to a set price or have periodic windfall taxes above a threshold and if the refuse option 2 then will go with option 1.

Agreed, this is on the government. They run this country apparently.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:49

*believe

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:48

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 01:42

Lie down? What are you talking about, and why would I need to pay 50% of my income on heating?

You do understand climate change, yes? You are able to understand why you need to stop using so much energy?

Can't you see it's going to get to a point where they'll charge you whatever they want. £20,000 per year? Is that OK?

Climate change is BS, its another bandwagon to support the rise in costs. Did you know the amount of carbon dioxide in the air actually increases when the weather is warmer. It is not the carbon dioxide in the air that makes the temperature increase. I don't know how you can gelieve humans are able to affect the climate. I'm sorry but you are a lost cause

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 01:42

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:39

It's matters what you think is reasonable because you are a human being with a brain. If you can't see that this is beyond ridiculous, then I dread to think how many other people there are like you, willing to lie down. It's common sense! I assume you have some kind if income from somewhere? Would you be happy to pay 50% of that to an energy company because THEY tell you too?

Lie down? What are you talking about, and why would I need to pay 50% of my income on heating?

You do understand climate change, yes? You are able to understand why you need to stop using so much energy?

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 01:40

Ushkin · 26/08/2022 01:33

Yes, it’s annoying when things that were once cheap become expensive, but why should the state get involved?

It may be “annoying” for you. For many it literally means not eating. Honestly, what planet do you live on?!

The same one as you. Why do you think anyone other than you is responsible for housing and feeding your family?

Do you not understand how unreasonable that is?

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 01:39

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 01:25

Why would it matter what I think is reasonable? These are international companies extracting oil and gas from the ground, and selling it for whatever they can. “Reasonable” doesn’t come into it. Buy it, don’t buy it, it’s really up to you what you choose to do.

If you aren’t happy with the cost get a word-burner and paraffin lamps, or move in with family, or just use less.

It's matters what you think is reasonable because you are a human being with a brain. If you can't see that this is beyond ridiculous, then I dread to think how many other people there are like you, willing to lie down. It's common sense! I assume you have some kind if income from somewhere? Would you be happy to pay 50% of that to an energy company because THEY tell you too?

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 01:38

Ushkin · 26/08/2022 01:31

If you aren’t happy with the cost get a word-burner and paraffin lamps, or move in with family, or just use less.

Great suggestions! Except that wood burners are associated with significant health risks and are an environmental disaster; not everyone has family they can conveniently just move in with; and many people are already using the bare minimum. Any other pearls of wisdom?

Not really. If that doesn’t work for you you’ve got two options, pay or accept being a bit cold.

Your post is a great example of your issue here though, you are asking other people to help with a situation that’s yours alone to solve.

If you can’t afford to heat your house this winter, why are you not the one coming up with answers?

Have you tried for a promotion at work, for example, or found a second job in the evenings or at weekends? Have you taken in a lodger, or reached out to a family in a similar situation to see about sharing one home and so halving your heating bills?

I know exactly how I’m going to get through this winter, and all the ones that follow, but that’s neither here nor there; how are you going to do it?

Ushkin · 26/08/2022 01:33

Yes, it’s annoying when things that were once cheap become expensive, but why should the state get involved?

It may be “annoying” for you. For many it literally means not eating. Honestly, what planet do you live on?!

Ushkin · 26/08/2022 01:31

If you aren’t happy with the cost get a word-burner and paraffin lamps, or move in with family, or just use less.

Great suggestions! Except that wood burners are associated with significant health risks and are an environmental disaster; not everyone has family they can conveniently just move in with; and many people are already using the bare minimum. Any other pearls of wisdom?