Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Energy don’t pay or what else

312 replies

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 26/08/2022 06:40

Mine’s simple enough, I’ll pay the bill, but if I think it’s too much we’ll spend much of the winter in the home in France where very little heating is needed.

Using the second home in France! Why didn’t everyone else think of that!

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 06:39

Baker90 · 26/08/2022 06:12

Not paying is a worrying idea but the idea behind what others are planning is to cancel direct debits in October as it will create mass work for the companies to organise sending out bills etc to everyone every month. (Think idea is to go back to paper bills) Then paying for usage (or what your energy bills were before mass hikes) only. Then raising a complaint. Higher cost for admin. No extra money from people being In credit over the year which they invest and earn profit on and then each complaint once it goes to deadlock, Then the ombudsman costs £500 to the company, £550 if over a certain amount of complaints are made. Idea being to hit them in the only part that hurts... money and profit.

Our fixed rate is coming to an end and we're generally petrified. We both work full time but fall into those bottom notches. Very little wiggle room. Add into that rent increasing by over 50% in the last year due to 2 landlords in a year wanting to sell and just those 2 bills will have increased by £700 a month. Let alone the rest..

So much of what you’ve posted here is wrong!

You don’t have to pay over the year monthly in even bouts, of course not.

But most people find a consistent mothly bill much easier to manage than £170 pcm for a few months when is warm, being ramped up to a potential maximum of £550 pcm when it’s colder and after the cap has been risen.

Unless they keep it to the side and put it onto a savings account.

Ombudsman don’t just fine energy companies because someone has moaned. Look it up. The Jack Monroe school of advice is plain wrong.

What are all these complaints meant to actually be about anyway???

BuddhaAtSea · 26/08/2022 06:38

@PasTrop you come across as incredibly arrogant and out of touch with reality, and that’s me being mild.
‘Why can’t you fuckity-fuck off to your own property in France, like the rest of us?!’

I’m not sure I can make you understand how preposterous your point of view is. But it might give you a moment to pause if I tell you you’ve embarrassed yourself. Massively.
Your solution it’s to tell people: ‘Pay!’

Other people’s circumstances ARE different from yours.

There are people in this world who’s children and loved ones depend on a machine that needs electricity in order to survive. Plugged 24/7.

When you’re old, your mobility decreases, elderly spend a bit more time than me sat in a chair. When you sit for a long period of time, you get cold. The pensions will mostly pay for (part of) the bills, leaving nothing for food. They simply cannot pay. In the real world, people actually die of hypothermia.

A family of 4, working full time, will see half of their income going on utility bills alone, most people don’t have trust funds, I hate to break it to you.

The ‘I’ll be alright Jacks’ of this world are 1-3% of the population.

Shall we think of a sensible solution now?

Quincythequince · 26/08/2022 06:33

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:51

if you have a belt that can be tightened, you are better off than someone who has no notches left to tighten in the first place

yes, I already acknowledged that I’m better off, I’m asking what, if anything, can I do to force the govt to help the No-notches? I’m alright, so fuck ‘em, not my problem, right?

You can’t really tbh. At least not in terms of not paying your bill. So much terrible and plain wrong advice out there on that front.

If you are using it, you have to pay it. You don’t have to pay more, or have a Dd that’s too high, but you have to pay what you use, which will be dear.

RedRiverShore2 · 26/08/2022 06:28

jetadore · 26/08/2022 00:08

I don’t buy into all that stuff about ombudsman fees costing energy companies millions. However if enough people didn’t pay it could cause cash flow problems for the providers which would force the government to step in to prevent them going under.

Maybe some small companies might go under like many already have and more probably will anyway but then we will just be left with the big six, how will that help anyone.

hamdden12 · 26/08/2022 06:26

@PasTrop if prices keep rising you'll be selling your second home in France to pay for your gas and electricity. But as long as you've used it and the company is charging you whatever they feel like that's okay right?

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 26/08/2022 06:15

jetadore · 25/08/2022 23:29

So the “don’t pay” movement seems to be gaining some traction but so does the “just shut up and pay” movement telling us to stop being so naive and how there are ‘much better ways’ to tackle the issue? What are these ‘better ways’ then? Place my faith in the leadership and benevolence of Liz or Rishi?

I remember people refusing to pay (and rioting) over the poll tax, you hear about protest movements in other countries, what about the yellow vests for fucks sake. Here we’re too scared to do anything in case it affects our precious credit scores, make excuses not to demonstrate because we allowed the government to take away our right to protest.

What am I allowed to do then? Wait for people to start going broke or dying, and then tut over the newspaper headlines? Wait for the next election so we can vote in the same bunch of bastards, or Starmer’s diet bastards? Research and publish my proposal for a coherent, long term energy policy since nobody in government can be bothered? Campaign for world peace? Come up with patronising explanations for how the crisis is due to a complex and unfortunate coincidence of geo-political factors and the prevailing economic doctrine which is actually much better than the alternative when you think about it what are you a socialist or something? How long should I wait and see if things magically get better? Is ofgem going to wait to announce the price cap? No, they’re doing it next month. Just enough time to get onto my bank.

I’m fortunate that I could probably afford the projected (can’t wait for the big reveal, so exciting) increase with a bit of belt tightening. But I’m inclined to cancel my payments all the same, if it would put the shits up them. I don’t want to be all “I’m alright jack” while others struggle, nor do I want to be intimidated by the threat of ccj’s and conservative claptrap, so that the Tories and their mates can sit there laughing at us and blathering on about how profit isn’t a crime whilst we all meekly wring our hands and wait in the cold for the invisible hand of the market to come to our aid.

Just feel like is there something I can practically do to make a difference, now, or am I actually powerless?

PS I know there was a thread on this recently there probably have been others since I didn’t find any when I searched though.

I think think the powers that be are sitting on their hands at the moment and choosing to ignore it out of plain laziness/ hoping that people will resign themselves to a new life of drudgery and hardship and just pay. This will have a domino effect as thousands of businesses will simply fold under. People will then find themselves having to try and cough up £7k+ a year in energy bills in the midst of a recession and without a job to pay for it.

I really don’t have a lot of hope at the moment given that the country is on a trajectory towards disaster while the Government is asleep at the wheel. And where’s Starmer when we need him? Some opposition - not!

Baker90 · 26/08/2022 06:12

Not paying is a worrying idea but the idea behind what others are planning is to cancel direct debits in October as it will create mass work for the companies to organise sending out bills etc to everyone every month. (Think idea is to go back to paper bills) Then paying for usage (or what your energy bills were before mass hikes) only. Then raising a complaint. Higher cost for admin. No extra money from people being In credit over the year which they invest and earn profit on and then each complaint once it goes to deadlock, Then the ombudsman costs £500 to the company, £550 if over a certain amount of complaints are made. Idea being to hit them in the only part that hurts... money and profit.

Our fixed rate is coming to an end and we're generally petrified. We both work full time but fall into those bottom notches. Very little wiggle room. Add into that rent increasing by over 50% in the last year due to 2 landlords in a year wanting to sell and just those 2 bills will have increased by £700 a month. Let alone the rest..

the80sweregreat · 26/08/2022 05:59

The price cap is forecast to be 3500 , but is going up every three months I believe
It's all such grim news all round

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 26/08/2022 05:56

Yay let's all fuck off to France for the winter!

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 26/08/2022 05:55

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:07

So, other than complaining on the internet, what’s your plan?

Mine’s simple enough, I’ll pay the bill, but if I think it’s too much we’ll spend much of the winter in the home in France where very little heating is needed.

So easy easy for you to say that people should just suck it up and pay up, even if it leaves them with no money to pay for anything else when you have just said in your post that you will just decamp to your other home in France. Massive hypocrite alert!

Many people stand to lose everything because of this. It is going to lead to financial devastation for many thousands of businesses and ordinary people and their families. People are going to get ill and some will die.

It is going to lead to homelessness for many, it is going to drive people to suicide. Families will be split up. Children are going to suffer - their parents won’t be able to afford to feed them nutritious food or keep their homes warm enough (that’s if they are lucky enough that they don’t end up losing their homes). Many schools are saying they won’t be able to afford to stay open 5 days a week so yet again children will lose out on a decent education.

But hey, so long as we pay up and the shareholders are paid their massive profits right? 🙄

Flapjacker48 · 26/08/2022 05:33

@BloodyCamping hydroelectric schemes have nothing to do with being surrounded by water. You need huge mountain ranges with lakes and fast flowing rivers. Scotland had some hydro but this contributes a tiny amount to the uk overall.

BloodyCamping · 26/08/2022 05:25

we are an island surrounded by water, why the hell don’t we have hydropower like New Zealand?

why aren’t all new houses built with solar panels?

why do we have so few wind farms?

Lilyann60 · 26/08/2022 05:10

Booklover3 · 26/08/2022 02:57

@PasTrop most people in the U.K. don’t have the luxury of going to their second home in France to avoid the price of gas and electricity this winter.

Exactly! Seems here is a total lack of empathy for many thousands who are already living hand to mouth and literally can not afford these massive price hikes. There is no money in the pot !
I’m seriously worried about the impact this will have on those families already struggling with inflation .
Yes there will be some Government aid but it’ll only cover a proportion of the increased costs.

I’m relieved I do have savings to cover the costs so at least I won’t freeze , go hungry , risk losing my home , go into poverty, become ill; all of which will happen to many many families over the winter.

I don’t know what the answer is but this “I’m alright Jack “ response sickens me.

the80sweregreat · 26/08/2022 05:06

Mine will double in the next few months.
It is awful what is going on here , but people won't just not pay their bills because of all manner of reasons. The energy companies will have to accept what people can pay I suppose.
I wish I had a second home to move to avoid a lot of this , Unfortunately I don't ! Along with millions of others.

Cyclemarine · 26/08/2022 03:44

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:10

You didn't answer the question though. Would you be willing to pay £20,000 for energy IF the energy companies demand that price? Would you think that's reasonable? There are lots of families with elderly realities and others with small children that can't afford extortionate pricing. Is it just too bad for them?

I just saw under a Martin Lewis post on Twitter a woman shared a screenshot of the price estimated quoted by Scottish power for the year - it was over 11K!! So if things continue the way they are, we aren’t far off from seeing quotes like 20K unfortunately.

Also to people going on about less usage, because standing charges have increased as well, a lot of people making reductions in usage may only see a limited benefit in terms of the bill since they can’t reduce the standing charges cost.

Bluebellberry · 26/08/2022 03:33

Surely @PasTrop posts are some sort of satire!

HRTQueen · 26/08/2022 03:28

Poll Tax was completely different situation

there is nothing stopping you making a placard and protesting. starting a Facebook/Twitter/Instagram campaign and it’s your choice if your don’t want to pay to make a stand send as many letter/emails/tweets as you feel you need to

the I’m so concerned for those less fortunate hand wringing posts doesn’t achieve anything

as much as mn would love to believe the country shall go wild rioting most will just be trying their best to get by we are tired and worried and can’t be arsed with playing out the revolution that the left so desperately seems to want the wc class to do

Booklover3 · 26/08/2022 02:57

@PasTrop most people in the U.K. don’t have the luxury of going to their second home in France to avoid the price of gas and electricity this winter.

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:39

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:29

Well yes, of course. If the UK valued the price that could be paid then no-one would sell us any gas at all.

Is there anyone among you lot with even the vaguest understanding of how energy markets work? Why would a company sell gas here for less than the wholesale price when Germany will pay more?

Because France has forced EDF to sell below market rate for energy for French consumers so it can be done

Nat6999 · 26/08/2022 02:37

Martin Lewis said put in a letter of complaint, they can't cut you off or anything while your letter is being investigated, when you get a reply escalate your complaint to the next level & keep going until you reach the top where your next step is the energy watchdog. If enough people complain it will take them ages to deal with the complaints & hopefully something will have been sorted out by the government. You can also refuse to have your DD increased, if you are paying something they can't cut you off.

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:29

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:21

OK so you think it's OK for anyone to charge any price they want without regulation?

Well yes, of course. If the UK valued the price that could be paid then no-one would sell us any gas at all.

Is there anyone among you lot with even the vaguest understanding of how energy markets work? Why would a company sell gas here for less than the wholesale price when Germany will pay more?

Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 02:22

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:19

Exactly. If everyone did the same thing, what could they do? They'd have to be more reasonable

The price issue though this time isn’t t energy retailers, it’s the production companies and demand being greater due to less supply, so the protest is targeting the wrong area.

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:21

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:19

Then don’t use it.

You are making very hard work of a really simple situation here. How can you not understand?

OK so you think it's OK for anyone to charge any price they want without regulation?

PasTrop · 26/08/2022 02:19

Aretheyhavingalaugh · 26/08/2022 02:16

This isn't about 'me' or 'my family' this is about everyone. I am in a fortunate enough position that it won't be castrophic for us BUT that's beside the point. If you went to the shop and a pint of milk suddenly cost £50? Would you buy it? Oh course mot, because its ridiculous. The same thing here with energy

Then don’t use it.

You are making very hard work of a really simple situation here. How can you not understand?