Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my daughter to finish eating her meal on time.

137 replies

A12326 · 25/08/2022 23:06

AIBU?

My daughter is 5 years old. And lately my patience with her is running low since I am pregnant and she just started school.

Today, she just got back from school and I served her meal, chicken and pasta and sat her on her little table to eat food. The food has been cut for her to eat it easily so it is not on big chunks and pieces. She sits down. But proceeds to do ANYTHING but eat. She's watching cartoons (fine with me as long as she eats) playing with her toys and standing up to talk to us instead of eating. The thing is she ASKED for her food. She came and asked me for cookies but I told her not until after dinner so I know she was hungry. I served her at 4:30 it is now 5:55 and she still is eating.

Her dad is now mad at me because I told her finish eating in an angry tone, and pulled her table in front of me to make sure she is eating. In the process her food slipped and fell all over the floor which I cleaned. My husband is now acting as if I'm the AH for doing that. When he was the one in charge of watching her eat her meal while I took a nap. Now, I did ask after waking up if she had finished her meal. He said she was eating, turns out she was not but as usual he was not paying attention.

So. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
WoodlandMummy · 26/08/2022 07:19

dreamingbohemian · 25/08/2022 23:28

I'm not from the UK so this thread really confuses me

In most places kids have a small snack after school and then everyone eats together at 6 or whatever. Can you try that?

What has this thread got to do with the UK Confused

ChronicOverthinkr · 26/08/2022 07:18

Toys and TV during meal times? Sitting on her own at a solo table to eat? And you are surprised she doesn’t choose to eat quickly?! 😂😂😂😂

Nobetterthansheoughttobe · 26/08/2022 07:15

A12326 · 25/08/2022 23:06

AIBU?

My daughter is 5 years old. And lately my patience with her is running low since I am pregnant and she just started school.

Today, she just got back from school and I served her meal, chicken and pasta and sat her on her little table to eat food. The food has been cut for her to eat it easily so it is not on big chunks and pieces. She sits down. But proceeds to do ANYTHING but eat. She's watching cartoons (fine with me as long as she eats) playing with her toys and standing up to talk to us instead of eating. The thing is she ASKED for her food. She came and asked me for cookies but I told her not until after dinner so I know she was hungry. I served her at 4:30 it is now 5:55 and she still is eating.

Her dad is now mad at me because I told her finish eating in an angry tone, and pulled her table in front of me to make sure she is eating. In the process her food slipped and fell all over the floor which I cleaned. My husband is now acting as if I'm the AH for doing that. When he was the one in charge of watching her eat her meal while I took a nap. Now, I did ask after waking up if she had finished her meal. He said she was eating, turns out she was not but as usual he was not paying attention.

So. Am I being unreasonable?

Why are you letting her eat with so many distractions? She is playing you. Take away the distractions, make her concentrate on the food. Talk to her about the meal while she is eating to interest her in the food.
She is probably acting up because you are pregnant; she is attention seeking

38daystogo · 26/08/2022 07:09

You've made hard work whilst preggs. Just remove the plate next time and tell DD to ask for the food when she is ready to eat!

The food surely went cold from 04.30. Kids ask for snacks all the time it's just what kids do. Agree with others though you need a kitchen table and TV off.

Softplayhooray · 26/08/2022 07:03

arethereanyleftatall · 25/08/2022 23:32

Doesn't sound like a very pleasant atmosphere.

This is fair...it might give your DD issues around food and your DH sounds like he'd rather lie about her eating than face your anger...why not just give her a little snack and food later, or just put the food away if she isn't hungry? After all as adults we eat when we're hungry not when someone tells us to!

JRsandCoffee · 26/08/2022 07:01

Loving all the “just eat together” responses, not possible for every family. I feel your pain OP. My DD was on the slow train when it came to eating and my DH is rarely home before 7.30/ 8.00pm then in no shape to just sit down and eat straight away (cycles). When she was 5/6/7 I used to sit her at the table and kind do my things/ have a cup of tea with her/ around her. Sometimes we would play a game on the side (Granny’s attic/ would you rather etc to keep things moving/ entertaining), occasionally I would let her watch a programme if I was super busy but mostly not, made her too slow. We always do family supper on a Sunday, something we all like and aim to just have a nice chilled meal together. She eats at table with others at school and when we are out as well and can pull out the pretty manners fine. She’s older now and so long as she eats it I’m less picky about where she eats!

stayathomer · 26/08/2022 06:42

Agree with people saying eat together and no screens but also I don’t love that you think shouting and pulling her table wasn’t just a bit out of order? Yes we lose our tempers sometimes but that doesn’t mean it’s fine. Also, she’s 5. It’s so young. And I get being pregnant you’re tired etc but still

Yerroblemom1923 · 26/08/2022 06:37

@OakAshBeech That was my concern too when I read that post....an hour in the toilet....rang alarm bells with me.

1AngelicFruitCake · 26/08/2022 06:28

Great update OP. I have a friend who used to let her child pick apart their meal, watch TV, go and play when she felt like it. I had her for tea a few times and she struggled because I asked her to sit at a table and eat with me and my child. When she started school she struggled at lunchtimes because she couldn’t get up and down as she always had.

I think it’s great you’re going to model good habits to her. I don’t think there’s anything wrong with putting the meal away after a set time if she hadn’t eaten it, with the understanding she won’t be eating after that (sure that is an unpopular opinion!)

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 26/08/2022 06:16

I grew up eating at separate times (or at the same time but in different rooms) to everyone else in my family, because that's just how it worked (they were all in different rooms too). So I get what you mean about it being normal for you OP. However I have my own family now and we do manage to sit together to eat dinner at least a few days a week, which is a decent compromise. One of my DC eats v slowly too but this has improved as he gets older :)

Caspianberg · 26/08/2022 06:05

She’s probably not hungry enough at 4.30pm for a full dinner after lunch. Just let her have a snack and then all sit together at 6.30pm for her dinner.

I know you say you eat main meal at lunchtime, but maybe it’s time to change that so she can see you all eating the same thing together now school age? Just swap so you eat lighter meal at lunch and main together in the evening

Zonder · 26/08/2022 05:58

Sorry I somehow missed your update. Well done OP. Hope you have a nice meal time together.

Zonder · 26/08/2022 05:58

Stickmansmum · 25/08/2022 23:09

At 5 it would probably be best if you all are together? She needs to learn what proper mealtime behaviour is and that’s the best way to teach it. Also tv/screens off. And no getting up and down. But as I said much harder if she’s expected to eat alone rather than as a family.

This.

inappropriateraspberry · 26/08/2022 04:44

What does she have for lunch at school? If she's having a hot meal at lunchtime, maybe she just isn't hungry enough for a cooked meal at home, especially at 4.30. I'd try and hold the mealtime back a little until 5pm at the earliest. Just because she asked for cookies, doesn't necessarily mean she's ready for her tea! Most small children will eat something sweet, hungry or not.

Pinkchicken85 · 26/08/2022 03:14

Discovereads · 25/08/2022 23:12

I agree with pp. You need to all eat dinner together at a table with no TV, no toys, no screens. If that means a snack after school to tide her over until a 6pm or later dinner, do it.

This works for us too.

Marvellousmadness · 26/08/2022 01:54

Mealtime is for eating not for watching tv
Tell her she can watch tv when she is finished
And no toys obviously..

To the pp that said that dinner couldtake hours: 🤣 setting limits and rewards/punishments seem to be a better road. Aint nobody got time to sit with a kid for hours ...

LAMPS1 · 26/08/2022 01:48

Glad you have decided to eat with her. It’s very sad for a young child to have to sit at a table alone to eat. Eating together in a loving family environment is key to general development.

johnd2 · 26/08/2022 00:59

Some great post here from both the OP and other people. I'd just like to add a small principle that helped me reduce the stress/annoyance.
Things I decide are how much food to offer, what food, how long it's available and where to offer it. And things my son can decide is whether to eat it, how much to eat of each thing, and when he is finished.
This is quite reassuring for him because he knows the rules, and the same for me, it's comforting to me too.
This means he can focus on eating rather than battling.
And it's a good boundary to divide the responsibility for things we ourselves have control, and not to try to take responsibility for things we can't control.
This is just to add to the excellent points from other posters.
Good luck and take care.

queenMab99 · 26/08/2022 00:36

My grandchildren are 14 and 11, when they eat at my house there are no screens, tv off, and sit at the dining table, otherwise they don't eat properly. Little ones need to learn from the start, how to eat at meal times.

Happyhappyday · 26/08/2022 00:36

I mean… basically everything you’re doing is not great for encouraging good eating habits… and easy to fix.

eat as a family. If she gets up, dinner is over. No TV or toys. Encouraging tv while eating encourages mindless eating.

Putting pressure on her, also not great.

also, most children will ask for cookies… I sure don’t eat them only when I’m hungry. I would offer a small healthy snack, ie an apple, celery and peanut butter, whatever. Then dinner at usual time.

mathanxiety · 26/08/2022 00:28

You are being massively unreasonable.

You caused quite a scene by pulling the table so hard that the plate was knocked to the floor.

Being pregnant and tired isn't an excuse for behaving badly toward a child.

Your daughter should have a snack when she comes home from school and the family should eat together. Sitting a child down to eat on her own at a different time from others' mealtime is the opposite of what mealtime is supposed to be.

Five years olds have the attention span of a gnat at tbe best of times. Your child has come home from a long day of school knackered If she wasn't interested in eating a full dinner at 4.30 you should have gently asked her if she's full or if she'd like to come back later to finish. If she had said she was hungry you should have offered a snack instead.

If I've got it right she's been sitting in front of a plate of food she clearly isn't inrerested in for an hour and a half, getting no exercise, nothing creative or olayful, and watching tv.

A12326 · 26/08/2022 00:18

I wanted to thank you all again for your insight. Me and my husband have agreed to sit down at the dinner table with her tomorrow. As many have commented I will give her a light snack and then give her dinner after unwinding.

I was not raised eating dinner at the table with my parents. We all ate a seperate dinner times so for me it is normal. It did work with her until now that she is in school and doesn't spend much time with us. Before, she would be all day with me or her grandma when I used to work at the office. Which may be why she is taking her sweet time because she needs attention. That being said, I think it is a good idea to start eating dinner now with our daughter since we work and when she gets home from school I am still working for like an hour. We all could use the added family time.

Wish me luck. Hopefully this works for our family too!

Again thanks. Especially to the people who were not judgemental. My daughter is being well taken care of at home, if she wasn't I wouldn't really have cared to ask strangers for ways to better our eating routines. Being a parent means making mistakes. In this household we do say sorry and cha ge habits that do not seem to be working. I doubt anyone here is a perfect parent. We all have failed one way or the other, that is the beautiful aspect of being human, learning from our mistakes and making them better.

OP posts:
Scepticalwotsits · 26/08/2022 00:06

Kids take forever to eat and even more so when distracted. Turn off the tv. Sit at the table with them, even if you are not eating and it will go quicker. Palming them off for an easier time now always rears it’s head with a problem magnified later

Cascais · 25/08/2022 23:58

eat your lighter version of dinner with her

WeAllHaveWings · 25/08/2022 23:57

stuck!