Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect my daughter to finish eating her meal on time.

137 replies

A12326 · 25/08/2022 23:06

AIBU?

My daughter is 5 years old. And lately my patience with her is running low since I am pregnant and she just started school.

Today, she just got back from school and I served her meal, chicken and pasta and sat her on her little table to eat food. The food has been cut for her to eat it easily so it is not on big chunks and pieces. She sits down. But proceeds to do ANYTHING but eat. She's watching cartoons (fine with me as long as she eats) playing with her toys and standing up to talk to us instead of eating. The thing is she ASKED for her food. She came and asked me for cookies but I told her not until after dinner so I know she was hungry. I served her at 4:30 it is now 5:55 and she still is eating.

Her dad is now mad at me because I told her finish eating in an angry tone, and pulled her table in front of me to make sure she is eating. In the process her food slipped and fell all over the floor which I cleaned. My husband is now acting as if I'm the AH for doing that. When he was the one in charge of watching her eat her meal while I took a nap. Now, I did ask after waking up if she had finished her meal. He said she was eating, turns out she was not but as usual he was not paying attention.

So. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
ChagSameachDoreen · 26/08/2022 08:45

ginslinger · 26/08/2022 08:41

we've got a new contender for 'cancel the cheque', folks

'all eat together'

I don't understand why a family wouldn't all eat together. I don't banish DH off to another table, so why would I do that to DD?

ginslinger · 26/08/2022 08:41

we've got a new contender for 'cancel the cheque', folks

'all eat together'

RunnyPaint · 26/08/2022 08:36

Great update OP. You are right in that none of us are perfect parents, and just when we think we have one thing sussed, the kids change and we have to figure it all out again. Good luck.

RedToothBrush · 26/08/2022 08:33

A12326 · 25/08/2022 23:53

Thank you all for your insight. I appreciate all of your advices.

  1. I do not sit her in front of the TV. The house I live in is an open area and while her father was watching TV she was watching it as well, so we turned it off.
  1. We eat at seperate dinner times because I eat much earlier with my husband while she is at school. I then eat a lighter version of dinner. I am not from the UK so my lunch at around 12 PM is my heavy meal of the day. Then I probably eat a heavy snack and at night maybe a sandwich. She does not eat dinner with us because of school. And we both are working from home so we eat earlier.
  1. That is the reason of the post, how me and my husband can't seem to agree with her not having toys or distractions while eating. Which can be frustrating since I feel I am fighting a battle alone which frustrates me even more. He is more of an ask her for her opinion about what she wants to do, while I am more of a believer that kids need rules like no toys at the table etc. Especially now that she is older. She was raised by both me and mother in law so she is heavily spoiled and was given food in front of the TV or playing games while being fed at thesame time by them. I am trying to take this habit away but it is proving difficult.
  1. I appreciate the comments that are understanding. Thanks! The ones that are more judgemental I do get your point though. And yes, she does sing loudly while she poos, thankfully she is quick at doing that.
  1. Based on what I have read I might start eating dinner time with her. Perhaps a later dinner where she eats her heavy meal and I eat my late night snack or something with her will work best.

Part of your problem here is your desire to eat at lunch no longer fits your family lifestyle and life in the uk.

Whilst you might want to stick to the habits of your culture, it's not really working and the one who is taking the brunt of this is your 5 year old daughter.

You need to organise your life around work and her day. Not your desire to maintain a habit that doesn't fit with your family life.

RayneDance · 26/08/2022 08:27

There is no way my children would have wanted a large meal at 4.30!

We eat at 6! Sometimes 7 or later.
In our house for one DC we have to use distraction to get her to eat because sitting around a silent table eating wasn't working.

I think people need to be flexible and apply different things at different times. My two have good table manners and can sit at a table however, we don't sit at a table together for every single meal at home.

AdriannaP · 26/08/2022 08:26

Dinner at 4.30pm alone in front of tv? Poor child

MdNdD · 26/08/2022 08:24

When my kids were that age and super hungry but super tired after school, I gave them fruit and veg snacks so even if they didn’t eat much of a ‘dinner’, I knew they’d had something healthy.

it is tricky at that age as they are starving after school but also so tired. Some people have a really early dinner and a snack later and some the opposite. Try different things and you’ll find something that works.

I agree with OPs that sitting at the table with her, setting an example should help. But, all kids are different and don’t be hard on yourself. It won’t change overnight, but if you stick to the routine, she’ll know what to expect. I’ve always eaten dinner at the table with my kids, since they were babies, they’re pretty good, but not perfect.

good luck :)

balalake · 26/08/2022 08:23

Stop the screen time at meals. Preferably never let it back, but if you do, not until several weeks of prioritising eating at meal times and finishing in a reasonable time.

Goldbar · 26/08/2022 08:21

OP, what works for us is that my DC has a substantial snack when home from school (peanut butter toast and apple, cheese and crackers etc). Then we eat at 6-6.30 together (DH is usually working late so just DC and I) and then it's straight upstairs into the bath (I run it before we eat) and then stories and bed.

HoneyFlowers · 26/08/2022 08:20

Take the blooming screens away so she can concentrate.

ThirteenLuckyForSome · 26/08/2022 08:13

Turn the TV off and stop with the "finish your plate and you can have a cookie" rubbish. I have a 4 and 6 year old, they eat away from the TV and stop when they decide they are full. I don't make them finish their food (hello childhood obesity). They take about half an hour at the very max, we ask are you finished and they say yes or no. Some days they eat more than other days, much like I do as an adult. Why do you make meal times seem like an ordeal?

Harrysmummy246 · 26/08/2022 08:13

Screen time while eating is not ok.

Pipsquiggle · 26/08/2022 08:13

My DS2 can take bloody ages to eat. After say 30 mins, when everyone else has finished eating by at least 15 minutes earlier, we give him a time frame of when his plate will be taken away and if he hasn't 'qualified' for dessert, his plate will be taken away and he won't have any food until his next meal

Hbhhhh193948484848 · 26/08/2022 08:08

Just act like you don’t care just play it cool don’t make a thing of food that’s how eating disorders start. Turn tv off sit with her away from toys have a snack with her if your not eating and talk about the day. If she doesn’t want it just save it for later ? Are you sure she likes the food ? Serve her something you know she loves and then offer it again later if she doesn’t want it. Otherwise just do some toast or porridge later on before bed. She will grow out of it. Just don’t make a thing of it and don’t let her see your frustrated.

Abraxan · 26/08/2022 08:05

Oops, I missed your update.

Well done for reconsidering the family eating times. I hope the new plan works out for you. It may not work immediately today. It could take a little time to adjust. You could perhaps engage your dd into helping set the table, a bit of simple food prep, etc. and get her involved and on board.

But it's a good thing to do anyway - all together, no distractions, just time to eat and chat together about what you've all enjoyed about your day, your plans for tomorrow/weekend, etc.

Abraxan · 26/08/2022 08:00

dreamingbohemian · 25/08/2022 23:28

I'm not from the UK so this thread really confuses me

In most places kids have a small snack after school and then everyone eats together at 6 or whatever. Can you try that?

That is, and was always, the norm for us with dd. Though dinner was nearer 6:30pm when dh got home from work, which shifted back to 7pm as she got older and could wait a bit longer.

We always ate as a family growing up to and it was something that was very important to me when I had a child.

Abraxan · 26/08/2022 07:57

Is she sat eating on her own?

She may eat better if sat at a table, without the distractions, but with you and/or your dh eating together with her. Would this be possible?

Demonstrate good dining etiquette as a family. Sit and eat, chat about the day, etc.

If she can't wait until a later time then you could have some healthy snacks prepared for straight after school, such as fruit, a slice of toast, etc.

On the odd occasion I eat alone I can very disinterested and distracted. It's not a nice experience to eat alone tbh.

ShandaLear · 26/08/2022 07:57

The other thing you could think about is whether she needs a lot of dinner. When my kids were at school they had school dinners and that, along with their after school snack, meant they weren’t that hungry in the evening, so they were easily distracted and took ages. I started giving them smaller portion sizes or eggs on toast or similar, with the proviso that if they were still hungry they could have more.

ItsRainingPens · 26/08/2022 07:52

WoodlandMummy · 26/08/2022 07:19

What has this thread got to do with the UK Confused

The extremely early eating maybe? As the poster says, in other countries this doesn't happen.
In France, for example, you would have "goûter" after school at about 4:30, then dinner at 7pm-ish, later if the kids are older

sheepdogdelight · 26/08/2022 07:52

Glad you've decided to change your meal times/routines about.

Not the point of the thread I know - but why are you cutting up her food still at 5? Fine if it's something particularly tricky/hard to cut, but in general a 5 year old should be getting used to using cutlery. They won't be cutting her food up for her at school. If she had to focus a bit more on her eating, that will also help stop her getting distracted by other things.

ItsRainingPens · 26/08/2022 07:49

Meals all sat down together, with no tv, phone, etc for anyone

Fivemoreminutes1 · 26/08/2022 07:46

4.30 is quite early for a 5yo. Maybe she’s not that hungry then. Why don’t you give her a snack at about 3.30 and then serve her tea at about 6?

MassiveSalad22 · 26/08/2022 07:40

Just chill out. If she’s sleeping and growing and learning then just chill out. She’s fine. Maybe she is eating enough at school. Maybe she’s ‘hungry’ but actually bored/tired/lonely/thirsty. Who knows but just relax, it will help.

Dumle · 26/08/2022 07:35

Why don't you all eat together at the same table? She shouldn't have to eat alone. She will be more encouraged to eat if you are together.

WoodlandMummy · 26/08/2022 07:20

ChronicOverthinkr · 26/08/2022 07:18

Toys and TV during meal times? Sitting on her own at a solo table to eat? And you are surprised she doesn’t choose to eat quickly?! 😂😂😂😂

It sounds fun, doesn’t it Confused

Swipe left for the next trending thread