Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how quickly I can expect to lose 8 stone on keto

39 replies

Imsosorryforanyoffencecaused · 25/08/2022 21:20

Due to postnatal depression and comfort eating, as well as PCOS, I gained a lot of weight to the point I am now over 19st at 5’5.

I have finally decided to do something about it and am doing keto. I have done it in the past and it really worked for me and I felt great, and I lost a reasonable amount of weight on it. However I only needed to lose a stone at the time.

Before my pregnancy (my son is now 2.5) I was a size 12 and healthy. I’ve always sat between a 10-12 so being as big as I am makes me feel so ashamed.

I’ve decided that for my health, my appearance, and the fact I want to be around for my son, to finally do something about it. I’ve never felt as ready as I do now to sort it out. But it’s a long road ahead of me.

I started keto on Monday at 19st 12lbs and I am now at 19st 7lbs. I know it’s mainly water weight but it’s making me feel motivated.

However as the weight loss slows down, how long would I reasonably expect it to take to lose 8 stone if I’m starting at the weight I am now?

and does anyone have any tips for keeping motivation going/getting over bad days if I do slip up?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TinySaltLick · 29/08/2022 13:17

missymarrk · 29/08/2022 12:19

This kind of stuff is verging on dangerous to suggest @TinySaltLick

How's it unrealistic?

people who keep fit walk 10,000 steps a day and do 3 workouts a week.. ? Calories of 1500 if you're wanting to lose weight isn't barking mad either. I'm not suggesting she eats 1000 calories and runs 10 miles a day.

Not the mild to moderate exercise obviously, but the claim that you will then lose a stone in a month - which not only is completely untrue based on the routine you have suggested, but isn't a safe rate of weight loss irrespective

Claims like that either set people up for failure, or encourage such extreme behaviour that isn't sustainable or safe

LimboLass · 29/08/2022 13:16

Please please and please do not go on this Keto fad. You might lose weight but you will not learn anything about nutrition.

When losing weight it is far better to think sustainable than fast

Reduce processed and junk food and try to cook from scratch with fresh meat, fish, and vegetables. Eat when you are hungry stop when you are full - nothing more to it.

Did I mention please do not use keto?

VladmirsPoutine · 29/08/2022 13:04

I can't say I know much about various diets but whenever I've needed to shift weight I've hit the gym and reduced my calorie intake. Good luck! I think slow and steady is your best bet even though I've always been inclined to throw everything I have into it.

Darkstar4855 · 29/08/2022 12:31

PS. Read “Why We Eat (Too Much)” if you want to know why the calorie restriction plus exercise approach being suggested above is not effective.

Darkstar4855 · 29/08/2022 12:30

My partner’s done really well on keto and lost 3 stone in six months so I would say 12-18 months if you stick to it. He has cut out alcohol completely which helped a lot.

You don’t need to buy “keto food” at great expense, you can find great keto recipes online and make stuff like cauliflower rice to bulk out your meals and replace the carbs.

Another option for weight loss 5:2, fast 800 or intermittent fasting. I lost 2 stone in 3 months just doing 16:8 and starting the day with a low carb breakfast like scrambled eggs.

missymarrk · 29/08/2022 12:21

Give or take a few lbs a month btw. Easiest and healthiest way to do it.

missymarrk · 29/08/2022 12:19

This kind of stuff is verging on dangerous to suggest @TinySaltLick

How's it unrealistic?

people who keep fit walk 10,000 steps a day and do 3 workouts a week.. ? Calories of 1500 if you're wanting to lose weight isn't barking mad either. I'm not suggesting she eats 1000 calories and runs 10 miles a day.

TinySaltLick · 29/08/2022 10:12

BIWI · 29/08/2022 10:09

@hotbankhols no.

But it irks me when so many people come on to a thread and try to help someone, and then never get a response. Common courtesy, isn't it?

Perhaps in the ancient days of letter writing

MagneticRubberDucks · 29/08/2022 10:11

Not me but my sister lost nearly 9st doing keto and intermittent fasting (after reaching the plateau)
it took her 3 years.
she was dedicated, made such an effort to stick to it, and exercise even if only in small busts, twice a day.

I’m so proud of her, she’s kept if odd and it’s definitely worked for her.

BIWI · 29/08/2022 10:09

@hotbankhols no.

But it irks me when so many people come on to a thread and try to help someone, and then never get a response. Common courtesy, isn't it?

Oysterbabe · 29/08/2022 10:03

The latest studies suggest keto is no more effective than simple calorie counting. There's no reason to massively restrict your diet. You'll never sustain it forever so what's the point? Find a plan you can follow forever, like a healthy balanced diet with reasonable portions.

hotbankhols · 29/08/2022 10:00

Are you going to send a warrant out @BIWI ? Hmm

BIWI · 29/08/2022 09:55

@Imsosorryforanyoffencecaused lots of people are here trying to help you, but you haven't replied to any of us Confused

What have you decided to do?

BirdOnTheBeach · 29/08/2022 09:41

I lost 5 stone last year between Jan and Oct doing Keto and have maintained since

Lemons1571 · 29/08/2022 09:27

I did Slimfast and went from 18 stone 6 to 8 stone 12. Took 14 months. But I was very strict and determined, and didn’t fall off the wagon.

Won’t lie though, maintenance is hard. As soon as I eat “normally” ie reintroduce carbs, I quickly start putting weight back on.

Oh and constipation is an issue when you get near your goal weight - plenty of fibre, psyllium and water required.

nottodaytomorrow · 29/08/2022 09:22

Not as quick as you will put it all back on when you go off plan.

hotbankhols · 29/08/2022 09:17

Lol at the just do some exercise and eat less calories.

TinySaltLick · 29/08/2022 09:13

missymarrk · 29/08/2022 06:53

Just drop your calories to 1500 a day, do 10,000+ steps and 3 weight based work outs a week. You'll drop a stone a month if you're rigid. Honestly don't do keto. The minute you stop you'll balloon!

I know this is trying to be helpful, but setting unrealistic expectations is counter productive. To lose a stone in a month is almost 0.5 pounds a day - which is a calorie deficit of 1750. That's two hours of intense exercise a day whilst maintaining no additional food, or an hour with say 800 calories a day. That just simply isn't possible outside of laboratory conditions - and you certainly couldn't live a healthy lifestyle at the same time eg go to work

This kind of stuff is verging on dangerous to suggest

stayathomer · 29/08/2022 07:09

Dh has lost over 2 stone in 3 months by totally changing his diet. He’s cut all white bread and now eats only 2 slices of a homemade brown bread a day, has cut out fizzy drinks, sweets, crisps, coffee, eats 3 meals a day and doesn’t eats after 8 at night. Also drinks loads of water. He says that’s the crux of it-, that and get used to being a bit hungry sometimes. He eats salads, poached eggs, fish, healthy curries (turmeric and chillis are apparently very very good for you), but still steaks and bolognaises and homemade pizza too, he has smaller portions of carbs but doesn’t cut them. His day off he’s still not as unhealthy as the rest of us(!) He said the first 3 weeks were miserable but he feels better now than he’s ever been but was told by the doctor to make sure to keep the weight loss slow- he said to look at guidelines from the hse and nhs

missymarrk · 29/08/2022 06:53

Just drop your calories to 1500 a day, do 10,000+ steps and 3 weight based work outs a week. You'll drop a stone a month if you're rigid. Honestly don't do keto. The minute you stop you'll balloon!

Carpy88999 · 29/08/2022 06:50

Just control your calories and get more active. I assume you're 19 stone because you enjoy eating carbs like most people on the planet you do not have to cut them out to lose weight. Why saddle yourself with a diet you're not going to be able to stick with long term.

Change the way you eat not what you eat, you'll be far more likely to stick to it long term and you'll still enjoy yourself.

redlou123 · 29/08/2022 06:32

I was struggling to conceive and wanted to lose around 7 stone a couple of years ago. I found keto worked really well for me (I'm better at sticking to things if I just completely cut certain things from my diet). I lost 4.5 stone in about 8 months through keto and exercise. I started losing really quickly initially (which was a big motivator for me) and then it did start to tail off and become more difficult but I was still seeing the numbers go down slowly. It then stalled completely, but I happily discovered it was because I was pregnant.

I was advised not to continue with the diet whilst pregnant so reintroduced carbs. I did start to regain some but nowhere near what I lost. I sadly lost the baby, but the ability to get pregnant was a massive motivator to get back on with weight loss and so I started keto again, and got back down to where I had previously when I found out I was pregnant again. I sadly had another 3 miscarriages but went back to keto between each one to re-lose the weight I gained during the pregnancies.

I never got back below the 4.5 stone total lost as thankfully my last pregnancy stuck and I am now 36 weeks. I have regained some weight but am still significantly less than I was before I started keto. I'm planning to go back to keto to help lose the baby weight after he gets here.

I know some people stay it is hard to stick to and not a long-term diet, but I found the opposite to be true and found it much easier to stick to than any other diet I've ever done. It just works for me and I would have happily continued it long-term had it not been for the pregnancies. Best of luck with it.

W0tnow · 29/08/2022 04:53

A friend did it. It took about a year and a half maybe? I’ve no idea how much weight she lost but it was dramatic. It’s all back on now though.

HairyMcLarie · 29/08/2022 04:25

Difficult to say as weight loss isn't linear. On Keto I lost almost a stone in a month then nothing, absolutely nothing for two more months, then a solid 2lb a week came off after that slowing down towards the end but my weight loss chart is up and down like a heartbeat! To lose 4lb one week and find 2 back on is disheartening but very very common. The general trajectory was down though.

Assuming 2lb a week loss, you have 112lb to lose so that's almost exactly a year to lose.

TinySaltLick · 29/08/2022 03:13

In terms of timing, a 500 calorie deficit a day (which isn't easy whatsoever) would lose a pound a week. So that's approx 4lbs a month, or about 3.5st a year.

So at that rate, to lose 8st would be a little over 2 years.